Is this mortal or venial sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter leastofthese
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

leastofthese

Guest
I want to start by saying that I was not sure where to post this question on the forums. If this is the incorrect sub-forum to be posting this question in then I apologize and ask the Mods to please kindly move it to where it belongs.

With that said, here’s the question: I know that sexual intercourse outside of marriage is the mortal sin of fornication, but what about other sexual acts that do not actually lead to sex? Are all sexual acts outside of marriage mortal sins or venial? Or do different acts fall into different degrees of sinfulness? For instance, is there a difference between making out with someone while single versus engaging in “heavy petting” or even more intimate forms of sexual activity?

I know this is a sensitive topic and I have tried to be as tactful as possible regarding it. I am sincerely interested in knowing what the Church teaches about this. The Catechism only addresses the major sexual sins of fornication, masturbation, adultery, and homosexuality as far as I can recall. But these other sexual acts, which I assume are at least venial sins, are not directly dealt with.

I appreciate any insights into this question, especially any responses that include links to official Church teachings/documents on the matter. Thank you.
 
It comes down to two things: the type of intimate acts you’re doing, and the intent of those acts.

Assuming you are talking about two non-married persons, as soon as one of them, or both, are led to think in a lustful way, and/or think about performing a sexual act, then at the very least you have a “near occasion” of sin, which we are called to avoid, lest it lead to grave sin. You may also have the grave sin of lust, which is mortal if there is full knowledge and consent of the will.

So, passionate kissing and other types of heaving touching would seem to fall into this category of lust, or atleast, the very near occasion of lust and/or fornication. Holding hands and/or light kisses, if not done with the intent of leading to a sexual embrace, could perhaps be done without them being near occasions, but continued repetition of them could easily lead to heavier, more sexual, doses.

Of course, even within the sacrament of marriage, you can have gravely sinful lust, especially if it is the dominant thought or motivator of one’s sexual actions. Lust is about focus and intent. It is sinful regardless of being inside or outside the sacrament. But passionate kissing and other “fore play” type acts among two sacramentally married people, if intended to lead to the selfless giving of each other in the conjugal act, are not sinful at all.

You might want to try posting this in the Moral Theology section.
 
Of course, even within the sacrament of marriage, you can have gravely sinful lust, especially if it is the dominant thought or motivator of one’s sexual actions. Lust is about focus and intent. It is sinful regardless of being inside or outside the sacrament. But passionate kissing and other “fore play” type acts among two sacramentally married people, if intended to lead to the selfless giving of each other in the conjugal act, are not sinful at all.
This is a good point; focus and intent are more important than the specific act.

If I have sincere knowledge and intent to get into an illicit sexual encounter, then I don’t have to so much as lay eyes on another and I will have have sinned. In the spirit world, the will matters more than the act itself. Actually in the spirit world, the physical contact involved in acting on these urges is optional.

St. Paul does tell us that if a single person is burning with passion, then that person should get married to have that taken care of. So IMO maybe it’s sinful or maybe it’s inescapable, but passion keeps the carnal world going around.

Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top