Italy Promises: No More Ransom

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
ITALY PROMISES: NO MORE RANSOMWell, well, well. Check this out from The Sunday Times-World:

March 13, 2005 Italy to stop paying ransoms
John Follain, Rome

THE Italian prime minister, Silvio Berlusconi, has promised President George W Bush that he will not pay more ransoms to free hostages in Iraq.

The Italian government has denied newspaper reports that $6m (£3.1m) was paid for the release of Giuliana Sgrena, who worked for the Communist daily Il Manifesto. But senior officials and intelligence sources have confirmed that money did change hands.

The affair ended when American soldiers opened fire on the car carrying Sgrena and killed the intelligence officer who had freed her.

Last year Italy paid a reported $5m (£2.6m) for the freedom of two aid workers, Simona Pari and Simona Torretta. Hours after Sgrena was seized, Berlusconi announced that “negotiations” had begun.

The reports of ransom payments have infuriated American officials, who say they fund violence and encourage more kidnappings. Mel Sembler, the American ambassador in Rome, told Berlusconi last week that the money bankrolled “the war being waged by Sunnis in Iraq”.

In response, Berlusconi has agreed to a change in policy. When a speaker during a debate in parliament urged an end to ransom payments, he nodded and said: “Certainly, certainly.”

On a related note, it’s now official: Slain Italian intelligence official Nicola Calipari “kept US in the dark.”

Rome - US authorities in Iraq were kept in the dark about an Italian operation to free a kidnapped journalist which ended in debacle with an intelligence officer killed by US troops, an Italian general was quoted on Saturday as saying. Italian agent Nicola Calipari died in gunfire near a US checkpoint and journalist Giuliana Sgrena was wounded as their car drove to Baghdad airport on March 4, just after her release.

Mario Marioli, a deputy commander of the US-led coalition troops in Iraq, was quoted by the Italian newspaper La Repubblica as saying: “I asked Calipari if I should inform our American allies of the hostage-freeing operation, but his reply was that under no circumstances was the ally to be informed.

Previous:

The ransom of the red reporter
More blog coverage here.
 
The Italian gov’t has every right to negotiate a hostage release the way they see fit. This is the problem with America, it wants everythng done it’s way.
It’s cler the Italian gov’t cares more for it’s citizens as it does not want to see it’s citizens beheaded on Arab telivision
 
40.png
Lilyofthevalley:
The Italian gov’t has every right to negotiate a hostage release the way they see fit. This is the problem with America, it wants everythng done it’s way.
It’s cler the Italian gov’t cares more for it’s citizens as it does not want to see it’s citizens beheaded on Arab telivision
And what do you think the terrorists did with millions of euros?
 
40.png
Lilyofthevalley:
The Italian gov’t has every right to negotiate a hostage release the way they see fit. This is the problem with America, it wants everythng done it’s way.
It’s cler the Italian gov’t cares more for it’s citizens as it does not want to see it’s citizens beheaded on Arab telivision
Unfortunately once they paid for the first, they guaranteed the second. However since Sgreda has said they were lovely people and she exaggerated her danger, perhaps they will want to send her back and get a refund?

Seriously the reason they were so anxious to keep it a secret is because they know full well that paying ransom to blackmailers simply increases the kidnappings.
 
40.png
Lilyofthevalley:
The Italian gov’t has every right to negotiate a hostage release the way they see fit.
Actually they don’t - a coalition force has specific understandings and agreements with each other. If one is going to abrogate them, it’s usually smartest to let your allies know.
 
America is not The God of the world and countries have a right to secure the release of their hostages as they see fit. You may disagree with their techniques, but Italy should not need to answer to The United States.
 
40.png
Lilyofthevalley:
America is not The God of the world
My dear fellow poster - that spurious claim emanates solely from yourself, not from anyone else.
40.png
Lilyofthevalley:
and countries have a right to secure the release of their hostages as they see fit. You may disagree with their techniques, but Italy should not need to answer to The United States.
Let me take you through it — slowly again:

When one makes an agreement with allies covering conditions of engagement with the enemy - it is assumed by one’s allies that your behavior follows your words. A coalition needs to believe that member has credibiity.

Should one desire to take action against those agreements, it behooves one to let other allies who have men with guns on the ground know that you are going to take an action – this is commonly called communication.

I suggest to you that the US could not have stopped the Italians outside of discussion from paying ransoms - but the poor judgment of the operative in charge of the Italian mission in not advising the US of precisely what was going “down” was rash and foolish. He unduly endangered his own mission.

Had he done the more sensible thing, communicate, he might well be alive, he would not have had to try and run a checkpoint, and it would have been much easier to be able to go to the nearest checkpoint and call for assistance in the departure. Poor judgment, and lack of communication cost this man his life. That is tragic, it was avoidable and while I certainly understand that poor judgment can kill a person with the resultant consequences , I would have preferred otherwise.

This is called reasonable action, prudence in judgment and good planning. In other words of more common parlance CYA. Capice?
 
40.png
Lilyofthevalley:
America is not The God of the world and countries have a right to secure the release of their hostages as they see fit. You may disagree with their techniques, but Italy should not need to answer to The United States.
No one ever said that America was the God of the world. How irresponsible is it to give millions to terriorests who are going to use that money to buy weapons to use against our troops in the field? Italy has troops in the field as well how many of their own troops will die because of weapons purchased with that money?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top