looking for a complete list of infallible statements from pope peter to the present

  • Thread starter Thread starter Big_Dummy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Big_Dummy

Guest
I know I asked this in some recent thread, but I can not find where it was answered.

I am looking for a complete list of infallible statements from all the popes from peter to now.

thanks
BD
 
I’m not sure if such a list exists in the manner of what you may think (i.e. Constitutional Amendments). That would be like asking for every Executive Order issued by all of the presidents since George Washington. The information is available, but it isn’t likely to be compiled in a summarized listing.

If there are specific topics you are curious about, you can look at almost any Church document that has been released on the Vatican website. Also, the Catechism of the Catholic Church can be helpful for Catholic beliefs.

If you don’t mind my asking, for what purpose do you desire this list?
 
I know I asked this in some recent thread, but I can not find where it was answered.

I am looking for a complete list of infallible statements from all the popes from peter to now.

thanks
BD
Someone might be able to find that somewhere, but I should point out the if such a list exists, it is probably considerably longer than most might think, and the check each item for inclusion on the list (to demonstrate for oneself that a particular statement is indeed infallible), might be somewhat harder than most might think.

Some very good (and recent) commentary on infallibility: The Infallibility of the Pope and the Magisterium. (:tiphat:: The American Catholic)
 
I know I asked this in some recent thread, but I can not find where it was answered.

I am looking for a complete list of infallible statements from all the popes from peter to now.

thanks
BD
As I remember it, the doctrine of Papal Infallability, for matters of Faith, was announced in the 19th century; and has been used twice. The first time was for the Immaculate Conception, and the second time for the Assumption.
 
As I remember it, the doctrine of Papal Infallability, for matters of Faith, was announced in the 19th century; and has been used twice. The first time was for the Immaculate Conception, and the second time for the Assumption.
Although some believe those to be the only two cases, the article referenced above by MG1S has a very well-written and clear explanation about the use of Papal Infallibility throughout the history of the Church, and cleared up several misconceptions I had as well!
 
Someone might be able to find that somewhere, but I should point out the if such a list exists, it is probably considerably longer than most might think, and the check each item for inclusion on the list (to demonstrate for oneself that a particular statement is indeed infallible), might be somewhat harder than most might think.

Some very good (and recent) commentary on infallibility: The Infallibility of the Pope and the Magisterium. (:tiphat:: The American Catholic)
I found a list, but I am not 100% certain about its accuracy, even though it’s supposed to be a Catholic apologetics page.
Is there a way to confirm the accuracy of this list?
 
Great list! And it is divided up into appropriate sections for easier navigation. I believe it said all of those things are derived from the Catechism, so anyone seeking to find the reasoning behind the statements can always find them there.

As for the total accuracy of the list (both in content and completeness), I cannot testify to that, but I briefly glanced at the section concerning Mary and everything was consistent with what I’ve known to be Catholic teaching.
 
Although some believe those to be the only two cases, the article referenced above by MG1S has a very well-written and clear explanation about the use of Papal Infallibility throughout the history of the Church, and cleared up several misconceptions I had as well!
Again, I cannot vouch for the actual number, but I agree it is most certainly higher than only two (the Marian dogmas referenced above).

For example (to BVM1221), take a read of Evangelium Vitae sometime. IMO it would take some extraordinary legalistic contortions, in the spirit the American Catholic article mentions and criticizes, to not see anything infallible in this document.
 
The Church has never seen fit to compile such a list. Some will tell you that there have been dozens or more. Some will tell you there are only a few. The Church is apparently content to let us debate the matter (or is unsure itself).
 
Lumen Gentium says that we are basically required to submit our minds and wills to the Pope in ex cathedra statements and even NON-ex cathedra statements so there’s no point in searching for an infallible list. Basically everything the pope teaches in infallible in LG’s vision of things…
 
BD

Any particular reason why you’re looking for the list?

Just curious, and best wishes on your search. Simeon 👍
 
archives.gov/federal-register/codification/numeric-executive-orders.html
archives.gov/federal-register/codification/numeric-executive-orders.html

EO is a good parallel, I am thinking if one can produce a detailed list of such, then it would at least demonstrate this was in existence from Peter on… to now.
But these are for executive orders created or amended between 1945 and 1989, a mere 54 years of our nation’s 234 year history (although I’ll give you 221 because Washington wasn’t elected President under the Constitution until 1789). Not to mention that once America was formed, we were not persecuted/oppressed and had to act in secrecy or risk public execution.

You have still yet to really answer why you want this list. Is it because lack of a list ‘proves’ something to you? If so, then the Catechism will detail you all of the beliefs of the Catholic Church and why.

I’m also confused by your statement ‘then it would at least demonstrate that this was in existence from Peter on…to now’. What is the ‘this’ you are referring to? Beliefs? The belief Papal Infallability?

If you believe the Bible to be divinely inspired, and you believe that Christ is true to His Words, than all the proof you need is when He says to Peter “Whatever you bind on Earth shall be bound in Heaven, and whatever you loosen on Earth shall be loosened in Heaven.” He gives Peter the authority to teach and apply the beliefs that Christ gave to them, and since we believe in divine inspiration (not to mention the gifts received by the Holy Ghost at Pentecost), we thus believe that the Peter and the entire line of Apostolic Succession has, does, and will continue to define dogma infallibly as guided by the Holy Ghost.
 
There are lists out there. However, there is no definitive list authorised by the Church. If you find lists you may find different documents on them because theologians do not agree on which documents are infallible.

There does seem to be some consensus that since Vatican I’s definition of papal infallibility it has only been used once when Pius XII defined the Assumption of the BVM in 1950.

Another document on which there seems to be consensus in the definition of the Immaculate Conception although this pre-dates Vatican’s I’s decree on papal infallibility.

If you are interested in infallibility, you may find this thread on Infallibility - revisited in the Eastern Catholicism Forum interesting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top