Is This Your Brain On God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Faith1960
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Faith1960

Guest
I came across this article tonight via Facebook. Actually, it’s a series of articles. What do you all think? It seems that the brain can evoke voices of God, or make a person feel God’s presence. According to these articles, God is nothing more than a product of the human brain. npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=110997741
 
I confess I haven’t any real interest in such research because I don’t think it “proves” anything. Besides, haven’t the researchers thought that maybe the brain isn’t “inventing” God through a chemical process, but rather the brain is reacting to being stimulated by encounters with another Person? Our brains certainly react when we talk to other people. Why not when we talk to God? It should be no surprise to anyone that our physical being would react to the Divine Presence.
 
I don’t understand… How can he be a product of the human brain?
It’s the faith that motivates us, not ‘feelings’. Feelings have almost nothing to do with it. It’s just when we feel at peace, that’s when we recognise the significance of God.

As I said before, don’t get confused with ‘feelings’ and ‘the brain’ with faith.

“I know my dog exists. Oh darn, that must mean she is just a product of my brain…”
 
I think the conclusion is that feelings of God are the product of the human brain. (correct me if I’m wrong; I haven’t read the articles, just skimmed them.)
I guess that would be a better way of saying it, yes.
 
I think this is the same news of a few years ago that scientists had discovered that man needs religion because it is in-built in the brain… that there is a part of the brain that encourages humans to need belief in God. Hence, the writers concluded that we just made up God as a result of this part of the brain.

As far as we know it is specific to humans.

If you think about it, for sound we have the receptor of ears, for light and vision, it’s the eyes. If we didn’t have receptors for those two things, we’d be deaf and blind. Why would it be unusual to have a receptor for God? God created us (by evolution or straight out ‘instant’ creation), would He not include receptors to Him and things spiritual so that we could discern such things?
 
This is just one of the problems of confusing the actual fact of the existence of the living God with “spiritual experiences” or “transcendent feelings”.

Feeling/experience does not equal God.

God transcends our experience.

I’m not saying mystical experience doesn’t happen - I certainly believe it does, and maybe it even causes certain changes in the brain if that is how God designed our bodies - but there is also such a thing as false mystical experiences that we can mistake for real ones. St. Teresa of Avila was aware of this centuries ago. St. John of the Cross was aware of it.

Mystical experiences, whether real or imagined, should never be the basis for our faith in God.
 
I came across this article tonight via Facebook. Actually, it’s a series of articles. What do you all think? It seems that the brain can evoke voices of God, or make a person feel God’s presence. According to these articles, God is nothing more than a product of the human brain. npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=110997741
If someone throws something at me, my brain will tell me to avoid it or catch it, whatever the case may be. The brain may perceive the item, and it will make the decision as to what to do about it, but the thrown item exists.

And in any case I make the claim that my father turned up in my room the night he died. He started with an apology, we argued and conversed, and then he gave this terrifying scream and disappeared.

Now I had no reason to know that he had died that night, and I was not told for another four days by normal human means. So how did my brain know? And why would it go to all the trouble of manufacturing a fictictious event, complete with judgment, for an atheist brain? And I was an atheist at the time?

These scientists don’t want to believe in God, basically. They’ll find out just how ***wrong ***they are in due course.

Actually it’s the other way round. The brain is a product of God.
 
I came across this article tonight via Facebook. Actually, it’s a series of articles. What do you all think?
what do I think?
I think one should rely for information on God the channels through which he has revealed himself to humanity, and I see no mention of facebook in the bible or in Church teachings.

why on earth would somebody blindly accept as authority a scientist, whose work is not even reported in a reputable scientific journal, over the authority of the church on matters of religion? why would you even ask a scientist for (name removed by moderator)ut on religion? why would a reputable scientist even be wasting his time on research outside the proper realm of science which is the natural world, not the supernatural?
 
