Judging the sin, not the sinner

  • Thread starter Thread starter AlanFromWichita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have an idea.

This thread has strayed into a topic I think is crucial for useful discourse, so I’ll be happy to keep going on it. I wish to at least come to a general agreement that others are willing to join me in a discussion that goes beyond the literal meaning and into what this all means to our mental, emotional, and spiritual health.

When it comes time to get back to the original topic, I think i’ll start a new thread with a fresh start using a new approach and I’ll link to it here. That way people who might want to participate in the discussion, don’t have to wade through my failed attempts at communicated before getting to the “good stuff.”

Alan
 
OK, I will respond to this thread, but I am no longer going to try to share my original point here because we got off to a bad start.

I’ve tried another approach to the discussion; hopefully this one will be more interesting and useful to us.

Here is the new thread.

Alan
 
Actually it does. When we do something wrong against the law made by us,we will be judged by a “earthly” judge. When we sin against God,we will be judged by God. It is not so simple,because a lot of our law are adopted from the heavenly,but that is the best point,in my mind,to (somehow) try to explain why we should judge only the sin,not the sinner. OK,this theory of mine works well in a “perfect” world,but it may be good also in the world we live in now. As a lawyer I have seen just about all. Stupid people,clever people,people who think they are clever,people who think I am stupid and people who have no heart,and people who have more heart then they should. (And a great deal more kind of people I would not talk about over a dinner.) But they have all one thing that makes them almost equal,they all have done something wrong,or in some cases,they have not. But the judge has a hard time when it comes to punishment. The law in Finland is different from the one in USA or UK,our judges must “go by the numbers” meaning that there is very little room for creative judging and we don’t have a jury neither,so in the end it is up to the judge. But in that part of the Bible Jesus answers two questions. The second is who have the right to judge on earth. When we “sin” against a “earthly” law,we are judged here,but a sin against God is one He will judge. Sometimes we somehow manages to do wrong against both people and God,but for every “yes” there is a “but” as well. I could dig deeper in to this problem,but sadly I have not time,not now anyway. The final point is that we **must understand that we have no right to judge the sinner **(we put people in jail because we must protect others,there is no other reason,because prison is not the best place,in most of the cases,sometimes yes.) cause that is up to God. We judge the sin,and thats all. Hope you got sense out of this,I can do better,but not now. God bless.
 
The final point is that we **must understand that we have no right to judge the sinner **(we put people in jail because we must protect others,there is no other reason,because prison is not the best place,in most of the cases,sometimes yes.) cause that is up to God. We judge the sin,and thats all. Hope you got sense out of this,I can do better,but not now. God bless.
I really enjoyed your post. Thank you for taking the time to write it. I also have limited time; have to leave for work in a few minutes. I do want to comment briefly on your conclusion:

When you say “judge the sin,” then, I gather you mean that you have judged an act that is observably in opposition to an earthly law, with high probability? In general, this is a good thing because the laws give us a way to lock up the dangerous?

When you say, “judge the sinner,” then I assume you mean that you know what God thinks of this person – which is impossible because that involves knowing his heart.

I can agree with both of those viewpoints. If we define “sin” and “sinner” that way, then I withdraw my claims against the “sin but not sinner” saying.

By “sin,” though, from my view, I take it to mean they have sinned against God’s laws, thus made some decision that God will be unhappy with.

A person may go around breaking man’s laws and performing acts of “grave matter,” but as I understand it, in order to be a mortal sin it also has to have intent?

Would it be a venial sin if it were grave matter but honest, loving intent? That makes no sense to me. It’s be like saying you are guilty of a lesser crime just because you were accused of a greater crime.

What kind of a sin against God’s law, can we infallibly know whether another human being (or ourselves for that matter) is guilty of?

So in the US, the jury of peers decides the verdict, then in most cases the judge adminsters the sentence, and has some flexibility based on his individual thoughts about any given case. In the model that I hear being used by some on this thread, if God were the judge, than in certain cases He could just as well entrust us to be the jury, as He would trust Himself to play that role.

I think this is the problem some people have when they go around claiming they know exactly what God means and feels about something – anything at all.
1 Cor 8:1b-3:
… we realize that “all of us have knowledge”; knowledge inflates with pride, but love builds up. If anyone supposes he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know. But if one loves God, one is known by him.
Alan
 
In the case of unrepentant mortal sin, who goes to hell – the sin or the sinner?
 
