Is the Catholic Church Pro-Sadducees on the Permanence of Matrimony

[thistle]

Thank you Thistle but now I’m not getting your point! If we cannot talk about the dead being raised during biblical times then why can’t we? What’s the difference?
Because I can read to you historical accounts of miracles since the time of Jesus and the apostles to the times of the early Church fathers and throughout the 2000 years history of the Church of dead people been miraculously raised from the dead (approved by the Church and non-approved ones), but now we are going to call those as made up stories with the exception of those in biblical times? All these dead people were just experiencing some kind of “coma”?

If you don’t believe in these I have no problem with that but for me, I do believe that by the power of God, these miracles had happened and still happen to these days.

Your stories are not about people being raised. These are fictitious stories verging on superstition.
However, I am intrigued. Tell who was raised from the dead (not biblical times) and direct me to the Church document (nothing less is sufficient) which states it is “approved”.

Back to topic now.
The Church PERMITS marriage of widowers//widows who find a new spouse so if your opinion contradicts the Church it means you are wrong.

 

[Tetiaroa]

Your stories are not about people being raised. These are fictitious stories verging on superstition.
However, I am intrigued. Tell who was raised from the dead (not biblical times) and direct me to the Church document (nothing less is sufficient) which states it is “approved”.

Back to topic now.
The Church PERMITS marriage of widowers//widows who find a new spouse so if your opinion contradicts the Church it means you are wrong.

Thank you Thistle,

1. My story is not about people being raised from the dead. Exactly! I agree with that. I am just trying to make sense out of what happened.
2. My story as fictitious and verged on superstition! I don’t know where you are from and I don’t care how you see it. I don’t call something that really happened and came out on our local newspaper fiction and superstition.
3. The Church permits marriage of widowers/widows. Exactly! I didn’t say I contradict the Church or going against the Church. I am just digging deeper in this teaching because I don’t find any solid foundation yet. If you can help me find it then please direct me and help me and STOP debating with me. If you want to debate we can start a new thread on it but I am not here to debate. I am here to seek for answers. If your child is asking you many stupid questions in seeking to find some answers to puzzling questions, would you just say “nonsense and superstition”?

Your responses don’t help much and the Catechism doesn’t help much either so I am now looking further into the Church Fathers. Share your ideas so we can all be prepared to give an answer to anyone who asks in gentleness and respect (1 Peter 3:15).

God Bless

 

[thistle]

Thank you Thistle,

1. My story is not about people being raised from the dead. Exactly! I agree with that. I am just trying to make sense out of what happened.
2. My story as fictitious and verged on superstition! I don’t know where you are from and I don’t care how you see it. I don’t call something that really happened and came out on our local newspaper fiction and superstition.
3. The Church permits marriage of widowers/widows. Exactly! I didn’t say I contradict the Church or going against the Church. I am just digging deeper in this teaching because I don’t find any solid foundation yet. If you can help me find it then please direct me and help me and STOP debating with me. If you want to debate we can start a new thread on it but I am not here to debate. I am here to seek for answers. If your child is asking you many stupid questions in seeking to find some answers to puzzling questions, would you just say “nonsense and superstition”?

Your responses don’t help much and the Catechism doesn’t help much either so I am now looking further into the Church Fathers. Share your ideas so we can all be prepared to give an answer to anyone who asks in gentleness and respect (1 Peter 3:15).

God Bless

I don’t regard a story in the newspaper as evidence of anything supernatural! Its not exactly a Church document declaring it to be true.

As for solid foundation, Scripture says widowers can remarry, and the Church allows it and marries such people.
How can you get anything more solid than Scripture and the Church?

 

[Tetiaroa]

I don’t regard a story in the newspaper as evidence of anything supernatural! Its not exactly a Church document declaring it to be true.

As for solid foundation, Scripture says widowers can remarry, and the Church allows it and marries such people.
How can you get anything more solid than Scripture and the Church?

Thank you Thistle,

I know it is the teaching of the Church and it is permitted. So just help me find where exactly in scripture does it say that widowers can remarry.

God Bless

 

[thistle]

Thank you Thistle,

I know it is the teaching of the Church and it is permitted. So just help me find where exactly in scripture does it say that widowers can remarry.

God Bless

You didn’t read my post #8??

Romans 7:2-3

2 Thus a married woman is bound by law to her living husband; but if her husband dies, she is released from the law in respect to her husband.

 

[Tetiaroa]

You didn’t read my post #8??

Romans 7:2-3

2 Thus a married woman is bound by law to her living husband; but if her husband dies, she is released from the law in respect to her husband.

And you also obviously didn’t read my response to your post in #10.

Isn’t the context on Romans 7:2-3 is about freedom from the old testament laws. See Romans 7:6 Is there a way to reconcile Romans 7:6 to remarriage?

The reason I sound too blunt on this one is because I couldn’t find a straight forward explanation to respond to an anti-catholic friend who accuses my Catholic Church of misinterpreting many scriptural passages and Romans 7:2-3 he said is one of them.

God Bless

 

[thistle]

And you also obviously didn’t read my response to your post in #10.

Isn’t the context on Romans 7:2-3 is about freedom from the old testament laws. See Romans 7:6 Is there a way to reconcile Romans 7:6 to remarriage?

The reason I sound too blunt on this one is because I couldn’t find a straight forward explanation to respond to an anti-catholic friend who accuses my Catholic Church of misinterpreting many scriptural passages and Romans 7:2-3 he said is one of them.

God Bless

It quite simply means when a spouse dies the marriage bond is dissolved.

Canon Law:

Can. 1141 A marriage which is ratified and consummated cannot be dissolved by any human power or by any cause other than death.