Losing my faith, fast

  • Thread starter Thread starter nitesnake
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nitesnake

Guest
There’s too many suffering innocent people in this world. Folks who suffer horribly without the slightest mercy from God. I don’t get it. The corrupt folks win, and the poor are powerless.

Why?
 
Evil, especially horrific evil, in this world, will always be a scandal, inasmuch as we allow it to tempt us from faith. That is all the more reason to believe in what Jesus says in John 16:33: “I have told you these things, so that in me you may have peace. In this world you will have trouble. But take heart! I have overcome the world.” As far as the mercy of God is concerned, is it possible that the absence of immediate relief may work for a greater good for a suffering individual? Even if we cannot see any reason in this life, we can still have faith, through the promise of our Lord, that He will not permit unnecessary suffering, and may reward those who suffer in the next life.
 
I recommend that you read C.S.Lewis’ book The Problem of Pain.

It is true there is much suffering in the world. However there are also many people working to alleviate suffering; for example for every sick person, there are several people working to improve his or her health, or comfort them.
Much suffering is caused by human evil, human choice. Jesus came and died to bring an end to evil, and our bondage to it.
How do you know that suffering people don’t experience “the slightest mercy from God?” We don’t know every suffering person and their situation. From stories I have heard, God often intervenes to provide help, strength and salvation to people in need.
Once I complained to God that there was no one to help a woman who was threatening suicide. I looked out the window and saw the cross on a church steeple; and felt as if God were saying, “Well, aren’t you there?” So I went and took the pills away from the woman (lost some hair in the process).
Rather than give up on God, we need to be part of the solution to suffering in the world.
 
I also strongly recommend The Problem of Pain and The Great Divorce, both by CS Lewis. They are excellent popular yet intelligent treatments of the subject, lacking the dryness and formality (and mathematical logic) of contemporary academic philosophical treatments of the problem of evil, such as Alvin Plantinga’s (even though his argument is good). NT Wright also has a book called something like Evil and the Justice of God which is good to read.

Generally, the problem you speak of - the problem of evil - is solved in theodicy by attributing to God the very good creation (Gen 1:31), and evil (which has no independent existence, but is the lack of good, as darkness is the lack of light) to the sin of man, who rebelled against God. Since man was created to rule over the earth as the steward of God, when he rebelled against God, he lost much of his authority over the earth (including his own body: “in the day that ye eat of the tree, ye shall dying, die”), which was then cursed for his sake, to “bring forth thorns and thistles, and increase pain in childbearing…for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” We all share in the sin, as Adam was the federal head of humanity. God permits this, but does not will it: even so, “where sin [evil] abounded, so did grace there abound all the more”.

The Fall affected not only man, but the cosmos; it was cosmic in scope. Christ is God’s answer to sin: it is his “No!” to sin, and his “Yes!” to sinful humanity, as he regenerates them to be sinless, looking forward to a time, the New Jerusalem, “where there are no more tears, for I beheld that death is no more”, a time where the lion will lay with the lamb again, at the consummation of the age, just as it was in God’s very good beginning. In Christ, God himself came to earth as a man - “who, being God by nature, did not consider equality with God robbery… who, emptying himself and taking upon him the form of a servant, humbled himself, being obedient unto death, even death on a cross” - and shared in all of our travails and pains, praying, “Father, if it could be so, let this cup pass from me”, so that he could redeem it, being like us in all things except for sin. Christ’s redemption is equally cosmic in scope and redeems all of us, as he is the last Adam - the new and continuing, eternal federal head of humanity. Thus we share in his divinity, “being made partakers of the divine nature”. God became man so that man might become by grace what God is by nature: he became flesh to redeem the flesh, entered in to the world to save it, suffered to end suffering, and died (and rose again) to conquer death.

It is properly called a mystery. We can not fully comprehend God, nor God’s ways: “for my ways are not your ways, nor are my thoughts your thoughts” - but this should not be used as an excuse to lack all comprehension of God and his ways: just because we can not fully understand, does not mean that we can not partially understand.

Please ask of me any further questions you may have, or any expansion or clarification upon anything I have written, so that you may understand. I pray for you, and the suffering innocents as well.
 
You aren’t losing your faith. You’re actually gaining it.

Surprised?

You shouldn’t be: it is the action of the love of God in your soul that makes you feel compassion and pain at the plight of others less fortunate than yourself or those who are victims of tragedies.

You want God to intervene?