If you don’t know the answer to that, you need more catechesis. 😉
The reason for my question to your question was because the thrust of this thread is about OUR judging, not God’s judging.

You said, “In the case of unrepentant mortal sin, who goes to hell – the sin or the sinner?”

Obviously we do not send someone to hell only God can do that so your comment seemed to be outside the scope of the thread.

If I misunderstood the thrust of you rcomment, I apologize.

Peace
James
 
I really enjoyed your post. Thank you for taking the time to write it. I also have limited time; have to leave for work in a few minutes. I do want to comment briefly on your conclusion:

When you say “judge the sin,” then, I gather you mean that you have judged an act that is observably in opposition to an earthly law, with high probability? In general, this is a good thing because the laws give us a way to lock up the dangerous?

When you say, “judge the sinner,” then I assume you mean that you know what God thinks of this person – which is impossible because that involves knowing his heart.

I can agree with both of those viewpoints. If we define “sin” and “sinner” that way, then I withdraw my claims against the “sin but not sinner” saying.

By “sin,” though, from my view, I take it to mean they have sinned against God’s laws, thus made some decision that God will be unhappy with.

A person may go around breaking man’s laws and performing acts of “grave matter,” but as I understand it, in order to be a mortal sin it also has to have intent?

Would it be a venial sin if it were grave matter but honest, loving intent? That makes no sense to me. It’s be like saying you are guilty of a lesser crime just because you were accused of a greater crime.

What kind of a sin against God’s law, can we infallibly know whether another human being (or ourselves for that matter) is guilty of?

So in the US, the jury of peers decides the verdict, then in most cases the judge adminsters the sentence, and has some flexibility based on his individual thoughts about any given case. In the model that I hear being used by some on this thread, if God were the judge, than in certain cases He could just as well entrust us to be the jury, as He would trust Himself to play that role.

I think this is the problem some people have when they go around claiming they know exactly what God means and feels about something – anything at all.

Alan
Well,in some cases the sinner get kind of two punishment. If he,or she,murders someone it against both “earthly” and “heavenly” law. In that case he or she will be judged both by our court and God as well. But because Gods understanding and forgiveness is far far beyond what we can ever understand,He may “free” the sinner/criminal if He sees that he or she really are sorry from the bottom of their heart and a ready to change what needs to be changed. A “earthly” judge or court can not do that. But the main point is still that the person who commit a crime [sin] is only the instrument,the deed comes from the evil it selfs. That is why,in my humble way at least try to be angry only for what the person has done,not the person himself. Sadly,to keep thees two a part,the person and the deed,is often very hard and I reckon it takes a lifetime to learn that.
 
Well,in some cases the sinner get kind of two punishment. If he,or she,murders someone it against both “earthly” and “heavenly” law. In that case he or she will be judged both by our court and God as well. But because Gods understanding and forgiveness is far far beyond what we can ever understand,He may “free” the sinner/criminal if He sees that he or she really are sorry from the bottom of their heart and a ready to change what needs to be changed. A “earthly” judge or court can not do that. But the main point is still that the person who commit a crime [sin] is only the instrument,the deed comes from the evil it selfs. That is why,in my humble way at least try to be angry only for what the person has done,not the person himself. Sadly,to keep thees two a part,the person and the deed,is often very hard and I reckon it takes a lifetime to learn that.
I don’t think we have any disagreements of substance. Our apparent disagreements sound rhetorical to me. We still don’t seem to be exactly synchronized on our usage of the terms “sin” and “crime,” and when we discuss the law, whose law and who’s enforcing it?

Still, I maintain that the saying, “judge the sin but not the sinner,” appears to me, at least on the surface, as being self-contradictory. I understand there may be explanations as for why it isn’t, based on nuances of the language. So I no longer claim that it is absolutely a contradiction, since others seem to have a way to explain it. As far as my opinion, though, it’s not only ambiguous but could lead a person to wrong behavior. That’s my opinion and is not debatable. My opinion could be wrong, and it may change in times, but for now, there it is.

Thank you again for you time and effort in explaining your views to me.

Alan
 
Here Alan, maybe this will help you.

Catechism of the Catholic Church, CCC 1933: “Liberation in the spirit of the Gospel is incompatible with hatred of one’s enemy as a person, but not with hatred of the evil that he does as an enemy.”

No offense brother, but I feel like you’re leaning towards moral relativism with some of your comments such as not knowing what is and isn’t truly sinful.
 
Here Alan, maybe this will help you.

