Kresta - A Catholic America

  • Thread starter Thread starter buffalo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

buffalo

Guest
A few day ago Al Kresta was advocating a Catholic America.

Do you want a Catholic America?
 
What do you mean/ what did he mean by “a Catholic America”. If you mean an America in which the majority of people are Catholic and that Catholic faith informs public decisions, then yes, of course I want a Catholic America.
 
I’m not an American, but I voted yes 😃

Let me explain, though. Throughout human history, at certain points in times, certain nations have had the power to influence others for good or evil. In the past, this was mainly through actual conquest and governance (such as the Greek or Roman Empires, or the British Empire for a more recent example), but in the post-WWI and WWII world, it has been possible to achieve this degree of influence (or, to put it colloquially, to be a “super-power”) through economic and cultural means.

America has occupied that place for some time, and though there are some apparent cracks in the edifice (for nothing human is infallible), it will probably continue to do so for that time.

Given this, a Catholic America would be very good news (feel free to capitalize that last phrase if you will…) not just for Americans, but for the rest of the world that is dependent on (or more accurately, “interdependent with”) them.
 
Yes, of course I do-as long as that choice was made freely and not by force. If you ask a Protestant if they want a Protestant America, or a vegan if they want a Vegan American, they’d say the same thing, hopefully.

I have a problem if it’s by force-IE a goverment edict demanding everyone is Catholic/Jewish/Agnostic/Yankee fan (the true spreaders of evil in the world)
 
****I long for a Catholic America, but would be content in a Christian America too. I wish I lived in the 1950s. A safer, happier and more innocent time for our society.

 
Yes, of course I do-as long as that choice was made freely and not by force. If you ask a Protestant if they want a Protestant America, or a vegan if they want a Vegan American, they’d say the same thing, hopefully.

I have a problem if it’s by force-IE a goverment edict demanding everyone is Catholic/Jewish/Agnostic/Yankee fan (the true spreaders of evil in the world)
Kresta made the point that Protestants had their chance and failed. Now it is time to let Catholics have a whack at it and support it.
 
Kresta made the point that Protestants had their chance and failed. Now it is time to let Catholics have a whack at it and support it.
We’re a Christian nation-Protestant/Catholic/Mormon/whatever. That works for me.
 
What would a Catholic America look like?

A Catholic America would be more self-governing, moral, ethical and principled. Families would be strong and encourage. A Catholic America would be a Culture of Life. It would be charitable.

It would require less resources spent on controlling the population. It would practice subsidiarity and distributism.

Government would once again be for the people, by the people.
 
It would require less resources spent on controlling the population. It would practice subsidiarity and distributism.

.
I agree with everything else you said, but if it means the goverment takes more of my money by force and gives it to other people-I’ll move to a more free country. Like Soviet Russia! 😉
 
Especially for racial, religious, and cultural minorities.:rolleyes:
👍

It’s actually better to be alive today then in any other time in human history, but people don’t understand that. I particulary like when people complain about how bad it is today on…the…internet…which wasn’t around back in 1950. I’m sure that people in 1950 complained about how good it was back in the 1920’s, etc, et
 
I know, in the 50’s, we could not all get on the forums and talk about how “great” the 50’s were.:cool:

…the 20’s were far cooler than the 50’s anyway actually;)
That’s why I still have my zoot suit! Zoot suit riot!
 
👍

It’s actually better to be alive today then in any other time in human history, but people don’t understand that. I particulary like when people complain about how bad it is today on…the…internet…which wasn’t around back in 1950. I’m sure that people in 1950 complained about how good it was back in the 1920’s, etc, et
Actually, the high point of Catholicism was the 1300’s or so.

By the way - manual labor and hard work is not necessarily a bad thing. I guess it depends on what one is measuring.
 
Actually, the high point of Catholicism was the 1300’s or so.

By the way - manual labor and hard work is not necessarily a bad thing. I guess it depends on what one is measuring.
Where in the world did you get that I was against manual labor/hard work? And…ok…the high point of Catholicism WAS in the 1300’s. Yup. Great. I don’t know, I’m not a historian. So what’s your point?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top