Speaking very little Español, I’m still able to gather that you’re talking about vacation apartments by the sea coast.Bienvenidos a ABA. - Oropesa del Mar. Marina d’Or .
Somos una empresa especializada en el alquiler, compra y venta de apartamentos en Marina d’Or, Oropesa del Mar ,Castellón. Alquilamos exclusivamente apartamentos dentro del complejo Marina d’Or. En los diferentes apartados que le presentamos podrán encontrar lo mejor de nuestra ciudad de vacaciones.
Highly unlikely as the professor in question is multilingual with multiple advanced degrees from prestigious pontifical universities (S.T.L. from the Angelicum & S.S.L. from the Pontifical Biblical Institute if memory serves). This interesting sidebar still does not support your dubious claim James Likoudis displays inferior scholarship.SanctusPeccator;9407014:
before assigning the book as required reading on his course syllabus. So much for the mistaken claim Likoudis displays inferior scholarship…Actually, there comes to mind one particular professor who recently taught at the F.S.S.P.'s Our Lady of Guadalupe Seminary in Denton, Nebraska. Do distinctly recall he mentioned having thoroughly vetted James Likoudis & Kenneth D. Whitehead’s The Pope, the Council, and the Mass: Answers to Questions the Traditionalists Have Asked
Thank you for reconfirming what i was already told by one Roman prelate to wit that the FSSP are not exactly academically up to much. That;s been my personal impression too. They are pious and mean well, but with a few exceptions, intellectuals they are not. But let us remember that that is not their vocation, so I do not fault them for it.
Nor should you feel yourself obligated to defend Hamilton’s proper application for argumentation; merely highlighting the lack of appropriate clarification in some of his claims. Appreciate the link to Perry C. Robinson’s website, Trebor135.
I’ve seen that link before. Unfortunately, Perry and Nick never picked up where they left off so as to work through the issue to its end. Hence, I don’t consider that post to be conclusive.Please check this out as well,
catholicnick.blogspot.com/2011/12/what-would-mr-robinson-do-did-st.html
Of course, one does not have to be an intellectual, but one does have to make some serious study of the material before one can recommend any work, especially one of a polemical nature. It is a commonplace that many Catholics, from all perspectives are so addicted to polemic that they rarely examine the evidence in an objective manner and look at what sholars have written. I was personally aquatinted with the late cardinal Stcickler, who took a very different view from that of LIkoudis and Whitehead, though I doubt he’d ever have heard of them.One doesn’t necessarily have to be an “intellectual” to investigate the accuracy of a book in a competent manner.
What are the most egregious errors you found in the book by Likoudis and Whitehead?
True.Of course, one does not have to be an intellectual, but one does have to make some serious study of the material before one can recommend any work, especially one of a polemical nature.
Hmm. Please provide some other examples you have encountered where Catholics have taken some apologetic work and run with it, the text’s reliability be damned.It is a commonplace that many Catholics, from all perspectives are so addicted to polemic that they rarely examine the evidence in an objective manner and look at what sholars have written.