Is using contraception a sin for both?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cshell2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

cshell2

Guest
I’m going to be 43 years old in January. I don’t want to get pregnant again. We simply cannot afford it in any sense of the work “afford”. I’m physically, emotionally and financially drained to the point of being suicidal and frankly, it seems like child abuse to me to bring a kid into our dysfunctional family.

Yesterday I told DH I was going to get my tubes tied and he flipped. He told me, “As your husband I am telling you, you will NOT do this and if you do I will never have sex with you again.” Sex was one of the few good things in our marriage, but I guess it’s gone now because I can’t deal with the constant worry. We’ve only been married 2 and a half years and he was perfectly fine with me being on the pill before we were married. I’m seriously considering just doing something behind his back. Either going back on the pill or getting essure springs that is just an in office procedure he wouldn’t have to know about.

I think what made me more angry than anything was him telling me what I could or couldn’t do with my own body. He said it would be a sin for him, but I disagree as it would be my decision. I’ll risk going to hell for it.
 
I am sorry you and your husband are going through such a difficult time. :console:

If you and your husband are Catholic, then you should be aware of the teaching that says that all sex must be “open to life”. By using any method of artificial birth control (barrier or hormonal) or by surgery intended to prevent conception, then yes, you are participating in a sinful act. The only moral way to avoid pregnancy is abstinence - either periodically (natural family planning or “NFP”) or abstaining completely until you discern that conception is appropriate in your life.

I know that you are hurting, but the way you describe intimacy with your husband does not sound at all like the Catholic understanding of marital intimacy. I would recommend taking a look at two books: Dr. Greg Popcak’s Holy Sex (a book on the theology of Catholic sexuality and how to apply it) and Christopher West’s Good News on Sex and Marriage - which delves into Catholic theology a bit more and uses a question and answer format. Both of these books draw heavily on Pope John Paul II’s Theology of the Body. I have been totally inspired by these texts, and I used to be a pro-birth control advocate and user myself. I had no understanding of the Catholic teaching on sexuality and viewed it as a list of “don’ts” (because I subscribed to the view that the Church never wants us to have fun) rather than seeing my marriage as a reflection of the love God has for us, and thus I need to do certain things to keep it holy - yes, sex is holy! My old perspective has done some harm to my marriage but the knowledge found in these books, and renewed commitment to my faith, have helped me tremendously and are working changes in my marriage.

I will keep both you and your husband in my prayers. :signofcross:
 
Our marriage is in serious trouble. It’s way too much to get into here, but we’ve gone through a lot in the first couple years and I really don’t know how we’re ever going to pull this together. What I DO know is that we are not stable enough as a couple to even think about having another child. I’m perfectly willing to go the complete abstinence route to guarantee that not happening, but how will we have any hope then?

I’ve read The Good News about Sex and Marriage. We are awful at NFP. When we were first married, we didn’t try to prevent pregnancy at all, in fact we were trying. I was 40 and we weren’t sure it was even possible anymore, but within 3 months of getting married I was pregnant. Of course then we had the entire pregnancy to not worry about it and I breastfed exclusively after that and didn’t start cycling again for a year after son’s birth so another free year. But this last 5 or 6 months we’ve had two scares and I find I’m always freaking out and worried about having sex now where as we used to go at it almost everyday. What started this whole tube tying arguement was day after we had sex I started having bad side pains which I recognized as ovulation pains, I pulled out the calendar and realized we had our dates wrong and I was a week off for the “safe time” and instead we did it at the most ideal time possible! I freaked out and ran to Walgreens for a Plan B pill which DH was very upset about. Our son is his whole life now and I’m on the back burner. I don’t want to be just his baby maker.
 
Our marriage is in serious trouble. It’s way too much to get into here, but we’ve gone through a lot in the first couple years and I really don’t know how we’re ever going to pull this together. What I DO know is that we are not stable enough as a couple to even think about having another child. I’m perfectly willing to go the complete abstinence route to guarantee that not happening, but how will we have any hope then?

I’ve read The Good News about Sex and Marriage. We are awful at NFP. When we were first married, we didn’t try to prevent pregnancy at all, in fact we were trying. I was 40 and we weren’t sure it was even possible anymore, but within 3 months of getting married I was pregnant. Of course then we had the entire pregnancy to not worry about it and I breastfed exclusively after that and didn’t start cycling again for a year after son’s birth so another free year. But this last 5 or 6 months we’ve had two scares and I find I’m always freaking out and worried about having sex now where as we used to go at it almost everyday. What started this whole tube tying arguement was day after we had sex I started having bad side pains which I recognized as ovulation pains, I pulled out the calendar and realized we had our dates wrong and I was a week off for the “safe time” and instead we did it at the most ideal time possible! I freaked out and ran to Walgreens for a Plan B pill which DH was very upset about. Our son is his whole life now and I’m on the back burner. I don’t want to be just his baby maker.
It sounds like your family need help beyond what anyone here can give you. You need to see a marriage counsellor - a good, Catholic one who will help and counsel you in accordance with the faith. Retrouvaille is a program I have heard many great things about, or speak to a priest about possible options in your area.
 
