Lipa, Philippines - approved or unapproved?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monica4316
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay I found this 🙂

November 12, 2009 Lipa, Phillipines

Decree from Archbishop Ramon Arguelles, DD, STL

Whereas, on April 12, 1951 the then Apostolic Administrator of Lipa, Rufino J. Santos, D.D., issued a decree banning public veneration of the image of Our Lady Mary, Mediatrix of All Grace;

Whereas, while the Carmelite nuns and some others, most specially the Lipa clergy, obediently observed the ban, the great majority of ordinary faithful silently but perseveringly continued their prayer to and devotion towards the Mediatrix of All Grace;

Whereas, on July 16, 1991 after 40 years of silence the Most Rev Mariano G. Gaviola in effect lifted the ban and allowed the veneration of the Image of Mary, Mediatrix of All Grace for the people to pray for world peace;

Whereas, the fervour of numerous faithful from the Archdiocese of Lipa and from elsewhere continued and even increased throughout the subsequent years and many miracles of physical and spiritual healing have been ceaselessly reported;

Whereas, increasing number of pilgrims heed the supposed call of the Blessed Mother Mediatrix of All Grace by visiting the monastery making penitential processions and praying almost everyday but most of all on first Saturdays and every twelfth day of the month;

Whereas, the faithful seek from the official church guidance and assistance in deeper faith;

Whereas, the local church of Lipa that will celebrate its centenary from April 10,2010 to April 10, 2011 looks forward to a deeper renewal of faith in all the faithful and the increase missionary fervour with the help of Mary, the Star of Third Millennium Evangelization;

Whereas in the last one hundred years apparently the issue on the Mediatrix of All Grace, regardless of the authenticity or not of the so-called Marian apparitions in the Carmel of Lipa, is the most celebrated event recorded of this local Church;

So, therefore, I, the undersigned Archbishop of the Archdiocese of Lipa declare and publicly announce:
  1. That pursuant to the instructions and conditions issued by my predecessor Archbishop Mariano G. Gaviola, the decree of 1951 is hereby reversed;
  2. That the public veneration of the image of Mary, Mediatrix of All Grace in the Carmelite Monastery of Lipa be continued and made available for the prayer of the pilgrims for true peace in our nation and the sanctification of all priests;
  3. That the contemplative and prayerful atmosphere of the Carmelite monastery as willed by the reforms of St. Teresa of Avila be properly maintained for the edification and spiritual growth of the pilgrims who join the prayers of the contemplatives of the said place;
  4. That all bans written or unwritten intended to curtail or diminish the devotion to Mary Mediatrix of All Grace be lifted;
  5. Finally, that a new commission be established to review the documents about the so-called apparitions in 1948 as well as to compile further documents thereafter up to the present.
Given this 12th day of November in the year of the Lord two thousand and nine.

Archbishop Ramon C. Arguelles, D.D.
Archbishop of Lipa
 
Okay I found this 🙂

November 12, 2009 Lipa, Phillipines

Decree from Archbishop Ramon Arguelles, DD, STL

Whereas, on April 12, 1951 the then Apostolic Administrator of Lipa, Rufino J. Santos, D.D., issued a decree banning public veneration of the image of Our Lady Mary, Mediatrix of All Grace;

Whereas, while the Carmelite nuns and some others, most specially the Lipa clergy, obediently observed the ban, the great majority of ordinary faithful silently but perseveringly continued their prayer to and devotion towards the Mediatrix of All Grace;

Whereas, on July 16, 1991 after 40 years of silence the Most Rev Mariano G. Gaviola in effect lifted the ban and allowed the veneration of the Image of Mary, Mediatrix of All Grace for the people to pray for world peace;

Whereas, the fervour of numerous faithful from the Archdiocese of Lipa and from elsewhere continued and even increased throughout the subsequent years and many miracles of physical and spiritual healing have been ceaselessly reported;

Whereas, increasing number of pilgrims heed the supposed call of the Blessed Mother Mediatrix of All Grace by visiting the monastery making penitential processions and praying almost everyday but most of all on first Saturdays and every twelfth day of the month;

Whereas, the faithful seek from the official church guidance and assistance in deeper faith;

Whereas, the local church of Lipa that will celebrate its centenary from April 10,2010 to April 10, 2011 looks forward to a deeper renewal of faith in all the faithful and the increase missionary fervour with the help of Mary, the Star of Third Millennium Evangelization;

