Hi, you weren’t speaking to me, but may I answer?
I don’t think women who go without the veil in this day and age are being disobedient because Canon Law is silent on the matter.
However I agree with Floresco and Red Sox Wife. A headcovering used to be required by the Church, and Our Lord asks us to follow the Churches requirements. So yes, you had to cover under pain of sin.
Dear Lamafacaja,
Cordial greetings and a very good day.
The Canon Law of 1983 did indeed officially abrogate all of the 1917 Code, including the requirement for women to don a veil at Holy Mass, but to say, as many modern Catholic women do, that veiling is now optional and can be discarded, is fallacious.
The tide of femenism was overwhelming in Western culture, especially in the English-speaking world, and sadly most Catholic women accepted the warped propaganda of the femenist movement uncritically. It is highly probable that the Vatican did find a potential problem with the old 1917 Code of Canon Law, requiring the veiling of women, as it could be used to bolster the case for the femenist argument. It is possible that for this reason the Vatican dropped the veiling requirement from the 1983 Code. As you intimate, under the old 1917 Law, women could theoretically be coerced under penalty to wear a veil against their will. The problem with this was twofold: First, this canon could be employed as a case to bolster the erroneous femenist argument against the veiling of women. Second, the canon actually defeated the authentic Catholic reason for wearing a veil in the first place, which is why one should not attach too much importance to the requirement being repealed by the 1983 Code of Canon Law.
The authentic Catholic reason for wearing a veil is the
biblical one. It is something all pious Catholic women are supposed to do, not because they have to, but rather because they want to in obedience to Sacred Scripture. The fact that our Church has decided to no longer enforce this custom through the Canon Law, means nothing more than the Church does not wish to be our nanny. The veil is a custom for women to do voluntarily in obedience to Sacred Scripture and not becuase they are compelled to do so under pain of sin. The idea is that women are to read what the biblical directives are and be convinced of what is written therein. For the veiling to be an authentic token of humility and holiness, it must be done freely without coercion; women are supposed to be veiled in Church, but it is never to be forced.
The biblical case for the veil is to be found in I Corinthians 11: 2-16. The tradition of the veil comes from Christ, by way of the Holy Spirit, through St. Paul, for the Apostle states later in this same Epistle, “What I am writing to you is a command of the Lord. If anyone does not recognise this, he is not recognised” (I Cor. 14: 37-38). Thus it is important to observe that biblical veiling has nothing to do with some man-made custom that is subject to change down through the vicissitudes of time, like ordinary headwear, which has been worn for all manner of reasons, some practical. Canon Law may currently be silent upon the issue, but Sacred Scripture is not and it is to this that we must repair for guidance.
"That women should cover their heads when in Church is a Christian custom based on the words of St. Paul in I Cor. 11: 6. There he definitely gives instruction that Christian women must cover their heads in divine worship. He gives two reasons for his decree, one theological and one moral. The theological reason is as follows: Every beings true glory and honour is to keep the place assigned to him or her by God. Now God Himself differentiated between the sexes, and that difference should be manifested during our public religious acknowledgement of Him. Man was first created, and woman dependently upon the man. The covering upon a woman’s head was to be a sign of this dependence. Both men and women are created, of course, for God; their souls are equally precious to Him. But secondarily, women were created as helpmates for men, so that secondarily women were created for men, rather than men for women.
The moral reason given by St. Paul deals with Christian modesty. Loose women of ill-repute went to their temples without any head covering, not veiling their beauty, but bent on a vain display of their attractions. St. Paul would have none of this in a Christian church: “Therefore ought the woman to have power (i.e. a veil) over her head, he writes, “because of the angels” (I Cor. 11: 10). He mentions these pure spirits to bring home the fact that spiritual considerations alone should prevail in the worship of God, and not sensual vanity. A woman’s hair is the object of her vanity and earthly glory - and she knows it. Let her at least veil it in Church, giving her attention to higher things, and allowing others to do so also. Thus you have the legislation of St. Paul and the reason for it” (
Radio Replies, Vol 2, question 1053, Fathers Rumble & Carty, Tan Books 1979).
Trust that this will be of help to those women who already veil in divine worship and those who, at the moment, are undecided and uncertain.
God bless.
Warmest good wishes,
Portrait:tiphat:
Pax