Catechism of the Catholic Church, CCC 1933: “Liberation in the spirit of the Gospel is incompatible with hatred of one’s enemy as a person, but not with hatred of the evil that he does as an enemy.”

No offense brother, but I feel like you’re leaning towards moral relativism with some of your comments such as not knowing what is and isn’t truly sinful.
I hated it when a crazy man shot and killed Dr. Tiller, the infamous elective late-term abortion provider. Was I glad that Wichita would not longer be the nation’s abortion capital? Yes. Was I pleased that Dr. Tiller was dead? No. Was I pleased that the man who killed Tiller was a professed Christian? No. So do I say it was destructive, unfortunate, or evil that a man was killed? Yes. Do I say it was a sin? No. Because to declare it a sin, and therefore that the man had sinned, I must judge his intent. Last I heard, grave matter does NOT imply sin. Is that relativistic?

I hated it when a hitchhiker stole my wallet when I was far away from home. It caused me a lot of hassles. Did the hitchhiker do harm to me? Yes. Was I happy about it? No. Did the hitchhiker sin? That’s not for me to judge. Was a sin committed? Well, unless it was by the hitchhiker and I can judge the hitchhiker as having sinned, then I can’t say for sure.

Did I hate that the twin towers were attacked and thousands of people killed? Yes. Do I think it was an act of intense evil? Yes. Are the hijackers the source of that evil? That I can’t really say, maybe they’re just uneducated pawns, victims of brainwashing. As I understand it, they did it consistent with their beliefs in, and for the glory of, God as they understood God to be. Are they horrible wrong? Yes. Are they sinful in their hearts? Not for me to judge. So did they sin? By their own conscience, probably not. By God’s, I don’t dare presume to say.

Can we agree that there is a difference between an act that is evil and destructive, and one that is sinful? I think that destruction and things that cause human suffering are evil. God allows them and uses them to turn into good, but He neither willed them nor condoned them.

Once again, how can I say that something another person did is objectively a sin, unless I can read their heart? Does not sin require intent? I can instruct my brother if I’m afraid he’s falling into sin, but I must not claim that I know absolutely from what I can see on the outside, because only God can make a right judgment.

So it comes to an argument of semantics, again.

My concern is that we have so many ways of analyzing things, that IMO we completely miss whatever message Christ was trying to get across when He said, “do not judge.”

Did He mean that we can say, “Phil, old buddy. I have to tell you something. You have sinned and I feel it necessary to inform you that you can go to hell for it. I know that God is displeased with what you have done, and I’m here to warn you about it to save your immortal soul.”

Have I not judges the sinner, as well as the sin? No, I didn’t specifically say, “I think God should send you to hell for it” or “I’m certain God will send you to hell if you don’t repent,” but what else are you implying?

How about this: “Phil, buddy, I’m concerned about the way you are getting along with your secretary. From what I can tell, and if I were in your situation, I’d be concerned about temptation. It seems to me you are risking your relationship with your wife.” Now I have not accused the person of sin, but I have warned them against what I have seen that looks on the outside, to my fallible perspective, as a sin.

And there goes that label again, “relativistic.” For most of us, it’s a loaded word. It seems to imply that I think I know better than God how to interpret rules, and that I have no desire to comply with His rules but would rather do as I please and explain it with lots of rhetoric so it sounds like I wasn’t really doing wrong.

Actually, if you call me a “chameleon” or a “relativist,” then IMO, and in the way I personally interpret those terms, that puts my strategy right in line with that of St. Paul and I even have to guard against pride. Here is one viewpoint of the mindset that I call “relativistic” morality:
1 Cor 9:19-23:
Although I am free in regard to all, I have made myself a slave to all so as to win over as many as possible. To the Jews I became like a Jew to win over Jews; to those under the law I became like one under the law–though I myself am not under the law–to win over those under the law. To those outside the law I became like one outside the law–though I am not outside God’s law but within the law of Christ–to win over those outside the law. To the weak I became weak, to win over the weak. I have become all things to all, to save at least some. All this I do for the sake of the gospel, so that I too may have a share in it.
How is it that becoming “like one outside the law,” either in fact or in appearance, not relativistic? If we insist on absolutely sticking to the law as written and literally interpreted, then that would be deceptive and sinful. If you don’t think that’s relativistic, then that proves we need a thread to discuss what relativistic means, both literally and how it strikes the heart to hear the words.

If that passage doesn’t speak to you, let me know. There are others that may help illustrate my point.

