Let's talk about Star Wars!

  • Thread starter Thread starter buzzoff1031
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t mind films with a lighter tone, it’s just the dialog and acting that mainly makes me cringe. I just can’t make it through any of the movies without barfing any time anyone besides Yoda, Vader, Obi Wan and Qui Gonn opens their mouth. Okay maybe I am exaggerating a bit but I just can’t fathom why George Lucas wouldn’t hire someone to write the script. I bet one of my little brothers could make a better script.
The acting isn’t much better either. Hayden Christensen anyone? Harrison Ford and Alec Guiness were the only ones I could stand from the originals.
Anyhow, now that I’ve properly trolled myself out, I will add that the lightsaber fights especially in the Phantom Menace are one of the best battle scenes I have watched.
The stories aren’t bad, I almost like the Empire Strikes Back, but I just can’t get past the previously mentioned issues.
Too be fair Lucas didn’t write the Empire Strikes Back or direct it. I never minded Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. I thought for the most part the entire cast for the original films played their characters well…

As far as the lightsaber fights I thought the Phantom Menace’s fight was to obviously choreographed. It was like they were intentionally hitting each others blades instead of attempting to actually hit the opponent’s body. Darth Mauls slow reaction to Obi Wan’s attack when he is sliced in half was silly too. The music was extremely epic though and the set was awesome too.

I personally thought the best fight was Luke vs Vader in Empire. A balance of some cool effects and sword fighting without being overly flashy. Sure the original didn’t contain the best duels however it was more of an internal fight. Vader was never sure that he wanted to kill Luke.

I don’t mind the actors in any of the films. Sure I would have cast a different person to play Anakin. However I think Hayden could have done a good job if he had a better script.

I personally enjoy the Star War dialog from the first two films. What in particular do you not like about them dialogue wise, any particular quotes? Star Wars a New Hope had a few cheesy lines from Han, Luke, and Leia, it didn’t ruin the film for me so. This problem wasn’t very evident in the Empire Strikes Back.
 
Too be fair Lucas didn’t write the Empire Strikes Back or direct it. I never minded Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. I thought for the most part the entire cast for the original films played their characters well…

As far as the lightsaber fights I thought the Phantom Menace’s fight was to obviously choreographed. It was like they were intentionally hitting each others blades instead of attempting to actually hit the opponent’s body. Darth Mauls slow reaction to Obi Wan’s attack when he is sliced in half was silly too. The music was extremely epic though and the set was awesome too.

I personally thought the best fight was Luke vs Vader in Empire. A balance of some cool effects and sword fighting without being overly flashy. Sure the original didn’t contain the best duels however it was more of an internal fight. Vader was never sure that he wanted to kill Luke.

I don’t mind the actors in any of the films. Sure I would have cast a different person to play Anakin. However I think Hayden could have done a good job if he had a better script.

I personally enjoy the Star War dialog from the first two films. What in particular do you not like about them dialogue wise, any particular quotes? Star Wars a New Hope had a few cheesy lines from Han, Luke, and Leia, it didn’t ruin the film for me so. This problem wasn’t very evident in the Empire Strikes Back.
The fight with Luke and Vader in ‘‘Empire’’ is a close second for me. Definitely the best saber fight in the originals in my opinion.
As for Maul’s slow reaction to Obi Wan, I always was under the impression that he was surprised that a padawan managed to get out of such a sticky situation.He underestimated him.
I always cringe when Luke says;’‘But I was gonna go to Toshies station to pick up some power converters’’. I know it shows his immaturity and shows his change in attitude later, but it really just comes off as a whiny brat, not to mention bad line delivery. Maybe it’s because I’ve seen them all so many times, but it doesn’t get easier for me listening to the lines. I can’t recall any more off hand, but most of the worst are in the prequels.
I knew Lucas didn’t direct ‘‘Empire’’ but I thought he wrote the dialog and parts of the story. I heard there was a certain scene which was cut ( thank goodness) between Luke and Leia which would have made things reaaalllyy awkward later. I won’t go into details. There was also originally a fight between Chewbaaka and the snow monster, that would have been cool.
Anyway, I like having a civil discussion of different opinions, you sound like a cool guy. By the looks of your profile, we have many similar interests. I look forward to talking with you more.👍
 
Yes civil discussions rock! 😃
I always cringe when Luke says;’‘But I was gonna go to Toshies station to pick up some power converters’’. I know it shows his immaturity and shows his change in attitude later, but it really just comes off as a whiny brat, not to mention bad line delivery. Maybe it’s because I’ve seen them all so many times, but it doesn’t get easier for me listening to the lines. I can’t recall any more off hand, but most of the worst are in the prequels.
Yea the line did make him look whiny. All the hugging was a bit cheesy too lol. The actors were good enough to pull it off though.

Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher had complained about Lucas’s directing skills as well as his dialogue. The thing about the prequels is the dialogue was much worse and the actors didn’t have the charisma that the original cast had. Plus they were majorly acting on green screens, which makes things even more difficult.

The Empire Strikes script wasn’t written by Lucas though he did the story. It had a less cheesy lines for sure. Return of the Jedi was definitely a step down in dialogue and plot though.

I will say Lord of the Rings is much more consistent as far as the quality from film to film goes. Of course that can be attributed to the director and writer being the same person through all three films.
 
Disclaimer: I am an employee of the Disney Company.

With that out of the way, when the Company bought Marvel, fans were concerned that Mickey Mouse would be interjected into the Iron Man and Captain America comics. All that happened was that Disney got Joss Whedon to tell a great story about the Avengers. There are even more films coming and they will continue to be Disney Character free.

Based on that success, and it was VERY successful, I see no reason to believe that Disney will mess with the Canon of Star Wars. I think that’s why George Lucas made the decision to sell to Disney.
Hey, that’s fun. 🙂

I know you’re correct about them not introducing Mickey Mouse and Disney Princesses into the Star Wars universe. It’s just fun to make jokes about it. 😛

With Disney owning Marvel and Star Wars, I do wonder if they’ll introduce some of those characters into “Once Upon a Time”. 🙂
 
As far as the lightsaber fights I thought the Phantom Menace’s fight was to obviously choreographed. It was like they were intentionally hitting each others blades instead of attempting to actually hit the opponent’s body.
A friend of mine, who knows something about martial arts, said they looked as if they were fighting with bo sticks, using the same types of moves that fighters with bo sticks would use. Really I think the problem is that a double-ended light saber is so totally unrealistic - you could hardly wield it without slicing yourself through the abdomen. So the choreography of the fight had to be artificial.
 
Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher had complained about Lucas’s directing skills as well as his dialogue. The thing about the prequels is the dialogue was much worse and the actors didn’t have the charisma that the original cast had.
I read somewhere that Lucas did something unusual with the actor tryouts for Star Wars (original film), he evaluated them in groups rather than as individuals. He chose Hamill, Ford and Fisher because they interacted well together. I think that decision paid off. During the sequence in the original film in which they are running around the hallways of the Death Star, they have some banter and wisecracking, which is kind of hard to believe given the situation; but the actors pull it off.

The actors in the prequels were just as talented as those in the originals, but they were handicapped by the story and the dialogue. Yes, the original film has some sloppy writing such as the line “I have a bad feeling about this” being used too many times. But it doesn’t detract (in my opinion) from the fact that the scenario is very well constructed (I think Lucas hasn’t gotten enough credit for this) and the characters are appealing, even if they are more of archetypes than fully developed characters.
 
Yes civil discussions rock! 😃

Yea the line did make him look whiny. All the hugging was a bit cheesy too lol. The actors were good enough to pull it off though.

Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher had complained about Lucas’s directing skills as well as his dialogue. The thing about the prequels is the dialogue was much worse and the actors didn’t have the charisma that the original cast had. Plus they were majorly acting on green screens, which makes things even more difficult.

The Empire Strikes script wasn’t written by Lucas though he did the story. It had a less cheesy lines for sure. Return of the Jedi was definitely a step down in dialogue and plot though.

