Is there a modern day Eremitical way of life?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Snerticus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Lay hermits are a different matter, and may or may not have private vows. However, they remain part of the lay rather than the consecrated states, and do not have either the same legitimate rights or responsibilities as a diocesan (C 603) hermit despite the similarity in the way they live. On the other hand, their vocations may speak to other lay persons in the way a diocesan hermit’s cannot do quite as well.
Wow, there is such a thing as a lay hermit? Can anyone give me information or links on that? Trying to see all available options if possible. 😊 I do want to try to relate to lay people.

Thanks so much and God Bless,
Snert
 
Your posts are very informative! Thank you so much! 🙂

I am the type of person who has become more of a contemplative as I have gotten older. I can sit for hours in contemplation and the time will hardly seem to go by. Hours will go by and it will have seemed like I just sat down to pray.

On the other aspect, one of solitary life, I already live that type of life, one could say. I long for a life in solitude, but I understand as a lay person that it is looked upon as unhealthy, so I “have to keep up appearances” so to speak. I’d rather not, but I don’t want to seem anti-social. I go out as little as possible, though. I love to pray and to be totally absorbed in the Lord, but because of recent financial problems, and the stress of being a union steward at work, worry creeps in and causes all sorts of havoc in my prayer life. I try, I really do. And I try to talk to God all day even if it’s for a few seconds here and there at work or on the way to and from there. At home, it’s a bit better, but I still carry that worry with me. Before I became union steward, life at work was perfect with regards to being as stress-free as possible. I was much more prayerful, even though I still had my financial problems. I have considered leaving the steward position to someone else to get back on track in my prayer life, but unfortunately it is a large place where I work and there is only one other steward who, unfortunately, is quite ill at the moment and needs to go in for surgery any day now. I would be the only steward and if I left, no one would have ready availablity to a steward if a problem arose.

As far as training goes, I meant in my OP that one would have to go through rigorous testing and training, psychological especially, to see if one was indeed cut out for the eremitical life. I have longed for that type of life for a long while now, even though I didn’t realize what exactly it was called way back when I was in my 20’s. However, all that said, I understand that just becuase I think I would like it or need it, doesn’t mean that it is cut out for me. I would have to research it more fully and speak to many in my diocese. And of course, those obstacles I mentioned in my other post would have to be taken care of even before serious consideration. However, research into it while I resolve those issues seems to be the remedy for my longing at this point.

Thanks all for your responses. They have helped me immensely.

God Bless,
Snert
Except for the fact that you still need to work outside the hermitage, everything sounds like you COULD or MIGHT be called to eremitical life. I would suggest you consider living as a lay hermit in a conscious way for a couple of years or more (3-4 years). There is a vast difference between sort of doing something and merely being hermit like, and embracing a countercultural vocation in a conscious way. Work regularly with a spiritual director during that time so you are clearly living a contemplative life and growing in that. Learn to leave your work at work as far as possible and, also as far as possible, work out a schedule where you do not need to be out of the hermitage too frequently.

Especially work with a director on the issue of work, which positions you take, how often you need to be there, or available, and how to maximize your time in the hermitage, etc. One thing you probably will need to determine is whether you are called to eremitical life OR to being a shop steward. I think you already sense this. As a hermit, relinquishing other goods one might well do for solitude and the love of God is the nitty gritty challenge. What does God really call you to here? As a lay hermit (or a lay person consciously trying to live an eremtical life) you would be freer to work out a semi-eremitical lifestyle, which you could not do under Canon 603.

Over time you would begin to see where God is really calling you, but again, you need to do this stuff deliberately and consciously, and with assistance and direction. That is the difference not only in contemplative life generally, but in regard to eremitical life specifically. Merely “keeping up appearances” is counter the nature of contemplative life which is a matter of deliberately and consciously being what you are and letting the truth of that be transparent to others. We may “slide into eremtical life” in all kinds of ways, but we are only really hermits (or anything else in the contemplative life) to the extent we have chosen to live this way consciously and obediently (responsively). All my best.
 
Wow, there is such a thing as a lay hermit? Can anyone give me information or links on that? Trying to see all available options if possible. 😊 I do want to try to relate to lay people.

Thanks so much and God Bless,
Snert
The majority of hermits today (not part of a congregation nor professed and consecrated under Canon 603) are lay hermits. That will always be the case, I think since the Church will admit to profession less often than not. I would suggest you check out my blog on this issue, and regarding the need for hermits (lay and otherwise) in the contemporary world.
 
