Is the Eucharist God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ldsouza
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

ldsouza

Guest
I was trying to explain to a protestant friend of mine that St. Augustine adored the Eucharist. But he was arguing that even though Augustine did believe that Jesus was physically present in the Eucharist, there was no conclusive evidence to show that he worshiped it. I told him that if protestants believed in the physical presence they would be on their knees worshiping it.

I also mentioned that when I worship/adore the Eucharist, I was worshiping God. He said that Transubstantiation is not that the Eucharist is God. Am I wrong? I tried to explain to him that Jesus was present physically and since Jesus is God, there was nothing wrong in what I said. But he said that since I believe Christ is physically present in the bread, but that does not mean you can call it God.
 
I was trying to explain to a protestant friend of mine that St. Augustine adored the Eucharist. But he was arguing that even though Augustine did believe that Jesus was physically present in the Eucharist, there was no conclusive evidence to show that he worshiped it. I told him that if protestants believed in the physical presence they would be on their knees worshiping it.

I also mentioned that when I worship/adore the Eucharist, I was worshiping God. He said that Transubstantiation is not that the Eucharist is God. Am I wrong? I tried to explain to him that Jesus was present physically and since Jesus is God, there was nothing wrong in what I said. But he said that since I believe Christ is physically present in the bread, but that does not mean you can call it God.
Augustine on the Real Presence in the Eucharist

The following statements made by St. Augustine strongly support the opinion that He held to the true presence of the Body and Blood of Christ in the Eucharist:

That Bread which you see on the altar, having been sanctified by the word of God IS THE BODY OF CHRIST. That chalice, or rather, what is in that chalice, having been sanctified by the word of God, IS THE BLOOD OF CHRIST. Through that bread and wine the Lord Christ willed to commend HIS BODY AND BLOOD, WHICH HE POURED OUT FOR US UNTO THE FORGIVENESS OF SINS. (Sermons 227)

Christ bore Himself in His hands, when He offered His body saying: “this is my body.”* (Enarr. in Ps. 33 Sermo 1, 10; on p.377}*

Nobody eats this flesh without previously adoring it.* {Enarr. in Ps. 98, 9; on p.387}*
[Referring to the sacrifice of Melchizedek (Gen 14:18 ff.)] The sacrifice appeared for the first time there which is now offered to God by Christians throughout the whole world. {City of God, 16, 22; on p.403}

He took flesh from the flesh of Mary…and gave us the same flesh to be eaten unto salvation…we do sin by not adoring.* {Explanations of the Psalms, 98, 9; on p.20}*

Not all bread, but only that which receives the blessing of Christ, becomes Christ’s body. (Sermons, 234, 2; on p. 31)

What you see is the bread and the chalice . . . But what your faith obliges you to accept is that the bread is the Body of Christ and the chalice the Blood of Christ. (Sermons, 272; on p. 32)

Christ is both the priest, offering Himself, and Himself the Victim. He willed that the sacramental sign of this should be the daily sacrifice of the Church. (City of God, 10, 20; on p. 99)

Not only is no one forbidden to take as food the Blood of this Sacrifice, rather, all who wish to possess life are exhorted to drink thereof. (Questions of the Hepateuch, 3, 57; on p. 134)

The Sacrifice of our times is the Body and Blood of the Priest Himself . . . Recognize then in the Bread what hung upon the tree; in the chalice what flowed from His side. (Sermo iii. 1-2; on p. 62)

Many, many more quotes like this exist from Augustine.
 
I was trying to explain to a protestant friend of mine that St. Augustine adored the Eucharist. But he was arguing that even though Augustine did believe that Jesus was physically present in the Eucharist, there was no conclusive evidence to show that he worshiped it. I told him that if protestants believed in the physical presence they would be on their knees worshiping it.

I also mentioned that when I worship/adore the Eucharist, I was worshiping God. He said that Transubstantiation is not that the Eucharist is God. Am I wrong? I tried to explain to him that Jesus was present physically and since Jesus is God, there was nothing wrong in what I said. But he said that since I believe Christ is physically present in the bread, but that does not mean you can call it God.
I hope you didn’t tell him you believe this.

