Laws as prevention vs punishment

  • Thread starter Thread starter HerCrazierHalf
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

HerCrazierHalf

Guest
Are laws just a definition of prohibited actions with penalties? Or should laws be crafted to make the commission of serious crimes more difficult?

For example, a person working a normal job has their taxes automatically withheld. By default they cannot commit tax evasion without actively falsifying their tax returns. In this case the law makes it difficult to commit serious crimes.

OTOH most newer cars are electronically prevented from exceeding the whatever speed the manufacturer deems stable. But that’s above the speed limit pretty much everywhere. Breaking the speed limit is trivially easy.

I’m sure other examples are out there
 
It’s probably both. Initially, someone does something bad, so society creates a law against. Later if it still happens, more laws are created to prevent it or reduce the chances it will happen. That continues until the crime rate stabilizes. The hard part is figuring out what laws to create. Many times when people commit a crime it’s not clear what laws would stop it. Then there may also people that don’t want their freedom restricted. For example gun control laws may reduce the number of shootings at the cost of legitimate gun owners having to jump through more hoops to remain in compliance.
 
This is an interesting question, because I recently heard that people who are not exposed to a certain temptation do not develop skills to avoid the sin and are therefore not really virtuous in that area.

If our laws were set up in such a way that no one faced the temptation (the opening) to do it, they would not become more virtuous; therefore, perhaps it would be better to avoid reducing the temptation+ability to maintain order.
 
There’s an entire subject area called “law and economics” or similar names that is all about deciding on the basis of costs and benefits what laws should be made and what the punishment should be for violations. Technological limitations on lawbreaking, such as cars that don’t exceed a certain speed or digital media with antitheft technology built in, would be similarly evaluated on a cost-benefit basis.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top