E
Ewald_Holzhaus
Guest
In all my 86 years, and except as an altar server, I have never lit a candle in church because I always thought -mistakenly, no doubt - that people lit candles instead of praying. Can someone ‘enlighten’ me?
Sure: Thanks for asking.=Ewald Holzhaus;13438133]In all my 86 years, and except as an altar server, I have never lit a candle in church because I always thought -mistakenly, no doubt - that people lit candles instead of praying. Can someone ‘enlighten’ me?
That is different from lighting candles and praying - at least I hope it is for Catholics! I’m a convert, so maybe I never got the memo, but lighting a candle is not for getting wishes (prayers) granted, but a symbol of the prayer. It is asking others to pray for your intentions. The money one gives when lighting a candle is to pay for the candle.…I finally looked it up in Wikimedia and read the following:-
“A votive deposit or votive offering is one or more objects displayed or deposited, without the intention of recovery or use, in a sacred place for broadly religious purposes…”
This is not the Catholic practice.I finally looked it up in Wikimedia and read the following:-
“A votive deposit or votive offering is one or more objects displayed or deposited, without the intention of recovery or use, in a sacred place for broadly religious purposes. Such items are a feature of modern and ancient societies and are generally made in order to gain favor with supernatural forces. Some offerings have apparently been made in anticipation of the achievement of a particular wish, but in Western cultures from which documentary evidence survives it has been more typical to wait until the wish has been fulfilled before making the offering,[citation needed] for which the more specific term ex-voto may be used. Votive offerings have been described in historical Roman era and Greek sources, although similar acts continue into the present day, for example in traditional Catholic culture and, arguably, in the modern-day practice of tossing coins into a wishing well or fountain. The modern construction practice called topping out can be considered as an example of a votive practice that has very ancient roots”.
Another reason to be cautious with Wikipedia.This is not the Catholic practice.
The bit of money given is to cover the cost of the candles, It isnt lit to get a favor or a wish and i would hope no practicing Catholic would use in this way.
You dear friend were NEAR “the light of truth”=Ewald Holzhaus;13438133]In all my 86 years, and except as an altar server, I have never lit a candle in church because I always thought -mistakenly, no doubt - that people lit candles instead of praying. Can someone ‘enlighten’ me?
Yes, the button pushed fake candles are not as nice as real candles, with the little sand boxes with sticks.Yes. Clearly votive candles are a profit center for parishes, as they usually charge more than the candles cost. So we are offering a monetary donation along with our prayers.
In my parish, one of the first things our pastor did was get rid of the ugly and stupid electric votives and install real candle racks. A nice elderly couple takes care of maintaining the candles and collecting the money. The suggested donation is $1 while the 3-hour votives probably cost $0.25 or less.