Is there a priest who can answer this question? I pray there is..

[AnnArbor]

My mother pinned her cloth one to her bra. No one ever knew.

Mine too. That’s the solution I was thinking would work.

 

[AKDee]

The scapular is a garment, not jewelry. If you’re allowed to wear a bra, I see no reason you couldn’t wear a scapular.

 

[Eliazer]

I am not sure why you specify the Discalced Carmelites. I have every bit as much confidence in the O. Carm. friars as I do in the O.C.D. friars…in fact I have worked with many O. Carm. friars personally over the decades; it is they, for example, who have the Shrine of Aylesford with the relics of Saint Simon Stock; I have far fewer encounters with the O.C.D. friars, who are assuredly quite lovely friars – but the O.C.D. is not greater or lesser than the O. Carm. when one is speaking of Carmelites.

The O. Carm, chose not to adopt the reforms which emerged from Spain. They each have their respective prior general who resides in Rome, just as the different branches of the Franciscans do.

The O.C.D. run the Teresianum in Rome while the O.Carm. run the Institutum Carmelitanum which is under the auspices of the Centro Internazionale Sant’Alberto

In any event, the website you recommend involves a group which is tragically in schism.

The things they relate about the discipline of the scapular, moreover, are not correct; these changed under the Blessed Pope Paul VI and subsequently.

I am Sorry Fr. I did not mean it in the wrong context my mother she is from the third order of the discalced Carmelties, that was why I wore it. I know what you wrote is right I should not have specified one order or another since they are both as good.

I am very Sorry everyone I did not mean to sound like a Sedevacantist, nor Schismatic, I do not belong to SSPX. I just found the website through google and because I saw the scapular requirements I posted it for that sole reason. and I needed to read more information and thank the user under Don Ruggero who is a Priest for the information.
Next time I will research more information.
I can Say I am not from Colorado I did not know, but I now I know what I need to do for next posts, I’ll find more information and I appreciate your help. Sincerely call me Eliazer.

 

[porthos11]

The scapular is a garment, not jewelry. If you’re allowed to wear a bra, I see no reason you couldn’t wear a scapular.

And further, if worn properly, it should not pop out the back of the neck. It should rest over the shoulders.

I find that wearing a LARGE scapular (large panels, long cords) make it more certain that it doesn’t ride up. I wear such a scapular and remains stable over my shoulders; it never becomes a “necklace.”

That said, if it’s that difficult, why not just not wear the scapular while at work?

 

[Eliazer]

I am Sorry Fr. I did not mean it in the wrong context my mother she is from the third order of the discalced Carmelties, that was why I wore it. I know what you wrote is right I should not have specified one order or another since they are both as good.

I am very Sorry everyone I did not mean to sound like a Sedevacantist, nor Schismatic, I do not belong to SSPX. I just found the website through google and because I saw the scapular requirements I posted it for that sole reason. and I needed to read more information and thank the user under Don Ruggero who is a Priest for the information.
Next time I will research more information.
I can Say I am not from Colorado I did not know, but I now I know what I need to do for next posts, I’ll find more information and I appreciate your help. Sincerely call me Eliazer.

sorry for typing error I meant Fr. that is why I wrote it not wore it. and I’ll find more information before posting a website. Thank you all

 

[Lormar]

I am Sorry Fr. I did not mean it in the wrong context my mother she is from the third order of the discalced Carmelties, that was why I wore it. I know what you wrote is right I should not have specified one order or another since they are both as good.

I am very Sorry everyone I did not mean to sound like a Sedevacantist, nor Schismatic, I do not belong to SSPX. I just found the website through google and because I saw the scapular requirements I posted it for that sole reason. and I needed to read more information and thank the user under Don Ruggero who is a Priest for the information.
Next time I will research more information.
I can Say I am not from Colorado I did not know, but I now I know what I need to do for next posts, I’ll find more information and I appreciate your help. Sincerely call me Eliazer.

Eliazer, don’t worry about it.