If you think about it, for sound we have the receptor of ears, for light and vision, it’s the eyes. If we didn’t have receptors for those two things, we’d be deaf and blind. Why would it be unusual to have a receptor for God? God created us (by evolution or straight out ‘instant’ creation), would He not include receptors to Him and things spiritual so that we could discern such things?
I concur. I don’t think this can explain away some NDE’s, but if there’s a naturalistic objection to “feeling God” moments for both believers and non-believers, that would be interesting. The one that would be a real jolt to my faith is on “part 4”, where they question if it is possible to be healed through prayer by thought rather than by God (i.e. your mind heals you because of such great passion), which would discredit 90% of all prayer healing, including that for the canonization of saints. Very interesting, either way.
 
I don’t understand… How can he be a product of the human brain?
It’s the faith that motivates us, not ‘feelings’. Feelings have almost nothing to do with it. It’s just when we feel at peace, that’s when we recognise the significance of God.

As I said before, don’t get confused with ‘feelings’ and ‘the brain’ with faith.

“I know my dog exists. Oh darn, that must mean she is just a product of my brain…”
One of the articles says: The disease was considered sacred because the ancients thought that sufferers were possessed by demons, or blessed with divine messages and visions. Devinsky says neurologists suspect some of the religious giants were epileptics themselves. Did Paul hear Jesus on the road to Damascus, or was he experiencing an auditory hallucination? What about Joseph Smith and the two angels? Muhammad? Joan of Arc? And what about Moses and that burning bush?

“Assuming for now a more rational scientific view, he was having a visual hallucination and he heard God’s voice,” Devinsky observes.

It could have been God; it could have been a seizure. But one thing Devinsky does believe is “whatever happened back there in Sinai, Moses’ experience was mediated by his temporal lobe.” ]
 
If the brain is merely a bunch of atoms ramming into each other randomly and without order, then how do these materialists know that their knowledge is reliable? Materialism contradicts the very thing it claims to solve. It amounts to saying “Every thought is a random chemical process…except that one. That is universal truth”.

See what I mean?If it’s all just a chemical process, then why is your chemical process (sorry I almost said thought:rolleyes:) more reliable than mine?
 
There are a lot of illogical jumps from observations to conclusions, automatic assumptions of correlations without considering lurking variables (to use Statistics terms here), and unfounded claims (such as Moses and St. Paul having epilepsy) for this to be considered viable.

For example, St. Paul was never reported to have had any epileptic symptoms in the Bible. He seemed to be a 100% sensible and zealous man, and with all of the suspicion that the other Apostles had after he converted, I’m sure someone would’ve been eager to mention his epileptic symptoms as proof that he didn’t see Jesus but was insane.

Muhammad, on the other hand (who is grouped along with St. Paul in terms of their experiences with God), was reported in the Hadith (the sayings and actions of Muhammad) to have had a seizure every time he received a revelation from Allah. That sounds more like epilepsy.

But it’s no secret that NDEs and that peaceful feeling you get after praying the Rosary is all in the mind. That’s why Buddhist mantras help people feel at peace even though these mantras are just words. But the thing is, God isn’t based on our feelings. Whether we feel happy or sad, God exists. You don’t need to feel peaceful after praying to know that your prayer was heard. You don’t need to feel happy after Mass to know that the Sacrifice of Christ was repeated. In fact, Jesus said that the opposite would happen for those who followed the truth. He said that they wouldn’t feel happy, they’d feel tortured in a way. That’s why He said “carry your cross daily” and not “do what feels good”
 
There are a lot of illogical jumps from observations to conclusions, automatic assumptions of correlations without considering lurking variables (to use Statistics terms here), and unfounded claims (such as Moses and St. Paul having epilepsy) for this to be considered viable.

For example, St. Paul was never reported to have had any epileptic symptoms in the Bible. He seemed to be a 100% sensible and zealous man, and with all of the suspicion that the other Apostles had after he converted, I’m sure someone would’ve been eager to mention his epileptic symptoms as proof that he didn’t see Jesus but was insane.

Muhammad, on the other hand (who is grouped along with St. Paul in terms of their experiences with God), was reported in the Hadith (the sayings and actions of Muhammad) to have had a seizure every time he received a revelation from Allah. That sounds more like epilepsy.