Except for the fact that you still need to work outside the hermitage, everything sounds like you COULD or MIGHT be called to eremitical life. I would suggest you consider living as a lay hermit in a conscious way for a couple of years or more (3-4 years). There is a vast difference between sort of doing something and being hermit like, and embracing a countercultural vocation in a conscious way. Work regularly with a spiritual director during that time so you are clearly living a contemplative life and growing in that. Learn to leave your work at work as far as possible and, also as far as possible, work out a schedule where you do not need to be out of the hermitage too frequently.

Especially work with a director on the issue of work, which positions you take, how often you need to be there, or available, and how to maximize your time in the hermitage, etc. One thing you probably weill need to determine is whether you are called to eremitical life OR to being a shop steward. I think you already sense this. As a hermit, relinquishing other goods one might well do for solitude and the love of God is the nitty gritty challenge. What does God really call you to here? As a lay hermit (or a lay person consciously trying to live an eremtical life) you would be freer to work out a semi-eremitical lifestyle, which you could not do under Canon 603.

Over time you would begin to see where God is really calling you, but again, you need to do this stuff deliberately and consciously, and with assistance and direction. That is the difference not only in contemplative life generally, but in regard to eremitical life specifically. All my best.
I really appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut!

I do not enjoy working as a union steward, that is for sure. I really wish I could leave it, but I made a commitment and feel that leaving in the midst of chaos is not a good thing to do, and I promised God I would try for a while even if I felt uncomfortable. For now anyway, I need to stay. If I were to consider erimetical life, I would leave that behind.

I have already spoken to the other steward who has been there a long time. She does not want me to leave for obvious reasons, but if I am hurting my spiritual life by staying, I cannot do it for long. For now, though, until things settle, I will stay.

I have a spiritual director, but I do not feel comfortable talking about spiritual things with him. Although we skim the spiritual, it’s also a lot of psychological issues we talk about. It’s difficult for me to find someone to talk deeply with and trust with spiritual issues that doesn’t try and change the subject when I bring up something spiritual. I’m having a hard time finding someone in my diocese. But I know that I need to somehow. And I have a feeling finding the right spiritual director is the first major step I have to take.

God Bless,
Snert
 
Where do I begin?

The CCC states that there is such a thing as the eremitical way of life. The Code of Canon Law focuses more precisely on this with c. 603.

To become a c. 603 (“diocesan”) hermit is a long process. One must have a spiritual director. You will also have to discuss this with your bishop, to whom you will be making vows, and who will be your superior. A psychological test is also required. With the assistance of the spiritual director, the hermit-aspirant writes their own plan of life. This is a charism in and of itself.

You are permitted to wear a habit after consecration. During training, habit-wearing is one day a week for a year, inside only. There is no answering the door, no being seen through a window. Email and phone calls are ok, as is Daily Duty. E911 cases are to be decided according to circumstances. During this year the final version of your habit and plan of life–essentially, what works best for you–is decided.

The eremitical community you’re probably thinking of is Bethlehem Hermitage in PA. Many, many souls go there for discernment purposes, and the hermitages’ Plan of Life is available to the general public. There is also the Monastic Family of Bethlehem and the Assumption of the Virgin and St. Bruno in Livingston Manor, NY. The Hermit Sisters of Mary are in ID.

To correct the others, the “nun” mentioned at Stillsong Hermitage is Sr. Laurel, and she is a diocesan hermit for the Diocese of Oakland, CA. Properly speaking, “nuns” are in monastery and make solemn vows.

HTH.

Blessings,
Cloisters
Foundress
Cloisterite Hermits
cloisters.tripod.com/cloisterites/
The term nun is used commonly and interchangeably today by Bishops, religious, canonists, etc, so the OP’s usage is not incorrect — it is simply not “technical”. As for the habit, etc, this matter is left up to the candidate’s Bishop, and one may well wear a habit for months or years prior to perpetual profession.

And regarding the stuff about answering the door and not being seen through a window, that (especially the latter) is silly and hardly practical; I have never heard such a rule imposed on or by a contemporary hermit, nor would it make sense. As with any Christian, Hermits remain responsible for neighbor’s legitimate needs (there are limits the hermit herself sets on ordinary contact and she may ask that no one knock during certain hours, but emergencies or perceived emergencies can always happen); further, hermits are not recluses generally, and can also be seen in all the normal ways one might be as they do their errands, live their lives, etc. Yes, we like and require privacy, but hermits living under the Rule of Benedict, for instance (or whose Rule of Life reflects that spirit or is subsumed under it) are responsible for hospitality as well (again, within limits); this is a very real obligation.

