Man Made Rules?

  • Thread starter Thread starter peace2u2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
in our Catholic parish, we have many collections other than our weekly tithe. we have the building church fund, CRS, for building a well in nigeria, Peter’s Pence, St. Vincent de Paul, and many others. since i have become Catholic, weekly i receive requests for donations from numerous charities that i had never heard of until i became Catholic. in the Catholic church, we usually don’t have homilies about tithing like they might do in the protestant churches. my daughter-in-law stopped going to her protestant church because week after week the sermons were on the importance of tithing. she felt like they were speaking directly to her. my problem right now is that i am experiencing financial difficulties and i would love to donate to the church and certain charities, but can’t until i begin working again.
We have the same sort of thing in my parish - the difference with what I experience in protestant churches is that at most the Priest might mention they’re there and can we read the information. Very rarely is a request for additional funds actually given - and no pressure is put on. I’ve never heard that unless I give to the Church or this or that charity I’m basically heading for hell.

I heard a 10 minute, minimum, sermon every single week about how I must give to the church. And oddly, in the 20 plus years I attended, never once heard a request for money for charities such as we see in Catholic parishes.
 
We have the same sort of thing in my parish - the difference with what I experience in protestant churches is that at most the Priest might mention they’re there and can we read the information. Very rarely is a request for additional funds actually given - and no pressure is put on. I’ve never heard that unless I give to the Church or this or that charity I’m basically heading for hell.

I heard a 10 minute, minimum, sermon every single week about how I must give to the church. And oddly, in the 20 plus years I attended, never once heard a request for money for charities such as we see in Catholic parishes.
So are you saying as I listen to Mike Murdoch, Rod Parsely, TBN and their understanding of “law of the seed”, that occupies 90% of their time speaking…I should not consider sending them money in order to get some back?😃
 
And what need can’t Jesus meer of yours? Only a question,not an insult.
I have no reason to take your question as an insult. I am sure that it is meant in all sincerity and based on what for you is a satisfying and complete relationship forged in your heart. That is well and good, but not all of us are that personalized in what ways our interior journey might take us.

For my part I was given an experience that completely unsettled my “normal” understanding of who and what a human being is, and how a human is in terms of perceptual abilities. I’ve made it a condition to not talk about that experience unless certain clear indicators were present in someone’s response that gave me a sign that there was a possibility of communication about it that would not end in frustration. By far the majority of instances indicate that silence is a much better option. As you can see, even the idea that there is something not clearly covered by the ordinary ministrations of the Church can be disturbing. To me it was devastating.

Ordinarily one would seek resolution in prayer and perhaps spiritual advice. I did both of those, and research, with great fervor. No person, lay or clerical, had any useful explanation for my experience or direction to send me in other than ones I had already perused. And of course I didn’t interview everyone in the OHCAC. Most of them are, in my experience, habitual Catholics, and the ones who had questions–resolved or not–were not plowing in my field, so to speak.

Over time my understanding and awe of Jesus as the Christ only increased, as did all of my considerations regarding the hypostatic union. My problem wasn’t and isn’t with Him. I needed, you might say, hands on technical help. If you read a red letter version of the Bible, you realize that there isn’t much of that there, and much of it is reference to the OT. I was not in a position to rely on the suspense offered by simple faith. I looked elsewhere and was more than satisfied, which satisfaction allowed me to more dispassionately again accept that there were, indeed, certain ones in the Church who had addressed my issues.

It was just that there wasn’t anyone in my reach who was Catholic who had a handle on them. Basically, I lucked out, big time. I found a spiritual counselor, who did not call himself that, who allowed me to keep my sanity regarding this matter and soothed my desperation with the Church through his own admiration of many Catholic Saints as well as having an exceptional versatility with the Teachings of Jesus. So, in a sense, I came in through a back door, and with an experiential appreciation of what might be called “human DOS,” and a phenomenal love of and respect for the Christ.
 
A friend of mine has left her Catholic Church for a non-denominational church stating that she left because the Catholic Church has too many man made rules. But, when asked to give more detail she just really couldn’t give me any other examples except for the fasting rules during Lent and that the amount of money we give to the church is between us and God and that there is no need to use envelopes for the collections. ?
JL: All groups have rules. There are very few rules that effect the individual.

I have never belonged to a parish that required envelopes for the collection. Many do not use envelopes but just drop money into the basket. Envelopes are mostly used for income tax purposes even in some Protestant groups.
 
I am going to be following this post.

I often hear people complain about the ‘man-made rules’ within the Church but don’t ALL religious organizations operate under man-made rules?

Man wrote the Bible, after all. Sure, God inspired the men who wrote those words but ultimately it was written by a man. So why can’t God also inspire men to make rules for the Church?

I dunno. I just can’t grasp my head around the logic of man-made = against God’s will.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top