Whereas in the last one hundred years apparently the issue on the Mediatrix of All Grace, regardless of the authenticity or not of the so-called Marian apparitions in the Carmel of Lipa, is the most celebrated event recorded of this local Church;

So, therefore, I, the undersigned Archbishop of the Archdiocese of Lipa declare and publicly announce:
  1. That pursuant to the instructions and conditions issued by my predecessor Archbishop Mariano G. Gaviola, the decree of 1951 is hereby reversed;
  2. That the public veneration of the image of Mary, Mediatrix of All Grace in the Carmelite Monastery of Lipa be continued and made available for the prayer of the pilgrims for true peace in our nation and the sanctification of all priests;
  3. That the contemplative and prayerful atmosphere of the Carmelite monastery as willed by the reforms of St. Teresa of Avila be properly maintained for the edification and spiritual growth of the pilgrims who join the prayers of the contemplatives of the said place;
  4. That all bans written or unwritten intended to curtail or diminish the devotion to Mary Mediatrix of All Grace be lifted;
  5. Finally, that a new commission be established to review the documents about the so-called apparitions in 1948 as well as to compile further documents thereafter up to the present.
Given this 12th day of November in the year of the Lord two thousand and nine.

Archbishop Ramon C. Arguelles, D.D.
Archbishop of Lipa
The letter you quoted confirms it is not approved by the Church.
 
it’s saying the opposite though?
Look at point 5. in the letter. A new Commission is being set up to look into everything. It even mentions “so-called” apparitions, meaning they are not approved apparitions but alleged apparitions. The new Commission is to investigate and come to a decision. Don’t confuse removing a ban as being the same as an approval.
 
That’s right, devotion is now allowed but doesn’t presently have the Church stamp of approval. These events have not been declared “worthy of belief;” a commission has been sent out to evaluate them.

Veneration of all kinds of supposedly holy objects and apparitions is permitted without Church approval, provided it hasn’t officially disapproved or banned the veneration.
 
That’s right, devotion is now allowed but doesn’t presently have the Church stamp of approval. These events have not been declared “worthy of belief;” a commission has been sent out to evaluate them.

Veneration of all kinds of supposedly holy objects and apparitions is permitted without Church approval, provided it hasn’t officially disapproved or banned the veneration.
just trying to understand this.

so Catholics can be devoted or worshipful towards an apparition which the CC has not approved or given the official green light on?

if the events mentioned have not been declared “worthy of belief” by Catholics, why does the Church allow that belief by allowing devotion?
 
just trying to understand this.

so Catholics can be devoted or worshipful towards an apparition which the CC has not approved or given the official green light on?
First of all, we definitely need to distinguish between “devotion” and “worship.” I’m allowed to, as a dutiful son, have a strong devotion to my Mom – in other words, treat her with high honor and reverence. Indeed, the Ten Commandments command me to: “Honor your father and your mother.” Jesus also calls us to be devoted to our fellow Christians, as you can see from passages like this:

Matthew 10:41-42 said:
“Whoever receives a prophet because he is a prophet will receive a prophet’s reward, and whoever receives a righteous man because he is righteous will receive a righteous man’s reward. And whoever gives only a cup of cold water to one of these little ones to drink because he is a disciple–amen, I say to you, he will surely not lose his reward.”

Or this:

Luke 1:41-45 said:
41
When Elizabeth heard Mary’s greeting, the infant leaped in her womb, and Elizabeth, filled with the holy Spirit,
42
cried out in a loud voice and said, “Most blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb.
43
And how does this happen to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?
44
For at the moment the sound of your greeting reached my ears, the infant in my womb leaped for joy.
45
Blessed are you who believed that what was spoken to you by the Lord would be fulfilled.”

Being devoted to our fellow brothers and sisters in Christ, honoring them and praising them when praise is due, is scriptural. Just consider Hebrews 11; the whole CHAPTER is devoted to honoring fellow Christians. God’s Word calls us to honor them and be devoted to them, for in doing so we bring glory to God by praising what He has done in the lives of His people, and praising the people for their choice to unite themselves to His will. Doing this brings honor to Christ; it is beneficial for our souls.

WORSHIPING anyone but God alone, on the other hand, is obviously completely out, as is obvious from passages like Revelation 22:8-9 and others.

The only apparitions one can be worshipful toward are apparitions of God Himself, for then one is worshipping God.

