Is Sola Scriptura self-defeating?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CaptainPicard
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CaptainPicard

Guest
Hello. My aim with this post is to show that the doctrine of sola scriptura is self contradictory. I’m going to do so using the “Canon argument” which is brought up sometimes by Catholic apologists. Mark Shea’s book, By What Authority?, contains this argument, for instance. I’m going to try boiling the argument down to the bare bones basics so that the logic doesn’t get lost in extra fluff. I’m not trying to be “mean” or argumentative. My goal is only to share information which I believe is logically and unavoidably true. Please read all the way through and try to understand what I’m arguing before responding.

My definition of sola scriptura here is that the Bible is the only infallible rule of the Christian Faith.

My first argument is that if the Bible alone is the infallible rule of Christian faith, then the information used in determining the books that belonged in the Bible was fallible, which means that the Bible is fallible, because the list of books included in the bible were fallible. So sola scriptura is self defeating. This image illustrates the point:
http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/6350/ss1lp.jpg

Second, even if the canon was self-attesting in some way (for instance, one of the books contained a list of infallible books), it would be circular logic, and wouldn’t guarantee that said books were infallible.
I tried to put an image here demonstrating this, but maybe we’re limited to one image per post. Reference the image in my next post.

So what do you think? Is sola scriptura self defeating?
Please, in responding, stay on topic. The topic is whether or not the above logic proves that sola scriptura is self defeating.
Here are some things that do not really pertain to the topic and I would ask for you** to not discuss**:

1.The Catholic Church or any Catholic teaching. It really has nothing to do with the above logic that I am trying to demonstrate. If you feel that Catholic teaching is just as inadequate or illogical as sola scriptura please start another thread on that topic. Whether or not Sacred Tradition or the Magisterium are infallible or not is of no relevance to the above logic which demonstrates the self-defeating nature of sola scriptura. I think that showing the logic of the Catholic understanding of the canon would be a good thing, but in another thread.

2.The Deuterocanonical/apocryphal books or their history. My argument is not about any one particular group of disputed books, but with the method of determining any book to be infallible/canonical under the presuppositions of sola scriptura. Please do not discuss the deauterocanon.

3.Please do not bring up other reasons as to why you believe sola scriptura to be false. I’d like to stay focused on the above reasons so that we don’t get bogged down.

4.There is probably no need to discuss any history at all. I think that the logic holds true whether it’s applied in the real world or in an historical vacuum.

5.Please do not discuss the effects of sola scriptura, whether you believe them to be good or bad. This isn’t relevant to the topic.
  1. Please, no ad hominems, whether Protestant, Catholic or otherwise. No name calling or useless bickering. It’s not charitable, not logical and simply obscures the topic we are discussing.
In the next post, I include a few possible responses that I’ve anticipated for this thread and my answers.
 
First, here is the second image showing the circular logic of the self attesting image as referenced from my last post:

http://img693.imageshack.us/img693/76/ss2p.jpg

Now, onto possible objections:
If I don’t believe that Sacred Tradition or the Magisterium are infallible, isn’t sola scriptura all that’s left?
No. It in no way follows that just because Sacred Tradition and the Magisterium are not infallible, that sola scriptura is true. Just because there exists an institution that erroneously (from a protestant view) claims authority, does not mean that the above logic demonstrating sola scriptura’s self defeating nature is any less true.
The Holy Spirit is guiding me to know which books belong in the Canon.
The Holy Spirit may well be guiding you, but that is not what I’m interested in. Let me ask you: Are you infallible? If you answered “Yes” then you don’t believe in sola scriptura because you hold another infallible rule of the Christian faith (yourself) and this thread doesn’t apply to you. If you answered “no” then you are still left with only a fallible means of determining the canon, resulting in a fallible canon.
I think that the Holy Spirit wouldn’t let me down in knowing what books belong in the bible, even if I’m fallible in other ways.
This sentiment is nowhere to be found in the bible, so is self-defeating for the holder of sola scriptura. Even if it were found in the bible, it would be circular logic because you’re assuming the very thing to be argued, namely, that the book which contained that statement is in fact infallible. See the second image above.
I think that such and such book is infallible because of X reason. X being historical accuracy, something supernatural about it, wise advice it contains, or consistency with other books.
This is self defeating because scripture doesn’t contain any criteria for determining scripture. So it is extra-scriptural reasoning, which means it is fallible and will result in a fallible canon. Even if scripture did include detailed information on determining the canon, it would be circular logic because it assume the very thing being argued (that the book is infallible). See the second image above.
If sola scriptura is false, how do we know what is God’s word?
Maybe there is no way. Or maybe there is an outside infallible authority which determines the canon. This would be an interesting discussion (for another thread)…

