LDS to Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Faith1960
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi! My story is weird. I come from a dual religion family. Mom is Catholic, and so I was baptized as a baby. But she wasn’t much of a church goer, (we did attend holiday Mass, but my knowledge of the Catholic Church was pretty much, we dress up and go for Easter/Christmas) so when my dad, who is Mormon, decided to become active again, it was decided he’d take over our religious upbringing. I remember enjoying Sunday school, and having a general good time with my friends there, but felt pressured into getting baptized. All my friends were doing it, my teachers encouraged it, and my dad seemed confused when I said I wasn’t sure. But, he did allow me the time and space I needed. By the time I was 11 (Mormons raised in the church generally get baptized at 8) my friends commented about how odd it was I wasn’t baptized. So, when my sister got baptized, I joined her.

I won’t get into the whole experience, but I remember my dad went from casual activity, to super active, there every week, and we had zero choice, even as we grew older. I grew to loathe church, because it wasn’t something I chose to participate in. I HAD to go. Then, there was the fact that, the older I got, the more the things I was being taught just didn’t make sense. (Again, that’s a whole different thread.) finally, about 17, I informed my parents that I would no longer be going. For some reason, me standing my ground, or maybe it was the fact that I was about to be an adult soon anyway, had them agreeing I could make that choice. (Later, when I returned from military duty, my dad stated I’d have to go to church if I wanted to live in his house. That lasted a couple months…because at this time, I REALLY didn’t believe. All I had to do was stand my ground again.) The church managed to sucker me into giving it another try a couple more times, the last, resulting in me going crazy, because they would not leave me alone when I’d finally had enough.

But because I didn’t believe what the church taught me, I spent (and still spend) many hours studying various religions. One day, a couple years ago, I was chatting with my mom about religion, and how Mormonism didn’t fit with me. I explained the beliefs I’d formed after my own reflections, and come to find out, they aligned very much with Catholicism.

I haven’t fully crossed over, because my dad seems to take personal offense at my desire to not attend Mormon church. (My daughter, who went with him until recently has chosen to stop attending church, seminary, and all other activities as well.) it doesn’t sit well with him, and he still tries to push it, for example, demanding we pray (the Mormon way) over meals when we dine together. My daughter, brave child, says the dinner prayer she learned from my mom. I’m not so brave, so if he calls on me, I mumble out something passable for him.

I know if I fully convert, (is it converting if I was already baptized?) he’ll lose his mind, and I’ll get talked about, like my bro and sis. “This is happening to them, because they left the church…” Type remarks. I might not hear the remarks, but I know he makes them, and gets angry when he tries to push the issue. “If you don’t want to be Mormon, call Utah and have them remove you!” It’s like a dare. (My dad is really a cool guy, but when it comes to religion…I just try to lie low, because he’s so passionate about his beliefs.)

So, that’s my story. I’m not the best church goer when it comes to Catholicism either, but I’m trying to be better about that.

As for leaving the Mormon church? I live in the town I grew up in. I still have friends in the church. News would spread like wildfire, and I’m not ready to deal with a bunch of well meaning friends trying to change my mind.
xpirategrrlx -

Know that you are not alone in your search. This happens not only with Mormons, but with Lutherans, Baptist’s, Methodists etc.

Catholic.com is a great resource for you, not only the forums but the library as well. You can type in just about any subject and get a list of articles / resources. The “Tracts” in particular make good reading.

I also would suggest a couple of things when and if you are ready:
  • visit your local Catholic Church and talk to the Priest. They are there to answer your questions and may set you up with someone in the Church that you can speak to on a regular basis. RCIA (Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults) is the how adults normally come into the Church. Weekly classes start in August, ending with initiation into the Church on the Easter Vigil (Today by coincidence!).
  • Try to attend the Catholic Mass regularly. There are numerous times, from Saturday to Sunday. The Priest may have resources so that you can follow along and understand. “Liturgy” is foreign to your background so some explanation is necessary.
Be prepared for criticism from friends and family. You are on a journey, and sometimes it’s one that divides. But the Truth is worth it! This includes receiving the resurrected Christ in the Eucharist, His Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity.

