Looking for true church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kengo19
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by deepwaters
What happens when Catholic Magisterium teachings and Traditions contradict the Sacred teachings of the Bible? There are many teachings that contradict. Do we then put aside the holy Scripture and follow the magisterium? To put aside the Bible is to disregard the Apostles, for they wrote the New Testament. And if there were any people who know what Christs religion really is, its the Apostles, for the walked with Christ.
I agree with wisdomseeker here.
Each person is giving his or her reason for choosing a particular church. Discussions and debates need to be handled either by allowing the OP to ask the questions that he/she needs answered, or by starting a new thread.
Running off willy-nilly into other debates will not be of help to the OP and is not the purpose of this thread.

Peace
James
 
No it is not rhetorical. I have seen many teachings promoted by the magisterium that clearly and directly contradict Biblical truths Its hard for most Catholics to notice this because we are not encouraged to read the Bible. They say that only the Priest should read it. Let me show you some disharmonies:
The Bible says, keep the Sabbath day (Saturday) holy, but the magisterium promotes Sunday (the pagan day of worship).
The Bible says, do not make or worship graven images, but the magisterium promotes them.
The Bible says, when we die, we stay in the grave awaiting the ressurrection day when Jesus comes back, but the magisterium teaches immortality of the soul and purgatory.
These and many others…
Start your own thread about your disagreements with the Catholic Church.

Your concerns are based in protestant prejudices and misunderstandings that have spread generation to generation since the Reformation.

These are falsehoods that you have been taught about the Catholic Church.
 
The Bible says, keep the Sabbath day (Saturday) holy, but the magisterium promotes Sunday (the pagan day of worship).
The Bible says, do not make or worship graven images, but the magisterium promotes them.
…
  1. We have Mass on Sunday because that is the day that Jesus rose from the dead. It doesn’t have anything to do with anything else.
  2. What “graven images” does the Magisterium promote?? We do not worship statues, Mary, or Saints (I am assuming this is what you mean). We use statues or pictures of Jesus, Mary, or Saints as the same way that you may use pictures of your beloved family members on the wall of your house… to remind you of them, to honor them, to remember them or an important event in your/their life, etc.
***I am sorry, this is a bit off topic and I already shared the reasons that I believe the Catholic Church is the true church, but I really felt the need to comment on this, as well. :o ****
 
No it is not rhetorical. I have seen many teachings promoted by the magisterium that clearly and directly contradict Biblical truths
I see you are very new. Please feel free to start a new thread with your concerns. You may be very surprised to learn that what you have been told about what Catholics do and believe is very wrong. All the points you listed are easy to refute.
 
Yes we should obey the Church, but only if it is teaching from the Bible, because the Bible is the word of God.
But Jesus only found one Church. where is the Scriptures saying what you just said?
 
  1. We have Mass on Sunday because that is the day that Jesus rose from the dead. It doesn’t have anything to do with anything else.
  2. What “graven images” does the Magisterium promote?? We do not worship statues, Mary, or Saints (I am assuming this is what you mean). We use statues or pictures of Jesus, Mary, or Saints as the same way that you may use pictures of your beloved family members on the wall of your house… to remind you of them, to honor them, to remember them or an important event in your/their life, etc.
***I am sorry, this is a bit off topic and I already shared the reasons that I believe the Catholic Church is the true church, but I really felt the need to comment on this, as well. :o ****
  1. Can any man decide to break one of Gods commandments, especially the one that begins with the word remember, and choose to worship on a different day? There is no where in the Bible that says that we should stop keeping the Sabbath on Saturday and change to Sunday because Jesus rose on Sunday. The Bible says, it is the Sabbath of the Lord, only the Lord can change it, not man.
    If you want to know more about this, go to this site; sabbathtruth.com/
  2. Im glad you dont worship those statues, but there are many others i have seen that worship them. And even pray to them.
Anyway, i can sense some people are getting uncomfortable with my statements. All i want to know is the truth, nothing but the truth. For the truth alone will set us free. Let us not be afraid to analyze our faith. If what we believe is the truth, then we should not be afraid to talk about it. Right?
 
