Is there a protestant conspiracy on this site

  • Thread starter Thread starter tdandh26
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems to me that sometimes there are so called “Catholics” or people posing as Catholics that start spewing the same worn out old arguments against Catholicism in an attempt to sway real Catholics into doubt. I’m sure some of them are real, but some ring false to me. So if there is a protestant conspiracy here, that could be it. Could it be…oh I don’t know…SaTAAN???
 
40.png
Sherlock:
Ah, a spy! A spy! How nefarious of you…

But your point is an excellent one: since those who believed that they were “truly born again” have been known to convert, why, one can’t be sure after all. I mean, I have two friends (Evangelicals) who truly believed that they were “born again” and were saved once and for all—they were totally convinced of their beliefs. Now, one does not practice any faith at all, and was convicted for insurance fraud and committed adultery. The other is on her way to Catholicism. Since they were so very sincere in their beliefs, do I conclude that a—they were lying, to themselves and all of their friends?

This conclusion needn’t follow​

If so, they put on a remarkably convincing performance! Or is it b—no one can really know with absolute certainty, as only God can absolutely know the future and the state of one’s heart. Which renders the “once saved, always saved” position moot. As Catholics, we can have a moral assurance, but an absolute assurance means that one can predict the future and know that one will not—oh horror of horrors!—convert to Catholicism.

However - none of this is incompatible with OSAS: OSAS is perfectly compatible with falling away for a while: it seems not to be compatible, with falling away finally.​

What is to stop God leading an Evangelical to be come a Catholic ? Why should an Evangelical not be acting as an Evangelical by becoming a Catholic ? If Evangelicals are consistent, I don’t see how they can rule out the possibility that , in particular instances, obedience to the Holy Spirit who leads them may require them to become Catholics. After all, the Church is not the property of its members - it is Christ’s; so those in it cannot do what they like - but what God Wills them to do. ##
 
I would say that there is definatly a protestant conspiracy, in fact I believe protestantism is a conspiracy. A conspiracy of Satan trying to lead people astray.
 
Traditional,

BTW, I am a girl. Sorry to get defensive, but I have not conflated liberalism with heresy. Someone said that evangelicals were liberal and gave Jim Wallis as an example. I countered with an catholic who is liberal to say that that Andrew Sullivan is liberal doesn’t prove that catholics are liberal anymore than Jim Wallis shows that evangelicals are liberals.

For whatever it is worth, I think both Jim Wallis and Andrew Sullivan are heretics.

Kendy
 
40.png
Andrew_11:
I would say that there is definatly a protestant conspiracy, in fact I believe protestantism is a conspiracy. A conspiracy of Satan trying to lead people astray.
Wow, I do not know quite what to do with this statement… On one hand my first reaction is to be stunned and kind of offended because what I read into this statement is that protestants are idiots led astray and being used as pawns in Satan’s plan to steal souls from God. We long to be near God and the thought that we are in ‘cahoots’ whether intentional or not with Satan is something I never want attached to me. How can Satan be using a protestant church to lead people astray when all it does is worship God and long to know Him on a deeper level? The only conspiriters are those who attack God’s children by attacking their heart and soul worship of God and telling them that while they seek God and worship only Him in their minds they are actually pawns of Satan and don’t know God at all.

Do ALL catholics think protestants are idiots or so naive?

On the other hand I remember those who spat on Jesus and His followers. Telling them that they were of Satan and/or evil. Who told them that what they believed about their relationship with God was wrong and disloyal to the very Father they worshipped. Who told them that Christ was evil and long to lead God’s children astray rather than bring them closer. I remember these people who knew in their hearts that they were right and I humbly pray that I stick to the path that God has set me on and that I would follow Him as closely and without fear that the apostles and disciples did so long ago. Thank you for reminding me of the struggles and that even though I do not face half of the pain and danger that those who live in other countries do or that the followers of Jesus faced all those years ago I know that I am on the path that God has designated for me and I need to keep my eyes on Him. 🙂
 
40.png
Singinbeauty:
Wow, I do not know quite what to do with this statement… On one hand my first reaction is to be stunned and kind of offended because what I read into this statement is that protestants are idiots led astray and being used as pawns in Satan’s plan to steal souls from God.