I will say Lord of the Rings is much more consistent as far as the quality from film to film goes. Of course that can be attributed to the director and writer being the same person through all three films.
I didn’t think the actors were worse in the prequels, they just didn’t have much to go on. Liam Neeson managed to do an adequate job, Ewan McGreggor wasn’t as good as Alec Guiness, but didn’t do a bad job of portraying a younger Obi Wan. By the way, Sir Alec Guiness hated the dialog, he asked Lucas to write him out of he next two movies after he did ‘’ A New Hope’’. He actually said he felt embarrassed reciting his lines.
George Lucas comes up with amazing worlds and interesting stories,it’s the way he executes them that I don’t care for.
The Lord of the Rings is definitely more consistent in quality, but I attribute that more to Tolkien’s writing than Jackson’s adaptation, although P J did do a fine job.
 
By the way, Sir Alec Guiness hated the dialog, he asked Lucas to write him out of he next two movies after he did ‘’ A New Hope’’. He actually said he felt embarrassed reciting his lines.
The remarkable thing is that you would never guess that from watching the movie. He delivers every line of dialogue with total conviction. Of course, he was a great actor, one of the best. Only in Return of the Jedi, I think (he has one or two ghostly appearances talking to Luke) does the pretense begin to fail, there are a couple of places where you can tell he is reciting lines that don’t really mean anything.
 
Too be fair Lucas didn’t write the Empire Strikes Back or direct it… As far as the lightsaber fights I thought the Phantom Menace’s fight was to obviously choreographed. It was like they were intentionally hitting each others blades instead of attempting to actually hit the opponent’s body. Darth Mauls slow reaction to Obi Wan’s attack when he is sliced in half was silly too. The music was extremely epic though and the set was awesome too.

I personally thought the best fight was Luke vs Vader in Empire. A balance of some cool effects and sword fighting without being overly flashy. Sure the original didn’t contain the best duels however it was more of an internal fight. Vader was never sure that he wanted to kill Luke.
…
Lucas has gone on record as saying Episode 5 was his “least favorite”–which shows he cannot be trusted with discerning quality from garbage. Episode 4 as originaly released was his freshest–despite lines that the cast could barely choke out (Guiness and Cushing in particular- and-Fisher has said she could barely keep from laughing every take) Lucas “restoration” of A New Hope was and remains a travesty (HAN SHOT FIRST!)

In terms of telling a story, the light saber duel between Vader and Luke in Empire has only been surpased in one other movie sword fight–1995’s Rob Roy, coreographed by William Hobbes, featuring Liam Neeson (Rob) with a claymore vs. Tim Roth (Cunningham) and a trasitional rapier
 
Lucas has gone on record as saying Episode 5 was his “least favorite”–which shows he cannot be trusted with discerning quality from garbage. Episode 4 as originaly released was his freshest–despite lines that the cast could barely choke out (Guiness and Cushing in particular- and-Fisher has said she could barely keep from laughing every take) Lucas “restoration” of A New Hope was and remains a travesty (HAN SHOT FIRST!)

In terms of telling a story, the light saber duel between Vader and Luke in Empire has only been surpased in one other movie sword fight–1995’s Rob Roy, coreographed by William Hobbes, featuring Liam Neeson (Rob) with a claymore vs. Tim Roth (Cunningham) and a trasitional rapier
I saw that fight scene. It was very good, but I wouldn’t quite call it the best. That fight shows the diversity of the two characters, Roth has the rapier and Neeson the broadsword. However the choice of weapons makes for a realistic but unflashy fight. Something I found both interesting and slightly odd. Roth spins and ducks most of the time but that is pretty much the only action for that sequence. The fight serves the purpose of the movie quite well, but as a stand alone fight scene the unequal combatant style is a little less appealing than say ‘‘The Princess Bride’’ fight where the two characters are equally matched.
Man this is cool, I get to talk about sword fighting movies with other people. I like it.
 
A friend of mine, who knows something about martial arts, said they looked as if they were fighting with bo sticks, using the same types of moves that fighters with bo sticks would use. Really I think the problem is that a double-ended light saber is so totally unrealistic - you could hardly wield it without slicing yourself through the abdomen. So the choreography of the fight had to be artificial.
Maybe so. If light saber were real the fighting style certainly wouldn’t involve a bunch of useless spinning. Heck real swords are sharp and deadly enough where you wouldn’t spin them around pointlessly.
I read somewhere that Lucas did something unusual with the actor tryouts for Star Wars (original film), he evaluated them in groups rather than as individuals. He chose Hamill, Ford and Fisher because they interacted well together. I think that decision paid off. During the sequence in the original film in which they are running around the hallways of the Death Star, they have some banter and wisecracking, which is kind of hard to believe given the situation; but the actors pull it off.