Do I think we should act to please God and not second-guess what He tells us to do? Yes. Do I think that we can read any number of books, and determine in advance exactly what to do in any situation so that we have no wiggle room for interpretation and thus know exactly and absolutely what we must and mustn’t do? No. Impossible, says I.

Alan
 
Alan - I did not read through all of your examples above… just the first couple actually - but in each you said,
Do I say it was a sin? No. Because to declare it a sin, and therefore that the man had sinned, I must judge his intent…
Or
Did the hitchhiker sin? That’s not for me to judge…
While I applaud your intention not to condemn, I don’t think you can square this attitude with Mt 18:15-18 which begins with ""If your brother sins, go and show him his fault in private; if he listens to you, you have won your brother…

So - how can you (we) fulfill this command if we use your viewpoint?

Peace
James
 
Alan - I did not read through all of your examples above… just the first couple actually - but in each you said,
Do I say it was a sin? No. Because to declare it a sin, and therefore that the man had sinned, I must judge his intent…
Or
Did the hitchhiker sin? That’s not for me to judge…
While I applaud your intention not to condemn, I don’t think you can square this attitude with Mt 18:15-18 which begins with ""If your brother sins, go and show him his fault in private; if he listens to you, you have won your brother…

So - how can you (we) fulfill this command if we use your viewpoint?

Peace
James
Thank you for the excellent question. 👍

My first reaction is that it means, “if my brother has done what appears to me to be a sin,” in other words, we are called to make a guess based on what we observe and using human empathy to discern that there is first of all, destructive behavior, and possibly with intent – to the degree of certainty that we should feel obligated to intervene."

If I tell my brother, “brother, I believe you have sinned. I say this because I saw you do X. Please hear me and take heed. He who has ears, let him hear,” then I don’t see the problem with it. ❤️

If I tell my brother, “brother, I saw what you did, and it is intrinsically evil. Therefore you sinned in doing it, and I’m warning you because it might not be as obvious to you that you not only did destructive behavior, but in doing so you have revealed that you have no desire to be obedient to God,” then you have claimed to have infallibly made a “right” judgment even though you only are assuming intent because you can only imagine if you were in the other person’s situation and did what you just saw him do, then YOU would have been doing it with intent. http://bestsmileys.com/angry1/6.gif

Kind of like “judge and ye shall be judged,” or “sin is in the mind of the beholder,” type thing. (Gosh, there goes another allusion to that ugly “R” word again. 😛 )

I don’t know if that’s theologically correct, but that’s my first reaction. :cool:

Alan
 
Thank you for the excellent question. 👍
You are wlcome. Thank you for your sincere response.
My first reaction is that it means, “if my brother has done what appears to me to be a sin,” in other words, we are called to make a guess based on what we observe and using human empathy to discern that there is first of all, destructive behavior, and possibly with intent – to the degree of certainty that we should feel obligated to intervene."
My first reaction to this is, “why assume it means anything more or less than what it says?” Then reading the rest of your response I see how you distinguish in your approach to your brother…
If I tell my brother, “brother, I believe you have sinned. I say this because I saw you do X. Please hear me and take heed. He who has ears, let him hear,” then I don’t see the problem with it. ❤️
This is a good and sound approach.
If I tell my brother, “brother, I saw what you did, and it is intrinsically evil. Therefore you sinned in doing it, and I’m warning you because it might not be as obvious to you that you not only did destructive behavior, but in doing so you have revealed that you have no desire to be obedient to God,” then you have claimed to have infallibly made a “right” judgment even though you only are assuming intent because you can only imagine if you were in the other person’s situation and did what you just saw him do, then YOU would have been doing it with intent. http://bestsmileys.com/angry1/6.gif
This approach has an initial element that is good and right but proceeds to a conclusion that is not right. It is perfectly acceptable to warn a brother that his action(s) are intrinsically evil and therefore sinful. But one jumps the track when one concludes from that that his brother has no desire to be obedient to God.
So - While you have judged rightly that the act or acts ARE sinful (judge the sin) it should stop here unless the brother refuses to recognize the sinful nature of the acts and the “wrong thinking” that is behind it. In such a case then one would need to move on to the next stages of instruction given in Mt 18:15-18.
Kind of like “judge and ye shall be judged,” or “sin is in the mind of the beholder,” type thing. (Gosh, there goes another allusion to that ugly “R” word again. 😛 )
I don’t know if that’s theologically correct, but that’s my first reaction. :cool:
I hope some of my explanation above is of help. It is indeed a tricky subject to get around.