Thank you for reading. I hope that for protestants reading this, that your faith in God is strong and that if you question sola scriptura you wont be led into pessimism and agnosticism. I (as a Catholic) believe these pessimism and endless agnostic skepticism to be dangerous and wrong. Again, though, that’s a discussion for another thread.
 
That is a nice chart in post #1. Dr. Peter Kreeft phrases it something like an effect (Bible) cannot be greater than its cause (Church & Tradition). :o
 
1.The Catholic Church or any Catholic teaching. It really has nothing to do with the above logic that I am trying to demonstrate. If you feel that Catholic teaching is just as inadequate or illogical as sola scriptura please start another thread on that topic.
This is always the problem. This discussion inevitably disintegrates into people trying to prove the Catholic Church is wrong on a particular doctrine (Sacred Tradition). The fact is, even if someone proves the Catholic Church is wrong about every single one of it’s beliefs, sola Scriptura will still remain unproven. Thus, no aspect of the Catholic faith should need to be mentioned in this thread.
 
Beautiful.
You need to post this on CM’s “It’s not in the Bible, okay” thread.
 
Wasn’t it the Catholic Church that declared the Bible to be inerrant? If so, why do you criticize non-Catholics for basing their authority on it? Is the Catholic authority less inerrant than the “inerrant” Bible?
 
Wasn’t it the Catholic Church that declared the Bible to be inerrant? If so, why do you criticize non-Catholics for basing their authority on it? Is the Catholic authority less inerrant than the “inerrant” Bible?
The OP’s argument has nothing to do with the Catholic Church. It is demonstrating that Sola Scriptura is self-refuting, and is therefore false. We can assume for the sake of argument that the Catholic Church is wrong about everything - it doesn’t matter.
 
That is a nice chart in post #1. Dr. Peter Kreeft phrases it something like an effect (Bible) cannot be greater than its cause (Church & Tradition). :o
That makes perfect sense. I read an article on the “called to communion” website which, even though it was describing a slightly different topic, gave the argument a slightly different spin. They likened it to multiplying a negative number (fallible) to a positive number (infallible). You always get a negative number, a fallible result. The allegory doesn’t hold if you multiply two negative numbers, though… (two wrongs don’t make a right, but two Wrights made an airplane and three rights make a left.)
This is always the problem. This discussion inevitably disintegrates into people trying to prove the Catholic Church is wrong on a particular doctrine (Sacred Tradition). The fact is, even if someone proves the Catholic Church is wrong about every single one of it’s beliefs, sola Scriptura will still remain unproven. Thus, no aspect of the Catholic faith should need to be mentioned in this thread.
I think that it’s the nature of people to get revved up and get into an argument when something so important to them is challenged. In this case, the arguing gets in the way of thinking about the fundamental issues, for both Catholics and Protestants.
Beautiful.
You need to post this on CM’s “It’s not in the Bible, okay” thread.
I was thinking it might just get lost in that thread. But I was thinking about posting it on another Protestant based message board. This board is frequented by mostly Catholics and Protestants who are usually fairly sympathetic to the the Church. I’d like to get an intelligent protestant critique of the argument to see if there is something wrong with it or some way to circumvent it. It seems almost “too easy” that such simple logic could be used to disprove one of the theological bedrocks of a belief system that claims over 500 million members, many of whom are very intelligent. Maybe they just never give it much thought? They learn it from birth from people they trust, so they just take it for granted?
 
