Hello,
I would like to recommend Mrs. Mike by Benedict and NancyFreedman. It is more Canadian, though. It is about a young Irish-Catholic girl from Boston, early 1900’s, who travels to Canada to stay with an uncle. There she meets a Mountie and gets married and goes with him to the wildnerness. There is alot in this novel about love, suffering, perserverance…
This doesn’t qualify as American literature, but I think many of Rumer Godden’s novels are very Catholic. In THis House of Brede, about a career woman who becomes a nun. Very moving! She also wrote the Kitchen Madonna (
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0dd6/a0dd67a17ec8b6e6bcb45d7047f3d9bfe87084bb" alt="Slightly smiling face :slight_smile: 🙂"
loved it!!!) about a young boy who sets out to make an icon of Our Lady for the family’s immigrant Slavic cook. The boy learns about reaching out to others and thinking about others more than himself. Another book that I was suprised to see how pro-Catholic was her novel, Pippa Passes. Unlike the other books I mentioned, I don’t recommend this for high school age children. It is about a young British ballet dancer who goes on a tour to Italy. The director of the ballet company, a woman, tries to seduce her (
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7079e/7079e2364c7e6bc9a509f3429fba1fa1c93d7548" alt="Eek! :eek: :eek:"
) and uses her position of power to try and manipulate the young dancer. It is another woman, a Catholic woman from Britain living in Italy, that rescues Pippa from this situation and gives her refuge in her home.
A good novel that really shows Catholics in a good light is On the Fields of Glory by Henryk Sienkiewicz. It isn’t that long and boys might like it!!!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b43e5/b43e59177c0ee1b978ff89157a42f60fe7175079" alt="Thumbs up :thumbsup: 👍"
It is set in medieval Poland, about a young knight who prepares to go with King Jan Sobielski’s army to save Vienna from the Turks. He has a priest as his mentor and the priest is a really cool guy. This is also a love story, very Catholic and beautiful. All of Sienkiewicz’s novels (including Quo Vadis) are very Christian and Catholic, but some are very, very long! On the Fields of Glory isn’t that long, though, so might be good for high school students. It teaches real history, too!
I wish I could think of American books that teach Catholic values!!! The only thing that comes to mind is the Father Dowling mysteries, which I have never read so I can’t say either way if they are good!