He already did. In you.

All you have to do is go out and help.

You can’t expect God to magically intervene in every disaster and at every injustice and, at a stroke, reverse the earthquake or undo the volcano. He can’t be expected to pluck the tyrant from the face of the earth and make every poor person win the lottery. To do any of that would be to destroy our freedom of action: the freedom to do good as well as ill.

We love God not just because he made us, but because in doing so he set us free to choose our own destiny - as human-kind, it is our job to repay that gift by being the best that we can, by showing that we’re worthy of that trust.

Your faith isn’t the problem. You just needed the answer to why you feel the way you do.
 
Well what do you want ? This is a mortal world… Good things happen because we make it happen… Bad things happen because we let it happen… God does not have us on a string as if we were puppets, we control our destiny, just because bad things happen,that is no reason to loose your faith…but all the more reason to embrace it…
You world is exactly how you have allowed it to become…
 
Evil, especially horrific evil, in this world, will always be a scandal, inasmuch as we allow it to tempt us from faith. That is all the more reason to believe in what Jesus says in John 16:33: “I have told you these things, so that in me you may have peace. In this world you will have trouble. But take heart! I have overcome the world.” As far as the mercy of God is concerned, is it possible that the absence of immediate relief may work for a greater good for a suffering individual? Even if we cannot see any reason in this life, we can still have faith, through the promise of our Lord, that He will not permit unnecessary suffering, and may reward those who suffer in the next life.
A great deal of suffering is a matter of choice. For example, Bill and Bob worked at a company but got laid off at the same time. Both have a wife and 2 kids.

Bill was angry about his job loss and scared. He took that out on his wife and children, yelling at them over trivial matters. She in turn began to nag him about money troubles. He began going to a bar at night to get away from the nagging. In the mornings he is hungover and does not look for work. The bills pile up. His health suffers, and eventually the wife and kids leave him.

Bob rejoiced to the Lord for the layoff with thoughts about what new opportunity might present itself, and the extra time he could spend with the kids. He woke early to work on his resume, and send out applications. Though money was tight, there was a nearby park and he walked to the park with the kids almost everyday. He used his predicament in a subtle way to teach his kids that they could have fun without needing the latest toy, the latest video game, or a trip to an amusement park. His joyous attitude rubbed off on the wife and kids so that their home was filled with peace.

Yes, this is an oversimplification but the Bible is very clear that we are to maintain praise and thankfulness to God in all circumstance and in all adversity, and if we do that, unto us shall be a blessing. In Bob’s case a peaceful house is blessing enough, but he would also be more likely to get rehired or get his old job back than Bill.
 
Evil, especially horrific evil, in this world, will always be a scandal, inasmuch as we allow it to tempt us from faith…
So then I’m guilty of the sin of despair?
Well what do you want ? This is a mortal world… Good things happen because we make it happen… Bad things happen because we let it happen… .
So a little child stricken with cancer “made it happen?”
Color me skeptical.
 
So then I’m guilty of the sin of despair?

So a little child stricken with cancer “made it happen?”
Color me skeptical.
The child didn’t make cancer happen, but we as the human race have it within us to cure cancer.

We live in a broken world. We broke it. If God were to simply fix everything, we’d no longer have any autonomy.
 
Nitesnake,
As another said above…you are actually gaining rather than losing spiritually.
True you’re being tested and this test is difficult, but I believe you will come through it.

When this question comes up, I’m reminded of this Gospel passage in John 9:
1As he passed by, he saw a man blind from his birth.2And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” 3Jesus answered, "It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be made manifest in him. 4We must work the works of him who sent me, while it is day; night comes, when no one can work. 5As long as I am in the world, I am the light of the world." 6As he said this, he spat on the ground and made clay of the spittle and anointed the man’s eyes with the clay, 7saying to him, “Go, wash in the pool of Silo’am” (which means Sent). So he went and washed and came back seeing.
At first this might seem like a strange thing to say - that God made the man blind so that God’s Glory might be made manifest??? Yet - if we can expand our very limited world view a bit we might see how this works.
You are looking at a very narrow world view that sees corporeal suffering and death as ultimate evils and ends. Yet God - and our faith - looks far beyond such things. God and our faith looks to eternity…Life everlasting with our corporeal life here as but one stage.

