Letter To Bishops

  • Thread starter Thread starter pkmksk
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

pkmksk

Guest
I have seen many people say they have sent letters to their respective Bishops in regards to liturgical abuses, so what are the responses? If anyone has done this, could you explain why you wrote and more importantly give the response you were given.

I am debating about wether or not to write a letter to my own Bishop about liturgical abuses I have noticed. I was wondering what the results have been with others who have already done so.
Thanks in advance. 👍
 
I suspect this question of yours will fly by unanswered by most on these forums. Most folks don’t want to go out on a limb…even here anonymously.
  • Female pastoral assistant gave unorthodox Holy Thursday Homily while priest sat and listened.
  • Routine use of female pastoral assistants for Homilies
  • Intinction (“illegal dipping”: receiving the host in the hand, going to the minister with the chalice, and dipping the consecrated host into the chalice and receiving communion)
  • Self – Communicating
  • Using leavened flavored bread for Eucharistic Bread
  • Unorthodox Penance Services – priest asked those present to turn to each other – tell each other our sins and then forgive each other.
  • Priest celebrating Mass and carrying on with a married woman when off the altar.
  • Emptying of Holy Water fonts during Lent
  • Priest using crystal pendulum to demonstrate healing on students
  • Use of parish education building for public school teenagers. Teenagers were invited in to ‘jam’ with song and musical instruments….pagan music and sinful lyrics were par for the course
How did the Bishop respond?

He always responded.

He always responded with a courteous acknowledgement. .

Did anything change?

No-everyone just kept doing their thang.

And I had a few more people dislike me with every letter written.

I live in a very liberal diocese. Not all are so difficult and rebellious to the Church.

If you don’t get results you can go beyond the Bishop.

Remember:’

Go to priest first with your concerns.

If you don’t get positive results from your priest then go to your Bishop. Be sure that your priest and bishop aren’t polishing you with untruth. You need to do your homework by looking for answers from good sources. Try CA Answers and EWTN for some answers to questions you might have.

Do your duty. Every letter counts.
 
Thanks for the reply, and I didn’t really expect many reponses. Yet, I think a few will do and to be honest I can pretty much guess most responses will be less than encouraging.

The abuses I observed are minor compared to the ones you have witnessed. I suppose I was lucky, and it could have been much worse.

My own problem is unique, I am in the military and we had a stand in priest from Florida here for a couple of weeks. He was a very good speaker and I enjoyed his homilies, however he had a tendancy to adlib during the Eucharisitic Prayer. Also, he had the congregation say part of the Eucharistic Prayer with him. I spoke with my priest about this and got the impression that he was not going to do anything about it. He basically just changed the subject, but in his defense he is very busy being the only priest for over 10,000 people. He also leads the military chaplain’s at this base so he has admin duties in addition to all the usual duties of a Catholic priest. I really feel for him because he is generally overworked and underappreciated. Basically the military looks at him as a naval officer first and a priest second and that is how they treat him.

So, my letter would be to the military archbishop who does not preside over the parish that our temporary priest is serving. Since the abuses took place in my church I am not sure if I should direct my concern to my Bishop or the temporary priests permanent Bishop in Florida.

Any opinions are welcome.
 
Your Bishop has what is called the duty of vigilance and has the obligation to protect orthodoxy in his Diocese so what would be correct is a letter to the Bishop with a cc to the Military Archbishop
 
I just sent one to my Bishop last week. These are the abuses I reported:
  1. A priest not giving a Homily in order to allow time at the end of the Mass for a woman, lay congregant to give a speech during Mass.
  2. The woman who gave the talk during Mass also had a question/answer session, in the Sanctuary after Mass (standing at the same lectern where the Gospel is read). During this Q/A session she proceeded to talk about all sorts of things that “needed to be changed” in the Catholic Church. She talked about how the Church’s stance on birth control is an outdated idea from the 1930’s, and how Pope Benedict was responsible for the "firing’ of that Jesuit priest from America magazine. She mentioned women’s ordination. The worst was when she talked about how she felt that the Church’s stance on homosexuality is wrong, and is just based on “a few verses from the Old Testament”. (Apparently totally forgetting about Romans 1:26-27 and 1 Cor. 6:9-10). She never made any attempt to say, “The Church’s stance on this is _______”. The priest who was present did not say anything to contradict her.
  3. When one of the priests used the altar for a magic trick during his Homily.
Since I have just sent this, I have not heard anything back. I did attempt to contact the priest about this, but instead of him calling me back, he had this other woman who had arranged for that speaker call me. She said she would relay my concerns to him, but then he never called back to address my concerns.
 
