Mailings from unknown orders asking for money

  • Thread starter Thread starter jofa
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jofa

Guest
Every few weeks I recieve in the mail requests for donations from religious orders which are unfamiliar to me. I am always concerned that it is a scam (anyone can set up a fake website) so I never send anything. Is there a way to confirm the legitimacy of a religious order including their mailing address?
Thanks and God Bless,
Sandra
 
Every few weeks I recieve in the mail requests for donations from religious orders which are unfamiliar to me. I am always concerned that it is a scam (anyone can set up a fake website) so I never send anything. Is there a way to confirm the legitimacy of a religious order including their mailing address?
Thanks and God Bless,
Sandra
Donate locally only to those organizations you are familiar with and can see. Anything else hits the circular file.
 
Donate locally only to those organizations you are familiar with and can see. Anything else hits the circular file.
Even that is suspect. I was sending a monthly check to my bishop’s Campaign for Human Development until I found out the USCCB was supporting ACORN. I’d even be willing to bet some of my money was used to pay for abortions.
 
Every few weeks I recieve in the mail requests for donations from religious orders which are unfamiliar to me. I am always concerned that it is a scam (anyone can set up a fake website) so I never send anything. Is there a way to confirm the legitimacy of a religious order including their mailing address?
Thanks and God Bless,
Sandra
I always tell people to be cautious when responding to junk mail asking for money.

What many people don’t realize is that in most cases, more money goes to the junk mailing company than goes to the actual charity.

I don’t recall the exact number, but it’s something like a 10% minimum that must go the the actual charity in order for the mailer to make the claim that your donation is tax deductible. It doesn’t mean that they all take 90%, it just means that they can.

The donor never knows how much of the donation goes to the charity, and how much goes to the company processing the donations Even though they’re required by law to tell you if you ask, they won’t volunteer the information.

This is what I advise people. Take it or leave it.

I suggest that if someone receives a solicitation for a donation, not to respond to the mailing itself, and not to make a donation over the internet—don’t use the enclosed envelope or donation card. Instead, lookup the actual address of the charity, and sent them a direct donation.

One can lookup a religious order (or, for that matter, ANY legitimate Catholic diocese, parish or organization) in a rather large book called the “Official Catholic Directory” printed by PJ Kennedy. Many parishes have a copy of this in the parish office. This is not the local diocese directory.

Since these books are a very expensive annual cost, many small parishes either don’t have them or only update them every few years, but larger parishes with bigger budgets often get them every year. If your parish doesn’t have one, try a large neighboring parish. Sometimes public or university libraries have them.
 
I always tell people to be cautious when responding to junk mail asking for money.

What many people don’t realize is that in most cases, more money goes to the junk mailing company than goes to the actual charity.

…
I can believe that. I began with a monthly check to a Catholic anti-abortion charity, and all of a sudden was receiving almost weekly appeals from them for more money. I wrote to them to take me off their mailing list and I would continue the monthly donations. I told them not to use my donations to ask me for more money. This didn’t work, so I stopped the donation.
 
I can believe that. I began with a monthly check to a Catholic anti-abortion charity, and all of a sudden was receiving almost weekly appeals from them for more money. I wrote to them to take me off their mailing list and I would continue the monthly donations. I told them not to use my donations to ask me for more money. This didn’t work, so I stopped the donation.
I support my local pro-life coalition, run by Catholics but not exclusive to the Church (anyone is welcome to pray at 40 Days for Life - some of the most stalwart happen to be Lutheran women). I am also considering supporting maternity homes, local of course. I would stay as local as possible. And make sure it’s not a big bureaucracy. (Although local pro-life organizations rarely are large.)
 
I support my local pro-life coalition, run by Catholics but not exclusive to the Church (anyone is welcome to pray at 40 Days for Life - some of the most stalwart happen to be Lutheran women). I am also considering supporting maternity homes, local of course. I would stay as local as possible. And make sure it’s not a big bureaucracy. (Although local pro-life organizations rarely are large.)
The concern I have (and which I often share in real-life) is not so much about the bureaucracy of the organization itself, but a matter of “who gets the money?”

