Is watching these shows a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catherine1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Depends on how mature your brother is. For most of these questions there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. If your brother is so young it’s going to negatively influence him, he shouldn’t watch. If he’s old enough to understand it’s just a tv show and it’s not something he should look at as a model for behavior, it’s fine.
 
That’s just nuts! The thing you need to confess about watching is porn. You are over reacting, you are not going to hell for watching the office. Relax
 
Last edited:
That’s all I heard on the radio when someone complained about a song: “Tame by today’s standards.” What standards? “Just shut up and get used to it.”? Seriously. Poisoning the mind, and spirit, has to occur slowly or people will catch on. They’ll notice. Just when you think “It’s not that bad.” it continues to get bad, bit by bit.
 
I’ve never, ever watched that. I think the closest I’ve ever come to watching something that bad was when I watched Titanic. I just have a hard time telling because I know it had inappropriate scenes in it. Now I’m wondering weather watching Titanic is bad. I’ve always just told the priest “ I’ve watched bad movies and shows” did he think I was watching something worse?!
 
Seriously? This is why I don’t think about my religion 24/7/365/Infinity
 
You see, I understand this, but why is it then that when I read books about say St. Gemma Galgani, St. Faustina and St. Therese they seem to have considered certain things to be very bad that other people tell me are not really that bad. Like, there was that time that St. Gemma looked up during mass to look at a girl’s outfit and her guardian Angel got very upset with her. This all confuses me so much.
 
The only thing i could say is that my spiritual director told me “it depends on why you’re watching it”. Is it for the plot, which you like, or is it for the “crudeness”?
 
There is nothing wrong with entertainment depicting the characters as sinners. What is wrong is glorifying sin.
 
Possibly, but they aren’t there to judge you. Maybe you are being called to sisterhood, you sound so innocent
 
It might work, if there’s away to get there. Catherine, i have the same thoughts as you when it comes to saying things like, “Oh it’s just the OCD”; it might be, but i feel also like it’s leading me away from taking responsibility. And when you do take responsibility , people will say, “don’t be so hard on yourself”. is that similar to you?
 
I’m starting to overcome those scruples, since my spiritual director said it depends on why you’re watching the show in the first place. Is it for the plot, or the immoral scenes/language, etc? Just watching for the plot she said isn’t a sin. But ask your own spiritual director about this.
 
It is a sin to watch any seasons of The Office past season 4 because they just aren’t good. The Office has imperfect characters that do immoral things. But this is true of any story. The problem is mainly in glorifying immoral behavior, although I think excessive representation of bad behavior isn’t good either.

Personally I don’t think The Office is that bad in the first few seasons. Later on they do have some more direct sexual content. Sadly compared to many current shows it is far better.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top