Thanks for the replies, now I have to find out who the Bishop is for the Fort Lauderdale area.
 
40.png
contemplative:
I suspect this question of yours will fly by unanswered by most on these forums. Most folks don’t want to go out on a limb…even here anonymously.
  • Female pastoral assistant gave unorthodox Holy Thursday Homily while priest sat and listened.
  • Routine use of female pastoral assistants for Homilies
  • Intinction (“illegal dipping”: receiving the host in the hand, going to the minister with the chalice, and dipping the consecrated host into the chalice and receiving communion)
  • Self – Communicating
  • Using leavened flavored bread for Eucharistic Bread
  • Unorthodox Penance Services – priest asked those present to turn to each other – tell each other our sins and then forgive each other.
  • Priest celebrating Mass and carrying on with a married woman when off the altar.
  • Emptying of Holy Water fonts during Lent
  • Priest using crystal pendulum to demonstrate healing on students
  • Use of parish education building for public school teenagers. Teenagers were invited in to ‘jam’ with song and musical instruments….pagan music and sinful lyrics were par for the course
How did the Bishop respond?

He always responded.

He always responded with a courteous acknowledgement. .

Did anything change?

No-everyone just kept doing their thang.

And I had a few more people dislike me with every letter written.

I live in a very liberal diocese. Not all are so difficult and rebellious to the Church.

If you don’t get results you can go beyond the Bishop.

Remember:’

Go to priest first with your concerns.

If you don’t get positive results from your priest then go to your Bishop. Be sure that your priest and bishop aren’t polishing you with untruth. You need to do your homework by looking for answers from good sources. Try CA Answers and EWTN for some answers to questions you might have.

Do your duty. Every letter counts.
This is very sad that this is STILL!!! Happening. I know some of these Bishops reprimand and love to do so on much very little stuff, but none seem to care for the Liturgy and to make sure the PASTORS religious order or diocesan are following and making sure their parochial vicars(assistant priests) are following GIRM and Redemptionis Sacramentum!! By the way, it seems lately from what I have seen here in this major East Coast archdiocese that most priests here have wiped their…noses with that document: Redemptionis Sacramentum, and this Cardinal here or those higer up’s charged with liturgy seem not to care, as to not ruffle feathers. Where is the great courage in cardinals as Robert Bellarmine, Cardinal Newman, bishops as St, Charles Borromeo, etc or Saint Francis de Sales. Or even Bishops as Saint Alphonsus Ligouri??? COURAGE!! POPE BENEDICT tell your cardinals in the USA and worldwide and the Bishops COURAGE!!! HAVE COURAGE!!! To make sure the liturgical liberalism, crystal/glass chalices stop!! Some pastors especially in the older religious orders continue to use those chalices, and they are doing it on purpouse!! I am sorry they cannot claim ignorance NOW after Redemptionis Sacramentum!! And with this great NEw POPE!!
 
I sent my bishop a lengthy letter regarding the United States Council of Catholic Bishops and pro-abortion politicians. His response took a month or do, but was very detailed and pastoral. He saw me several months later and asked if his response was adequate.

Love & peace,
Bob
 
  1. A priest not giving a Homily in order to allow time at the end of the Mass for a woman, lay congregant to give a speech during Mass.
  1. The woman who gave the talk during Mass also had a question/answer session, in the Sanctuary after Mass (standing at the same lectern where the Gospel is read). During this Q/A session she proceeded to talk about all sorts of things that “needed to be changed” in the Catholic Church. She talked about how the Church’s stance on birth control is an outdated idea from the 1930’s, and how Pope Benedict was responsible for the "firing’ of that Jesuit priest from America magazine. She mentioned women’s ordination. The worst was when she talked about how she felt that the Church’s stance on homosexuality is wrong, and is just based on “a few verses from the Old Testament”. (Apparently totally forgetting about Romans 1:26-27 and 1 Cor. 6:9-10). She never made any attempt to say, “The Church’s stance on this is _______”. The priest who was present did not say anything
to contradict her.

