Japan's nuclear crisis widens

  • Thread starter Thread starter BVM_1221
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Charlie Martin
This would all be easier if people would give me a damn link to what they’re reading. In this case, I think you’ve got the units confusion that we’ve all been running into:
UPDATE (11:48 AM EST): A report by the Federation of Electric Power Companies of Japan indicates that radiation levels as a result of the Unit 4 fire were higher than those reported previously. Radiation levels early this morning at the outside of Unit 3 measured at 400 millisieverts/hr. At the present time however, radiation levels at the boundary of the facility are 1530 microsieverts/hour. We will continue to update as further reliable information is available.

That’s from MIT’s Nuclear Science and Engineering department, www.mitnse.com

Notice your rumor is 1500 mSv, the real reading is 1500 μSv, 1/1000th as much.

March 16, 2011 - 1:36 pm Link to this Comment | Reply

pajamasmedia.com/blog/fear-the-media-meltdown-not-the-nuclear-one/
Thanks. Managed to read some of the other comments in the link as well and one’s thoughts and prayers are for those who are working within the plants’ premises.
 
One thing that I do not understand with the purported certainty that this is not a Chernobyl or a TMI is that: can anyone really make a definite assessment of end results with a liquid situation?
Source:

pajamasmedia.com/blog/fear-the-media-meltdown-not-the-nuclear-one/3/
  1. R. L. Hails Sr. P. E.
    The author gets a B, maybe a B+. Some of the comments get an F.
I engineered nine Boiling Water Reactors in the US, this plant may not be identical so maybe I am a tough/wrong grader. I have worked on a score of US nukes. Our fundamental problem is that we are getting a Niagara of bum information; I can not make sense of anything. The same thing happened at Three Mile Island (I am a personal friend of the engineer who saved that plant) and at Chernobyl (I was debriefed by technical experts who photographed the melted guts of that plant.) A few thoughts may help.

Eisenhower, a killer, formed a policy as President, Atoms for Peace. He stated a conundrum; either man uses this technology for peace or it will destroy us. The US never solved the riddle; we spend every few months, the entire first cost value of the nuclear industry, on our military. When the first designs were discussed, people like me told him that if every critical component was put in a steel pot, a containment, safety would be increased. He ordered: spend the money. These Japanese nukes have a fancy pot, called the light bulb and the donut, the drywell and the wetwell, or steam suppression pool. They are Mark I designs: I have engineered Mark II, and developed the Mark III. These are better than this early design.

There are several ways to design a nuke. One is better if you want bomb fuel, the graphite reactors like Chenobyl. Stalin wanted bombs; electricity was a by product. But in certain operational modes, it was thought, in the 1950s, that a graphite reactor might run away, explode, so there were a zillion pain-in-the-elbow systems to prevent this, designed by people like me, engineers. The plant manager jury rigged the plant to remove all the safety systems while it was running, and did an illegal test to prove engineers deserve our reputation. They took seven days, round the clock, to get ready. We learned the results, a few milliseconds into the test. Chenobyl had a containment; if the yanks had one, the commissars wanted one, but on the cheap. The Japanese containment is ~ 15 stories high, the Chenobyl containment is a closet with little inside, except pipes. Chenobyl’s core is laying in the parking lot, covered with dirt. TMI recovery people got the last pepper grain out of the pot. About 200 people were killed at Chenobyl fighting fires; all were volunteers and knew the score. Nobody died from nuclear energy at TMI; there were heart attacks.

The Japanese disaster will be worse than TMI, but not as bad as Chenobyl. All reactors were shut down for maintenance or immediately “shut down” with the earthquake detection. They are now fighting the residual heat, an ocean of heat, but perhaps 5 % of a roaring reactor. The heat lessens with every passing hour, in about a week, it will be “nuclearly cooled”. But even this situation requires cooling water, and pumps, for years.

If a core melts, the monster may awaken; no one has had the courage to test this “beyond design basis event”. My answer: daily Mass.

There are many “facts” which I can not understand. I read some from some PhD in Brussels, pure nonsense. Our problem is that the real experts are working round the clock in the plant, and have no time for anyone. Their handlers are technical dummies and misstate facts, and there are divisions of experts with a political bias. We are the victims of ignorance and lies. And I do not know everything.

Have courage, and pray for a grievously suffering people.

March 15, 2011 - 7:48 am Link to this Comment | Reply
 
Amen to that. Watching the news one cannot help but admire them. People standing in line for food and water and when it ran out, those who had got some while others did not… shared it with others. There is No looting going on. Amazing grace and fortitude if you ask me.
:amen:
:byzsoc::gopray2::crossrc:
Through the prayers of the Mother of God, have mercy on us and save us. Amen.