Junk mailers and telemarketers provide a “service” to the charity, of soliciting donations. In return for that service, they take a fee. Donors should be aware of this and know that just because they respond to a mailing asking for money for “Sister Theresa’s Orphanage” doesn’t necessarily mean that all the money will indeed go to “Sister Theresa’s Orphanage.” If the donation goes through the advertising company, the most likely they’re getting a percentage. It might be a small percentage (in fairness, they are paying for the printing and postage, etc) or it might be a huge percentage–sometimes as high as 90%. On the other hand, donating directly to the organization we can be sure that the organization itself gets 100% of the donation.
 
The concern I have (and which I often share in real-life) is not so much about the bureaucracy of the organization itself, but a matter of “who gets the money?”

Junk mailers and telemarketers provide a “service” to the charity, of soliciting donations. In return for that service, they take a fee. Donors should be aware of this and know that just because they respond to a mailing asking for money for “Sister Theresa’s Orphanage” doesn’t necessarily mean that all the money will indeed go to “Sister Theresa’s Orphanage.” If the donation goes through the advertising company, the most likely they’re getting a percentage. It might be a small percentage (in fairness, they are paying for the printing and postage, etc) or it might be a huge percentage–sometimes as high as 90%. On the other hand, donating directly to the organization we can be sure that the organization itself gets 100% of the donation.
Yes, that is why I give the way I do. The Coalition for Life does not advertise so all of the money I contribute goes to support saving babies from certain death in abortion clinics.
 
… I am also considering supporting maternity homes, local of course. I would stay as local as possible. And make sure it’s not a big bureaucracy. (Although local pro-life organizations rarely are large.)
Having been disappointed by my experience, I decided to support a local maternity home and sent them a check. The check never cleared, and after about a month, I got a notice from my bank that the home had returned my check. That’s got to be a first.
 
The concern I have (and which I often share in real-life) is not so much about the bureaucracy of the organization itself, but a matter of “who gets the money?”

Junk mailers and telemarketers provide a “service” to the charity, of soliciting donations. In return for that service, they take a fee. Donors should be aware of this and know that just because they respond to a mailing asking for money for “Sister Theresa’s Orphanage” doesn’t necessarily mean that all the money will indeed go to “Sister Theresa’s Orphanage.” If the donation goes through the advertising company, the most likely they’re getting a percentage. It might be a small percentage (in fairness, they are paying for the printing and postage, etc) or it might be a huge percentage–sometimes as high as 90%. On the other hand, donating directly to the organization we can be sure that the organization itself gets 100% of the donation.
This is good advice. Donate directly to the charitable organization, not through the direct mail marketer.

Unfortunately, I find that even if one donates directly, one will end up on the mailing list of a direct mail marketer, or even worse, on the calling list of a telemarketer hired by the charity, and one can’t get off the calling list by using the do-no-call list.
 
my husband’s company services third party mass mailers who solicit for charity so we know something about this business.

If you get the request by mail you can assume it comes from a third party for-profit company, not from the charity itself, until proven otherwise. Unless they are willing to provide information on their activities, who runs it, and transparent financial info, don’t bite. If you respond by mail some if not all your donation goes to the mass mailer, and the charity just gets the addresses so they know who to keep hitting on for money. It is best not to respond at all or to get put on a do not call do not mail list (which can be done online). This is especially true if they send trinkets or raffle tickets.

research the charity on-line or call the office of the diocese in which they are located to get contact info. that is a lot of work and you are better off doing your giving only to organizations of which you have personal knowledge.

If you order something by catalog that includes a line for a donation to a charity, the charity gets no money, just your address and contact info. don’t bite.
 
Isn’t that fraud?
no not really because the charity is getting something that has monetary value, namely, the contact information for someone who is a proven soft touch
ethical? I don’t think so, but not illegal.
 
Lots of good charities rely on direct mail to sustain their mission. The key is telling the difference between the worthy causes and the scams. I like to check charitynavigator.com.
 
no not really because the charity is getting something that has monetary value, namely, the contact information for someone who is a proven soft touch
ethical? I don’t think so, but not illegal.
But They are creating the impression that the charity is getting at least most of the donation to devote to their mission as opposed to supporting a business.

On a separate note, the IRS should allow a deduction for only that portion that actually does go to the charity’s work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top