Just turtles all the way down

  • Thread starter Thread starter jofa
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jofa

Guest
Some of you have heard the story of the woman who was arguing that the world wasn’t suspended in space but sat on the back of a turtle. When asked what the turtle was perched on, she responded " it’s just turtles all the way down". Similarily,most athiests I’ve spoken to about “first cause” for creation respond with “there was no first cause - it just goes back indefinitley”. Any ideas how to counter this? Obviously dealing with people who aren’t deeply familiar with philosophy…
Thanks,
Sandra
 
Some of you have heard the story of the woman who was arguing that the world wasn’t suspended in space but sat on the back of a turtle. When asked what the turtle was perched on, she responded " it’s just turtles all the way down". Similarily,most athiests I’ve spoken to about “first cause” for creation respond with “there was no first cause - it just goes back indefinitley”. Any ideas how to counter this? Obviously dealing with people who aren’t deeply familiar with philosophy…
Thanks,
Sandra
Refutation in one sentence: “Granted that there is no empirical evidence for anything before the big bang, prove it.”

Turtles all the way down (and the causal multiple universe theory associated with it) is merely a faith based statement, one for which there is no evidence whatsoever.
 
Similarily,most athiests I’ve spoken to about “first cause” for creation respond with “there was no first cause - it just goes back indefinitley”.
Astronomy and astrophysics don’t currently support that theory.

In addition, the atheist viewpoint is insufficient in explaining the fine tuned universe that developed in support of intelligent life within our galaxy, in our universe, on Earth.

Intelligent design is also found in our DNA.
 
Dosent the turtles all the way down explanation also support our assertion that God has always existed. I mean we also advocate a belief in an unmoved mover.
 
Similarily,most athiests I’ve spoken to about “first cause” for creation respond with “there was no first cause - it just goes back indefinitley”.
So there’s an eternal regression of causes? How religious-sounding :P…
 
Dosent the turtles all the way down explanation also support our assertion that God has always existed. I mean we also advocate a belief in an unmoved mover.
The difference is that the “turtles” must be standing on something, whereas God doesn’t. “Turtles” don’t just float on nothing, holding up everything above them. The same is true for every material chain of causes. An immaterial being that is its own being isn’t empirically verifiable, but it doesn’t require a chain of causes beyond itself.

Peace and God bless!
 
thanks for reply. I just wanna make sure i got this right:

Turtle Lady is wrong because the turtles must stand on something. This is because turtles are physical things which take up finite amounts of space,

We (Christians) are right because God is not a physical thing, we dont critically investigate at what point in time God came into being because he is immaterial and transcends the concept of time and space itself. Therfore its approriate for one to say “Its God all the way down”

Question is why cant you say turtles all the way down? if God can get a pass simply by saying “well he is immaterial” then why cant we just say the chain of turtles is immaterial in that in goes on forever.
 
Question is why cant you say turtles all the way down? if God can get a pass simply by saying “well he is immaterial” then why cant we just say the chain of turtles is immaterial in that in goes on forever.
They are both faith based statements, however, one is backed by what we call “compelling proof” (miracles, personal experiences/accounts, the ability to make real predictions, etc) and the other is backed by absolutely no proof whatsoever.

It was Judeo-Christianity that stood alone in predicting that the universe had a beginning for thousands of years until science could finally catch up to this reality about 50 years ago.

It is judeo christianity that logs hundreds and hundreds of authenticated miracles which are not explanable by science.

Turtles offer no evidence whatsoever. They are simply invisible turtles that someone thinks up.
 
Question is why cant you say turtles all the way down? if God can get a pass simply by saying “well he is immaterial” then why cant we just say the chain of turtles is immaterial in that in goes on forever.
Well, I think the most apparent answer is that turtles are not immaterial, they are material. I think your question is this though: couldn’t someone argue that there is an immaterial infinite cause that is not God? Not really. The problem is that most scientific naturalists deny there is any such thing as “immaterial” being. Even if it were admitted that an immaterial thing could exist that caused the creation of the universe, that is precisely the basic philosophical definition of God from the Cosmological Argument. He is the uncaused cause that is the foundation of all existence.
 
The absurdity of infinite regression is easily seen in the analogous absurdity of the ball that will never reach you. A ball thrown at you must first make it half way to you. It then makes it half way between that point and the thrower, and then to the half way point between that point and the thrower again. There is never a point at which the half way point is negated, no matter how small it is, thus the ball will never get to you. … It is when they catch the ball that infinite regression is refuted, if they were interested in a truthful answer in the first place.

Another answer is that nothing causes itself. This is seen in God’s Creation (Rom 1:20) and is applied to God as the source of, and basis for, causes and causation. The problem is that today’s mechanistic and materialistic basis for truth is deficient and cannot attain the true metaphysical causality known in the full Aristotelian sense. Causality is seen through the deficient mechanistic philosophy and it causes its own absurdities, like Dawkins’ “bowling ball appearing out of nowhere” view of causality written about in “The God Delusion”.

Where this ends, I think, is that no one will be given an answer that will convict them to believe. The proof they seek, and know they will not find, is one of force, a proof of 2+2=4 related to God. It is just not that way in this world, and they will accept absurdity before they accept God. It isn’t up to us to convert or convince them, but to remain faithful, truthful, and giving in charity because our answers to their inanities happen only seldom, but God’s answers to them are rejected continuously and at deeper levels than we can ever influence. The prayer and sacrifice for those whom God wills for us to help is infinitely more efficacious than intellectual sparing, even with those mental midgets faithful to regressive absurdities.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top