Is there a difference between Catholic and Presbyterian Baptism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dfp42
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dfp42

Guest
Does anyone know if there is a difference between the two on beliefs or procedures or are they the same?

Thanks
 
Hi there!

I recently converted from Presbyterian and my Baptism was recognized because it was
done in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

Hope that helps.
 
You are confusing two things: the baptism itself and what comes after

Both Presbyterian baptism and Catholic baptism are valid.

But, the context of this question is that your Catholic aunt and uncle have married invalidly outside the Church and have ceased going to the Catholic Church. They have started going to the Presbyterian church and plan to baptize their child in the Presbyterian church and raise him/her Presbyterian. (from another thread).

The Presbyterian church holds beliefs contrary to the Catholic Church. It is a grave sin for your aunt and uncle to do what they intend.

Presbyterians are validly baptized. However, they lack the sacraments and some of their theology is greatly in error.

God calls all men to unity and the fullness of truth in the Catholic Church.
 
Well I don’t know. I have heard that there is a bit of a question about the amount of water. A valid baptism requires a generous amount of water so that the water contacts the skin of the head and runs off. Whereas some mainline denominations use a kind of sprinkling. I thought the Presbyterians sprinkled so I am suprised to hear that they were judged valid. Gerry Matatix was a Presbyterian Minister and I remember hearing on one of his tapes that he was conditionally baptised when he converted which would indicate that there was some doubt as to whether his baptism was valid.
 
Presbyterians have valid baptism, if that is what you are asking, because they baptize with water and the Trinitarian formula and intend what the Church teaches about baptism. The difference is that the person is now a Presbyterian, and does not become Catholic unless or until he makes a profession of the Catholic faith and is confirmed.
 
I don’t know why they don’t want to do the baptism in the Catholic Church. I honestly don’t know if anyone ever asked them either. I think everyone is afraid to speak out for the sake of offense. I think that they are confusing the difference by thinking all Churches are the same and that baptism is baptism. I just wonder if they think because it’s valid and the Catholic Church will accept it, then it’s okay to do.

I guess it depends on if I look at it from the child’s sake. It’s not the child’s fault that the parents are doing this. He will still be baptized, but not Catholic…a huge difference
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top