Do ALL catholics think protestants are idiots or so naive?
No, I think our friend Andrew is mis-stating his sentiments (at least I hope he is). IMHO, I think that Luther began as a God-fearing man who wanted to change the Church, as some changes were necessary - Changes in its practices, not in its teachings. But he later became a tool of Satan to break up God’s Church.

Protestants who have been taught all their lives how to live their faith are not held up to this same accusation. We feel that Protestants, who are baptized are truly Christians. We just feel that, not being in Communion with our Church, you may not be fighting Satan with all the tools that Jesus gave us, i.e. the Eucharist, Penance, and numerous other “Catholic” things.

Notworthy
 
Another thing on this topic. Think of it this way.

Your all familiar with the Prodigal Son. Our Church, for the first 1500 years was the family in the story. Then 500 years ago, during the reformation, the Prodigal Son demanded his inheritance and left. We Catholics, as the father in the story, are waiting for the son to return home.

You may ask, well if we compromise, there might be a better chance of re-unification. The problem is, in order to compromise, we’d have to change some of our teachings or dogma’s. The problem is, THAT CAN’T HAPPEN! If we change even one of our “unchangeable teachings” or dogma’s, then we become a house of cards. You can’t be the “Pillar and Foundation of Truth” if you change the truth to accomodate some dis-satisfied people. So, like the Father in the Story, we continue to wait for the son to return home.

Peace and God Bless!

Notworthy

P.S. I don’t mean to imply in any way that Protestants are sinful the way the Prodigal Son was. As I re-read my post, I saw how that might be interpreted. Please don’t take it that way.
 
Well said, Singinbeauty.

quote: Singinbeauty
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew_11
I would say that there is definatly a protestant conspiracy, in fact I believe protestantism is a conspiracy. A conspiracy of Satan trying to lead people astray.

Wow, I do not know quite what to do with this statement… On one hand my first reaction is to be stunned and kind of offended because what I read into this statement is that protestants are idiots led astray and being used as pawns in Satan’s plan to steal souls from God. We long to be near God and the thought that we are in ‘cahoots’ whether intentional or not with Satan is something I never want attached to me. How can Satan be using a protestant church to lead people astray when all it does is worship God and long to know Him on a deeper level? The only conspiriters are those who attack God’s children by attacking their heart and soul worship of God and telling them that while they seek God and worship only Him in their minds they are actually pawns of Satan and don’t know God at all.

Do ALL catholics think protestants are idiots or so naive?

On the other hand I remember those who spat on Jesus and His followers. Telling them that they were of Satan and/or evil. Who told them that what they believed about their relationship with God was wrong and disloyal to the very Father they worshipped. Who told them that Christ was evil and long to lead God’s children astray rather than bring them closer. I remember these people who knew in their hearts that they were right and I humbly pray that I stick to the path that God has set me on and that I would follow Him as closely and without fear that the apostles and disciples did so long ago. Thank you for reminding me of the struggles and that even though I do not face half of the pain and danger that those who live in other countries do or that the followers of Jesus faced all those years ago I know that I am on the path that God has designated for me and I need to keep my eyes on Him. 🙂
Merry Christmas, 👋

reen12
 
May I ask a question??
(Only a Christian for 3 years so please be patient)
If I were to meet someone and in casual conversation they said they were born again, would a person automatically assume they were evangelical??
Doesn’t it say in the Bible when Jesus is talking w/Joseph of Aramatha (sp) that a man must be born again of water & spirit to enter the kingdom?
I thought all christian’s believed that! Why would it be exclusive to evangelicals?