But it’s no secret that NDEs and that peaceful feeling you get after praying the Rosary is all in the mind. That’s why Buddhist mantras help people feel at peace even though these mantras are just words. But the thing is, God isn’t based on our feelings. Whether we feel happy or sad, God exists. You don’t need to feel peaceful after praying to know that your prayer was heard. You don’t need to feel happy after Mass to know that the Sacrifice of Christ was repeated. In fact, Jesus said that the opposite would happen for those who followed the truth. He said that they wouldn’t feel happy, they’d feel tortured in a way. That’s why He said “carry your cross daily” and not “do what feels good”
What’s your opinion about what is said in Part 2:

[That question led me to Michael Persinger’s laboratory in Sudbury, Ontario. It’s 6:30 on a Saturday evening, and Persinger, a neuroscientist at Laurentian University, has pasted eight electrodes on my scalp. He eases a modified motorcycle helmet with its own sensors onto my head. He calls it the “God helmet.”

The helmet is supposed to stimulate my right temporal lobe with weak magnetic fields, and create the illusion of God in my head. Well, not God exactly, but a sensed presence, a feeling that another being is in the room.

When the helmet is in place, Persinger covers my eyes with goggles stuffed with napkins. I sink deeper into the threadbare, overstuffed chair, feeling like a teenager hanging out in someone’s basement. He leaves me in the chamber and returns to the control room, where I’ve placed a recorder.

For the next 30 minutes, I listen to magnetic fields shift over my skull. Occasionally, I report seeing images, or a dark forest. I’ve place a recorder in the control room, which is picking up both his comments and mine. At some point, I say, in an almost incomprehensibly muffled words, “There’s kind of a roiling darkness, like a battle of darkness; it’s off to my left.”

Persinger observes, excited: "You’ve just reported the actions on your left. And now you are beginning to experience — and my compliments to you — what is called ‘The black,’ or ‘The dark of the dark.’ "

Of course, I couldn’t hear him say that. He was talking into my recorder. At one point, Persinger predicts I am right on the verge of feeling the “Sensed Presence.” But it never happens. There were several times when Persinger predicted I would see an image, or a face — and I did. To Persinger, this is evidence that God and all spiritual experience are a product of your brain.

“What is the last illusion that we must overcome as a species?” he asks theatrically. “That illusion is that God is an absolute that exists independent of the human brain — that somehow we are in his or her care.”]

npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=104291534
 
What’s your opinion about what is said in Part 2:

…

npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=104291534
Dr. Persinger makes a conclusion based on a misconception that he has. He says that because we can simulate a mystical experience without there being anything mystical about it, that God doesn’t exist.

There’s a huge gap between that observation and that conclusion. That gap is Persinger’s misconception, and that misconception is the assumption that the only way God can exist is if we directly experience Him. That is not a Christian belief and that is not a requirement for God’s existence (or for the existence of anything, really).
  • Of all the mystical experiences reported, how many times did that perfect condition that existed in Persinger’s experiment (the condition that existed with just the right about of stimulation from magnetic fields) exist for the seers such as St. Pio, St. Gemma Galgani, or St. Bernadette Soubirous to actually allow a pseudo-mystical experience to occur? And then, how can it be explained that in these mystical experiences, people were told things they would never believe (as in the case of St. Paul) or things they never knew (as in the case of St. Bernadette Soubirous)? Persinger’s experiment dealt only with induced visions in the right condition and not with knowledge being imparted by the visions that happened in different scenarios, such as the visions of these Sts.
  • Even if we were to conclude that that perfect condition in Persinger’s experiment magically existed for every single mystical experience (highly unlikely, though possible in the cases of some which probably already have been deemed unworthy of belief by the Church), this still doesn’t allow for Persinger’s conclusion of God being an illusion to be true. No one ever sees the entire Trinity here on Earth, so any visions are not of the Trinity but are of angels, Mary, or Jesus (who is only one Member of the Trinity). Belief and faith in God is not based in visions, and visions are not what Jesus based His teachings off of. Jesus never said “You will receive a vision of me being crucified”, but the crucifixion was an event actually orally told by eye-witnesses to others and recorded by an eye-witness (St. John). Christianity is not based on a vision, and even if every single vision and mystical experience was proven to be bogus, Christianity and God are still not disproven because Christianity’s truth and God’s existence isn’t based on visions and mystical experiences.
The only conclusion that can logically be made from Persinger’s “God Helmet” is that not all mystical experiences are from God and that some of them are just our minds playing tricks. In other news, the Pope is Catholic and the sky is blue.
 