Praying for you tonight!

(a plug for RebeccaJ and Iepuras … PM them with any questions that you might have… they and others have walked directly in your shoes)
 
xpirategrrlx -

Know that you are not alone in your search. This happens not only with Mormons, but with Lutherans, Baptist’s, Methodists etc.

Catholic.com is a great resource for you, not only the forums but the library as well. You can type in just about any subject and get a list of articles / resources. The “Tracts” in particular make good reading.

I also would suggest a couple of things when and if you are ready:
  • visit your local Catholic Church and talk to the Priest. They are there to answer your questions and may set you up with someone in the Church that you can speak to on a regular basis. RCIA (Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults) is the how adults normally come into the Church. Weekly classes start in August, ending with initiation into the Church on the Easter Vigil (Today by coincidence!).
  • Try to attend the Catholic Mass regularly. There are numerous times, from Saturday to Sunday. The Priest may have resources so that you can follow along and understand. “Liturgy” is foreign to your background so some explanation is necessary.
Be prepared for criticism from friends and family. You are on a journey, and sometimes it’s one that divides. But the Truth is worth it! This includes receiving the resurrected Christ in the Eucharist, His Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity.

Praying for you tonight!

(a plug for RebeccaJ and Iepuras … PM them with any questions that you might have… they and others have walked directly in your shoes)
👍 Great post!
 
By the way I don’t know if anyone here has found her but there is a convert to Catholicism from Mormonism that has the title servant of God her name was Cora Evans.
 
Hi! My story is weird. I come from a dual religion family. Mom is Catholic, and so I was baptized as a baby. …
I know if I fully convert, (is it converting if I was already baptized?)
When someone was validly baptized, as you were as a baby, they are baptized forever. You were baptized Catholic, you died with Christ in the waters of baptism and were given new life. If you attended RCIA you would be considered a candidate not catechumen. My brother like you was baptized as a baby and received no other sacraments, I’ve been trying to get him to consider RCIA for some time.
 
Thank you to those who have given me, and the others in this thread great advice! I was out of town for the past week, so I was only just able to get around to responding. (International fees can be crazy, and the wifi was iffy.)

I’ve been investigating off and on for the past couple years, but I really think I’m ready to take that last step, and actually move forward in my journey. 🙂
 
Thank you to those who have given me, and the others in this thread great advice! I was out of town for the past week, so I was only just able to get around to responding. (International fees can be crazy, and the wifi was iffy.)

I’ve been investigating off and on for the past couple years, but I really think I’m ready to take that last step, and actually move forward in my journey. 🙂
God bless you on your faith journey!
 
Thank you to those who have given me, and the others in this thread great advice! I was out of town for the past week, so I was only just able to get around to responding. (International fees can be crazy, and the wifi was iffy.)

I’ve been investigating off and on for the past couple years, but I really think I’m ready to take that last step, and actually move forward in my journey. 🙂
There are several of us here who are former Mormons. If you find yourself coming into the Catholic Church and have moments of LDS teachings confusing you, let us know.

For me, there was a time of having to see where I was confusing the two and needed help “detangling” the distortions.

God’s blessings!! 🙂
 
Thank you to those who have given me, and the others in this thread great advice! I was out of town for the past week, so I was only just able to get around to responding. (International fees can be crazy, and the wifi was iffy.)

I’ve been investigating off and on for the past couple years, but I really think I’m ready to take that last step, and actually move forward in my journey. 🙂
It’s good that you are willing to keep looking. There are many many LDS who become atheists after leaving Mormonism because once they learn the truth about their church they feel so betrayed and so disgusted that they have a hard time believing in anything afterwards. All their lives they were taught to believe everything their leaders say. Questioning is highly looked down upon. So when they find out the whole thing is a fraud they are so devastated they don’t know what/who to trust anymore.

Just curious, has this happened to you, and if so, how were you able to even consider the possibility that there is still truth out there?

