T
Tomdstone
Guest
No. All we have is now and the present moment. The real line extends without bound into the past and future and yet there is a point on the line corresponding to 2016, the present year.It’s not possible for a cyclic universe to exist from the infinite past, because if it did then we would now be at the end of an infinite series of actual events. But by definition it is not possible to reach the end of an infinite series. Therefore, at some point the universe had a beginning.
I don’t accept your argument because there is no point at infinity to take as your starting point.