The actors in the prequels were just as talented as those in the originals, but they were handicapped by the story and the dialogue. Yes, the original film has some sloppy writing such as the line “I have a bad feeling about this” being used too many times. But it doesn’t detract (in my opinion) from the fact that the scenario is very well constructed (I think Lucas hasn’t gotten enough credit for this) and the characters are appealing, even if they are more of archetypes than fully developed characters.
I don’t know, Harrison Ford’s charisma is not something that many actors have. I do agree Lucas did a great job casting. I don’t mind the I have a bad feeling about this line. It was actually only twice in the first film. Its like a catchphrase. I do give full credit to Lucas for a New Hope. It wasn’t perfect but no movie is.
I didn’t think the actors were worse in the prequels, they just didn’t have much to go on. Liam Neeson managed to do an adequate job, Ewan McGreggor wasn’t as good as Alec Guiness, but didn’t do a bad job of portraying a younger Obi Wan. By the way, Sir Alec Guiness hated the dialog, he asked Lucas to write him out of he next two movies after he did ‘’ A New Hope’’. He actually said he felt embarrassed reciting his lines.
George Lucas comes up with amazing worlds and interesting stories,it’s the way he executes them that I don’t care for.
The Lord of the Rings is definitely more consistent in quality, but I attribute that more to Tolkien’s writing than Jackson’s adaptation, although P J did do a fine job.
I do agree, that is why I often give much more credit to Star Wars as it wasn’t a direct adaption of a book. I don’t think the actors in the new films were bad. Liam Neesen managed to be the best part of the Phantom Menace despite his bad dialogue. Lucas does have great ideas that he has managed to adapt to screen greatly but only once, which is of course Star Wars a New Hope.
The remarkable thing is that you would never guess that from watching the movie. He delivers every line of dialogue with total conviction. Of course, he was a great actor, one of the best. Only in Return of the Jedi, I think (he has one or two ghostly appearances talking to Luke) does the pretense begin to fail, there are a couple of places where you can tell he is reciting lines that don’t really mean anything.
Yes Alec guinness is a great actor. I know he disapproved of the script but in the end I think it fit well with the tone of the film.
Lucas has gone on record as saying Episode 5 was his “least favorite”–which shows he cannot be trusted with discerning quality from garbage. Episode 4 as originaly released was his freshest–despite lines that the cast could barely choke out (Guiness and Cushing in particular- and-Fisher has said she could barely keep from laughing every take) Lucas “restoration” of A New Hope was and remains a travesty (HAN SHOT FIRST!)

In terms of telling a story, the light saber duel between Vader and Luke in Empire has only been surpased in one other movie sword fight–1995’s Rob Roy, coreographed by William Hobbes, featuring Liam Neeson (Rob) with a claymore vs. Tim Roth (Cunningham) and a trasitional rapier
Yes Lucas really went off the deep end. Cushing and Guinness did such a marvelous job though. Cushing never let Darth Vader overshadow him.
I saw that fight scene. It was very good, but I wouldn’t quite call it the best. That fight shows the diversity of the two characters, Roth has the rapier and Neeson the broadsword. However the choice of weapons makes for a realistic but unflashy fight. Something I found both interesting and slightly odd. Roth spins and ducks most of the time but that is pretty much the only action for that sequence. The fight serves the purpose of the movie quite well, but as a stand alone fight scene the unequal combatant style is a little less appealing than say ‘‘The Princess Bride’’ fight where the two characters are equally matched.
Man this is cool, I get to talk about sword fighting movies with other people. I like it.
I don’t mind stylized fighting at all. It just has to be done well. The majority of attacks should have a purpose instead of just endless and pointless back and fourth. I thought Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon did a great job with this.

The Princess Bride sword duel between the Man in Black and Indigo was certainly one of Cinemas best. The ending duel between Robin Hood and Sir Guy of Gisborne in the Adventures of Robin Hood was fantastic too. A movie can have a great fight but it loses its impact when you don’t care about the characters.
 