Maybe they just never give it much thought?
I think there are some that give it a lot of thought. Sola Scriptura, when taken to it’s logical end by Protestants such as R. C. Sproul, results in the Bible being a fallible collection of infallible books. However, I’m still not sure how they know that every book that made it into the Bible was an infallible one…

Source:
books.google.ca/books?id=lpm2Lv3yjY8C&lpg=PA82&ots=Dd4sEAx_AV&dq=r%20c%20sproul%20fallible%20canon&pg=PA82#v=onepage&q=&f=false
 
Wasn’t it the Catholic Church that declared the Bible to be inerrant? If so, why do you criticize non-Catholics for basing their authority on it? Is the Catholic authority less inerrant than the “inerrant” Bible?
Yes, it was the Catholic Church that declared the Bible inerrant. But that is an extra-Biblical source. If you truly want to claim “sola Scriptura”, you cannot refer to the Tradition of the Catholic Church for any of your doctrine.
 
Wasn’t it the Catholic Church that declared the Bible to be inerrant? If so, why do you criticize non-Catholics for basing their authority on it?
Would you like the obvious reason? We criticize them because they accept the Catholic Church’s word and authority only when it is convenient for them and reject it when that same word and authority it is not. It’s embarrassing that you would even ask!
 
I think there are some that give it a lot of thought. Sola Scriptura, when taken to it’s logical end by Protestants such as R. C. Sproul, results in the Bible being a fallible collection of infallible books. However, I’m still not sure how they know that every book that made it into the Bible was an infallible one…

Source:
books.google.ca/books?id=lpm2Lv3yjY8C&lpg=PA82&ots=Dd4sEAx_AV&dq=r%20c%20sproul%20fallible%20canon&pg=PA82#v=onepage&q=&f=false
They dont, its bogus. The proper terminology, BTW is a fallible collection of inerrant books. They cant even get that straight.
 
My definition of sola scriptura here is that the Bible is the only infallible rule of the Christian Faith.

My first argument is that if the Bible alone is the infallible rule of Christian faith, then the information used in determining the books that belonged in the Bible was fallible,…
Why go back only to the information used in determining the books? You could start with fallible men being used in the writing of the books in the first place. If God, however, is involved in and controlling the process then it doesn’t matter that fallible men were used to record God’s Word, to preserve God’s Word and to canonize God’s Word. In that case the end result would be infallible notwithstanding the involvement of fallible men and it would be a matter of faith as to whether God was completely controlling the process when the Latin Church established its canon or when the Syriac Church established its canon or when the Reformed Church established its canon (for example). The doctrine of SS then, starts with the shared assumption (matter of faith) between Protestants and Catholics that God acted to ensure that his Word was properly recorded, preserved and recognized.
Second, even if the canon was self-attesting in some way (for instance, one of the books contained a list of infallible books), it would be circular logic, and wouldn’t guarantee that said books were infallible.
Again you are ignoring the perceived role of God. Ultimately, b/c God’s involvement is assumed by faith, the authority behind the Bible is seen to be God himself, not a single fallible man inspired to write an infallible list or a group of fallible men inspired to hammer out an infallible canon.

BTW…you make an rather inspired set of rules. 😉
 
The doctrine of SS then, starts with the shared assumption (matter of faith) between Protestants and Catholics that God acted to ensure that his Word was properly recorded, preserved and recognized.
Problem 1: This assumption (matter of faith) is not found in the Bible, therefore defeating the doctrine of Sola Scriptura.

Problem 2: Even if it were found in the Bible, the logic would be circular, since we are assuming the very thing we are trying to prove (that the Bible is infallible).
 
