Living with a couple who is cohabitating- sinful?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SMA_12
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SMA_12

Guest
I’m fresh out of college and I will be looking for a new living situation very shortly.

I have been invited to live with a good friend. However, he is cohabitating with his girlfriend.

I get along with both of them and it would be perhaps the best option for me financially. I would obviously have my own room.

I am strong in my faith and do not think it would be a source of scandal for me. In fact, I see it as an opportunity to bring him back to the Church. He knows I didn’t approve of him cohabitating in the first place, I made that pretty clear.

But if it’s sinful for me to split rent and live in the same apartment, obviously I would not wish to do it.

Advice?
 
Aside from the issue of morals, I think it could be a little weird to be a third wheel.

Would you really want to be roommates with a newlywed couple, for instance?
 
Aside from the issue of morals, I think it could be a little weird to be a third wheel.

Would you really want to be roommates with a newlywed couple, for instance?
Very valid point. I am definitely taking that into consideration as well.
 
Very valid point. I am definitely taking that into consideration as well.
I’ve been in the same exact situation, lived with my best friend while working on my Master’s as he cohabited with his girlfriend. Every relationship is different, so I don’t know what yours is with your friend, but I had very minimal issues with this arrangement, just knowing the situation and respecting each other made for a perfectly fine situation. Of course, it’s never ideal, but I had to do what was best for me financially at the time and he was kind enough to offer the help.

I really don’t think that you are morally culpable in this situation, I certainly did not feel any reason to feel otherwise, but I suppose it’s something each person needs to discern.

In any case, best of luck!

God bless,
Paul
 
I think it would “normalize” the behavior. I would think it would be a bad example to others (along the lines of, if you live with them, you must be at least somewhat ok with it… it can’t be that awful if you don’t mind living with them). You may feel it won’t affect you, but it could as well. It isn’t a healthy environment.
 
Aside from the issue of morals, I think it could be a little weird to be a third wheel.

Would you really want to be roommates with a newlywed couple, for instance?
👍

Just because you get along with people does not mean you can live with them.
 
the fact that you are going to live with them after telling your friend that you do not approve is already you consenting to the act.

I suggest finding a room mate instead, because it will look like you are going to be the third wheel here even if you will have your own room.

Cohabitating is sinful. Read CCC 2391.
 
Thanks everyone. I definitely had some reservations about it. I guess I was hoping I was just being over-scrupulous so that I wouldn’t have to turn him down- he was pretty excited about the idea.
 
No. No way Jose. :eek:
I rented out my basement apartment to a nice guy in2012. Nicest guy you would want to meet. After three months, he asked if his girlfriend could move in. I told him I was not wild at all about the idea, but because he seemed like such a good guy, and he would have to move out, I stupidly said yes.

She was not so nice. I won’t go into her character defects, but the whole thing went down hill in a horrible way. It was pure ****. I will NEVER do this again. If nothing else, consider when they argue, it is hard for you not to get into the middle of it. They are a couple so it is harder to fuss at them about leaving lights on, cleaning up, doing their share etc.

A roommate on the other hand is a 50/50 deal. There is nothing to “get in the middle” of. Couples go through experiences and phases. Being around this is uncomfortable as a third wheel. When they argue or get “all silly” and giggly, you have to hear this.

Don’t do it. If you are strong in your faith, you will feel nauseated after a while, because the longer they are there, or you are there, the more “comfortable” they are going to be around you.

I will never do that again as long as I live unless it means living under a bridge. Take my advice, change your phone number now!😉

PS: If you get a roommate, tell him that he cant have spend the night dates. They will keep coming back. Seriously.
 
I’m fresh out of college and I will be looking for a new living situation very shortly.

I have been invited to live with a good friend. However, he is cohabitating with his girlfriend.

I get along with both of them and it would be perhaps the best option for me financially. I would obviously have my own room.

I am strong in my faith and do not think it would be a source of scandal for me. In fact, I see it as an opportunity to bring him back to the Church. He knows I didn’t approve of him cohabitating in the first place, I made that pretty clear.

But if it’s sinful for me to split rent and live in the same apartment, obviously I would not wish to do it.

