Marital Chastity

  • Thread starter Thread starter dal314
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dal314

Guest
I am a man seeking to better understand the Church’s teaching on chastity in marriage.

Specifically, I am trying to discern what is meant by the Catechism in CCC2366: “it is necessary that each and every marriage act remain ordered per se to the procreation of human life.”

A good friend who has read the CCC and Humanae Vitae has argued that foreplay leading to male ejaculation (e.g., oral sex, etc.) can be permissible (and part of the unitive aspect of the marital act) as long as it is part of a sexual encounter that is also consummated with normal sexual intercourse.

I am familiar with Christopher West’s take on the Theology of the Body and the distinction between “oral stimulation” and “oral sex”.

It seems to me that the morality of the above depends on whether or not this entire sexual encounter can be considered a single “marital act” – in which case it would be both unitive and open to life – or if it must be considered two separate acts – in which case the first act would not be open to life.

Has the Church ever defined what constitutes the “marital act”?

Many thanks for your help.

Peace in Christ.
 
From my understanding, the marital act includes foreplay but the final ejaculation should be in a procreative text. Oral sex with the semen expelled in the mouth is not open to life, but oral sex where the consummation of the union is in the proper place. Unitive to me indicates that there are no barriers (no physical or chemical barriers to prevent conception.) So I think in the terms you provided, oral stimulation is acceptable, but oral sex is not.

Why? Well you ask if they are separate or the same act. Oral sex on it’s own is still sex. The culmination of the marital act is ejaculation. A person who simply has oral sex, is still having sex. A person who has sex in the proper context is still said to have sex. The only way it can be considered one act is for them both to be tied to the same ejaculation. (Else we could argue that oral sex wasn’t sex at all, because it didn’t finish intravaginal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top