I especially urge catholics to call on the aid of St. Francis Xavier, the patron saint of Japan, in their prayers.

Let’s keep the Japenese in our prayers.

Just my two cents.

For what is worth.
:signofcross::gopray::gopray:
 
Source:

pajamasmedia.com/blog/fear-the-media-meltdown-not-the-nuclear-one/3/
  1. R. L. Hails Sr. P. E.
    The author gets a B, maybe a B+. Some of the comments get an F.
I engineered nine Boiling Water Reactors in the US, this plant may not be identical so maybe I am a tough/wrong grader. I have worked on a score of US nukes. Our fundamental problem is that we are getting a Niagara of bum information; I can not make sense of anything. The same thing happened at Three Mile Island (I am a personal friend of the engineer who saved that plant) and at Chernobyl (I was debriefed by technical experts who photographed the melted guts of that plant.) A few thoughts may help.

Eisenhower, a killer, formed a policy as President, Atoms for Peace. He stated a conundrum; either man uses this technology for peace or it will destroy us. The US never solved the riddle; we spend every few months, the entire first cost value of the nuclear industry, on our military. When the first designs were discussed, people like me told him that if every critical component was put in a steel pot, a containment, safety would be increased. He ordered: spend the money. These Japanese nukes have a fancy pot, called the light bulb and the donut, the drywell and the wetwell, or steam suppression pool. They are Mark I designs: I have engineered Mark II, and developed the Mark III. These are better than this early design.

There are several ways to design a nuke. One is better if you want bomb fuel, the graphite reactors like Chenobyl. Stalin wanted bombs; electricity was a by product. But in certain operational modes, it was thought, in the 1950s, that a graphite reactor might run away, explode, so there were a zillion pain-in-the-elbow systems to prevent this, designed by people like me, engineers. The plant manager jury rigged the plant to remove all the safety systems while it was running, and did an illegal test to prove engineers deserve our reputation. They took seven days, round the clock, to get ready. We learned the results, a few milliseconds into the test. Chenobyl had a containment; if the yanks had one, the commissars wanted one, but on the cheap. The Japanese containment is ~ 15 stories high, the Chenobyl containment is a closet with little inside, except pipes. Chenobyl’s core is laying in the parking lot, covered with dirt. TMI recovery people got the last pepper grain out of the pot. About 200 people were killed at Chenobyl fighting fires; all were volunteers and knew the score. Nobody died from nuclear energy at TMI; there were heart attacks.

The Japanese disaster will be worse than TMI, but not as bad as Chenobyl. All reactors were shut down for maintenance or immediately “shut down” with the earthquake detection. They are now fighting the residual heat, an ocean of heat, but perhaps 5 % of a roaring reactor. The heat lessens with every passing hour, in about a week, it will be “nuclearly cooled”. But even this situation requires cooling water, and pumps, for years.

If a core melts, the monster may awaken; no one has had the courage to test this “beyond design basis event”. My answer: daily Mass.

There are many “facts” which I can not understand. I read some from some PhD in Brussels, pure nonsense. Our problem is that the real experts are working round the clock in the plant, and have no time for anyone. Their handlers are technical dummies and misstate facts, and there are divisions of experts with a political bias. We are the victims of ignorance and lies. And I do not know everything.

Have courage, and pray for a grievously suffering people.

March 15, 2011 - 7:48 am Link to this Comment | Reply
Theres a very interesting page on wiki on ‘nuclear meltdown’. I spent a long time yesterday reading it slowly, only cause it has the type of language that tends to replace the words ‘deadly explosion’ with words like incident or movement etc.
But reading through all the different and mostly theoretical disaster scenarios which the article explains, and there are many, it seems that the japanese plant was victim to almost every unlikely, rare, and ‘in theory’ disaster which could happen to a nuclear plant.

The trouble with three mile island sounded serious on one hand but not serious after the event, the containment, the big building covering the reactor was too strong to be damaged by gas explosions and the meltdown was stopped accidently when molten core material froze in the base of the reactor vessel and that bit of frozen material seems to have saved the reactor.
But in japan it is almost like every thing was orchestrated to go wrong that could even only in theory be speculated about. Giant earthquake, oldish reactor, old fashioned containment, tsunami, pumps needed to cool reactor, backup generators, hydrogen explosions, no power to remove gas, damaged fuel rods, radioactive steam, everything went totally wrong in japan; in three-mile island it accidently stopped getting worse and it was safely held inside its containment anyway.
I am probably wrong in this but I thought I heard that a dentist uses 0.04millisev of xray radiation to make dental photographs, but I think the dentist disappears behind a protective screen when taking the xray photo and someone will correct me if I’m wrong but I though I heard that in Tokyo 200km away there were measurements of 1.4millisevs or 4.something, I don’t remember what the report said exactly except that it sounded like there was many times more radiation measured in tokyo than a dentist uses and I keep seeing that dentist disappearing behind a protective screen.
 