You are concerned that God makes some innocent people suffer in this world. It is true…but if they ARE innocent…then are they not likely to have happiness in the next world? After all, God is just.
And if an innocent suffers in this world…is it not for the very reason that Jesus relays above…that the works of God (through us) be made manifest? Suffering in this world is a challenge to us as Christians more than it is some sort of indictment of God.
In truth…the more Christian we become the less unnecessary suffering there will be in the world…For we will be putting the work of God ahead of our own personal comfort and gain.

I know the above is not a slam dunk answer to your question…but perhaps it will provide something to take to God in prayer and perhaps He can explain it to you better than I can…😊

Peace
James
 
Nitesnake,
As another said above…you are actually gaining rather than losing spiritually.
True you’re being tested and this test is difficult, but I believe you will come through it
I wish you were right. But I can feel myself fading. And there is absolutely nothing I can do about it. .
 
So then I’m guilty of the sin of despair?
Sin is a human act of the will. You sin only when you willingly think, say, do something wrong or willingly fail to do something good you should’ve. Are you guilty of the sin of despair? (I’m not expecting you to give a public answer. Just answer it for yourself.)
 
I wish you were right. But I can feel myself fading. And there is absolutely nothing I can do about it. .
Been there.

This is the time when we must set things aside…We must not try so hard and just trust that God is in His heaven and, through a very simple faith and trust in Him, He will eventually make things clear.

Peace
James
 
I wish you were right. But I can feel myself fading. And there is absolutely nothing I can do about it. .
You can choose to read one of the recommended Lewis books, you can choose to pray for conviction in your faith, you can choose to not let go. The evil one is beckoning you to take that passive route - don’t do it.
 
Forgive me, but I don’t understand, what do you mean by “there’s nothing you can do about it”. It sounds as if you relinquished control of your thought process to someone else. I hope that is not the case. I don’t know how old you are but life is a long journey, I wouldn’t give up on God, too many miracles going on all around us.
 
You can choose to read one of the recommended Lewis books, you can choose to pray for conviction in your faith, you can choose to not let go. The evil one is beckoning you to take that passive route - don’t do it.
Forgive me, but I don’t understand, what do you mean by “there’s nothing you can do about it”. It sounds as if you relinquished control of your thought process to someone else. I hope that is not the case. I don’t know how old you are but life is a long journey, I wouldn’t give up on God, too many miracles going on all around us.
These are both good replies…It is quite right that we CAN make choices that are helpful to holding on to our faith.

However - I will suggest (from my own experience) that there are times when we must just let go…not try so hard…rest and recuperate…

The thing that struck me about the OP’s last reply was the idea of “I can’t do anything about it”. This speaks of trying too hard to understand things and a lack of reliance on God’s strength…a lack of trusting in God.

In such a case I have generally found it advisable to back off a bit rather than continuing to push. Pushing the matter would almost always result only in more confusion and a more negative outlook.
Backing off, placing my trust in God, allowing things to “percolate” on the “back burner” for a while would generally provide much more clarity.

I do not say this to counter either reply above…Indeed I agree with both of them.

Peace
James
 
Even if we cannot see any reason in this life, we can still have faith, through the promise of our Lord, that He will not permit unnecessary suffering, and may reward those who suffer in the next life.
And yet He does permit unnecessary suffering. Why?
You aren’t losing your faith. You’re actually gaining it.

Surprised?
I wish that were the case. It’s not true. My faith is gone. Sure, I attend mass every sunday, but it’s force of habit and the fear of being sent to hell if I don’t. It’s like a chore I am obligated to do, and the threat of condemnation if I don’t.
 
And yet He does permit unnecessary suffering. Why?
Why do you assume that the suffering is unnecessary?

I pointed out a passage in Scripture where a very similar question was raised…and what was Jesus answer?
So that the, “works of God might be made manifest in him.”
I wish that were the case. It’s not true. My faith is gone. Sure, I attend mass every sunday, but it’s force of habit and the fear of being sent to hell if I don’t. It’s like a chore I am obligated to do, and the threat of condemnation if I don’t.
And yet her you are asking questions and seeking help and insight. This speaks of the Holy Spirit working within you.

Peace
James
 
There’s too many suffering innocent people in this world. Folks who suffer horribly without the slightest mercy from God. I don’t get it. The corrupt folks win, and the poor are powerless.

Why?
The innocent who suffered in this life will be rewarded greatly. We live in a world where free will operates; God wants us to come to him freely, and return his Love.

We need many generous Christians to come to the aid of those who are suffering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top