A good piece of advice for Mormons who are leaving is to remind them that just because Mormonism is a counterfeit doesn’t mean there isn’t a genuine still out there.
 
It’s good that you are willing to keep looking. There are many many LDS who become atheists after leaving Mormonism because once they learn the truth about their church they feel so betrayed and so disgusted that they have a hard time believing in anything afterwards. All their lives they were taught to believe everything their leaders say. Questioning is highly looked down upon. So when they find out the whole thing is a fraud they are so devastated they don’t know what/who to trust anymore.

Just curious, has this happened to you, and if so, how were you able to even consider the possibility that there is still truth out there?

A good piece of advice for Mormons who are leaving is to remind them that just because Mormonism is a counterfeit doesn’t mean there isn’t a genuine still out there.
Actually, yes. There was a time where I didn’t believe in anything. But, eventually, I kept feeling a pull. Almost like a desire to rethink things. I researched many religions for years, tried to go back to Mormonism a couple times, thinking that maybe I was just doing it wrong. But it just didn’t fit!

Eventually, I started talking to my mother (I was in my 30’s and for some reason, talking to my mom about her beliefs never dawned on me until then!) and tried explaining what I was going through, what I believed, and how I didn’t feel as if I fit with the Mormon church. She told me my beliefs fit very much with her Catholic upbringing. I didn’t even know until she pointed it out! So I have been looking and digging when I can. (I’m very shy, and approaching strangers in person can be tough for me, especially with religion.) but maybe that pull all those years ago was just trying to point me in the right direction.
 
I researched many religions for years, tried to go back to Mormonism a couple times, thinking that maybe I was just doing it wrong. But it just didn’t fit!
Oh how many times I’ve heard ex-LDS say this exact same thing. That’s the circular logic of Mormonism. Pray about something to know that it’s true, and if you don’t get the answer that it is true then the problem must be with* YOU*. And round and round you go. In other words, it must be YOUR fault if you don’t know it’s true, because the church certainly can’t be wrong. Sound familiar?
 
Oh how many times I’ve heard ex-LDS say this exact same thing. That’s the circular logic of Mormonism. Pray about something to know that it’s true, and if you don’t get the answer that it is true then the problem must be with* YOU*. And round and round you go. In other words, it must be YOUR fault if you don’t know it’s true, because the church certainly can’t be wrong. Sound familiar?
all too true…
I’ve felt like that almost my whole life until I left the LDS!
 
Oh how many times I’ve heard ex-LDS say this exact same thing. That’s the circular logic of Mormonism. Pray about something to know that it’s true, and if you don’t get the answer that it is true then the problem must be with* YOU*. And round and round you go. In other words, it must be YOUR fault if you don’t know it’s true, because the church certainly can’t be wrong. Sound familiar?
Sounds VERY familiar!
 
Eventually, I started talking to my mother (I was in my 30’s and for some reason, talking to my mom about her beliefs never dawned on me until then!) and tried explaining what I was going through, what I believed, and how I didn’t feel as if I fit with the Mormon church. She told me my beliefs fit very much with her Catholic upbringing. I didn’t even know until she pointed it out! So I have been looking and digging when I can. (I’m very shy, and approaching strangers in person can be tough for me, especially with religion.) but maybe that pull all those years ago was just trying to point me in the right direction.
Xpirate -

There is nothing greater than to receive Jesus Christ in the Eucharist: His body, blood, soul and divinity.

Think this: In the Old Testament, the Passover lamb was sacrificed. Yet, this was not enough! If you only did this at the first Passover, your first born would have died. Why? You have to ALSO, eat the Lamb. Christ is our Passover Lamb, prefigured by the OT Passover. Likewise, we must eat the lamb, just as John 6 describes.

A common objection to the Real Presence is the belief that Christ was speaking symbolically or metaphorically. People cite Christ’s words: “do this in remembrance of me.”

“Remembrance” though in the Jewish faith, particularly seen in the Passover belief, means to make the past, present… NOW.