Finally some good news - I just read that they’ve got one of the emergency generators running, and there are fire trucks on the site putting water into the spent fuel pool.
 
Finally some good news - I just read that they’ve got one of the emergency generators running, and there are fire trucks on the site putting water into the spent fuel pool.
Fantastic. Thanks for posting it.

The crew that’s staying there and working are absolute heroes.
 
Engineers have connect a power line to the #Fukushima nuclear plant, allowing cooling pumps to be restarted. #Japan
The **@officialtepco **bio says “We sincerely apologise for causing serious worries and trouble over the accident” continued below
8 minutes ago via Twitter for iPad
CONFIRMED: Power is connected to the #Fukushima Daiichi No.1 Nuclear power plant. Reactor 2 first to be connected. #Japan
**Confirmed: **engineers were able to lay an external grid power line cable to unit 2 at #Fukushima Daiichi No.1 Nuclear plant
twitter.com/TepcoDisaster

Praying all be well.
 
Thought this was a nice article, by Larry Elder, giving a possible explanation of why the Japanese people have good as calm as they have been during this tragedy.

“Looters Missing In Action In Disaster-Sticken Japan”

investors.com/NewsAndAnalysis/Article/566360/201103171815/Looters-Missing-In-Action-In-Disaster-Sticken-Japan.htm

From it:
Culture and values explain the fear in Egypt and Libya of looting from museums that house precious historical and cultural artifacts.
Culture and values explain why in Los Angeles, a city with a 46% Hispanic population and a 10% Asian population, one sees no Latinos or Asians holding up “Will Work for Food” signs. When South Korea played for soccer’s 2010 World Cup, the Los Angeles Korean community received permits to view games on big-screen monitors in the streets near Koreatown. The police said the streets were more trash-free after the games than before.
Culture and values are not set in stone. They can and do change for the better — especially when we accept responsibility and stop blaming bad behavior on poverty. Plain and simple.
 
Outside electricity is now being supplied to the stricken Fukushima nuclear site. However, the effectiveness of this electricity is not yet clear.
According to Reuters, Tokyo Electric Power Co (TEPCO) said on Friday it had connected an external transmission line with the Fukushima Dai-ichi power plant, confirming that electricity can once again flow to the stricken facility.
The company said it “planned to supply Unit 2 first, followed by Unit 1, Unit 3 and Unit 4 … because Unit 2 is expected to be less damaged,” according to Reuters.
However, officials have said that even if power is restored, there is no guarantee the cooling system will work again.
cbsnews.com/stories/2011/03/18/501364/main20044547.shtml
 
The media hysteria seems to be dropping.

The evacuation of workers was only for an hour because they needed to get official permission to exceed normal limits on their film badges.

The coolant problem turned out to be in the used fuel storage “tanks” which had lost water.

The nuclear reactor containment vessels seem to be cooling down and seem to be intact.

Radiation leakage / exposure will be extremely limited in distance and intensity.

pajamasmedia.com/blog/fear-the-media-meltdown-not-the-nuclear-one/3/

mitnse.com/

And here are some articles on how they measure radiation:

Everybody used to be more or less happy with the “rad”, which was used “by the community” for a hundred years. 1917 or so.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rad_(unit

But then, some folks decided they weren’t happy with the rad, and I guess they wanted to honor another scientist [like when they changed cycles per second to Hertz], so they came up with the Sievert. Meanwhile, OTHER folks were also unhappy with the rad, so they created the “gray”.

It only makes sense among radiation physicists. Radiation is confusing enough because it is invisible and you need special instruments AND math to figure it out.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sievert

medpagetoday.com/Blogs/25376

sievert-system.org/WebMasters/en/index.html
 
The Japanese media is reporting that generators 1, 2 and 3 at Fukushima are stable at this time. Generators 4 and 5 are still in process. I’m not sure what this actually means, but here in Nagoya, some 500 kilometers away from Fukushima, life continues normally. Today began a 3 day weekend in Japan, so many people are taking the opportunity to leave Tokyo and points farther north to visit family in other parts of the country. Lets hope and pray that everything will be resolved before the cherry blossoms appear.
 
The Japanese media is reporting that generators 1, 2 and 3 at Fukushima are stable at this time. Generators 4 and 5 are still in process. I’m not sure what this actually means, but here in Nagoya, some 500 kilometers away from Fukushima, life continues normally. Today began a 3 day weekend in Japan, so many people are taking the opportunity to leave Tokyo and points farther north to visit family in other parts of the country. Lets hope and pray that everything will be resolved before the cherry blossoms appear.
I hope and pray that the generators are indeed stable.
 
