C
CaptainPicard
Guest
Hello. My aim with this post is to show that the doctrine of sola scriptura is self contradictory. I’m going to do so using the “Canon argument” which is brought up sometimes by Catholic apologists. Mark Shea’s book, By What Authority?, contains this argument, for instance. I’m going to try boiling the argument down to the bare bones basics so that the logic doesn’t get lost in extra fluff. I’m not trying to be “mean” or argumentative. My goal is only to share information which I believe is logically and unavoidably true. Please read all the way through and try to understand what I’m arguing before responding.
My definition of sola scriptura here is that the Bible is the only infallible rule of the Christian Faith.
My first argument is that if the Bible alone is the infallible rule of Christian faith, then the information used in determining the books that belonged in the Bible was fallible, which means that the Bible is fallible, because the list of books included in the bible were fallible. So sola scriptura is self defeating. This image illustrates the point:
http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/6350/ss1lp.jpg
Second, even if the canon was self-attesting in some way (for instance, one of the books contained a list of infallible books), it would be circular logic, and wouldn’t guarantee that said books were infallible.
I tried to put an image here demonstrating this, but maybe we’re limited to one image per post. Reference the image in my next post.
So what do you think? Is sola scriptura self defeating?
Please, in responding, stay on topic. The topic is whether or not the above logic proves that sola scriptura is self defeating.
Here are some things that do not really pertain to the topic and I would ask for you** to not discuss**:
1.The Catholic Church or any Catholic teaching. It really has nothing to do with the above logic that I am trying to demonstrate. If you feel that Catholic teaching is just as inadequate or illogical as sola scriptura please start another thread on that topic. Whether or not Sacred Tradition or the Magisterium are infallible or not is of no relevance to the above logic which demonstrates the self-defeating nature of sola scriptura. I think that showing the logic of the Catholic understanding of the canon would be a good thing, but in another thread.
2.The Deuterocanonical/apocryphal books or their history. My argument is not about any one particular group of disputed books, but with the method of determining any book to be infallible/canonical under the presuppositions of sola scriptura. Please do not discuss the deauterocanon.
3.Please do not bring up other reasons as to why you believe sola scriptura to be false. I’d like to stay focused on the above reasons so that we don’t get bogged down.
4.There is probably no need to discuss any history at all. I think that the logic holds true whether it’s applied in the real world or in an historical vacuum.
5.Please do not discuss the effects of sola scriptura, whether you believe them to be good or bad. This isn’t relevant to the topic.
My definition of sola scriptura here is that the Bible is the only infallible rule of the Christian Faith.
My first argument is that if the Bible alone is the infallible rule of Christian faith, then the information used in determining the books that belonged in the Bible was fallible, which means that the Bible is fallible, because the list of books included in the bible were fallible. So sola scriptura is self defeating. This image illustrates the point:
http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/6350/ss1lp.jpg
Second, even if the canon was self-attesting in some way (for instance, one of the books contained a list of infallible books), it would be circular logic, and wouldn’t guarantee that said books were infallible.
I tried to put an image here demonstrating this, but maybe we’re limited to one image per post. Reference the image in my next post.
So what do you think? Is sola scriptura self defeating?
Please, in responding, stay on topic. The topic is whether or not the above logic proves that sola scriptura is self defeating.
Here are some things that do not really pertain to the topic and I would ask for you** to not discuss**:
1.The Catholic Church or any Catholic teaching. It really has nothing to do with the above logic that I am trying to demonstrate. If you feel that Catholic teaching is just as inadequate or illogical as sola scriptura please start another thread on that topic. Whether or not Sacred Tradition or the Magisterium are infallible or not is of no relevance to the above logic which demonstrates the self-defeating nature of sola scriptura. I think that showing the logic of the Catholic understanding of the canon would be a good thing, but in another thread.
2.The Deuterocanonical/apocryphal books or their history. My argument is not about any one particular group of disputed books, but with the method of determining any book to be infallible/canonical under the presuppositions of sola scriptura. Please do not discuss the deauterocanon.
3.Please do not bring up other reasons as to why you believe sola scriptura to be false. I’d like to stay focused on the above reasons so that we don’t get bogged down.
4.There is probably no need to discuss any history at all. I think that the logic holds true whether it’s applied in the real world or in an historical vacuum.
5.Please do not discuss the effects of sola scriptura, whether you believe them to be good or bad. This isn’t relevant to the topic.
- Please, no ad hominems, whether Protestant, Catholic or otherwise. No name calling or useless bickering. It’s not charitable, not logical and simply obscures the topic we are discussing.