Lebanese Psycholist on Islam

  • Thread starter Thread starter GregoryPalamas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
GregoryPalamas:
While I don’t agree with her secularism I certainly agree with her sentiments. Listen to this video from, of all places. Al Jezeera.

switch5.castup.net/frames/20041020_MemriTV_Popup/video_480x360.asp?ai=214&ar=1050wmv&ak=null
Click to expand...
Quite an amazing woman! Here’s another video of her
switch5.castup.net/frames/20041020_MemriTV_Popup/video_480x360.asp?ai=214&ar=783wmv&ak=null

and here’s the transcript
memritv.org/Transcript.asp?P1=783

By the way, you can view the transcipt for the video you linked to here memritv.org/Transcript.asp?P1=1050
 
I do not see the point why religious and open-minded people should take her opinion seriously. Secularist hate religion and I am sure she has something negative to say also about Christianity and Judaism. She has disregarded all the contribution of Muslims (e.g.science, agriculture, etc) for mankind specially during the dark ages of europe. Her short sightedness about Islam is obviously reflected in her statements on linking Islam with the extremist actions of some Muslims.
 
manx said:
I do not see the point why religious and open-minded people should take her opinion seriously. Secularist hate religion and I am sure she has something negative to say also about Christianity and Judaism.
Click to expand...
on the contrary, she praised their contributions to humanity.
She has disregarded all the contribution of Muslims (e.g.science, agriculture, etc) for mankind specially during the dark ages of europe.
Click to expand...
because she is giving her opinion as to what is going on now.
but Her short sightedness about Islam is obviously reflected in her statements on linking Islam with the extremist actions of some Muslims.
Click to expand...
she is talking in general…calling us names, fighting non-moslems, discriminating …these are in quran, not only extremist.
Click to expand...
 
She may have been wiser to use a Pseudonym but then how does one speak anonymously on the telly? Her experience reminds one of the now famous Bat Ye’or (an obvious pseudonym) who with her family fled Egypt and is now the foremost scholar on the Dhimmi. Let us pray that Dr. Sultan is protected by the hand of God.

CDL
 
40.png
Muslim:
thats wafa sultan… a fraud who abuses Islam and uses the same old story as she was ‘devout’ blah blah blah… that 2434 other people used to get attention…
Click to expand...
Ah, now I see. You are attempting to be serious. Show us where she is a fraud. Show us how advanced Islamic countries are. Show us how they treat others fairly. Show us in what ways Dr. Sultan is a fraud. If you can then we will change our minds. If not then we know that you are a fraud.

CDL
 
40.png
GregoryPalamas:
Ah, now I see. You are attempting to be serious. Show us where she is a fraud. Show us how advanced Islamic countries are. Show us how they treat others fairly. Show us in what ways Dr. Sultan is a fraud. If you can then we will change our minds. If not then we know that you are a fraud.

CDL
Click to expand...
you have seen many evidence yet you choose not to believe.
 
40.png
Muslim:
you have seen many evidence yet you choose not to believe.
Click to expand...
Oh, I believe alright. I believe that Islam tends to be a very violent religion. While some Muslims are progressing out of that, maybe even a majority, there are several who are simply extremely violent.

CDL
 
40.png
GregoryPalamas:
Oh, I believe alright. I believe that Islam tends to be a very violent religion. While some Muslims are progressing out of that, maybe even a majority, there are several who are simply extremely violent.

CDL
Click to expand...
i dont disagree with you that there are violent Muslims… there are violent people all over the world. some use religion as excuse some use something else…
but there is a diff. between Islam and Muslim. people can claim to be whatever they want to be and blow stuff up, that does not mean anything.
 
40.png
Muslim:
i dont disagree with you that there are violent Muslims… there are violent people all over the world. some use religion as excuse some use something else…
but there is a diff. between Islam and Muslim. people can claim to be whatever they want to be and blow stuff up, that does not mean anything.
Click to expand...
It does if you are blown up with the terrorist…

CDL
 
40.png
Muslim:
thats wafa sultan… a fraud who abuses Islam and uses the same old story as she was ‘devout’ blah blah blah… that 2434 other people used to get attention…
Click to expand...
yes to get attention she risks her life by showing on tv …talk about logic.
 
She’s a total bigot. Proclaiming that the west is the most glorius place or center of ideology on this earth is ridiculous. Frankly the West has created more suffering and destructive contributions to the world then the Middle east. The middle east only spread their ideologies to the rest of the world as did other civilizations.

She also argues her points with an unknowledgeable Muslim. If an Imam was their her points would have been totally crushed. Where do they get these people from. Sheesh trying to argue her ignorant position with little opposition is ridiculous. Maybe she is just afraid that if she really engaged a Knowledgeable Muslim in Islam that she would have been totally crushed.
 
40.png
Shadowcry:
She’s a total bigot. Proclaiming that the west is the most glorius place or center of ideology on this earth is ridiculous. Frankly the West has created more suffering and destructive contributions to the world then the Middle east. The middle east only spread their ideologies to the rest of the world as did other civilizations.

She also argues her points with an unknowledgeable Muslim. If an Imam was their her points would have been totally crushed. Where do they get these people from. Sheesh trying to argue her ignorant position with little opposition is ridiculous. Maybe she is just afraid that if she really engaged a Knowledgeable Muslim in Islam that she would have been totally crushed.
Click to expand...
i see the scheikh all the time on tv in lectures…he IS well-known…and SHE crushed him when she said he has no right to not argue with her based on her “religion”.
 
Just cause he’s well known doesn’t make him intelligent. Go find an Imam to tell her off I know one, she talks total nonsense and should be educated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top