Maronite Teaching on Purgatory

  • Thread starter Thread starter garysibio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

garysibio

Guest
I was listening to one of the call-in shows on Catholic Answers Live and someone mentioned that the Maronite understanding of Purgatory was slightly different from the Latin Rite understanding. Can anyone enlighten me as to the differences?
 
Over on the Eastern side of things, they have different emphases and images for the theology post-death purification. I understand that they see it as a sort of journey.

But I don’t know much about it. (Not knowing the right name to look under is a pain.)
 
Over on the Eastern side of things, they have different emphases and images for the theology post-death purification. I understand that they see it as a sort of journey.

But I don’t know much about it. (Not knowing the right name to look under is a pain.)
Thanks, Mintaka.
 
At the risk of sparking a rehash of a debate from a few months ago, if a Maronite is an orthodox Catholic he or she accepts the universal Magisterial teaching on Purgatory as on all matters of faith and morals, but may use different terminology, different emphases, etc. in speaking about it.
 
At the risk of sparking a rehash of a debate from a few months ago, if a Maronite is an orthodox Catholic he or she accepts the universal Magisterial teaching on Purgatory as on all matters of faith and morals, but may use different terminology, different emphases, etc. in speaking about it.
Those are the differences I’m trying to learn about.
 
I do know that there are Maronite churches that are called “Our Lady of Purgatory Maronite Church”

I dont know if that helps?
 
I do know that there are Maronite churches that are called “Our Lady of Purgatory Maronite Church”

I dont know if that helps?
Now that seems strange. I’m pretty hardcore Western but the use of the actual word “purgatory” in the name of a Maronite parish seems a little odd even to me. Usually I thought Eastern Christians used different terms to refer to the same process.
 
There was a lot of bickering among Latin/Eastern theologians about the nature of purgatory. The Latins viewed it as a place of punishing fire, drawing upon (among other things) Jesus’ parable about gold being purified by fire. The Catechism (#1030) refers to a “cleansing fire” which is “entirely different from the punishment of the damned.”

The Eastern theologians viewed purgatory as a place of darkness, where we are able to know and contemplate the true nature of our sins, and where we will be aware of God but be entirely separated from him. Our sorrow for our sin and our “separation anxiety” is what liberates us from purgatory.

This disagreement was one of the main topics of the Council of Florence, which attempted reunification of the Latin and Orthodox churches.

Personally, I think this is a pointless debate.
 
The only definitive judgement the Magesterium has made concerning Purgatory relates only to it’s existence. Whether there is a literal fire, or whether it is a place of darkness is outside the scope of the doctrine.
 
According to Fr. Anthony J. Salim who authored “Captivated by your Teachings” - a resource book for adult Maronite Catholics:
Although the Fathers of the early Church, including St. Ephrem, attest to the reality of the soul’s need for purification after death, the widely known term “purgatory” is not explicitly stated in the Scriptures. The term comes from Western Tradition, and did not even appear in it until the 11th century at the earliest. The formulation of the teaching became a source of controversy between Greek East and Latin West; the Syriac Churches, including the Maronites, never became involved in the controversy. Since the 16th century, the Catholic Church officially teaches that the departed stand in need of purification from whatever keeps them from full union with the Trinity in the Kingdom and is wisely silent about further details about the nature of that purification.
We must remember that what is being described is a state of the soul, not a place.
Maronite Tradition repeatedly expresses two ideas about the Faithful Departed. The first is that not all the dead have yet completed their journey to the happiness of the Kingdom. They are “at rest” and “awaiting” the final saving action of the Lord. Second, they need our prayers for the forgiveness of their sins and purification. This theme is conveyed through the prayers offered up on Sunday of the Faithful Departed, on the Maronite Calendar.
 
According to Fr. Anthony J. Salim who authored “Captivated by your Teachings” - a resource book for adult Maronite Catholics:
Great quote from Fr. Salim’s book! I’d say that pretty accurately describes the Eastern view of purgatory.

Long story short, as another poster mentioned, the only definitive teaching of the Church on purgatory is that it exists as a state of the soul. What it is and what the nature of its purification is has not been defined, and there is rightly a great deal of variation in the different chruchs’ approach to the matter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top