I’m going to be 43 years old in January. I don’t want to get pregnant again. We simply cannot afford it in any sense of the work “afford”. I’m physically, emotionally and financially drained to the point of being suicidal and frankly, it seems like child abuse to me to bring a kid into our dysfunctional family.
I am sorry to hear that you are having such difficulty.
Yesterday I told DH I was going to get my tubes tied and he flipped. He told me, “As your husband I am telling you, you will NOT do this and if you do I will never have sex with you again.” Sex was one of the few good things in our marriage, but I guess it’s gone now because I can’t deal with the constant worry. We’ve only been married 2 and a half years and he was perfectly fine with me being on the pill before we were married. I’m seriously considering just doing something behind his back. Either going back on the pill or getting essure springs that is just an in office procedure he wouldn’t have to know about.
Contraception and tubal ligation are both gravely immoral.

You do not mention natural family planning anywhere in your posting. I suggest that you two educate yourselves on the moral teaching of the Church and the methods of natural family planning you can easily learn and utilize.

You list do not your religion as Catholic, so I’m not sure if you are Catholic, he is, or you both are… but I hope you and he will seriously consider your moral obligations here.
I think what made me more angry than anything was him telling me what I could or couldn’t do with my own body. He said it would be a sin for him, but I disagree as it would be my decision. I’ll risk going to hell for it.
Your body is not “yours” and his is not “his.” You are one flesh.

*1 Corinthians 7: 3-5
The husband should fulfill his duty toward his wife, and likewise the wife toward her husband. A wife does not have authority over her own body, but rather her husband, and similarly a husband does not have authority over his own body, but rather his wife. Do not deprive each other, except perhaps by mutual consent for a time, to be free for prayer, but then return to one another, so that Satan may not tempt you through your lack of self-control. *
I’m not sure why your husband was unconcerned with your pill usage, but he seems to be taking a lead spiritually at this point. I encourage you to both prayerfully discern the use of natural family planning.

It would be wrong to deceive him by implanting a device without his knowledge.

He needs to talk to his priest in the confessional if you proceed with sterilizing yourself against his will.
 
It sounds like your family need help beyond what anyone here can give you. You need to see a marriage counsellor - a good, Catholic one who will help and counsel you in accordance with the faith. Retrouvaille is a program I have heard many great things about, or speak to a priest about possible options in your area.
Retrouvaille is a very good suggestion.
 
My husband is a cradle Catholic. I went through RCIA and my older son was baptized in the Catholic church after we were married.

I don’t know why he was ok with the pill before we were married, but as soon as we were engaged he decided the premarital sex had to stop, so except for a couple slip ups we went for about 10 months before the wedding without.
 
I’m sorry, but this is a complete and total cop out.

If you have a serious reason to avoid a pregnancy, then you need to be serious.
Call it what you want, but even a minute possibility of pregnancy is too much for me. Forget about abortion, in my current state of mind, it could be enough to drive me to pull in front of the next train. Call me evil, overdramatic, or a horrible monster for even thinking of that, but it is what it is. Maybe in you eyes, that isn’t serious, and I should look at a potential child as blessing to be joyful about, but I’m not in that happy place and haven’t been for quite a while.
 
I freaked out and ran to Walgreens for a Plan B pill which DH was very upset about. Our son is his whole life now and I’m on the back burner. I don’t want to be just his baby maker.
I would have been very upset about this as well. Plan B works primarily by preventing ovulation (so, as a contraceptive), which is gravely wrong, but it can also prevent the implantation of a fertilized egg (embryo). I would have been extremely upset and sad if my spouse was deliberately taking a drug to potentially end the life of my child.
Plan B website:
Emergency contraceptive pills are not effective if a woman is already pregnant. Plan B One-Step is believed to act as an emergency contraceptive principally by preventing ovulation or fertilization (by altering tubal transport of sperm and/or ova). **In addition, it may inhibit implantation (by altering the endometrium). **It is not effective once the process of implantation has begun.
 
Call it what you want, but even a minute possibility of pregnancy is too much for me. Forget about abortion, in my current state of mind, it could be enough to drive me to pull in front of the next train. Call me evil, overdramatic, or a horrible monster for even thinking of that, but it is what it is. Maybe in you eyes, that isn’t serious, and I should look at a potential child as blessing to be joyful about, but I’m not in that happy place and haven’t been for quite a while.
cshell, no one thinks you’re a monster. It’s clear you’re suffering, and you obviously have very serious reasons to avoid pregnancy. I think 1ke was commenting on your dismissiveness of NFP. NFP can be used very, very successfully if you put in the time, effort, and discipline. Which method of NFP did you try?
 