Here is an excerpt from the current issue of the newsletter “The Week That Was”, available at www.sepp.org

THIS WEEK:
By Ken Haapala, Executive Vice President, Science and Environmental Policy Project (SEPP)

The dominant news this week was the disastrous earthquake …

Yet to the American popular press, …

Though not all, many of the reports, pronouncements by anti-nuclear groups, and comments by politicians play on the scientific ignorance of the general population concerning nuclear energy. Although it is premature for a thorough analysis, a tentative review of what happened is useful for evaluating various reports and comments on modern nuclear power from uranium.

Number of the Week: Three to five percent as compared with ninety percent plus. In general, naturally occurring uranium is made up of about 0.7% of the U-235 isotope, with the balance of U-238 isotope. U-235 can support a fission chain reaction, but U-238 cannot. Most modern nuclear power plants use uranium oxide in which the percentage of U-235 has been increased to 3 to 5%. Uranium nuclear weapons require that the percentage of U-235 be about 90% or above. Very simply, the fuel used in a modern nuclear power plant cannot create a nuclear explosion, even if it is in the correct configuration and has an appropriate trigger.

All six of the reactors at the Fukushima Daiichi power plant are Generation II boiling water reactors of GE design. The oldest is …

In a nuclear plant, the heat from the nuclear reaction is used to…

Adding to the difficulty, if the fuel rods are exposed to air / steam, the zirconium that coats the rods combines so strongly with oxygen, that it can strip oxygen from steam, forming free hydrogen. Hydrogen is so chemically reactive that it is not found in the atmosphere. It burns rapidly in the atmosphere, giving the impression of an explosion.

…

The US Geological Survey reports …

Northeastern Japan is in a geologic …

Apparently, the earthquake destroyed the electric grid to which …

About an hour later, the tsunami overwhelmed the sea wall …

When plant workers opened valves to release pressure…

The earthquake and tsunami effectively destroyed regular communications…

What appears to be the most prolonged problem were the pools used for cooling the fuel assemblies. …

As of this writing, the latest reports are that the reactors are cautiously under control and that the temperatures of the cooling pools are being stabilized. Much of the instrumentation failed, but, based on theory, it appears that a few percent of each active reactor cores had damage.

Although not confirmed, if the above fairly reflects what took place, then it can be a basis to evaluate some of the more excited claims in the press and by anti-nuclear groups and politicians.
  1. The reactors withstood the earthquake significantly above designed strength.
  2. Although the primary source of electricity failed, initially the backup systems worked as required.
  3. The reactors withstood the tsunami which was above planned height.
  4. The tsunami disabled the diesel generated backup of electricity and the battery backup was either disabled or inadequate.
  5. The destruction of the standard communications between the plant operators and corporate and national leaders lead to a slow decision to flood the active reactors with sea water, which destroyed them.
  6. The observed “explosions” were chemical, probably burning of free hydrogen.
  7. Some meltdown of active reactors probably occurred.
  8. Some of the cooling pools overheated, probably exposing the fuel rods and giving off hydrogen and radioactive gases.
  9. Thus far, except for the immediate area around the reactors, the radioactivity released has been insignificant.
From this natural disaster, we can learn that properly built nuclear plants can withstand powerful earthquakes and tsunamis. But backup cooling systems and any on-site cooling pools must be protected from any after effects of an earthquake. Cooling pools should be separated from the reactors. Also, solid communications must be available in spite of scope of the natural disaster.

… The plant Fukushima plant had Generation II reactors that require active safety features such manually opening valves and electricity to run cooling pumps. Among other features, Generation III reactors have passive safety systems that do not require manual effort or electricity to run cooling pumps. The Westinghouse AP 1000, is one such example: “designed to achieve and maintain safe shutdown condition without any operator action and without the need for ac power or pumps. Instead of relying on active components, such as diesel generators and pumps, the AP1000 relies on the natural forces of gravity, natural circulation, and compressed gases to keep the core and containment from overheating.”
ap1000.westinghousenuclear.com/ap1000_saf…

As expected, many anti-nuclear groups and politicians are making much of the natural disaster to include calling for stopping the approval process of Generation III reactors.

In light of this tragedy, it is prudent that nations address the safety of their nuclear power plants. However, the anti-nuclear groups are so adamant in their opposition to this reliable source of electricity, that they oppose new nuclear plants that address the design flaws of plants built 40 years ago.

(Please see Articles # 1, 2, 3, & 4 and articles referenced under “Calming the Fears of Nuclear Energy,” “Fanning the Fears of Nuclear Energy” and “Responses and Issues Remaining.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top