Something else that you might wish to consider is that neither the Greek or the hebrew for “Sin” means “Crime”, which I think is how most people interpret the term sin today.
Chata’ (Hebrew)
to sin, miss, miss the way, go wrong, incur guilt, forfeit, purify from uncleanness
Hamartano, (Greek)
To be without a share in; to miss the mark; to err, be mistaken; to miss or wander from the path of uprightness and honor; to do or go wrong; to wander from the law of God, violate God’s law, sin
In both cases we see sin as being “error”. Being on the wrong path or road. Actions point to attitude. The real sin (error) is not so much in the action as in the underlying error that give justification to the act.
I believe this is what St James is speaking to when he speaks about faith requiring works and he’ll show his faith by his works. Jesus also speaks of a tree bearing fruit. Actions - our fruits - are not something in and of themselves but spring from either right thinking or wrong thinking. Correctness or error.

Just some more to consider.

Peace
James
 
This approach has an initial element that is good and right but proceeds to a conclusion that is not right. It is perfectly acceptable to warn a brother that his action(s) are intrinsically evil and therefore sinful. But one jumps the track when one concludes from that that his brother has no desire to be obedient to God.
So if I understand you, I can restate it as it doesn’t have to have “intent” to be a sin?

As far as making the conclusion you say we can’t make, I fully agree with you. For better or worse, I said that with an agenda – because I’ve seen threads that go through approximately that logical loop.
So - While you have judged rightly that the act or acts ARE sinful (judge the sin) it should stop here unless the brother refuses to recognize the sinful nature of the acts and the “wrong thinking” that is behind it. In such a case then one would need to move on to the next stages of instruction given in Mt 18:15-18.
I see the scripture you quoted as being useful for public safety purposes, but I have some things I noticed that could lead one to wonder if it contradict’s Jesus’ command (or recommendation) not to judge.

On earth, there are people intent on preventing us from worshiping and even gathering to pray and learn and receive the sacraments.

Some members of the body of Christ have the job of protecting our borders. :knight2:

Other members have the job of feeding the hungry however they got here. 🍕

These do not conflict, they are different functions. :hug3:

I would very much dislike the job of a security guard, because I hate it when people are coerced to submit to my authority because of bribes or threats if they do or don’t, respectively. But that’s how you have to get through to some people in order to protect others’ God given rights. For my own work, I’d rather stay behind the lines and do what I can from back here. :o

But I appreciate those who do protect our sacred boundaries. 👍

Alan
 
So if I understand you, I can restate it as it doesn’t have to have “intent” to be a sin?
Something that is intrinsically evil is a sin regardless of intent…Yes.
However there may be extenuating circumstances that might mitigate the gravity of the sin.

For instance stealing is a sin…"Thou shall not covet thy neighbor’s goods. In an earlier post you said:
I hated it when a hitchhiker stole my wallet when I was far away from home. It caused me a lot of hassles. Did the hitchhiker do harm to me? Yes. Was I happy about it? No. Did the hitchhiker sin? That’s not for me to judge.
You say it is not your place to say whether the hitchhiker sinned…Well lets examine this.
Did the hitchhiker covet your goods? Yes.
Did he violate the commandment about coveting? Yes.
Did he treat you as he would wish to be treated?
Does this violate a commandment? Yes (the second greatest commandment Mt 22:36-40)
Given the answers to the above questions - and we need not know the intent, we can confidently say that this person sinned.

Now, you wish to say - “I don’t know his intent, maybe he was starving. Maybe there was some other extenuating circumstance.”
You may be right. There may well be extenuating circumstances. And these could conceivably reduce the culpability, but it they do not make a sin not a sin…
I don’t see “intent” covered in the 10 commandments. I DO see intent mentioned in the two great commandments… the Intent to Love…Is it loving to rob a man who is a long way from home?
As far as making the conclusion you say we can’t make, I fully agree with you. For better or worse, I said that with an agenda – because I’ve seen threads that go through approximately that logical loop.
That may be. I simply dealt with the statement as made.
I see the scripture you quoted as being useful for public safety purposes, but I have some things I noticed that could lead one to wonder if it contradict’s Jesus’ command (or recommendation) not to judge.
I agree that it is useful for public safety. I also see it as useful for spiritual safety of the body of Christ - The Church. I do NOT see it as contradicting Christ’s command not to judge since the person has every opportunity to express any extenuating circumstances - that is to make known his heart - to you and to others and even to The Church.