Though I suspect you’re defining “worshipful” differently than we would. Singing a hymn in praise of someone is not worshipping her, any more than singing, “America, America,” is worshipping America. Asking for someone to pray for you to God (which is all we do when we “pray” to saints) is also not worshipping the person. Bowing to someone, or to a representation of someone, is also not worshipping that person but is honoring them (Gen. 37:7, 49:8).

Here’s a good article describing some of these things in more depth. There are more articles on the same website that describe all these issues and provide a lot of scriptural evidence and good discussion. God bless you; I hope you enjoy it :).

catholic.com/library/Praying_to_the_Saints.asp

We may praise saints, bow to their images out of respect for what they represent, and speak to the saints who have fallen asleep, for in Christ all are alive (Luke 20:37-38), but we may not worship them.
if the events mentioned have not been declared “worthy of belief” by Catholics, why does the Church allow that belief by allowing devotion?
Millions of spiritual experiences occur in people’s lives, from God, without the Church authenticating them. There’s no way the Church could physically have the finances and time to authenticate each one.

However, that doesn’t mean we’re left to our own devices. We have spiritual directors to help give us guidance in matters of spiritual experiences and interior life. When something big is happening that’s impacting quite a number of people, these are the primary occasions the Church steps in and makes a statement about it. Otherwise the local priest or spiritual director will give Catholics guidance regarding their spiritual experiences.

Besides, true apparitions always teach what the Church has taught from the time of Christ up to today. They don’t contradict the Sacred Tradition. If an apparition contradicts the Catholic faith, this is a foolproof evidence that it is not from God, for the Church is the Pillar and Foundation of Truth (1 Tim. 3:15) and consequently cannot lie or fall into error (Matt. 16:18, Rev. 21:27).
 
Lief ~

at the same time, there is a difference between asking a person in front of you to pray for you, and offering them help, and praying to a saint who is no longer alive on this earth and who has been cannonized by the Church.

technically and oficially there may certainly be a difference between reverance and worship, but in practice i see many, many lay Catholics literally praying to saints, visiting their tombs, leaving prayers to be answered by that saint, and invoking that saint’s help for specific problems in exactly the same manner God would be invoked in private prayer. in addition to asking the saints to pray for them.

i’m not criticizing the practice, i’m just pointing out its reality.

the interest for me is in something like an apparition, and then the site of that appartition becoming a focal point for Catholic devotion. say, someone claims to see the Virgin Mary at a certain chapel. rumors of this vision spread, and many people flock to this chapel to pray the rosary, offer prayers to Mary, leave prayer requests, and seek healing for themselves and others. the place soon essentially becomes a shrine, and often the apparition is given a name (such as “Our Lady of ___”).

this tends to develop rather quickly, and for such a concentrated, location-specific event and public phenomenon, i’m just surprised the Church would allow devotion, worship, and laymen to believe in the authenticity of the visions when the Church itself has not verified that the visions are authentic, and worthy of belief.
 
Lief ~

at the same time, there is a difference between asking a person in front of you to pray for you, and offering them help, and praying to a saint who is no longer alive on this earth and who has been cannonized by the Church.
What’s the difference, if they’re all one and alive in Christ?
technically and oficially there may certainly be a difference between reverance and worship, but in practice i see many, many lay Catholics literally praying to saints, visiting their tombs, leaving prayers to be answered by that saint, and invoking that saint’s help for specific problems in exactly the same manner God would be invoked in private prayer. in addition to asking the saints to pray for them.

i’m not criticizing the practice, i’m just pointing out its reality.
What you are doing is MISUNDERSTANDING the reality of what these Catholics going to the shrines or parishes are doing. I’ve prayed in some of these ways myself and certainly don’t see a problem with doing any of what you mentioned, but you don’t understand what I (or the other Catholics who do these things) are doing when we do these things.

When we pray to a saint, asking their help in a particular situation, visiting their tombs, addressing the saint directly for help, wisdom or guidance, we know and expect that the saint will offer our intention up to Jesus.

I might say, “Mary, grant me wisdom and peace,” and if I say this, I am assuming that she will ask the Lord. Or I might say, “St. Andrew, bring my friend back to the faith,” or “St. Andrew, help me find my lost dog,” and I’m assuming in that request that the person will do what I ask (if the prayer is answered in the affirmative) by praying for me :). We don’t believe it’s only the saint, on his own authority, doing whatever happens. We know whenever we pray to a saint that the saint will go to Jesus and we wouldn’t have it any other way. Nothing in Heaven happens without the will of God or the action of the Holy Spirit. We know that when we ask a saint for something or tell a saint something, the glory of our praise or the intention of our prayer goes immediately to God through the saint. This is not always explicit in our prayers, but when it is not explicit, it’s implicit.