Call it what you want, but even a minute possibility of pregnancy is too much for me. Forget about abortion, in my current state of mind, it could be enough to drive me to pull in front of the next train. Call me evil, overdramatic, or a horrible monster for even thinking of that, but it is what it is. Maybe in you eyes, that isn’t serious, and I should look at a potential child as blessing to be joyful about, but I’m not in that happy place and haven’t been for quite a while.
If this is how you feel about “a minute possibility of pregnancy,” you need to see a counselor and abstain completely from sexual relations with your husband. It does not mean that you are “evil, overdramatic, or a horrible monster,” but it does mean that you need to speak with someone about your fears and concerns. Catholic Charities is a great resource - some have their own counselors, but if your local one doesn’t they can recommend a Catholic marriage counselor for you. I would also recommend setting up an appointment with your pastor.

Contraception or sterilization will just “cover up” the more serious issues going on here; they will not be a “cure.”
 
Call it what you want, but even a minute possibility of pregnancy is too much for me. Forget about abortion, in my current state of mind, it could be enough to drive me to pull in front of the next train. Call me evil, overdramatic, or a horrible monster for even thinking of that, but it is what it is. Maybe in you eyes, that isn’t serious, and I should look at a potential child as blessing to be joyful about, but I’m not in that happy place and haven’t been for quite a while.
This is very troubling… I think that you need some professional help for the way that you are feeling. Emotions are such a strong driving force that sometimes we can find them to be overpowering and it’s easy to start to feel out of control.

Don’t let the devil into your marriage. Trust in God. Pray. He will help you see the right path to take.
 
It sounds like your family need help beyond what anyone here can give you.
😦

I was in individual counseling last fall/winter. I had PPD, and DH was struggling with addictions and a job loss. It helped quite a bit, for one thing when working with me we uncovered that DH had ADD, which he now treats and functions on a much higher level than before. But, our insurance doesn’t cover family and marriage counseling and when we switched to that it became really expensive. So much so that it became more of an additional stress on us than anything.
 
If this is how you feel about “a minute possibility of pregnancy,” you need to see a counselor and abstain completely from sexual relations with your husband…"
I agree with this, but at what point is that “wrong” too??
 
😦

I was in individual counseling last fall/winter. I had PPD, and DH was struggling with addictions and a job loss. It helped quite a bit, for one thing when working with me we uncovered that DH had ADD, which he now treats and functions on a much higher level than before. But, our insurance doesn’t cover family and marriage counseling and when we switched to that it became really expensive. So much so that it became more of an additional stress on us than anything.
Catholic Charities works on a sliding income scale. Call them and ask about getting an appointment. You need help, dear sister in Christ. Are you on an anti-depressant? I had terrible PPD with my 2nd son and ended up in a hospital for suicidal intention. Please at least get on some medication. Your son needs you. And your husband needs you, and not to be his “baby-maker.”

I will put you in my prayers.
 
Call it what you want, but even a minute possibility of pregnancy is too much for me. Forget about abortion, in my current state of mind, it could be enough to drive me to pull in front of the next train. Call me evil, overdramatic, or a horrible monster for even thinking of that, but it is what it is. Maybe in you eyes, that isn’t serious, and I should look at a potential child as blessing to be joyful about, but I’m not in that happy place and haven’t been for quite a while.
I’m saying that just throwing up your hands and saying “we are awful” at NFP is a cop-out. Be **serious **about using NFP properly and consistently.

I am **not ** referring to your need to avoid.

There are women who post here who use NFP because they have life-threatening conditions. They have successfully avoided for over a decade.
 
1ke,

I think this poster is seriously depressed and really needs some intervention, she has mentioned suicide twice now and I doubt if NFP can be done seriously from that point of view.
 
I agree with this, but at what point is that “wrong” too??
The short answer is, “It depends.” Making an appointment with your priest will help you make this decision (and keep in mind that abstinence is a decision you can change at any time without cost or effort.)

In the meantime, you can choose to abstain “for now” and prolong or not as needed. The main thing will be getting your husband on board. Personal and/or marital counseling will help give you the tools to communicate with him, as well as explore your reasons for feeling this way.

Sterilization is ALWAYS objectively morally wrong. Abstinence is not, and in many cases can be a very, very good thing.
 
1ke,

I think this poster is seriously depressed and really needs some intervention, she has mentioned suicide twice now and I doubt if NFP can be done seriously from that point of view.
I did not see the PPD post until after I responded, but I agree the OP needs to talk to a professional.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top