Liturgical abuse, what to do?

  • Thread starter Thread starter vince2paul
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

vince2paul

Guest
I attended mass on Dec 31 in Indonesia (my hometown). The usual timing for Sunday is 8 am and 5pm. I attended in the morning, 8 am. However, on that day, the schedule was changed, so the evening mass was at 7pm instead of 5pm. I had an argument with mum, because I know that it was the same mass, but mum insisted that it was different as 7pm is a year-end mass. So in the end, I gave up and went along with her. To my surprised, many people who attended the morning mass, also attended the evening mass. Some of them were actually active members of the church (few days later, I asked the deacon, even he only knew that both were the same mass 1-2 hours before the evening mass because he was the one preparing the reading!)

It was just unfortunate that the priest celebrated the mass was Fr.A. Don’t get me wrong, he was a very nice priest, but not during mass. I believe that mass was the worse Sunday mass I’ve ever attended in my life.

First, we had 40 minutes homily (I know there’s not any rule for this, but still it’s strange). During the prayer of the faithful, before the concluding prayer, he started to do healing service (there’s a young man bla bla bla… A man who is suffering from this disease, you are healed). I know he is blessed with gift of the Spirit, but I think it’s inapproriate for him to do this during Sunday mass. Lastly, During the consecration, where we suppose to do adoration silently, he said "Let’s do it together, praise and worship Him, praise and worship Him, praise and worship Him, your God). So the whole church started to sing together this lines, (I think) except my mum and I.

It didn’t really affect me, because I’ve read many other litturgical abuses happened in other churches worldwide, but my mum was so shocked and it affected her quite badly.

Few months ago, someone already mentioned to the bishop and the bishop asked the parish priest to warn him about it. But now he started it again. I talked to the parish priest about it, and he told me that it’s difficult because it’s Fr. A’s personal devotion. I really don’t know whether I should do something or just try to ignore it. I want to tell the bishop, but then I’m afraid it will affect the parish priest as the bishop might think that the parish priest doesn’t do his job well. Any suggestion?
 
I attended mass on Dec 31 in Indonesia (my hometown). The usual timing for Sunday is 8 am and 5pm. I attended in the morning, 8 am. However, on that day, the schedule was changed, so the evening mass was at 7pm instead of 5pm. I had an argument with mum, because I know that it was the same mass, but mum insisted that it was different as 7pm is a year-end mass. So in the end, I gave up and went along with her. To my surprised, many people who attended the morning mass, also attended the evening mass. Some of them were actually active members of the church (few days later, I asked the deacon, even he only knew that both were the same mass 1-2 hours before the evening mass because he was the one preparing the reading!)

It was just unfortunate that the priest celebrated the mass was Fr.A. Don’t get me wrong, he was a very nice priest, but not during mass. I believe that mass was the worse Sunday mass I’ve ever attended in my life.

First, we had 40 minutes homily (I know there’s not any rule for this, but still it’s strange). During the prayer of the faithful, before the concluding prayer, he started to do healing service (there’s a young man bla bla bla… A man who is suffering from this disease, you are healed). I know he is blessed with gift of the Spirit, but I think it’s inapproriate for him to do this during Sunday mass. Lastly, During the consecration, where we suppose to do adoration silently, he said "Let’s do it together, praise and worship Him, praise and worship Him, praise and worship Him, your God). So the whole church started to sing together this lines, (I think) except my mum and I.

It didn’t really affect me, because I’ve read many other litturgical abuses happened in other churches worldwide, but my mum was so shocked and it affected her quite badly.

Few months ago, someone already mentioned to the bishop and the bishop asked the parish priest to warn him about it. But now he started it again. I talked to the parish priest about it, and he told me that it’s difficult because it’s Fr. A’s personal devotion. I really don’t know whether I should do something or just try to ignore it. I want to tell the bishop, but then I’m afraid it will affect the parish priest as the bishop might think that the parish priest doesn’t do his job well. Any suggestion?
Why can’t he just do the healing after the Mass has ended. If he has the gift of healing I’m sure people wouldn’t rush away after Mass but would stay for a while.
 
Why can’t he just do the healing after the Mass has ended. If he has the gift of healing I’m sure people wouldn’t rush away after Mass but would stay for a while.
He never did it before and actually I didn’t know that he has the gift. Before that, people only know that he had the gift to be able to communicate with Mary and Jesus. This priest is quite sensational in the parish, very famous and many people like him (just like da vinci code, sensational!).

I suspected that he was inspired by an event; few weeks earlier, he and another priest helped a famous priest, Fr. J, do a healing mass in other diocese, it was a healing mass. I attended that mass, and the mass was very good. I truly felt the presence of Jesus. He might feel it was the right time.

Do you think I should tell bishop about it? because next month the bishop will be here again.
 
Write to your Bishop, tell him everything you think is wrong. Let your Bishop decide if it is wrong or not. If you Bishop does not respord then you can write to Vatican…I urge you to follow chain of command though. The vatican address is. below.

**Cardinal Francis Arinze
Prefect - Congregation for Divine Worship
Piazza Pio XII, 10
Vatican City (Europe) 00120 **
 
Write to your Bishop, tell him everything you think is wrong. Let your Bishop decide if it is wrong or not. If you Bishop does not respord then you can write to Vatican…I urge you to follow chain of command though. The vatican address is. below.

**Cardinal Francis Arinze
Prefect - Congregation for Divine Worship
Piazza Pio XII, 10
Vatican City (Europe) 00120 **
Thanks! The bishop will definitely do something, but I just don’t know whether it’s appropriate to do. Because I don’t want to embarrass the parish priest. Should I inform him before I tell the bishop?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top