S
SteveVH
Guest
That is a very Catholic teaching.May I speculate a bit here? I admit, it’s pure speculation, but I have thought about this issue as well.
A lot.
I think that…all religions have truth in them, even the most outlandish (by our lights, anyway) Even if everything around this truth is offbase, the ‘truth’ is still there, and still ‘true.’
I think what you say is true, but there is another side to this and that is the amount of error that may be present in any given faith tradition.For instance, suppose we have a Catholic, a Mormon, and a Muslim…and they all teach the 'Golden Rule." (Most religions do).
Suppose that someone, praying to know the truth of this precept, gets confirmation from the Holy Ghost that yes, treating your neighbor as you would wish to be treated is 'the way to go."
Now I think that, in many cases, the investigator will take that confirmation of that one truth…and hang all the context in which that truth is found on it. So, if the rule is true in Islam, the believer might figure that everything else about Islam is true, too. The same would go for Catholicism and Mormonism and Hinduism and, and, and…
Like finding a diamond in the dirt and deciding that the rest of the mountain is diamonds, too, without really paying attention.
I think that’s a pretty good part of it. There are a lot of other factors, too.
Well, that’s what I think, anyway.
Now, we believe as Catholics that our dogmas and doctrines are protected from error by the Holy Spirit, who Jesus said would guide us into all truth. And, obviously, if any one varies from these truths we believe they are in error to one degree or another.
The big difference between Catholicism and Mormonism is that we don’t claim new revelation, as you know, but rather defend and guard the truth handed down to us from the Apostles themselves. So we really never have the same dilemma; do I accept this new revelation or not?
But as for depending upon the Holy Spirit to confirm a teaching as true or erroneous, we do not believe the Holy Spirit works that way. He protects the Church from teaching error and we are to listen to the Church (the pillar and foundation of truth) rather than what we might believe to be the voice of Holy Spirit. There are other voices out there as well and we can be fooled.