Because we know what we’re talking about, a great many of us feel very free to pray directly to saints without using the technical terminology of, “please pray for me that this will happen . . .” We know the saint will do that so we don’t always bother with the excess verbiage. I can understand your confusion, not being a Catholic and just judging for yourself based on your view of what you can see, but trust me, all the Catholics I’ve ever spoken with acknowledge the truth of this. We know what we’re talking about when we pray, so we don’t always bother with using technical terminology describing what takes place.

To clarify this a little further, I’ll just add that this is exactly the same as when a Protestant goes and says to his friends, “Billy Graham converted two thousand people at that meeting he hosted!” Because we’re fellow Christians, we know the Protestant means, “The Holy Spirit converted two thousand people through Billy Graham.” We know that no human converts anyone else; the Holy Spirit acting on the heart is the one Who converts. However, as we know what we’re talking about, we don’t always bother with the excess verbiage in ordinary conversation.

Hope that clarifies this.

One other thing I wanted to say is that receiving graces by visiting the tombs of holy people is perfectly Biblical; see II Kings 13:21.

Also remember how even handkerchiefs that touched Paul could be taken back to people, and those people would be healed. And other people were healed by falling under Peter’s shadow or touching Jesus’ tunic. These objects weren’t the men themselves but nonetheless because of their association with the holy ones of God, God acted through them (and the faith of those who received) to heal, similar to how he acted through David’s harp, or the Ark of the Covenant, or the serpent Moses raised on a pole, and so on.
the interest for me is in something like an apparition, and then the site of that appartition becoming a focal point for Catholic devotion. say, someone claims to see the Virgin Mary at a certain chapel. rumors of this vision spread, and many people flock to this chapel to pray the rosary, offer prayers to Mary, leave prayer requests, and seek healing for themselves and others. the place soon essentially becomes a shrine, and often the apparition is given a name (such as “Our Lady of ___”).

this tends to develop rather quickly, and for such a concentrated, location-specific event and public phenomenon, i’m just surprised the Church would allow devotion, worship, and laymen to believe in the authenticity of the visions when the Church itself has not verified that the visions are authentic, and worthy of belief.
The Church doesn’t ban something unless she has a reason to do so, such as if the apparition is teaching false doctrines. There’s no assumption of invalidity until proof of validity appears. There’s no assumption made either way. The Church just carefully investigates and then makes a statement when she feels she knows the answer.

Would it be right for the Church to shut down the work of the Lord simply because she isn’t sure it’s Him yet? To make Him work on her timetable?

That wouldn’t make sense. The Church doesn’t host true apparitions like events, and she doesn’t control them. God does. Hence the Church moves carefully out of respect for the work of God, while working to distinguish whether or not an apparition is genuine.
 
Lief ~

the difference is that the saint is no longer here on earth, to interact with us as flesh and blood human beings. we can not see them, or personally interact with them as we would a living person.

prayers to the dead are just that, Lief, prayers to the dead. yes they are alive in Christ and alive forever, but they are no longer with us. if in heaven, they are worshipping and adoring God and the Lamb.

one is essentially asking an invisible, living power in heaven to powerfully and supernaturally intercede and offer their personal help to change matters for the better. that is the very definition of prayer, friend.
 
Lief ~

the difference is that the saint is no longer here on earth, to interact with us as flesh and blood human beings.
Neither is Jesus visibly, physically (except in the Blessed Sacrament), yet we interact with Him.
we can not see them, or personally interact with them as we would a living person.
Yes we can, as countless Catholics on these forums will tell you. How can you claim to know what you haven’t tested or experienced?

Here are a few stories of interaction with St. Therese of Lisieux from these forums:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=189178&highlight=Flowers+of+St.+Therese&page=2
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=359280&highlight=stories+of+saints

The communications between saints in Heaven and those saints on Earth who have now been canonized are often far more extraordinary and personal than those in these threads. Though this doesn’t diminish the beauty of the experiences with saints Catholics on these forums have encountered.

Speaking on a personal level, interaction with saints has become a deeply loving part of my spiritual life. I cannot tell you how much love I have received and offered through this, or how Mary has turned my love of God from a pond into what (only in comparison to how much I loved Him before I met Mary, NOT in comparison to how much I should love Him) is now a lake.

