Les Miserables

  • Thread starter Thread starter Christianus_Dei
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Christianus_Dei

Guest
So Les Miserables in being released in theaters on Christmas Eve. As many of you know, it is a very emotionally stirring story. How about we pray that God use it to stir all this emotion in just the right way, that people may find him?

Also, how many are excited for it?
 
I am.

While some theatres are doing a Christmas eve showing, it opens on Christmas Day.

I hadn’t thought about useing the film as an evangilization tool. 🙂
 
I am.

While some theatres are doing a Christmas eve showing, it opens on Christmas Day.

I hadn’t thought about useing the film as an evangilization tool. 🙂
It’s a very Catholic story, one of redemption and conversion, not just in the heart, but put into action. The singing will not be on par with the broadway show (particularly from the clips I’ve heard of Russell Crowe even though I think he’s awesome as an actor) but the movie itself looks brilliant. I’m very excited about it!
 
Lord, please use Les Miserables to lead souls to your Son - to a life of supernatural grace and charity. May Les Miserables bring about many conversions. Amen.
 
I just started reading the novel. Beautiful. I am only on chapter 8 and it is still describing the saintly life of the Bishop Myriel. I have it on *Nook *so I don’t get overwhelmed with all the pages to go. Just taking it slow and easy and loving it.
 
I saw the movie. It was honestly the most Catholic movie I’ve seen in… ever. I saw the play, and had no idea that Jean Valjean was a devout Catholic. He’s really into his faith in the movie.

Though he ruined “Bring Him Home.” Aside from that, he was fine.

Russel Crowe was a perfect Javert.
 
Lord, please use Les Miserables to lead souls to your Son - to a life of supernatural grace and charity. May Les Miserables bring about many conversions. Amen.
“What is the history of Fantine? It is society purchasing a slave.”

Who are those in need of conversion? Often those who least think they need it and “society” itself.
 
Give me a break! We cheer a movie that puts, in a good light, those who attacked a Masonic government in Mexico, but, then, cheer a story that puts, in a good light, a revolution, or one that calls to mind the French Revolution, that slaughtered Catholics and others suspected of being anti-revolutionary? Really? Oh, I loved that Catholic part where Javert kills himself instead of, wouldn’t you want, becoming a better man and redeeming himself? What’s with the sick bum in a St. Nicholas suit doing having sex in this film (I think the scene was a bit over the top in its portrayal of the debauchery of the inn)? I think, short of the good Catholic man (is he a priest), it’s really pious people being kooks and decent people, like ValJean having values that are not evidently Church-inspired (he stole for another long before his freedom and there’s no mention of that sacrifice being Catholic), and possibly his return of the favor being man-inspired. Are poor people taking up arms to start a revolution that could result in the death of unintended targets to get rid of a maybe equally morally-corrupt justice system Catholic inspired? They seem celebrated in the film. Jean even says the boy has done nothing wrong. Really? It’s not like the wronged were actually in the process of being persecuting, so these rebels were pretty much starting an unjust war–and that’s a virtuous thing?.
 
I saw the movie. It was honestly the most Catholic movie I’ve seen in… ever. I saw the play, and had no idea that Jean Valjean was a devout Catholic. He’s really into his faith in the movie.

Though he ruined “Bring Him Home.” Aside from that, he was fine.

Russel Crowe was a perfect Javert.
I saw that movie after Christmas and I cried when I saw many things happened in movie.
 
I just watched the movie today. It was so inspiring… a story of loving and forgiveness. I watched it with a family member who won’t let go of his bitterness. His unforgiving attitude has caused him not to have any peace… and not just him, but also us, his family. I tried to sermon him about letting go and forgiving but to no avail. It was good that he liked the movie, I hope it has touched him in a way and would start working on forgiving and loving others even those who has caused him pain. Anyone know of a movie similar to this one? I’d like to watch more of this sort of movie with him.
 