Thank You
MM
 
Mat(name removed by moderator):
May I ask a question??
(Only a Christian for 3 years so please be patient)
If I were to meet someone and in casual conversation they said they were born again, would a person automatically assume they were evangelical??
Doesn’t it say in the Bible when Jesus is talking w/Joseph of Aramatha (sp) that a man must be born again of water & spirit to enter the kingdom?
I thought all christian’s believed that! Why would it be exclusive to evangelicals?

Thank You
MM
Not to be picky, but it was Nicodemus who was talking to Jesus.

Jesus mentioned that one must be born “anothen” (John 3:3), the Greek adverb anothen means both "from above" and “again.” Jesus means “from above” (see John 3:31) but Nicodemus misunderstands it as “again.” This misunderstanding serves as a springboard for further instruction.

Nicodemus, seeming to misunderstand the translation, asks, “How can one be born again”, when actually Jesus is saying in John 3:5 - Jesus answered, "Amen, amen, I say to you, no one can enter the kingdom of God without being born of water and Spirit.

John 3:31 - The one who comes from above (anothen) is above all. The one who is of the earth is earthly and speaks of earthly things. But the one who comes from heaven (is above all).

God Bless.

Notworthy
 
40.png
Alfie:
Catholic programs now use Protestant words like “born again” to mislead minimal Protestants to think that the Catholic definition of “being born again” is equal to the Protestant equivalent.
This is pretty comical, since the words are in the Scriptures and they’re not “your words” (surprise, if it wasn’t for Catholic monks and theologians translating and keeping the scriptures in tact you wouldn’t even have a whole Bible today). And being “born again” is not a one time event similar to an altar call in today’s protestant churches (where is an altar call and reciting the sinners’ prayer in the scriptures?). Being born again means literally being born from above. “Born again” is a pretty bad translation and refers to our baptism into the Christian faith.

(And yes I am an ex-Protestant, born Catholic turned Seventh-day Adventist and now back home in Rome. ;))

Merry Christmas & have a Happy New Year.
 
Singinbeauty -

On the one hand, the Church teaches that the Holy Spirit can work through the Protestant churches. And why not? They believe in the Father, the Son, and the Spirit, they wish to do God’s will (some of them are quite dedicated to doing good works), and they believe in the grace of God - that they need God’s help to be able to live good lives. They do God’s work. In this regard, Protestantism is the opposite of being the tool of Satan.

But can Satan still use the Protestant churches to his benefit? Unfortunately, he can and does. While most of what Protestants teach is true, some of it is false. When Protestants teach these false things (even though they don’t realise that it is false), they are not doing God’s will. It can have negative effects - particularly when Catholics are misled and end up losing their faith. Also, Protestantism wrecks Christian unity (the thing you are promoting) - because, before there were Protestants, and before the great schism, all Christians were Catholic which was what God wanted. But then the schisms and reformation split up the Church, which gave the Christian faith less credibility, and made it harder for us to work with one another, and caused people to start believing some wrong teachings because they had lost contact with Apostolic Tradition.

You sound like you’re already working to try and undo the work of Satan by working for Christian unity. The other thing you have to do, now, is just make sure that you don’t teach or believe anything false - the thing about that is it means you would have to become Catholic.
 
Hi, Mat(name removed by moderator),

Glad you’re aboard the forums!

As to feeling “timid and nervous”, I’ve found
that there are many charitable and knowledgeable
people, here on CAF, and I’m hoping that
you’ll feel right at home in a very short time.

Looking forward to seeing many a post from
you, in the future.

Best wishes, and Merry Christmas, 👋

reen12
 
SinginBeauty,

Let me further explain what FlopFoot is talking about. I’m on another forum right now talking about why Catholics added 7 books to the Bible at Trent. The First poster gave a link to the Forum’s Home WebSite which plainly said that Catholics added the Deuterocanonicals (or Apochrypha as my friends over there affectionately call them) at Trent. When I pointed out this falsehood (OK, I called it a downright lie), all they’ve done is spent the next 24 hours trying to disprove the inspiration of the DC’s.