Ultimately, Jesus is our final example for how we should live our lives. In some ways, I think we Catholics hold to this more firmly than do most Protestants, because Protestants refuse to follow His example when He spoke to Moses and Elijah at the Transfiguration. He took His disciples with Him and they saw Him shining in dazzling light and speaking with the souls of two departed saints.

All Christians followed His example until the Reformation.
prayers to the dead are just that, Lief, prayers to the dead. yes they are alive in Christ and alive forever, but they are no longer with us.
That cannot be true, for we are one Body. As Paul writes in 1 Cor. 12:21, “The eye cannot say to the hand, ‘I do not need you,’ nor again the head to the feet, ‘I do not need you.’” No part of the body can say of any other part, “I do not need you,” yet many Protestants say of those in Heaven, “I do not need you.” In verse 25, Paul writes, “there may be no division in the body.” No division at all, which includes between those in Heaven and those on Earth, until the Protestant Reformers decided to invent a new interpretation that argues for division.

Jesus Himself emphasizes Paul’s teaching even more deeply in John 17:22, when He prays to His Father, “And I have given them the glory you gave me, so that they may be one, as we are one.” This is the unity of the Trinity itself He is talking about, for that is the unity He and His Father share. A total oneness of life, love, doctrine, and communion on every level. This total oneness cannot exist in a family that is split in two and forbids unity between the halves. Instead, this is the unity Jesus expressed plainly when He talked openly with Moses and Elijah in the presence of His Apostles, the Body of Christ in Heaven and on Earth united in one company on that one mountain, working together with one purpose, Jesus’ purpose, the salvation of the human race.
if in heaven, they are worshipping and adoring God and the Lamb.
Indeed they are. And one of the most important ways of loving God is loving your neighbor. They have never stopped loving their neighbors on Earth, just as God has not, and they continually express this love through prayer for us, just as we continually express our love for our neighbors in Heaven by honoring, praising and communing with them in prayer.
one is essentially asking an invisible, living power in heaven to powerfully and supernaturally intercede and offer their personal help to change matters for the better. that is the very definition of prayer, friend.
Let’s say I asked St. Peter while he was alive on Earth to pray for me. I’m then asking a visible, living power to powerfully and supernaturally (or not supernaturally; we don’t argue that a saint praying is supernatural, though it can have supernatural consequences) intercede and offer personal help to change matters for the better. Am I “praying” to Saint Peter when I ask him to pray for me?

The only differences between this and what you said is that in my example Peter would be visible and on Earth as opposed to invisible and in Heaven. I don’t see why you think invisibility and being in Heaven make all the difference. If these are sufficient factors to prevent us praying to someone, we have to rule out praying to Jesus as well.

Do you think it is wrong for Protestants to create religious websites with forums dedicated to prayer? If invisibility is a factor, this should be wrong. Because they can’t see who all is praying and they don’t know them personally (though we Catholics actually can and do often come to know the saints we pray to).

Also, do you think it is wrong to converse with angels or receive their aid simply because they are spirits from Heaven? I don’t think you’ll count their being spirits from Heaven a sufficient reason to exclude our receiving their help. You might have a reason for thinking it’s valid to speak with them and receive their help but not that of saints, but you don’t consider their being spirits from Heaven a factor against them. So there’s a double-standard when you use saints being spirits from Heaven as an argument against communication with them.
 
Lief ~

to respond to you.

thank you for writing back, firts of all.

no, i do not pray to or interact with angels, or ask their help. they are messengers of God and divine beings, but it is to God alone and to the Son to whom we ought to direct prayers, and cries for help.

the difference between the Lord Jesus and a deceased saint is that Jesus Christ is God. the saints are not. Jesus is in heaven, yet is also alive, divine, God, and eternal. He is not a finite being who was created into the world by God, but the Eternal Son, God the Son. hence He is worthy of our prayers and cries for help, and as i read Scripture He and He alone intercedes / mediates to God the Father on our behalf, with the Holy Spirit.

as to Protrestants creating websites for prayer requests, again that is a living person asking a living person to pray for them, and this is Biblical. the saints addressed in the Epistles are asked to pray for one another, yet this is within the context of a letter written to living people interacting with other living people within the Christian community.

another issue worth raising is, if according to Catholic idealogy, if all are alive in Christ in heaven and all are one (so why not ask the dead to pray for us?), could not a Catholic ask any deceased, pious Catholic to pray for them from heaven? why, or why not would this be alright?
 