Maybe so. If light saber were real the fighting style certainly wouldn’t involve a bunch of useless spinning. Heck real swords are sharp and deadly enough where you wouldn’t spin them around pointlessly.

I don’t know, Harrison Ford’s charisma is not something that many actors have. I do agree Lucas did a great job casting. I don’t mind the I have a bad feeling about this line. It was actually only twice in the first film. Its like a catchphrase. I do give full credit to Lucas for a New Hope. It wasn’t perfect but no movie is.

I do agree, that is why I often give much more credit to Star Wars as it wasn’t a direct adaption of a book. I don’t think the actors in the new films were bad. Liam Neesen managed to be the best part of the Phantom Menace despite his bad dialogue. Lucas does have great ideas that he has managed to adapt to screen greatly but only once, which is of course Star Wars a New Hope.

Yes Alec guinness is a great actor. I know he disapproved of the script but in the end I think it fit well with the tone of the film.

Yes Lucas really went off the deep end. Cushing and Guinness did such a marvelous job though. Cushing never let Darth Vader overshadow him.

I don’t mind stylized fighting at all. It just has to be done well. The majority of attacks should have a purpose instead of just endless and pointless back and fourth. I thought Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon did a great job with this.

The Princess Bride sword duel between the Man in Black and Indigo was certainly one of Cinemas best. The ending duel between Robin Hood and Sir Guy of Gisborne in the Adventures of Robin Hood was fantastic too. A movie can have a great fight but it loses its impact when you don’t care about the characters.
Funny thing, Lucas originally was adamant about not casting Harrison Ford as Han Solo because he already worked with him in Indiana Jones and I think American Graffiti. Ford was just in the auditions to repeat lines with those trying for the parts. The producers and staff felt Ford was perfect and eventually convinced ol’ George to cast him. Good for them.
I came across an interesting web page, ‘thought you guys would get a kick out of it. notstarring.com/movies/star-wars
Interesting observation made about Cushings character. Come to think of it he never seemed intimidated by Darth Vader.
I feel the same about stylized fights which is why I don’t like the final fight between Obi Wan and Aniken in ‘‘Revenge of the Sith’’ which is hailed as one of, if not the best fight in the series by fans. Talk about spinning and unnecessary flailing.
You don’t mind the ‘’ I have a bad feeling about this’’ line? I don’t understand why it’s in every one of the films. Seems like they could have said he same thing in different words.
I have to check out ‘‘Crouching Tiger and Hidden Dragon’’ now. I just watched the Rob Roy fight scene again and I have to say, there’s now way a rapier blocks a strike from a broadsword that many times and doesn’t break. Although that would have ruined the fight scene.
I just have to disagree with the end fight in ‘‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’’. That’s another film I have seen more times than I care to remember and while the sword fight is certainly the highlight of the film, I really don’t think it is very good. Most of it is super sped up to make it appear faster and more intense, but Erroll Flynn comes off as more clownish and less willing to fight than Gisbourne. That film is just too cheesy and sparkly for my tastes. Not that I only enjoy dark gritty films, but it seems overly campy and corny.
 
Funny thing, Lucas originally was adamant about not casting Harrison Ford as Han Solo because he already worked with him in Indiana Jones and I think American Graffiti. Ford was just in the auditions to repeat lines with those trying for the parts. The producers and staff felt Ford was perfect and eventually convinced ol’ George to cast him. Good for them.
I came across an interesting web page, ‘thought you guys would get a kick out of it. notstarring.com/movies/star-wars
Interesting observation made about Cushings character. Come to think of it he never seemed intimidated by Darth Vader.
I feel the same about stylized fights which is why I don’t like the final fight between Obi Wan and Aniken in ‘‘Revenge of the Sith’’ which is hailed as one of, if not the best fight in the series by fans. Talk about spinning and unnecessary flailing.
You don’t mind the ‘’ I have a bad feeling about this’’ line? I don’t understand why it’s in every one of the films. Seems like they could have said he same thing in different words.
I have to check out ‘‘Crouching Tiger and Hidden Dragon’’ now. I just watched the Rob Roy fight scene again and I have to say, there’s now way a rapier blocks a strike from a broadsword that many times and doesn’t break. Although that would have ruined the fight scene.
I just have to disagree with the end fight in ‘‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’’. That’s another film I have seen more times than I care to remember and while the sword fight is certainly the highlight of the film, I really don’t think it is very good. Most of it is super sped up to make it appear faster and more intense, but Erroll Flynn comes off as more clownish and less willing to fight than Gisbourne. That film is just too cheesy and sparkly for my tastes. Not that I only enjoy dark gritty films, but it seems overly campy and corny.
I’ll have to watch the Adventures of Robin Hood again, haven’t seen it in a while. I adored that film as a child, so maybe that is where some of the love I have for it comes from. I always found the action scenes and set in it to be quite impressive. I always liked the scene where he announces to Prince John that he will use all in his means to fight him, though it was a bit of a stupid idea going in all by himself like that :D.