To all who have responded to deepwaters,
I have taken the liberty of asking the moderator to look over this thread with an eye toward movng the discussion of deepwater’s objections to it own thread.

Peace
James
 
Yes we should obey the Church, but only if it is teaching from the Bible, because the Bible is the word of God.
The Catholic Church celebrates Mass daily. Each Mass contains two parts, the Liturgy of the Word (readings for Sacred Scripture - or as you write the Holy Bible) and the Liturgy of the Eucharist.

Those readings from Sacred Scripture are on a three year cycle. Some protestant denominations also use the Church’s 3 year liturgy cycle.

Daily Mass readings are available online at:

usccb.org/nab/

Daily Mass and Sacred Scripture readings and their homilies are available on EWTN (but are normally one day behind):

youtube.com/user/EWTN#p/u/4/XFOTwYjTFr4
 
But Jesus only found one Church. where is the Scriptures saying what you just said?
“Knowing this first that, no prophecy of the Scripture is of any private interpretation. For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke as the were moved by the Holy Spirit.” 2 Peter 1:20-21
“All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto good works.” 2 Timothy3:16-17

This is why im saying the Church should use the Bible to lead people to Jesus Christ. When the church teaches something that is contradicted in Scripture, should we still follow that teaching?
 
“Knowing this first that, no prophecy of the Scripture is of any private interpretation. For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke as the were moved by the Holy Spirit.” 2 Peter 1:20-21
“All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto good works.” 2 Timothy3:16-17

This is why im saying the Church should use the Bible to lead people to Jesus Christ. When the church teaches something that is contradicted in Scripture, should we still follow that teaching?
Still waiting for the passage in the Bible that says what you said. if you claim to follow the Word of God, i need to see where the Word Says to obey hte Church if only the church follows the Bible. please.
 
I can see that there are some of you who suggest i stick to the topic in this thread. Thank you for the reminder. Im sorry, i got carried away, and felt the need to share these things to all of you. Im sorry if i offended anybody here, this was not my intention.
I will follow your suggestions and start a new thread.
God Bless
 
I can see that there are some of you who suggest i stick to the topic in this thread. Thank you for the reminder. Im sorry, i got carried away, and felt the need to share these things to all of you. Im sorry if i offended anybody here, this was not my intention.
I will follow your suggestions and start a new thread.
God Bless
Thank you -
Do let us know when you do and what the title is.

Peace
James
 
Still waiting for the passage in the Bible that says what you said. if you claim to follow the Word of God, i need to see where the Word Says to obey hte Church if only the church follows the Bible. please.
There is no specific sentence that says that, but what i’m trying to share with you is a Biblical principle. The Word of God (Bible), is the highest authority on earth, even higher than the church. The church can make mistakes, because it is made up of human beings. But Gods word is perfect, for it is the very word of God. Therefore, everything should be judged by the Bible. There are many churches nowadays that claim to be Christ’s church, but we all know that Christ started one church, and promised that the gates of hell shall not prevail over it. This means that, Christ’s true Church is still here on earth. And in order for us to know which one it is, we must bring up the standard (Bible). This is what im trying to say, i hope you understand.
 
There is no specific sentence that says that, but what i’m trying to share with you is a Biblical principle. The Word of God (Bible), is the highest authority on earth, even higher than the church. The church can make mistakes, because it is made up of human beings. But Gods word is perfect, for it is the very word of God. Therefore, everything should be judged by the Bible. There are many churches nowadays that claim to be Christ’s church, but we all know that Christ started one church, and promised that the gates of hell shall not prevail over it. This means that, Christ’s true Church is still here on earth. And in order for us to know which one it is, we must bring up the standard (Bible). This is what im trying to say, i hope you understand.
dw - I say again - please hold these comments until you begin another thread. It is only cluttering things up here.
Barb and Wisdomseeker, please do the same…It’s just getting out of hand.