I just had an idea, Grace. I have no interest in argument for argument’s sake; my sole interest is truth, and I suspect the same is true with you. My goal is not to justify my beliefs but to find deeper unity with you in Truth. But I feel that at the rate we’re going, neither of us will make any headway in developing the other’s understanding of truth because we’re too committed to our different viewpoints. Even if one of us finds his or her arguments completely undone, right now that person would not be convinced. Because we aren’t approaching this issue only intellectually. We’re also approaching it emotionally, from different backgrounds, with different assumptions and biases.

All we can do in our arguments is bounce off each other’s minds. The Holy Spirit of Truth, however, reaches hearts, and then after our hearts have been filled with His light, our minds become open to entering deeper unity with God’s Mind. The heart must be touched first and only the Holy Spirit can do that.

That brings me to my idea! 🙂 What if we both just set the arguments aside and pray for each other and for ourselves for three days. I fervently believe that yours or my enlightenment on the matter is worth a three day prayer period. If I’m wrong in these matters, I’ll be saved from wasting a heck of a lot of time making useless prayers!

We’ll pray for wisdom and openness of heart equally for ourselves and for each other. In that way, we’ll both become soft clay, through the Holy Spirit, for God to mold into whatever form He chooses. I have confidence in the Lord’s power to impact our lives through prayer and bring us into deeper unity in His Truth.

He prayed for His disciples, “Consecrate them in Truth; Your Word is Truth!” (John 17:17). So the effort would be worth it. If we humbly pray for openness of heart and wisdom for ourselves and each other, and for full and complete unity with each other and with God in Truth in this matter, I believe He will answer our prayers.

Then we can begin the discussion again when the three days are over and I think we’ll each profit more from what the other has to say. If you think our increased unity with Truth in this matter is worth it, I’d love to participate with you in seeking Him in this way.

I’m also planning to fast from all food on Friday. I’ll keep this intention in my prayers that day.

Would you be willing to do some serious praying with me for the next three days with these intentions? I think it would be profitable for both of us and we may come closer to unity with each other in the light of Christ. After the three days, we could start the discussion again, more open to God’s Spirit than we were at the start.

May God illuminate us both :).

Your brother in Christ,

Lief
 
Lief ~

you have asked me a number of questions concerning angels, saints, and prayer, and i have answered you as best i am able, with Scripture, and the conclusions drawn from there.

as to why i do not pray to angels, or to deceased believers, and why i would cite these practices as wrong, and not profitable.

as to Catholic beliefs and practices, would you be willing to answer my question?

is there any fault if a Catholic choses to pray to any pious, deceased Catholic of his or her chosing? or more clearly, to ask the deceased Catholic to pray for them, or intercede? why or why not would this be alright?

God bless you, and i look forward to your insights and responses.
 
Lief ~

you have asked me a number of questions concerning angels, saints, and prayer, and i have answered you as best i am able, with Scripture, and the conclusions drawn from there.

as to why i do not pray to angels, or to deceased believers, and why i would cite these practices as wrong, and not profitable.

as to Catholic beliefs and practices, would you be willing to answer my question?

is there any fault if a Catholic choses to pray to any pious, deceased Catholic of his or her chosing? or more clearly, to ask the deceased Catholic to pray for them, or intercede? why or why not would this be alright?

God bless you, and i look forward to your insights and responses.
The answer is no, there is nothing wrong with praying to someone you believe is in Heaven. If your prayer ends up with one of the damned, then obviously that person won’t carry it to God. This is why many of us stick to praying to Jesus and canonized saints. Though it is fine to pray to others who you believe are in Heaven. None of this bears any parallel to necromancy or divination, which involve creating your own mystical experience through magic or mental “techniques” to hear from loved ones or try to learn the future. It is simply asking one’s fellow brothers and sisters in Christ for prayer.

But Grace, I have a lot more to respond to your post 13. I’m certainly not done with it. I simply want to pray with you for three days for openness of heart and wisdom on behalf of both of us so that God can lead us together in unity in His Truth. Otherwise I think this discussion won’t go anywhere, but I want unity with you in this matter and I believe we won’t be sufficiently open to hear God speaking through each other if we haven’t surrendered our minds to Him in a concentrated way.