Advice?
What is the saying, "Birds of a feather, flock to gether, if you as a practising Catholic disagree with what is going on, you don’t live with the immoral lifestyle. I have a tenant for one of my two bedroom apartment, anyone who asks can I have my girlfriend/Boyfriend visit over night , I know this person is not leading a life style in accordance with my Catholic life style and gets told accommodation elsewhere would be better after all would you ask your mother this… When money has been tight I have had to say this, you have to stand up and be counted for one’s belief. I have told them I am not running a brothel.
 
What is the saying, "Birds of a feather, flock to gether, if you as a practising Catholic disagree with what is going on, you don’t live with the immoral lifestyle. I have a tenant for one of my two bedroom apartment, anyone who asks can I have my girlfriend/Boyfriend visit over night , I know this person is not leading a life style in accordance with my Catholic life style and gets told accommodation elsewhere would be better after all would you ask your mother this… When money has been tight I have had to say this, you have to stand up and be counted for one’s belief. I have told them I am not running a brothel.
I let this guy and later his girlfriend move in before I became Catholic. [Which has changed my life for the better btw] but I ended up throwing them out. I also have a rental house, and rented it years ago to a co-habitation couple. I had to evict them and the place was a disaster. A wonderful married couple with a child have been there now for three years. What a difference. I guess the rule here is, if they are morally deficient in one area, you run the risk that they are deficient in other areas.
 
Looks like I’m in the minority on this one. Ah, well, to be expected.
 
My college friend lived (for a semester) with his cousin and her live-in boyfriend.

He found it uncomfortable and weird.
 
I’ve never lived with a couple, but I’ve been a part of a couple that has a roommate. During the time that my husband and I cohabited we lived with his friend for a year, and a friend of mine for 6 months. We also offered to let his brother, who had fallen on hard financial times move in, but he decided to move back in with his dad instead.

I won’t tell you not to to do this, but there are a lot of things to consider.
  1. What does the privacy situation look like? I’d highly recommend that you not only have your own room, but that you and the couple have separate bathrooms. If they choose to shower together, that could be weird for you to hear, or see them entering and leaving the bathroom together. They may also have a fairly open door policy, and pop in to talk to each other during showers, or while getting ready in the morning. Again, this could leave you feeling like something of an outsider.
  2. Food. They will likely cook and eat most meals together, or run out for food, or go out to eat. What are the expectations? If they cook dinner, are you welcome to join them? When you cook, do they want you to cook enough for everyone, or are you on your own? (Obviously, you making enough for everyone would mean that they do the same for you, or that you get a break on the food bill, or whatever).
  3. Overnight guests. They already live together, but this is still an important rule anyway. What if they see themselves as more of a family, and want to host out of town relatives for the weekend, or even a week? Are you ok with this, or no? Obviously, you would get the same house guest privileges, but it is something to discuss.
  4. If you are or start seeing someone, how much time are they allowed to spend at the home? Personally, my husband and I were always fine with our roommates having guests, because we understood that being the third wheel could be weird. But some people may conclude that even though they are in a relationship, they don’t want a lot of strangers coming over and spending extended periods of time in their home.
Basically, these are all issues that you would need to discuss with any roommate and set ground rules on, but they can be more complicated when your roommate is a couple.

And of course, when they fight, they need to keep you out of it. If they try to pull you in, you need to make it clear in no uncertain terms that you will not be a part of this and that they need to keep it away from you. When my husband and I had roommates and we were fighting, we would always go out to the car, drive to a Wal-Mart parking lot, or a park, or a coffee shop, and hash it out in the front seat. To this day, his best friend (our roommate of a year) thinks that we have a remarkable, completely fight-free relationship.

Finally, don’t move in with them thinking that you will get your friend to change his mind. This will not work out well for you. This is why my husband’s brother did not move in. He did not approve of us living together before marriage, and he made it known. We offered to let him move in anyway, but the condition was that he could not try to undermine our relationship. That is, he could not make comments to either one of us about how we should consider moving, how the arrangement was wrong, etc. We would not tolerate a guest or roommate trying to meddle in our relationship-period.
 
**Thanks for all of the advice. With your help I have decided not to go through with it because of all of the reasons you have given me- both moral and practical.

You all are awesome! What a great resource this place is! 👍

God bless!**
 
You should not live with sinners. Unfortunately, that leaves only two potential roomates, both of which are in heaven.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top