Peace
James
 
It is already late at night here. I will be going to sleep. But i will start a new thread tomorrow entitled, “Do all the teachings of the Catholic Church agree with Bible teachings?”
I hope you will join that thread. God Bless.
 
“Knowing this first that, no prophecy of the Scripture is of any private interpretation. For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke as the were moved by the Holy Spirit.” 2 Peter 1:20-21
“All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto good works.” 2 Timothy3:16-17

This is why im saying the Church should use the Bible to lead people to Jesus Christ. When the church teaches something that is contradicted in Scripture, should we still follow that teaching?
You have that correct. The Church, first instructed by Peter and the Apostles, told their ordained priests and bishops to use Scripture for doctrine, reproof, correction, and rightousness. For man’s holiness and for his good works.
 
To all who have responded to deepwaters,
I have taken the liberty of asking the moderator to look over this thread with an eye toward movng the discussion of deepwater’s objections to it own thread.

Peace
James
Thank you
 
What good is an infallible book without an infallible interpreter. The Catholic Church is the living proof Christ walked this earth over 2000 years ago! It has been there since the beginning and founded by Christ’s own hands. For 1500 years there was one Holy Roman Catholic and Apostolic Church that encompassed all Christians. The reason Protestantism came about is because of the failure of some shepherds to show the continuity of the faith.

God is a Trinity because he is infinite and each one has a concrete purpose

The Father is the almighty creator of all existence. He is infinite in all dimensions and incapable of comprehension

The Holy Spirit is the one who interacts with us through prayer and understanding. He is the one who gives us the gift of faith and is responsible for the joy that comes with perusing the Truth. He is also the one who guides the Magisterium of the Church

Finally we have Jesus, Christ, Son of God. He is the VISIBLE person of God. His purpose is to be seen and heard, to have a limited (in size and scope) character that makes Him more easily understood, for if you have seen Him, you have seen the Father. He did not come 2000 years ago and abandon his goal. He was present at the flood, and he is present today, not just in spirit because that is what the Holy Spirit is for but in a physical and concrete presence! THAT IS THE EUCHARIST! And the Church (Roman and Orthodox) and its Priests are the only ones that claim a physical presence of our savior today.

I am Catholic because God gave us logic as a tool to understand him sufficiently to achieve confidence in our faith. The Catholic Church fulfills the logical arguments for God.

We have the Communion of Saints to guide and point us towards God. These are people who have been so selfless that it lead to misery and even death or martyrdom.

We have the Sacrament of Reconciliation. This with the Eucharist you have a “factory” for saints. We do not forgive our sins merely to a priest like most people think. We ask and receive forgiveness on several levels. All Catholics are required to do an examination of conscience before going to bed and asking forgiveness (asking by yourself). Then at Mass we ask forgiveness of our sines and those of our brothers and sisters at the Penitential Rite (asking with the whole Church). Then we have confession, which is a literal act for asking forgiveness. Being Catholic is not easy, its not an escape goat for dealing with dead friends or explain why evil is in the world. It is hard, salvation is hard, no one is guaranteed salvation because none of us actually deserve it.

The Church gives JOY. It is hard to be Catholic, the hardest thing of my life, but it is the happiest and most rewarding also.
 
Hello, Ive recently begun a religious search trying to find what i feel is the true church of God. I am posting this in different religions forums hoping hoping i might find an answer. I know if I ask what is the right church everyone is going to say their own is. So I thought what would be the right question to ask and i came up with this.

Why do you believe your church is the true church that god intends us to follow?

How did you came to the conclusion that your church is the true Church?

Thank you for you time and may God Bless you all.
Qualifications
  • Must be started by God. Jesus is God. Therefore His Church has all the promises of God made to it
  • No seperation from this Church is allowed…by definition and command from God.
Only one Church qualifies. The Catholic Church
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top