Give me a break! We cheer a movie that puts, in a good light, those who attacked a Masonic government in Mexico, but, then, cheer a story that puts, in a good light, a revolution, or one that calls to mind the French Revolution, that slaughtered Catholics and others suspected of being anti-revolutionary? Really? Oh, I loved that Catholic part where Javert kills himself instead of, wouldn’t you want, becoming a better man and redeeming himself? What’s with the sick bum in a St. Nicholas suit doing having sex in this film (I think the scene was a bit over the top in its portrayal of the debauchery of the inn)? I think, short of the good Catholic man (is he a priest), it’s really pious people being kooks and decent people, like ValJean having values that are not evidently Church-inspired (he stole for another long before his freedom and there’s no mention of that sacrifice being Catholic), and possibly his return of the favor being man-inspired. Are poor people taking up arms to start a revolution that could result in the death of unintended targets to get rid of a maybe equally morally-corrupt justice system Catholic inspired? They seem celebrated in the film. Jean even says the boy has done nothing wrong. Really? It’s not like the wronged were actually in the process of being persecuting, so these rebels were pretty much starting an unjust war–and that’s a virtuous thing?.
I don’t believe Victor Hugo actually believed the cause was right, but he portrayed them sympathetically anyways.

Did you not see how Pious Jean Valjean was throughout the story? He prays several times(Bring him Home, for one), declares God to be his master, etc. Yes, that man was a Priest. And yes, stealing a loaf of bread is possibly in Church teaching when in that circumstance. Read the Catechism on Stealing. The whole point of the film is forgiveness and sacrifice, and because someone commited suicide, why is that a bad thing in storytelling?
 
Give me a break! We cheer a movie that puts, in a good light, those who attacked a Masonic government in Mexico, but, then, cheer a story that puts, in a good light, a revolution, or one that calls to mind the French Revolution, that slaughtered Catholics and others suspected of being anti-revolutionary? Really?

You are sacrificing a minor point (the revolution) to the whole point of the books and film. Yes, Victor Hugo approved of Napoleon, and praised the French revolution. That’s nothing like the whole point of the movie.

Oh, I loved that Catholic part where Javert kills himself instead of, wouldn’t you want, becoming a better man and redeeming himself?

So basically a movie or book showing a person killing themselves rather than face God and mercy. The book especially did a wonderful job. Nonetheless, the way it was portrayed, using the same music as What Have I Done portrayed Javert’s death in a quite good light, not making it seem a good thing at all.

I think, short of the good Catholic man (is he a priest),

He was a bishop, and a very holy one at that.

it’s really pious people being kooks and decent people, like ValJean having values that are not evidently Church-inspired (he stole for another long before his freedom and there’s no mention of that sacrifice being Catholic), and possibly his return of the favor being man-inspired.

Congratulations on missing all the point of Valjean’s (not ValJean) repentance. He stoel the loaf of bread uncaringly; from his earliest years he was consumed by a lack of love for his family and for life in general. It wasn’t until the Bishop lied to save his skin that he began to repent, and it wasn’t until he cared for Cosette that he learned to love.

Are poor people taking up arms to start a revolution that could result in the death of unintended targets to get rid of a maybe equally morally-corrupt justice system Catholic inspired? They seem celebrated in the film. Jean even says the boy has done nothing wrong. Really? It’s not like the wronged were actually in the process of being persecuting, so these rebels were pretty much starting an unjust war–and that’s a virtuous thing?.

Considering how infatuated with patriotism they were, i doubt they were overguilty. In the book in fact, marius wasn’t even a member of the revulotion; he just traveled to the barricade to die there.

Nonetheless, all you’re targeting are the nonessentials of the movie. Seriously, the revolution was only a minor part. The main theme of repentance and honesty in Valjean, and the wonderful clash between pure justice and mercy with him and Javert… Javert was hardly even religious, incidentally. He never thought about God until he was about to kill himself. Les Mis has a multitude of Christian themes (for instance, Hugo spends several chapters describing a cloistered order, contrasting it with Valjean’s time in prison, and concluding by basically praising the religious order being examined) and moral depth. I suggest you read the book, familarize yourself with the plot, and realize how badly you’re misrepresenting this story.
 
And foolishmortal, I apologize if we’ve been rude at all. We’re just defending a story we love, and if we insulted you or seemed harsh at any time, I’m sorry.
 
Hugo’s portrayal of religious life is not very flattering although Bishop Myriel is an inspiration. I am glad the book begins with him. Too bad a novel does not focus on him.
 
I pray for the highest love and highest good and for God divine will to prevail. Amen
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top