This does not discount the fact that their own web-site is knowingly peddling a lie. Now, would you call this Evangelizing (you know, the ends do justify the means, right?) or would you call using a deliberate falsehood the tool of Satan?

Notworthy
 
But IF you are going to claim that Satan can use protestant churches you have to agree that he also uses the catholic church. We cannot forget the things that the catholic church has done in the past (at least her members) and this has furthered Satans plans so just as there may be protestant people being used by Satan there are also catholic people he uses… Just a thought…
 
40.png
Alfie:
…When I watch EWTN there are countless numbers of these so-called ex-Protestants on various programs bemoaning how they wasted all their time in Evangelical churches. Catholic programs now use Protestant words like “born again” to mislead minimal Protestants to think that the Catholic definition of “being born again” is equal to the Protestant equivalent. I get the feeling that it is all one great big propaganda machine…
I have yet to hear one ex-protestant claim that they wasted their time in their previous religion(s). All of the “conversion stories” that I’ve heard are beautiful and some have even thanked their previous background for getting them interested in scripture. I’m not sure who you’ve been watching, but our faith isn’t about jumping over the line and looking back and slandering other churches. We have a much deeper rooted system of worship that stems nearly 2000 years and that’s how and what matters. You speak of a propaganda machine and have yet to look at the whole picture. Propagada is the key tool for most modern so called protestants to bring people away from the Body of Christ. We don’t make “soldiers” and enlist people out of churches to build our forces to conquer other churches.There is a much bigger battle than that. The battle is against an ex-angel who has found a way to strip the Church of millions of souls by creating scandal, confusion and controversy called “reformation” in a very complex and shaky time in history. The timing was perfect for him and it’s effects are ongoing. Jesus said that the “gates of hell shall not prevail”. Well the Church never has, and never will fall, but this doesn’t mean that the devil make great attempts and be somewhat victorious in his taking of souls. What better way for the devil to try and win than to convince people that the Church is the evil one, bring multitudes away and then create over 33,000 divisions? Most all of which claim Luther as their fearless leader who conquered the evil Church, but have only small specs of Lutheran idealogies in their faith basis? Meanwhile, since the establishement of the one and only single, non plural Church, the 33,000 are all correct and the supposed evil Church is wrong? I think not. The history since the (de)formation in the 1500s is rather recent. Because of the development of technolgy, history is somewhat easier to follow. Even though biased and distorted protestants have tried to preserve the history with it’s (name removed by moderator)ut of ideology, Luther’s writings are still available and one can easily see the compounding changes in the protestant belief system starting even during Luther’s lifetime. I believe he even wrote something like, “there are almost as nearly sects as there are heads…” Propaganda at it’s most evil, although probably genuinely unintentional, began with a posting of 95 thesis. Had Luther accepted the rulings of the Church and cooperate within the same system he had brought his thesis up and appealed to, who knows how the world would be shaped now.
 
40.png
Singinbeauty:
But IF you are going to claim that Satan can use protestant churches you have to agree that he also uses the catholic church. We cannot forget the things that the catholic church has done in the past (at least her members) and this has furthered Satans plans so just as there may be protestant people being used by Satan there are also catholic people he uses… Just a thought…
I absolutely agree that Lucifer uses some MEMBERS of the Catholic Church for his work. Martin Luther may be one of those members that Lucifer used quite effectivley! :eek: YEs, we do acknowledge that there have even been “bad” Popes! I quoted in a different thread from Francis Cannon Ripley’s book, “This is the Faith,” that “the roads in Hell are paved with the skulls of Bishops.” The difference is, between the Catholic Church and protestant churches is, that Lucifer may use some members of the CC to do his bidding but the church as a whole never has, nor it will, teach falsehoods in line with him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top