I say all this to make clear…what the apostolic faith has been, trusted to the Saints now for 2,000 years.

If you haven’t watched this video, I highly recommend doing so. It’s by Dr. Brant Pitre. He relates the ways the OT foreshadows the Eucharist, including the Passover Lamb prefigurement described above.

youtube.com/watch?v=P45BHDRA7pU
 
Oh how many times I’ve heard ex-LDS say this exact same thing. That’s the circular logic of Mormonism. Pray about something to know that it’s true, and if you don’t get the answer that it is true then the problem must be with* YOU*. And round and round you go. In other words, it must be YOUR fault if you don’t know it’s true, because the church certainly can’t be wrong. Sound familiar?
The other statement commonly heard is, “I studied my way out of mormonism”.

Once people really start digging into facts, they realize that it all just doesn’t add up. The more they find awry, the more they study, and the more they leave.
 
I went from Catholic to LDS and back to Catholic.

I joined the LDS church and left a couple months short of a year in. I just returned to the Catholic faith in February.

Why did I return? Because , pure and simple, I believe all that the Catholic Church teaches to be true. I believe in the Eucharist, have a devotion to the Blessed Virgin, and those things never really changed in my heart.

I got swept away by the wonderful people and support I got in the LDS faith, and things happened in a whirlwind. I didn’t realize all I was giving up by leaving the Catholic faith, and in my heart, like I said, I was still a Catholic.

Once you’ve known Jesus in the Eucharist, it’s hard to deny Him.
 
I heard a former Mormon talking about the idea of three heavens and how Joseph Smith was unaware of what that would mean to Jewish people. There is a verse in second Corinthians that mentions the third heaven and I asked a priest about it and he just told me that it was about Paradise he didn’t specify about it. This former Mormon though mentioned the creation story in Genesis and the Jews would know exactly what Paul was referring to in I believe 2 Corinthians. It is my understanding that there really is no concept of Hell in Mormonism but there is something called the outer Darkness how does the outer Darkness differ from the orthodox Christian(Trinitarian) view of hell? I’m just fascinated by the people who converted from Mormonism
From what I was taught when I was Mormon, there are three kingdoms: Celestial, Telesrtial, and Terrestrial, which all correspond to the glory of the Sun, Moon, and Stars. Righteous Mormons who have had all the ordinances go to the Celestial. People that accepted Christ but weren’t “valiant” in their testimony go to Telestrial. Terrestrial is for the “wicked”.

“Outer darkness” they teach is reserved for “Apostates”…aka people like me that “heard the Gospel (their gospel) , accepted it and then rejected it”. Outer darkness is similar to hell.

Within the Celestial realm, there also are three levels there: you only make it to the highest and can attain “godhood” if you are sealed to a worthy spouse…and you will only be with your spouse and family forever if your spouse/family honors the same covenants.

There’s speculation that Smith got the ideas of the Kingdoms , and the Book of Mormon, from two other books published before the Book of Mormon, namely “View of the Hebrews” by Ethan Smith and “The Wonders of Nature and Providence Displayed” , found here: 20truths.info/mormon/plagiarism.html
 
. I didn’t realize all I was giving up by leaving the Catholic faith, and in my heart, like I said, I was still a Catholic…
Interesting this…

I work with a LDS who recently told me that “we believe the same things”.

I haven’t had the opportunity to carry the conversation further.

Quite frankly… I was a bit speechless.

As I’ve told my family in the past: “one thing about people is that you can never be surprised by what they will say.”

(sometimes this applies to me… and I ask myself “did I really say that?”) 😃
 
Interesting this…

I work with a LDS who recently told me that “we believe the same things”.

I haven’t had the opportunity to carry the conversation further.

Quite frankly… I was a bit speechless.

As I’ve told my family in the past: “one thing about people is that you can never be surprised by what they will say.”

(sometimes this applies to me… and I ask myself “did I really say that?”) 😃
I would be speechless too! If that were true, then why is the LDS church necessary? Why don’t they all become Catholic then? 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top