Is this a sin that would result in excommunication

  • Thread starter Thread starter ellzeena
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ellzeena

Guest
I have an acquaintance I have never met in person. He works for a national (actually worldwide) religious organization. He has been corresponding with me and we have talked on the telephone. He has told me that he is having conjugal relations with a woman he “loves” but with whom he is not married. I have attempted to correct him insofar as the Catechism and church authority but he always has an “excuse”. This man goes to confession but does not truly regret his sin (he says this himself and also intends to repeat the sin). I don’t know why the priest (if he goes to the same priest) continuously absolves him nor do I stand in any judgment of either of these people. But this man receives the Eucharist at Mass every Sunday, knowing he refuses (because he doesn’t “think” it’s a “sin”) to give up his physical relationship with this woman. Is this an automatic excommunication, to receive the Eucharist knowing you are not adhering to the fundamental teachings of the Church? How should I deal with this person? I’m thinking that I need to remove him from my life, not because I’m in any way “better” but because I DO subject myself to the teachings of the Church (whether or not I “agree” with them) and he does not. Any help here? Thank you.
 
Well I would just walk away from the person. I am a terrible person but I don’t blame it on anyone other than myself. I don’t like to hang around people who blame others for their problems. And yes this guy sounds like someone I’d sort of just walk away from. God will deal with him.
 
No, this is not an excommuicable offence. Several mortal sins - Yes. There are very few offences that have the penalty of automatic* excommunication.*

By the way, one thing many people don’t realize, is that even if an offence does have the penalty of automatic excommunication, if they don’t know that the penalty is an automatic excommunication, then they don’t incur that penalty (they still may be in a state of mortal sin, but not excommunicated).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top