Christ is not physically present in the bread. That would be consubstantiation, not transubstantiation. There is no bread there at all after the Consecration, so Christ could not be present in the bread. It may look like bread, break like bread, and taste like bread but it is in reality the Body of Christ.
 
Thanks for your reply Randy.

I did show him those quotations from St. Augustine, but he was still saying it was inconclusive. But my question was by calling the Eucharist as God, did I make a mistake?
 
Kay,

I said that Christ was physically present in the Eucharist. He assumed that transubstantiation is Christ physically present in the bread.

Thanks
 
Kay,

I said that Christ was physically present in the Eucharist. He assumed that transubstantiation is Christ physically present in the bread.

Thanks
Whew! That’s good!

I hope you’ve corrected his misunderstanding!
 
Kay,

So i am guessing it is fine to refer to the Eucharist as God?
 
I hope you didn’t tell him you believe this.

Christ is not physically present in the bread. That would be consubstantiation, not transubstantiation. There is no bread there at all after the Consecration, so Christ could not be present in the bread. It may look like bread, break like bread, and taste like bread but it is in reality the Body of Christ.
I’m a little confused here. Would you please explain further or re-word your post? I’m having a problem understanding this because I think I know what transubstantiation is and I believe that I am consuming God to be as part of me but aren’t we all already part of God? :confused:
 
Kay,

So i am guessing it is fine to refer to the Eucharist as God?
Pope Benedict XVI in Post-synodal apostolic exhortation Sacramentum Caritatis (2007):

Interior participation in the celebration
Reverence for the Eucharist
  1. A convincing indication of the effectiveness of eucharistic catechesis is surely an increased sense of the mystery of God present among us. This can be expressed in concrete outward signs of reverence for the Eucharist which the process of mystagogy should inculcate in the faithful. (190) I am thinking in general of the importance of gestures and posture, such as kneeling during the central moments of the Eucharistic Prayer. Amid the legitimate diversity of signs used in the context of different cultures, everyone should be able to experience and express the awareness that at each celebration we stand before the infinite majesty of God, who comes to us in the lowliness of the sacramental signs.
Adoration and eucharistic devotion
The intrinsic relationship between celebration and adoration [66]

(191) In the Eucharist, the Son of God comes to meet us and desires to become one with us; eucharistic adoration is simply the natural consequence of the eucharistic celebration, which is itself the Church’s supreme act of adoration. (192) Receiving the Eucharist means adoring him whom we receive. Only in this way do we become one with him, and are given, as it were, a foretaste of the beauty of the heavenly liturgy.
 
Kay,

So i am guessing it is fine to refer to the Eucharist as God?
The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is when we offer TO God the Father, the Body & Blood of His Son Jesus, under the accidental form of bread in rememberance as Jesus commanded in the Last Supper. The issue with which you are wrestling is the definition of the Trinity and how that definition holds during the Mass.

The Eucharist IS Jesus, the 2nd person of the Holy Trinity. By the Trinity, 3 in 1, all three the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are God. But all have a unique presence as well, in which we can approach each singularly. This is the most difficult concept because there are not true physical examples, models or precedents that allows our very weak minds and intellects to fully understand. I cannot point to something and say the Trinity it is like that, to which you would say, Oh, now I get it.

Yes, as an indivisible member of the Holy Trinity, Jesus is God, and is in the Eucharist. But when we offer the Eucharist to God the Father, we are singularly offering Jesus in the Eucharist the 2nd person of the Trinity to God the Father in Heaven, the 1st person of the Holy Trinity. And all of this is accomplished by the intercession of the Holy Spirit, the 3rd person of the Trinity who acts through the priest to bring Jesus from Heaven into the accidental species of bread and wine upon the alter.

Jesus Himself separated His identity from God the Father on several occassions, “…the Father who sent Me…” in Matthew 16 in speaking to Peter, he affiremed that Peter knew the answer because His Father gave him that answer.

There are simply times when we approach God as a Trinity and when we approach God singulary through one of the three persons within the Trinity of God.
 
