S
SGTTOM
Guest
Too be fair Lucas didn’t write the Empire Strikes Back or direct it. I never minded Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia. I thought for the most part the entire cast for the original films played their characters well…I don’t mind films with a lighter tone, it’s just the dialog and acting that mainly makes me cringe. I just can’t make it through any of the movies without barfing any time anyone besides Yoda, Vader, Obi Wan and Qui Gonn opens their mouth. Okay maybe I am exaggerating a bit but I just can’t fathom why George Lucas wouldn’t hire someone to write the script. I bet one of my little brothers could make a better script.
The acting isn’t much better either. Hayden Christensen anyone? Harrison Ford and Alec Guiness were the only ones I could stand from the originals.
Anyhow, now that I’ve properly trolled myself out, I will add that the lightsaber fights especially in the Phantom Menace are one of the best battle scenes I have watched.
The stories aren’t bad, I almost like the Empire Strikes Back, but I just can’t get past the previously mentioned issues.
As far as the lightsaber fights I thought the Phantom Menace’s fight was to obviously choreographed. It was like they were intentionally hitting each others blades instead of attempting to actually hit the opponent’s body. Darth Mauls slow reaction to Obi Wan’s attack when he is sliced in half was silly too. The music was extremely epic though and the set was awesome too.
I personally thought the best fight was Luke vs Vader in Empire. A balance of some cool effects and sword fighting without being overly flashy. Sure the original didn’t contain the best duels however it was more of an internal fight. Vader was never sure that he wanted to kill Luke.
I don’t mind the actors in any of the films. Sure I would have cast a different person to play Anakin. However I think Hayden could have done a good job if he had a better script.
I personally enjoy the Star War dialog from the first two films. What in particular do you not like about them dialogue wise, any particular quotes? Star Wars a New Hope had a few cheesy lines from Han, Luke, and Leia, it didn’t ruin the film for me so. This problem wasn’t very evident in the Empire Strikes Back.