B
ben_dy
Guest
amgid,That is not quite true. Our position is not the same as the sola scriptura of Protestantism.
Absolutely so. My assertions does not in any way question or cast doubt on the validity of that authority. If you are unclear about what I meant, I refer you to posts #17 and #32 of the thread called “Can even a ‘true’ prophet have false revelations?” That subject was discussed in other threads as well.
Certainly not! I am a member of the regular LDS Church.
In your original post you had made this statement:
So you are looking for a website that provides you with the following three things:
Let me briefly respond to each of these points.
- Answers the tough questions.
- Provides current LDS doctrine in a manner that appeals to faith and reason.
- doesn’t dismiss problematic past doctrine.
amgid
- I would like to know what you mean by “tough questions”. There is an official LDS website called www.mormon.org, which is designed specifically for investigators. Its aim is to provide answers to the basic questions that an investigator might have about the Church and its beliefs. But I don’t think that that is what you are looking for. That website does not answer any “tough” questions! I don’t want to disappoint you, but in reality there isn’t such a thing as “tough questions”. There are certain things that God has revealed, and many more things that He hasn’t. That which is revealed is in the standard works. There are many parts of the standards works that are ambiguous or difficult to understand. The book of Isaiah, for example, is difficult for most people to understand. But it is not the policy of the authorities of the Church to provide a detailed, running commentary on every scriptural ambiguity. The General Authorities counsel Church members to study the scriptures for themselves, and obtain the Spirit of the Lord for themselves to understand its deeper meanings. Just out of curiosity, I would like to know what your “tough questions” are. There are several LDS on this board who are well informed, and they can probably provide a satisfactory answer to most of your questions.
- Next, you are looking for something that “provides current LDS doctrine in a manner that appeals to faith and reason”. Again, the above official LDS website is designed basically to do that. If you want a bigger resource, the Church publishes a book called Gospel Principles which is designed to teach the gospel to investigators. You can obtain a copy from your LDS friends and missionaries, or order it direct from the LDS distribution centre. But somehow I don’t think that is what you are looking for. Ultimately there is only one resource that can answer that requirement—it is called the Book of Mormon! If you ignore that, you are looking beyond the mark.
- And lastly, you are looking for something that “does not dismiss problematic past doctrine”. That is itself a “problematic” statement. All doctrine, be it past or present, is true LDS doctrine if it can be affirmed by LDS scripture, is speculation if it cannot, and is false if it contradicts it. That is the bottom line for resolving “problematic past doctrine”. Now, just out of curiosity, I like to know what are the “problematic past doctrines” that you are concerned about.
Wow! I didn’t even realize that this thread was still active.
You know what I mean, I think by “problematic past doctrines” - they’re frequently discussed here but I don’t mean even the ‘big things’ like BY “Adam-God” thing but even small things, such as the LDS position, which differs (or did - someone told me otherwise yesterday) from the RLDS, on the JSI Bible. Some place like… this! Yes, that would be terrific - a website run by faithful LDS that serves LDS apologetics and is tolerant of other religions to the point where the “rules” are similar to the rules here.
You know (by now) how frustrated I am about no short ‘single source’ book of doctrine for LDS - so perhaps a “LDS Answers” website would be just the thing. Wouldn’t it be a good place for LDS to not only learn about the history and doctrine of the LDS church but where one could speculate, educate we apostates, etc.? FARMS isn’t the answer, FAIR isn’t the answer, the two official LDS sites (mormon.org and lds.org) are much too ‘lite’.
As this board is an apostolate, so could this sort of LDS website - not every message officially sanctioned by the church, just individuals getting together pooling knowledge, engaging in controversies (in the good sense of the word), etc.
As I understand the way tithing works in the LDS church, as a matter of fact, someone with an average income could tithe to support such an operation and others may be called to acted as moderators. Seems as if it’s at least an idea worth mentioning to a bishop, don’t you think? I think it would be terrific!