In my own life my neighbors know that if I am in the living area of my hermitage (front room with computer, kitchen, etc) during certain hours (day time), they can actually knock softly and come in so long as there is no sign on the door that I am in session with a client. However, they also know to enter quietly so if I am in cell (the inner room with chapel, lectio desk, etc) they do not disturb me. They simply leave again without bothering me (or they will leave a note on my desk next to the computer or under the door on their way out). Emergencies are a different matter and are dealt with on a case by case basis. My own neighbors know when I am in my chapel//cell, and they know when I am in my patio reading or praying. That is all pretty visible (lights in the cell, a patio that is not completely secluded, etc). What is true is that my neighbors TRULY respect my needs for privacy; I have never had anyone abuse this trust or permission. The (front) door is open (unlocked) though, and if they really need me they will come to get me. That is as it should be.

Solitude requires stricter physical separation from the world (defined rightly as that which is opposed to Christ or not open to him), but hermits also experience an inner solitude which carries them through and can even be enhanced by some contact with and ministry to others. It is this inner solitude most hermits consider more important than the physical solitude, necessary as that is.

Finally, another small correction, one does not make vows to the Bishop. A diocesan hermit makes vow to God but in the hands of the Bishop. This may seem a bit of nit-picking, but it is important. We NEVER make vows to persons, but only to God. Our vow of obedience is still to God but the will of God may be mediated to us by the Bishop, and our obedience to God may be similarly expressed as obedience to legitimate superiors. All my best.
 
The term nun is used commonly and interchangeably today by Bishops, religious, canonists, etc, so the OP’s usage is not incorrect — it is simply not “technical”. As for the habit, etc, this matter is left up to the candidate’s Bishop, and one may well wear a habit for months or years prior to perpetual profession.

And regarding the stuff about answering the door and not being seen through a window, that (especially the latter) is silly and hardly practical; I have never heard such a rule imposed on or by a contemporary hermit, nor would it make sense. As with any Christian, Hermits remain responsible for neighbor’s legitimate needs (there are limits the hermit herself sets on ordinary contact and she may ask that no one knock during certain hours, but emergencies or perceived emergencies can always happen); further, hermits are not recluses generally, and can also be seen in all the normal ways one might be as they do their errands, live their lives, etc. Yes, we like and require privacy, but hermits living under the Rule of Benedict, for instance (or whose Rule of Life reflects that spirit or is subsumed under it) are responsible for hospitality as well (again, within limits); this is a very real obligation.

In my own life my neighbors know that if I am in the living area of my hermitage (front room with computer, kitchen, etc) during certain hours (day time), they can actually knock softly and come in so long as there is no sign on the door that I am in session with a client. However, they also know to enter quietly so if I am in cell (the inner room with chapel, lectio desk, etc) they do not disturb me. They simply leave again without bothering me (or they will leave a note on my desk next to the computer or under the door on their way out). Emergencies are a different matter and are dealt with on a case by case basis. My own neighbors know when I am in my chapel//cell, and they know when I am in my patio reading or praying. That is all pretty visible (lights in the cell, a patio that is not completely secluded, etc). What is true is that my neighbors TRULY respect my needs for privacy; I have never had anyone abuse this trust or permission. The (front) door is open (unlocked) though, and if they really need me they will come to get me. That is as it should be.

Solitude requires stricter physical separation from the world (defined rightly as that which is opposed to Christ or not open to him), but hermits also experience an inner solitude which carries them through and can even be enhanced by some contact with and ministry to others. It is this inner solitude most hermits consider more important than the physical solitude, necessary as that is.

Finally, another small correction, one does not make vows to the Bishop. A diocesan hermit makes vow to God but in the hands of the Bishop. This may seem a bit of nit-picking, but it is important. We NEVER make vows to persons, but only to God. Our vow of obedience is still to God but the will of God may be mediated to us by the Bishop, and our obedience to God may be similarly expressed as obedience to legitimate superiors. All my best.
I was simply expressing that which was told to me by our hermit-canonist in regards to training with the habit for a year. It is what she went through when she was training to be a hermit, and this is part of the TRAINING/FORMATION that our hermits are going through.

Again, you’ve misread what I’ve written.

Of course, hermits make vows to God. That’s a given.

Blessings,
Cloisters
 
There is a Cistercian community in Tucson, and someone had recommended that to me. Is that another type of order that lives in solitude? They do give retreats, so I’m thinking not.
Thomas Merton was a Cistercian in community who became a Cistercian Hermit. As I understand it this is not uncommon. As a previous poster mentioned many religious grow into the eremetic life.
 