Problem 1: This assumption (matter of faith) is not found in the Bible, therefore defeating the doctrine of Sola Scriptura.
What you seem to be missing is that the doctrine of SS developed in a specific set of circumstances (and so it is to be used within a specific context). Those circumstances allowed certain assumptions to be made and so SS, properly described would be of this sort: Given A, then B. “A” is that God acted so as ensure that his Word was properly recorded, preserved and recognized. (If you wanted to go further, you could add into “A” that God exists, that he created and cares about us enough to reveal his will to us, that he did so in a written form etc.,) “A” was admitted by all those involved in the issue that gave rise to SS and so an advocate of SS should only assert SS in an audience where “A” is admitted. Further, if “A” is admitted by the audience (which would be the case if the audience consisted of conservative Catholics) then the problems you perceive are bi-passed by the admission. In any case, everyone should realize that SS is built upon a set of assumptions and SS can not serve to validate those assumptions (and it shouldn’t be expected to validate them).
Problem 2: Even if it were found in the Bible, the logic would be circular, since we are assuming the very thing we are trying to prove…
This discloses a problem in your approach. SS is not offered as a proof. It is the answer to a relatively modern question: Where can God’s rule of faith be found today, free of any error? The answer of “only in scripture” was given by some b/c they believed that Church and tradition had been proven to be corrupt. No other candidates where given serious consideration. Again, the answer is given in the context that, “Since all involved agree that the Bible is w/o error…” The answer then, is not acheived by circular logic, but by eliminating all other options from the short list of possibilities.
 
In any case, everyone should realize that SS is built upon a set of assumptions and SS can not serve to validate those assumptions (and it shouldn’t be expected to validate them).
I completely agree, and herein lies the crux of the issue. If Sola Scriptura proves itself, then it is circular. If something else (fallible or infallible) is used to prove it, it is self-defeating.

And this is as far as we need to go in order to show that Sola Scriptura is illogical.
This discloses a problem in your approach. SS is not offered as a proof. It is the answer to a relatively modern question: Where can God’s rule of faith be found today, free of any error? The answer of “only in scripture” was given by some b/c they believed that Church and tradition had been proven to be corrupt. No other candidates where given serious consideration. Again, the answer is given in the context that, “Since all involved agree that the Bible is w/o error…” The answer then, is not acheived by circular logic, but by eliminating all other options from the short list of possibilities.
The OP uses the following definition of SS, which is what I was using in my argument:
My definition of sola scriptura here is that the Bible is the only infallible rule of the Christian Faith
Saying that the Church has become corrupt and therefore the Bible is the only infallible source left is fallacious, because the fact that the Bible was infallible in the first place is the very thing we are trying to prove.
Again, the answer is given in the context that, “Since all involved agree that the Bible is w/o error…”
An infallible conclusion can only be reached by using infallible premises. You use the premise: “all involved agree that the Bible is w/o error”
  1. If “all involved” are fallible, then the best we can do is show that the Bible is a fallible source of faith.
  2. If any person involved was infallible, then there is and extra-Biblical infallible source of faith.
Also keep in mind that SS (by the definition given above) has a duel nature: not only are all the books in the Bible infallible, but that all the other books that were excluded are by necessity fallible. Rejecting the Church as corrupt gets us nowhere in terms of actually proving this, which is why I think we should just leave the Church and the rest of Catholic theology out of this discussion.
The answer then, is not acheived by circular logic, but by eliminating all other options from the short list of possibilities.
If your only option left is a self-defeating one, then there are clearly some possibilities that you forgot to consider, don’t you think? 😉
 
Saying that the Church has become corrupt and therefore the Bible is the only infallible source left is fallacious, because the fact that the Bible was infallible in the first place is the very thing we are trying to prove.
You seem to have a hard time grasping the concept that one does not need to prove that which is admitted. You remind of a convicted fellow (who entered a guilty plea) complaining that they didn’t prove he was guilty.
An infallible conclusion can only be reached by using infallible premises. You use the premise: “all involved agree that the Bible is w/o error”…
It is not a mere premise, it is a fact. Go ask the official teaching authority of the Catholic Church if they agree that the Bible is w/o error…tis a little rich for one who is subject to that teaching authority to complain that the Protestant hasn’t provided a proof that the Bible is inerrant
  1. If “all involved” are fallible, then the best we can do is show that the Bible is a fallible source of faith.
all men are fallible, agreed?
  1. If any person involved was infallible, then there is and extra-Biblical infallible source of faith.
and that infallible person would be God
Rejecting the Church as corrupt gets us nowhere in terms of actually proving this, which is why I think we should just leave the Church and the rest of Catholic theology out of this discussion.
yet again, at the time of the emergence of SS the infallibility of the Bible was admitted. What is admitted need not be proven. What wasn’t admitted by the Protestants is the infallibility of Church or Sacred Tradition. After the CC has admitted the inerrancy of the Bible and since the CC can’t rely on an admission from the Protestants wrt Church and Tradition, the CC must prove the inerrancy of Church or Sacred Tradition in order to eliminate the sola of SS. The Protestant needs to prove the error in Church and Tradition to gain the sola of SS.
 
