Love your neighbor as yourself or more than yourself?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tomo_pomo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

tomo_pomo

Guest
I believe that true love requires sacrifice.
So how can we love our neighbor as ourselves if we are sacrificing ourselves.
Should it be “Love your neighbor more than yourself”?
If not, please explain why not.
Thanks
 
“Love your neighbor more than yourself” is heroic. It brings to mind the saints who sacrificed themselves to help others, such as those who nursed sick people till they themselves caught the illness and died, or St. Maximilian Kolbe who volunteered to take the place of a condemned prisoner so he could help the other condemned prisoners as they all starved to death.

The commandments are a set of rules for living that we’re expected to keep in order to attain salvation. Not everybody is capable of being a hero - at least not to everyone, though we might sacrifice ourselves for our child, our parent, our close friend - and Christ doesn’t require us to be heroic in order to be saved. If we go beyond the basic requirement to love our neighbor as ourselves, and love our neighbor MORE than ourselves, then we’re heading for an exalted level of holiness, not just basic salvation.
 
Last edited:
As St Thomas Aquinas explained, there are two dimensions on loving something or someone: an objective dimension and subjective dimension.

The objective dimension, the thing being loved, dictates the quality or type of love it should receive. I love sunsets a different way than fried chicken, and both loves are different to the love I have for my mother. I do not want to eat my mother, nor do I want to just gaze at fried chicken, nor do I want to hug a sunset. Based on this, the types of love can be qualitatively higher or lower based on the object being loved. Obviously, it is a higher kind of love to love someone compared to the love of an inanimate object. In this way it is a higher kind of love to love oneself than to love others, because the commandment “love your neighbor as yourself” means that the love of neighbor should be modeled on the love of self. You cannot love somebody else well if you cannot love yourself well.

On the other hand, the subjective dimension, the love of the lover themselves, dictates the quantity or intensity of love. It depends on the judgement and predisposition of the lover to determine how intense this love should be. Even if the kind of love a mother has for her child is higher than that of the dog, the mother would have a more intense love and care for the dog if she noticed the dog has a wound. From this it is clear that, normally, we are to love our neighbor more intensely than ourselves, because it is natural to love ourselves, maybe even too natural: we do not normally need to tell ourselves to eat when we’re hungry, while it may need rather prodigious urging to ourselves to feed others.
 
Last edited:
Thank you and you’re welcome, LittleFlower378!

I would also like to add that these two dimensions of love can be seen in God’s love for us too. God loves saintly people qualitatively more than sinful people because they can receive and are able to use His graces more. It is well documented how full of peace, joy and miracles saintly people’s lives were and are. On the other hand, God loves sinners way more intensely than saintly people because of His mercy. This is why God is, in Jesus’ parable, willing to leave the 99 good sheep to search for the one lost sheep.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top