LDS Church to Go Forward with Scouting Program

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So is the LDS church changing it’s beliefs?
The LDS change their beliefs all the time. It would be wholly unsurprising to me if the “prophets” had a new “revelation” that said homosexuality was A-OK because that is the way the culture is going and it would be unpopular of them to remain with the teaching that it is wrong. Much in the same way that they repudiated the practice of polygamy after it proved to be inconvenient for them.
 
It might not be VIEWED as such by all, but that does not change the reality that morality IS objective.
I don’t think we’re effectively communicating here. I’ve not said that morality is truly subjective – the point is that in a society like ours (which is not a theocracy), many community members disagree about what is moral and what isn’t moral. Simply telling them to accept Catholic morality isn’t going to work. Beating them with Catholic morality is also likely to fail.

There are plenty who accept the BSA’s decision as perfectly moral (and to be fair, there are lots of ways to interpret “morally straight” that have nothing to do with heterosexuality). Of course, what’s interesting here is the LDS Church’s decision to accept the BSA’s decision. I don’t really have a problem with either since I don’t see gay men as inherent predators of children, and I also recognize that as Catholics, we aren’t called to shun them. 🤷
 
I don’t think we’re effectively communicating here. I’ve not said that morality is truly subjective – the point is that in a society like ours (which is not a theocracy), many community members disagree about what is moral and what isn’t moral. Simply telling them to accept Catholic morality isn’t going to work. Beating them with Catholic morality is also likely to fail.

There are plenty who accept the BSA’s decision as perfectly moral (and to be fair, there are lots of ways to interpret “morally straight” that have nothing to do with heterosexuality). Of course, what’s interesting here is the LDS Church’s decision to accept the BSA’s decision. I don’t really have a problem with either since I don’t see gay men as inherent predators of children, and I also recognize that as Catholics, we aren’t called to shun them. 🤷
I understand that, but if you go back to earlier in the thread, you will see I am taking about a Catholic Troop encountered a ‘married’ set of male leaders.

We cannot tell our boys anything other than such a situation being a violation of the Scout Oath.
 
I don’t really have a problem with either since I don’t see gay men as inherent predators of children, and I also recognize that as Catholics, we aren’t called to shun them. 🤷
I’m not sure that the objection to homosexuals in leadership roles is rooted in the identification of them as predators, although this is probably in some people’s minds. An open, practicing homosexual is setting a bad example for youth – by word or by act he is teaching youth that homosexual behavior is morally acceptable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top