I think the line “I have a bad feeling about this” just became a catch phrase. Its like yippie kay yay from Die Hard. Maybe not as Iconic as that but still.
 
Any thoughts on what the new episodes could be like?
My initial thought when I heard Disney bought Lucasfilms was; o great the new ones will probably be worse than the prequels if Disney is making it. Now I’m not so sure.
 
Any thoughts on what the new episodes could be like?
My initial thought when I heard Disney bought Lucasfilms was; o great the new ones will probably be worse than the prequels if Disney is making it. Now I’m not so sure.
I’m hoping they’ll go back to the Thrawn series…
 
I am not familiar with any of the material other than the films and some clone wars stuff. Care to elaborate on the proposed series?
The Thrawn trilogy was written by Timothy Zahn and dealt with Luke, Leia and Han’s lives after Return of the Jedi. It’s a great series with old and new characters. I read it years ago when it first came out, and after last week’s announcement I picked it up again to re-read it! 😃
 
Funny thing, Lucas originally was adamant about not casting Harrison Ford as Han Solo because he already worked with him in Indiana Jones and I think American Graffiti. Ford was just in the auditions to repeat lines with those trying for the parts. The producers and staff felt Ford was perfect and eventually convinced ol’ George to cast him. Good for them.
I think you must have that backwards. Star Wars came out in 1977, Raiders of the Lost Ark not until 1981. It is interesting, though, that Lucas didn’t want to have the same major actor in both films.
 
…I feel the same about stylized fights which is why I don’t like the final fight between Obi Wan and Aniken in ‘‘Revenge of the Sith’’ which is hailed as one of, if not the best fight in the series by fans. Talk about spinning and unnecessary flailing. …I have to check out ‘‘Crouching Tiger and Hidden Dragon’’ now. I just watched the Rob Roy fight scene again and I have to say, there’s now way a rapier blocks a strike from a broadsword that many times and doesn’t break. Although that would have ruined the fight scene…
I just have to disagree with the end fight in ‘‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’’. That’s another film I have seen more times than I care to remember and while the sword fight is certainly the highlight of the film, I really don’t think it is very good. Most of it is super sped up to make it appear faster and more intense, but Erroll Flynn comes off as more clownish and less willing to fight than Gisbourne. That film is just too cheesy and sparkly for my tastes. Not that I only enjoy dark gritty films, but it seems overly campy and corny.
Rapiers were tougher than most people imagine–while narrow in width they tended to be thick (a semi flattened diamond profile was most common) except in the last eight inches or so for raking slashes (which Cunnigham uses to wear Rob down). Also, a rapier user is really going to be avoiding any direct block stopping actions against heavier weapons and use “single time” dodges and re-direction parries–again which Cunningham does.

The late Bob Anderson happened to be the fight director for both Robin Hood and Princess Bride and what he did he did well, but for gritty and realistic I can’t think of any better than Bill Hobbes–with the possible exception of John Waller who directed John Cleese (the Black Knight) and Terry Gilliam (the Green Knight) in the initial fight at the bridge in Monty Python and the Search for the Holy Grail

Personaly, I pretty much avoid any “wire-fu”, though Tiger/Dragon did it as well as it can be done–episodes 2 & 3 fights of Star Wars were bloody ridiculous
 
Wire fu can be enjoyable at least for me. Though the fights sometimes lose their impact because they become somewhat repetitive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top