Lord have mercy! Thank you for writing to your Bishop!

Peace,

MilesJesu
 
In terms of the liturgical abuses I have personally witnessed, I have always gone to the priest first.

In one case, the priest became agitated and personally attacked me. I continued to ask why he chose B when the GIRM and the Church called for A. He never changed a thing until I went to the Bishop. The Bishop did an awesome job.

In another case, the priest was awesome. He said, I didn’t realize we were doing that. He made the change.

I think many times, we owe more than just a letter to the Bishop. If the words of consecration are changed, we should call, and visit. Abuses will not stop unless we are persistent in obtaining what is rightfully ours: An authentic Catholic Mass, celebrated according to the prescribed method by the Holy Church.

Peace,

MilesJesu
 
pkmksk,

Fort Lauderdale is contained within the Archdiocese of Miami. The info for Miami is:

Archbishop John Clement Favarola
9401 Biscayne Blvd.
Miami Shores, FL 33138

Telephone: (305)757-6241
Fax: (305) 754-1897

John
 
I have written to my Bishop, but I won’t discuss the details here. Jesus instructed to go public only in the event that our corrections were rejected. Therefore, posting the responses on a public forum would most inappropriate. :tsktsk:
 
I have written to my Bishop, but I won’t discuss the details here. Jesus instructed to go public only in the event that our corrections were rejected. Therefore, posting the responses on a public forum would most inappropriate.
Not to sure how to reply to this…If you don’t want to share your experience then don’t post. My thread was meant to gauge how Bishops respond to written complaints. I never asked for names, only what the original complaint was and then the resolution. My intent is to gather information so I can gauge what type of response I will receive to my letter.
 
40.png
contemplative:
I suspect this question of yours will fly by unanswered by most on these forums. Most folks don’t want to go out on a limb…even here anonymously.
  • Female pastoral assistant gave unorthodox Holy Thursday Homily while priest sat and listened.
  • Routine use of female pastoral assistants for Homilies
  • Intinction (“illegal dipping”: receiving the host in the hand, going to the minister with the chalice, and dipping the consecrated host into the chalice and receiving communion)
  • Self – Communicating
  • Using leavened flavored bread for Eucharistic Bread
  • Unorthodox Penance Services – priest asked those present to turn to each other – tell each other our sins and then forgive each other.
  • Priest celebrating Mass and carrying on with a married woman when off the altar.
  • Emptying of Holy Water fonts during Lent
  • Priest using crystal pendulum to demonstrate healing on students
  • Use of parish education building for public school teenagers. Teenagers were invited in to ‘jam’ with song and musical instruments….pagan music and sinful lyrics were par for the course
How did the Bishop respond?

He always responded.

He always responded with a courteous acknowledgement. .

Did anything change?

No-everyone just kept doing their thang.

And I had a few more people dislike me with every letter written.

I live in a very liberal diocese. Not all are so difficult and rebellious to the Church.

If you don’t get results you can go beyond the Bishop.

Remember:’

Go to priest first with your concerns.

If you don’t get positive results from your priest then go to your Bishop. Be sure that your priest and bishop aren’t polishing you with untruth. You need to do your homework by looking for answers from good sources. Try CA Answers and EWTN for some answers to questions you might have.

Do your duty. Every letter counts.
Maybe I missed it, but did you ever forward those responses to the CDW or did you follow up with the CDW when you got no response?
 
40.png
Lux_et_veritas:
Maybe I missed it, but did you ever forward those responses to the CDW or did you follow up with the CDW when you got no response?
No I have not.
The incidences described involved 4 different priests within a three year span.
To be honest with you at the time I felt like I was in a maelstrom forcing me to the point I am now.
Only in the past 1/2 year have I felt peace. It isn’t too late to write a letter?
Do you have an address for the Congregation of Divine Worship? Is this really the next step?
Who do I address my letter to?
 