I was simply expressing that which was told to me by our hermit-canonist in regards to training with the habit for a year. It is what she went through when she was training to be a hermit, and this is part of the TRAINING/FORMATION that our hermits are going through.

Again, you’ve misread what I’ve written.

Of course, hermits make vows to God. That’s a given.

Blessings,
Cloisters
Thanks then for the clarification, Gemma, though I am unclear how I have misunderstood you, much less “again”. You might be sure next time to clearly state that this is what is happening within a particular diocese in a single case rather than expressing it as a general rule. My objection was to the statement that this is how it is without qualification. That is not true and misleads people in what to expect in their journeys toward eremitical profession and consecration .

Further, if it goes without saying that vows are made to God, then I would think you would agree that one should take care not to say they are made TO a Bishop. They are made in his hands, and set up a legal relationship related to the old fealty oaths where one placed one’s hands in the hands of their overlord. This is not a technical distinction re the nature of vows, but a substantive one, and it corrects a significant mistake I see made time and again. All my best.
 
Thomas Merton was a Cistercian in community who became a Cistercian Hermit. As I understand it this is not uncommon. As a previous poster mentioned many religious grow into the eremetic life.
Generally Cistercians are not an eremitical, but a cenobitical order. Camaldolese and Carthusian are eremitical or eremitical/cenobitical mix. Merton had lots of problems getting permission to become a hermit because most of his confreres saw it as incompatible with community life or the Cistercian charism. That changed only over time, with reflection and the urging of those both inside and outside the Order who understood the eremitical life as an outgrowth of cenobitical life for some; for this and other reasons today Cistercians have hermits — though not as a common vocation — but Cistercian life remains an essentially cenobitical form of life.
 
— but Cistercian life remains an essentially cenobitical form of life.
That is absolutely true, and I did not mean to infer otherwise, but several cenobitical religious of various orders have gone on to become hermits of which Merton was an example.

Marsha
 
You might want to google the Spiritual Life Institute, founded by Father William McNamara, OCD. I believe the whole group is eremitical, and Carmelite in their spirituality. They include both men and women. They have one community in Arizona, and one in Sligo, Ireland. There was a community in Nova Scotia, but human nature being what it is, greed and money made life there impossible for the hermits.
 
Yes there are! We are one of them we believe the Holy Spirit has inspired to help Our Lord and Our Lady in the salvation of souls through our prayers and little sacrafices.

We are a small new community of men and women hermits started by laity studing at the Angelicum and Gregorian universities in Rome during the Holy Year 2000.

While we are Carmelite at heart, our way of life closely resembles that of the Carthusians / Camaldolese. Our vision (and rule of life) is to live in seperate hermitages, the men on one side of the property and the women on the other. We are devoted to our Blessed Mother, spend several hours a day in adoration of the Blessed Sacrament, and are obedient to the Magesterium and the Holy Father. Presently, we are under a bishop in the Netherlands. We do wear habits
Please let us know if you would like to know a little more about us and our charism. Br John Marie
 
Albeit an old thread, I really found it interesting.

I am trying to live as a lay Benedictine hermit in a town.

Is such a thing possible? What would my relationship be with the parish and diocese?

Being a separated man, is that considered a problem?
 
If you are seriously interested in living the Benedictine way of life, you may want to look into becoming an Oblate. If there is a Benedictine monastery near you (men or women), you should contact them about this. It is difficult to live the Benedictine way in isolation, as community is pretty fundamental to what it is all about. This does not mean necessarily becoming a monastic, but you should look into being connected to a monastery. They can also provide spiritual direction and other spiritual benefits. I don’t believe your marital status would be a problem.
 
If you are seriously interested in living the Benedictine way of life, you may want to look into becoming an Oblate. If there is a Benedictine monastery near you (men or women), you should contact them about this. It is difficult to live the Benedictine way in isolation, as community is pretty fundamental to what it is all about. This does not mean necessarily becoming a monastic, but you should look into being connected to a monastery. They can also provide spiritual direction and other spiritual benefits. I don’t believe your marital status would be a problem.
Will look into your suggestion. Thanks.
 
There’s a strong tradition of withdrawal in the Celtic church - in Wales, Ireland and Scotland. I know one nun who lives as a hermit (alone… in an ordinary house, in an ordinary village), supported by her Bishop. So it is possible, for sure, in this part of the world. Some Bishops support such a vocation, here… some do not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top