I think praying for ourselves and one another, for illumination and unity in Truth, is a good path toward coming together. Then we can pick the discussion up where we left off and I’ll respond to the whole of your earlier post, and we’ll continue the conversation. For the sake of unity in truth, that there might be no divisions between us, let’s come together in prayer for ourselves and one another for, for openness of heart and mind, wisdom and unity in truth, I propose for three days and then we’ll continue :).

What do you think of my idea?
 
Lief ~

quite honestly, i’m ok with an absence of unity. it’s a nice idea, and a gracious offer. but i simply don’t believe as you do on prayers to the dead, and i’m ok with limiting my prayers for help and intercession to the Father and the Son. that is what i see as Scriptural, and nothing Christ says indicates that prayer ought to be directed to any but the Father, and the Son.

the Catholic Church reasons out Scripture in such a way as to allow for prayer to saints for their intercession, but my Christian faith sees no room for that. and i’m ok with the differences, Lief. sometimes it’s better to remain distinct rather than attempt to forge a unity based on conflicting ideas and approaches.
 
Thank-you for the reply :).

I’m not trying to forge a unity based on conflicting ideas and approaches but on united ones. If I find that you’re right about praying to saints, you will have saved me from wasting a heck of a lot of time in useless praying! 😉 That’s got to be of some value to you, in Christian charity :).

On the other hand, if I’m right, you will suddenly find yourself with a great number of powerful intercessors in Heaven to call upon, making a dramatic difference in drawing your life into deeper righteousness and spiritual beauty. For as the Apostle James says, “the prayer of the righteous man is powerful and effective,” and there is no one more righteous than those in Heaven.

So whichever of us discovers the other to be right, if God hears your prayers and mine and guides us in humility into unity in truth, we will be wonderfully blessed!

We have every reason to unite in a deeper oneness in Christ than we now share, a unity in truth and not in division.

1 Corinthians 1:10 says, “I appeal to you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that all of you agree with one another so that there may be no divisions among you and that you may be perfectly united in mind and thought.”

I desire deeply that you and I be fully united in mind and thought in these matters, so that there is less division between us. For this, I trust in the Holy Spirit of Truth to consecrate us in Truth (John 17:17) if we appeal to Him humbly and sincerely to unite us both fully with His Mind in these matters.

Don’t think you’ve heard the last of the arguments I can make for why intercession of saints is both logical and scriptural; I’m far from through with the discussion if you’re willing to continue after this kind of serious prayer. I just don’t want to waste my time failing to listen openly if God is speaking through you, and you failing to listen openly if God is speaking through me. If we pray humbly, biases and false assumptions we both have can melt if we surrender our perspectives to God for unity with His Mind.

I know we both have natural barriers built up that only Christ can melt down through His Spirit. A concentrated, united time of praying is the best way for us both to become one with Him in truth rather than divided by the errors one of us has inherited from his or her spiritual forbears.

I won’t push though if you really don’t want to join me in seeking the Mind of Christ on this matter. I know you feel comfortable with your reasoning and conclusions, and so do I with mine, but nonetheless one of us is mistaken. And one thing I’m not comfortable with AT ALL is the existence of division in the One Body of Jesus Christ, something St. Paul (1 Cor. 12:25) and my own heart cry out against.

This’ll be my last post about it though if your answer is no; I don’t mean to be very pushy. Only a little :p.

Over to you!!! 😃
 
Lief ~

thank you for the offer, but i’ll politely decline. with all due respect Lief, i am not going to pray to the Father or to Christ on whether or not an issue i know is wrong, is truly right.

any more than you might feel inclined to pray to Christ (whose mystical body you understand to be the Catholic Church) as to whether or not you ought to become a Baptist.

my prayers are offered up to Christ, the Lamb, and to the Father, God Almighty. i do not ask the deceased to pray for me, nor would i be so inclined. i have access to the Father through Christ’s blood and person, and am very thankful for that.

i’m ok with us not believing the same things, and never believing the same things. i do, however, thank you for your answers to my questions, and for hearing my side as well.
 
All right :).

Thank-you for the conversation and discussion! It has been interesting and I’m glad we talked.

May God bless you richly and abundantly, my sister in Christ 🙂 :). May you and all your loved ones be richly blessed with all His graces and tender loving care. May you shine as a star in the sky or a city on a hill. May the living God watch over your steps every moment of your life and bless you without ever the smallest ceasing. In the Name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, I pray, Amen.

It has been good to meet you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top