40.png
contemplative:
No I have not.
The incidences described involved 4 different priests within a three year span.
To be honest with you at the time I felt like I was in a maelstrom forcing me to the point I am now.
Only in the past 1/2 year have I felt peace. It isn’t too late to write a letter?
Do you have an address for the Congregation of Divine Worship? Is this really the next step?
Who do I address my letter to?
  1. The Apostolic See
[181.] Whenever the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments receives at least a plausible notice of a delict or an abuse concerning the Most Holy Eucharist, it informs the Ordinary so that he may investigate the matter. When the matter turns out to be serious, the Ordinary should send to the same Dicastery as quickly as possible a copy of the acts of the inquiry that has been undertaken, and where necessary, the penalty imposed.

[182.] In more difficult cases the Ordinary, for the sake of the good of the universal Church in the care for which he too has a part by virtue of his sacred Ordination, should not fail to handle the matter, having previously taken advice from the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments. For its part, this Congregation, on the strength of the faculties given to it by the Roman Pontiff, according to the nature of the case, will assist the Ordinary, granting him the necessarydispensations[289] or giving him instructions or prescriptions, which he is to follow diligently.
  1. Complaints Regarding Abuses in Liturgical Matters
[183.] In an altogether particular manner, let everyone do all that is in their power to ensure that the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist will be protected from any and every irreverence or distortion and that all abuses be thoroughly corrected. This is a most serious duty incumbent upon each and every one, and all are bound to carry it out without any favouritism.
**
[184.] Any Catholic, whether Priest or Deacon or lay member of Christ’s faithful, has the right to lodge a complaint regarding a liturgical abuse to the diocesan Bishop or the competent Ordinary equivalent to him in law, or to the Apostolic See on account of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff.**[290] It is fitting, however, insofar as possible, that the report or complaint be submitted first to the diocesan Bishop. This is naturally to be done in truth and charity.

CONCLUSION

[185.] “Against the seeds of discord which daily experience shows to be so deeply ingrained in human nature as a result of sin, there stands the creative power of the unity of Christ’s body. For it is precisely by building up the Church that the Eucharist establishes fellowship among men.”[291] It is therefore the hope of this Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments that also, by the diligent application of those things that are recalled in this Instruction, human weakness may come to pose less of an obstacle to the action of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist, and that with all distortion set aside and every reprobated practice removed,[292] through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary, “Woman of the Eucharist”, the saving presence of Christ in the Sacrament of his Body and Blood may shine brightly upon all people.

[186.] Let all Christ’s faithful participate in the Most Holy Eucharist as fully, consciously and actively as they can,[293] honouring it lovingly by their devotion and the manner of their life. Let Bishops, Priests and Deacons, in the exercise of the sacred ministry, examine their consciences as regards the authenticity and fidelity of the actions they have performed in the name of Christ and the Church in the celebration of the Sacred Liturgy. Let each one of the sacred ministers ask himself, even with severity, whether he has respected the rights of the lay members of Christ’s faithful, who confidently entrust themselves and their children to him, relying on him to fulfill for the faithful those sacred functions that the Church intends to carry out in celebrating the sacred Liturgy at Christ’s command.[294] For each one should always remember that he is a servant of the Sacred Liturgy.[295]

All things to the contrary notwithstanding.

This Instruction, prepared by the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments by mandate of the Supreme Pontiff John Paul II in collaboration with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, was approved by the same Pontiff on the Solemnity of St. Joseph, 19 March 2004, and he ordered it to be published and to be observed immediately by all concerned.

From the offices of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, Rome, on the Solemnity of the Annunciation of the Lord, 25 March 2004.

Francis Card. Arinze
Prefect

Domenico Sorrentino
Archbishop Secretary
 
Address:

Antonio Maria Cardinal Javierre Ortas
Sacred Congregation for Divine Worship
Piazza Pio XII 10
00193 Rome, VATICAN CITY
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top