Peace
James
 
Something that is intrinsically evil is a sin regardless of intent…Yes.
OK. Until and unless someone objects, then I am going to assume starting in this post, that acts can be absolutely determined by outward observation, to be a sin.

Now when I say “absolutely,” I mean infallibly. That means, for example, you have to exclude the possibility that you are actually hallucinating or suffering from delusional thinking. I have experience at delusions and have close friends who know about hallucinating. For us, we can see a blatant sin and come up with a way to see it as an unselfish act of love – modeled directly after something Jesus did – or we can see something that is perfectly OK and be convinced beyond any doubt that it is intrinsically evil. I could write a book of examples, but in one case I was playing the organ (I was the only one in the organ loft) of a church, when I became very afraid of the crucifix, and had a pretty good idea that satan had replaced the original statue of Jesus’s body on the cross, with a live minion of His own. I ducked down behind the wall and hid during Mass because I was convinced satan was using this phony crucifix to influence my music in some way to convey his evil to the crowd. I only got up when I had to play, and each time before I played I prayed to the Lord to take my music and do with it what He will, not what I will.

Why did I tell that story? One reason is that I am familiar with what it is like to think of things from radically different points of view. I do not assume anybody else shares my own understanding of anything to the degree where I could buy into it as being absolute and infallible.
You say it is not your place to say whether the hitchhiker sinned…Well lets examine this.
Did the hitchhiker covet your goods? Yes.
Did he violate the commandment about coveting? Yes.
Did he treat you as he would wish to be treated?
Does this violate a commandment? Yes (the second greatest commandment Mt 22:36-40)
Given the answers to the above questions - and we need not know the intent, we can confidently say that this person sinned.
I hear what you’re trying to explain I think, that a sin can be defined outside of knowing intent.

However, picking on this example a bit, I notice the term “covet.” What does “covet” mean? By my understanding of the word “covet” I think it implies that you have a desire for it above and beyond need for survival – and hence implies reading one’s mind.
I DO see intent mentioned in the two great commandments… the Intent to Love…Is it loving to rob a man who is a long way from home?
Thank you for this example. To me, it is an act of unlove against me, but once again, how do I know his love for his family and his obligation to feed them is what drove his behavior – either thinking nothing about it or thinking that it was a choice between family’s survival or needed medical care, and my inconvenience. In the interest of self-defense, I can give him the benefit of the doubt that he may have been filled with love, but I just didn’t feel it at a the time.
I agree that it is useful for public safety. I also see it as useful for spiritual safety of the body of Christ - The Church. I do NOT see it as contradicting Christ’s command not to judge since the person has every opportunity to express any extenuating circumstances - that is to make known his heart - to you and to others and even to The Church.
Now I have challenges for you. How, exactly, do you see judgment as useful from a spiritual standpoint? I can think of some ways, but I want to hear your opinion based on the statements you’re making.

If you accuse the person and then find him not guilty after considering more evidence, then have you not effectively judged him just to make the indictment? You may not be able to prove he is guilty, but in indicting him you are at least saying, “I believe that you, based on what I’ve seen of your external behavior, is somebody that I cannot trust to be above the sin I’m accusing you of.” To me, in the spiritual realm we have already judged.

Maybe I can state my idea like this: if I suspect my brother of a sin, then in my heart I have judged him capable of doing it, and thereby have called his righteousness into question. Acquittal down the line may prevent certain punishment, but we’ve already punished the person by the fallout from the accusation itself, so basically an accusation is a punishment.

For example, if my wife accuses me of being unfaithful based on what she has learned and believes it is sufficient evidence to raise the issue, then she has already expressed distrust in me, and whether or not I did it, and whether or not she can prove her case, the spiritual damage to the marriage is already done.

There is an advertising campaign by an insurance company that I think is not only funny, but does an excellent job of conveying the message, “don’t jump to conclusions.” In each of these cases, it seems like we have enough evidence to indict or even convict a person of doing terrible things. I mentioned this earlier in this thread or another, but didn’t link to it because I thought it might bother some. Now I think it is useful for the discussion, so I’ll link to it with the following caution. If you ignore the caution and are offended, don’t say I didn’t warn you. I think it makes an important enough point to watch it unless it is offensive.

CAUTION: there are references to vulgar and possibly disturbing behavior. If you won’t be offended, and want examples of why we should be very careful in judging each other, then I’m not giving a link, but you might find by searching Youtube with keywors: don’t judge too quickly we won’t ameriquest

Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top