This adds a few lines to what Randy already posted.

“‘And was carried in His Own Hands: ‘how carried in His Own Hands’? Because when He commended His Own Body and Blood, He took into His Hands that which the faithful know; and in a manner carried Himself, when He said, ‘This is My Body.’” Augustine, On the Psalms, 33:1,10 (A.D. 392-418).
 
Kay,

So i am guessing it is fine to refer to the Eucharist as God?
Yes, you can write that as a syllogism:

Jesus is God.
The Eucharist is Jesus.
Therefore, the Eucharist is God.

Your Protestant friend will agree with the major premise but most likely deny the minor premise.
 
Augustine on the Real Presence in the Eucharist

The following statements made by St. Augustine strongly support the opinion that He held to the true presence of the Body and Blood of Christ in the Eucharist:

That Bread which you see on the altar, having been sanctified by the word of God IS THE BODY OF CHRIST. That chalice, or rather, what is in that chalice, having been sanctified by the word of God, IS THE BLOOD OF CHRIST. Through that bread and wine the Lord Christ willed to commend HIS BODY AND BLOOD, WHICH HE POURED OUT FOR US UNTO THE FORGIVENESS OF SINS. (Sermons 227)
Bad apologetic’s Randy, shouldn’t you always quote things in full context?

which he shed for our sake for the forgiveness of sins. If you receive them well, you are yourselves what you receive. You see, the apostles says, We, being many, are one loaf, one body (1 Cor 10.17). That’s how he explained the sacrament of the Lord’s table; one loaf, one body, is what we all are, many though we be. In this loaf of bread you are given clear to understand how much you should love unity. I mean, what that loaf made from one grain? Weren’t there many grains of wheat? But before they came into the loaf they were all separate; they were joined together by means of water after a certain amount of pounding and crushing. Unless wheat is ground, after all, and moistened with water, it can’t possibly bet into this shape which is called bread. In the same way you too were being ground and pounded, as it were, by the humiliation of fasting and the sacrament of exorcism. then came baptism, and you were, in a manner of speaking, moistened with water in order to be shaped into bread. But it’s not yet bread without fire to bake it. So what does fire represent? That’s the chrism, the anointing. Oil, the fire-feeder, you see, is the sacrament of the Holy Spirit.

Notice how he avoids dwelling on the physical body of Christ and directs attention to His ecclesial body!!!
 
The Israelites referred to the gold calf as eloyhim, so you’d be no different than them.
myfavoritemartin,

Just to be clear – is it your position that Catholics who adore Christ the Lord, whom they believe to be present, are identical to the Israelites who worshipped the gold calf?

VC
 
myfavoritemartin,

Just to be clear – is it your position that Catholics who adore Christ the Lord, whom they believe to be present, are identical to the Israelites who worshipped the gold calf?

VC
To be clear my stand is this, the Israelite people created the calf AS the manifestation of the God who had lead them out of egypt (Eloyhim/God Almighty) and worshipped it as such. It is really pretty identical to how you guys recognize the Host as God.
 
To be clear my stand is this, the Israelite people created the calf AS the manifestation of the God who had lead them out of egypt (Eloyhim/God Almighty) and worshipped it as such. It is really pretty identical to how you guys recognize the Host as God.
John 1 The Word Became Flesh
1In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2He was with God in the beginning.

The Bible is the Word of God, Jesus is the Word of God, Jesus is God. Do you worship a book?
 
To be clear my stand is this, the Israelite people created the calf AS the manifestation of the God who had lead them out of egypt (Eloyhim/God Almighty) and worshipped it as such. It is really pretty identical to how you guys recognize the Host as God.
Thank you for the clarification. Perhaps you can provide the basis for your view of this scriptural event? What translation are you using? Commentary?

Thanks again,
VC
 
John 1 The Word Became Flesh
1In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2He was with God in the beginning.

The Bible is the Word of God, Jesus is the Word of God, Jesus is God. Do you worship a book?
No i don’t do you? I worship “the Logos” He who spoke creation into existence…The Word
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top