What’s your opinion about what is said in Part 2:

[That question led me to Michael Persinger’s laboratory in Sudbury, Ontario. It’s 6:30 on a Saturday evening, and Persinger, a neuroscientist at Laurentian University, has pasted eight electrodes on my scalp. He eases a modified motorcycle helmet with its own sensors onto my head. He calls it the “God helmet.”

The helmet is supposed to stimulate my right temporal lobe with weak magnetic fields, and create the illusion of God in my head. Well, not God exactly, but a sensed presence, a feeling that another being is in the room.

When the helmet is in place, Persinger covers my eyes with goggles stuffed with napkins. I sink deeper into the threadbare, overstuffed chair, feeling like a teenager hanging out in someone’s basement. He leaves me in the chamber and returns to the control room, where I’ve placed a recorder.

For the next 30 minutes, I listen to magnetic fields shift over my skull. Occasionally, I report seeing images, or a dark forest. I’ve place a recorder in the control room, which is picking up both his comments and mine. At some point, I say, in an almost incomprehensibly muffled words, “There’s kind of a roiling darkness, like a battle of darkness; it’s off to my left.”

Persinger observes, excited: "You’ve just reported the actions on your left. And now you are beginning to experience — and my compliments to you — what is called ‘The black,’ or ‘The dark of the dark.’ "

Of course, I couldn’t hear him say that. He was talking into my recorder. At one point, Persinger predicts I am right on the verge of feeling the “Sensed Presence.” But it never happens. There were several times when Persinger predicted I would see an image, or a face — and I did. To Persinger, this is evidence that God and all spiritual experience are a product of your brain.

“What is the last illusion that we must overcome as a species?” he asks theatrically. “That illusion is that God is an absolute that exists independent of the human brain — that somehow we are in his or her care.”]

npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=104291534
I know this wasn’t aimed at me, but an atheist completely destroyed the God Helmet idea at least once:
Attempted replication of God Helmet on Wikipedia
Electrical brainstorms busted as source of ghosts @Nature
Sensed presence and mystical experiences are predicted by suggestibility, not by the application of transcranial weak complex magnetic fields
 
The only conclusion that can logically be made from Persinger’s “God Helmet” is that not all mystical experiences are from God and that some of them are just our minds playing tricks. In other news, the Pope is Catholic and the sky is blue.
What does that say about St. Paul and Moses? According to one of the articles, they might have had epilepsy instead of true mystical experiences.
 
What does that say about St. Paul and Moses? According to one of the articles, they might have had epilepsy instead of true mystical experiences.
In the case of St. Paul - if an epileptic fit can cause a man to stop persecuting the Church and become a faithful Christian, impressive preacher, and write beautiful theology, then yay epilepsy. :rolleyes:

One way to distinguish between a true mystical experience and a false one is the effect on the person’s life afterward. I read in a book written by a scientist that one man who had brain damage claimed to have “mystical” experiences. He also did drugs and had extramarital sex and compared those experiences to his “mystical” experiences. This is a totally different scenario from St. Paul or St. Augustine or anyone who has a radical conversion experience that causes them to change their lives and make genuine sacrifices.
 
The only conclusion that can logically be made from Persinger’s “God Helmet” is that not all mystical experiences are from God and that some of them are just our minds playing tricks. In other news, the Pope is Catholic and the sky is blue.
LOL. Yup. 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top