I posted this on a protestant forum. Most posters didn’t have anything particularly interesting to contribute, but one poster was intelligent and, alas, pointed out a flaw in my reasoning.

Here’s where I went wrong. Just because the forces contributing to the compilation of the Bible were fallible, doesn’t necessarily mean that they got it wrong. This is obviously true once I think about it. Fallible forces could have gotten it right. So this means that we have to discuss whether or not there’s any reason to believe that they did get it right. Which means that we can’t simply argue in an historical vacuum. Which is frustrating because it opens up a whole other can of worms and levels of ambiguity. Mark Shea’s book does spend a whole lot of time looking at various protestant criteria for determining the canon and explaining where each is illogical, arbitrary, or inconsistent. I see now that that is a necessary argument to make.

I think a Catholic could make the argument that Protestants employ a double standard in allowing themselves to determine something as important as the canon of scripture from non-scriptural sources, but disallow Catholics to define any dogma based on non scriptural sources. This of course is a different argument than my original post.
 
It is not a mere premise, it is a fact. Go ask the official teaching authority of the Catholic Church if they agree that the Bible is w/o error…tis a little rich for one who is subject to that teaching authority to complain that the Protestant hasn’t provided a proof that the Bible is inerrant
The point is that the Catholic Church has a different reason for believing that the Bible is infallible than Protestants. We aren’t arguing that the Bible isn’t infallible, we’re arguing whether or no protestants have sufficient reasoning for believing so based on what they hold themselves to. You say that you believe the scriptures are infallible because the Catholic Church said so? I wish that you believed that!
all men are fallible, agreed?
Yes, all men are fallible. However, Catholics believe that the Church and the Pope are infallible when speaking on faith and morals (and certain other criteria are met).
and that infallible person would be God
God is infallible, yes.
yet again, at the time of the emergence of SS the infallibility of the Bible was admitted. What is admitted need not be proven. What wasn’t admitted by the Protestants is the infallibility of Church or Sacred Tradition. After the CC has admitted the inerrancy of the Bible and since the CC can’t rely on an admission from the Protestants wrt Church and Tradition, the CC must prove the inerrancy of Church or Sacred Tradition in order to eliminate the sola of SS. The Protestant needs to prove the error in Church and Tradition to gain the sola of SS.
We’re off topic now, but that’s ok because I don’t think my argument as it stands in the initial post holds in the form its in, so we’ll have to branch out a little anyway (see my last post).
Catholics believe the following:
  1. That the Holy Spirit keeps the Church from teaching error regarding faith and morals.
  2. The Scriptures are historical.
  3. That this historical information in scripture and to a lesser degree, other sources, is enough to prove that the Holy Spirit keeps the Church from error.
  4. The Church that cannot err on faith and morals proclaimed that a certain canon is infallible.
  5. Therefore, that cannon is infallible.
You may disagree with any one of these facts, but you have to admit that if one through four are true, then five is also true, correct? When you deny point three (which protestants do), you can no longer use the above model for proving a certain canon to be infallible. The question that this thread is asking is why do protestants believe that their canon is infallible. Since they deny the Catholic model of proving infallibility they have to come up with another reason for believing that the canon is infallible (and the criteria used can’t contradict with their other beliefs), otherwise they have no reason for believing in its infallibility.

Perhaps your confusion came from the fact that you were unaware as to how Catholics prove the infallibility of scriptures. This is understandable as you aren’t Catholic. I hope this helps.
 
You seem to have a hard time grasping the concept that one does not need to prove that which is admitted. You remind of a convicted fellow (who entered a guilty plea) complaining that they didn’t prove he was guilty.
What would you say to an atheist?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top