Here Alan, maybe this will help you.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, CCC 1933: “Liberation in the spirit of the Gospel is incompatible with hatred of one’s enemy as a person, but not with hatred of the evil that he does as an enemy.”
No offense brother, but I feel like you’re leaning towards moral relativism with some of your comments such as not knowing what is and isn’t truly sinful.
I hated it when a crazy man shot and killed Dr. Tiller, the infamous elective late-term abortion provider. Was I glad that Wichita would not longer be the nation’s abortion capital? Yes. Was I pleased that Dr. Tiller was dead? No. Was I pleased that the man who killed Tiller was a professed Christian? No. So do I say it was destructive, unfortunate, or evil that a man was killed? Yes. Do I say it was a sin? No. Because to declare it a sin, and therefore that the man had sinned, I must judge his intent. Last I heard, grave matter does NOT imply sin. Is that relativistic?
I hated it when a hitchhiker stole my wallet when I was far away from home. It caused me a lot of hassles. Did the hitchhiker do harm to me? Yes. Was I happy about it? No. Did the hitchhiker sin? That’s not for me to judge. Was a sin committed? Well, unless it was by the hitchhiker and I can judge the hitchhiker as having sinned, then I can’t say for sure.
Did I hate that the twin towers were attacked and thousands of people killed? Yes. Do I think it was an act of intense evil? Yes. Are the hijackers the source of that evil? That I can’t really say, maybe they’re just uneducated pawns, victims of brainwashing. As I understand it, they did it consistent with their beliefs in, and for the glory of, God as they understood God to be. Are they horrible wrong? Yes. Are they sinful in their hearts? Not for me to judge. So did they sin? By their own conscience, probably not. By God’s, I don’t dare presume to say.
Can we agree that there is a difference between an act that is evil and destructive, and one that is sinful? I think that destruction and things that cause human suffering are evil. God allows them and uses them to turn into good, but He neither willed them nor condoned them.
Once again, how can I say that something another person did is objectively a sin, unless I can read their heart? Does not sin require intent? I can instruct my brother if I’m afraid he’s falling into sin, but I must not claim that I know absolutely from what I can see on the outside, because only God can make a right judgment.
So it comes to an argument of semantics, again.
My concern is that we have so many ways of analyzing things, that IMO we completely miss whatever message Christ was trying to get across when He said, “do not judge.”
Did He mean that we can say, “Phil, old buddy. I have to tell you something. You have sinned and I feel it necessary to inform you that you can go to hell for it. I know that God is displeased with what you have done, and I’m here to warn you about it to save your immortal soul.”
Have I not judges the sinner, as well as the sin? No, I didn’t specifically say, “I think God should send you to hell for it” or “I’m certain God will send you to hell if you don’t repent,” but what else are you implying?
How about this: “Phil, buddy, I’m concerned about the way you are getting along with your secretary. From what I can tell, and if I were in your situation, I’d be concerned about temptation. It seems to me you are risking your relationship with your wife.” Now I have not accused the person of sin, but I have warned them against what I have seen that looks on the outside, to my fallible perspective, as a sin.
And there goes that label again, “relativistic.” For most of us, it’s a loaded word. It seems to imply that I think I know better than God how to interpret rules, and that I have no desire to comply with His rules but would rather do as I please and explain it with lots of rhetoric so it sounds like I wasn’t really doing wrong.
Actually, if you call me a “chameleon” or a “relativist,” then IMO, and in the way I personally interpret those terms, that puts my strategy right in line with that of St. Paul and I even have to guard against pride. Here is one viewpoint of the mindset that I call “relativistic” morality:
1 Cor 9:19-23:
Although I am free in regard to all, I have made myself a slave to all so as to win over as many as possible. To the Jews I became like a Jew to win over Jews; to those under the law I became like one under the law–though I myself am not under the law–to win over those under the law. To those outside the law I became like one outside the law–though I am not outside God’s law but within the law of Christ–to win over those outside the law. To the weak I became weak, to win over the weak. I have become all things to all, to save at least some. All this I do for the sake of the gospel, so that I too may have a share in it.
How is it that becoming “like one outside the law,” either in fact or in appearance, not relativistic? If we insist on absolutely sticking to the law as written and literally interpreted, then that would be deceptive and sinful. If you don’t think that’s relativistic, then that proves we need a thread to discuss what relativistic means, both literally and how it strikes the heart to hear the words.
If that passage doesn’t speak to you, let me know. There are others that may help illustrate my point.
Do I think we should act to please God and not second-guess what He tells us to do? Yes. Do I think that we can read any number of books, and determine in advance exactly what to do in any situation so that we have no wiggle room for interpretation and thus know exactly and absolutely what we must and mustn’t do? No. Impossible, says I.
Alan