Marriage and Contraception

  • Thread starter Thread starter Habesha
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Using any one birth control method alone is bound to be less reliable than using multiple types at the same time. … I also know people who have gotten pregnant much sooner than they would have liked while using NFP. As I said before, all these couples probably weren’t doing it right or something, but I would just rather not worry about it.
If we’re talking about NFP, there is no evidence that using NFP + condoms is any more reliable than using NFP without barrier methods. In fact, one 2007 study found HIGHER rates of pregnancy in couples who used NFP and then used some barrier method during the fertile period. That makes perfect sense. You’re much less likely to get pregnant if you just don’t have sex when ovulation is taking place than if you have any sort of sexual activity during that most fertile period of the cycle.

As for people getting pregnant “much sooner than they would have liked,” in most cases this is due to the decision not to abstain. Even if a couple thinks they might want to wait longer to have a baby, if they make the decision to have sex when they know they are fertile and they conceive, we need to be clear that they have abandoned the method as a way to avoid pregnancy and adopted it as a way to achieve pregnancy. There is nothing to “worry” about with NFP, because a woman gets to know the signs of her fertility and doesn’t have to worry about a condom breaking or breakthrough ovulation occurring. She knows if conception is likely to take place and acts accordingly.
My cycle is very irregular and I wouldn’t trust myself to be an accurate judge of whether or not I’m fertile…
My cycle is very irregular too, and no one’s cycle is so irregular that NFP wouldn’t work for them. Modern methods of NFP rely on each individual woman’s signs of fertility and helping her to understand how her body works. Charting can help identify the causes of irregular cycles, PMS, abnormal bleeding, inadequate luteal phase, etc. Honestly, NFP charting is an empowering tool for any woman, sexually active or not, and is an important part of healthy living overall. There is no reason not to trust our bodies.

It might be better to start a separate thread on women’s liberation and Catholic views of feminism, but I’ll answer some of the questions you raised.
Women’s liberation - You seem to think this is a bad thing? Is there something wrong with women joining the workforce?
Objectively, no, there is nothing wrong with women joining the workforce. Men and women are equal in the eyes of God and they should be equal in the eyes of men. At the same time, men and women reach fulfillment in different ways. Much of the focus in the women’s liberation movement was simply getting women out of the home and allowing them to “be truly fulfilled” in the workforce. That women could be fulfilled inside the home has been devalued, and often today women who are “just” SAHMs are viewed as “wasting” something.
Children born out of wedlock - Just because their parents weren’t married doesn’t mean the child was an accident, or that the parents don’t plan to be married, etc.
A stable household with a married mother and father is the best option for raising healthy, well-adjusted children. Research supports this fact. I know several people who have had children out of wedlock–none of them intended to marry the baby’s father at the time they conceived, and all were using some kind of contraception to prevent it from happening. I’m not saying that they are bad parents, but it’s clear that the contraceptive mentality–that every romantic relationship should come with sexual intimacy w/o the possibility of a baby–did lead to those out of wedlock births.
Girls reaching puberty earlier - This is often blamed on the artificial growth hormones in the meats we eat and doesn’t seem to have a lot to do with women’s liberation or the sexual revolution.
Girls reaching puberty earlier is likely due to a number of environmental estrogens. And if you want to check out some artificial growth hormones and environmental estrogens, look no further than hormonal contraception. Birth control pills have such high levels of synthetic estrogens and progesterones that they can’t be processed by a woman’s liver and are eliminated in her urine. Those hormones cannot be filtered out of the water supply, so the rest of us consume them. Estrogen dominance is a problem on the rise, leading to women’s health issues such as PCOS, endometriosis, infertility and obesity. The pill’s contribution to these problems is not negligible.
Girls sexually active earlier - I probably shouldn’t even address this due to its controversial nature, but personally I don’t care when girls choose to become sexually active so long as they are using protection. I feel it’s a personal decision.
And the reason you “feel” this is because contraception allows you to separate sex from procreation. Contraception allows you to view sex as a recreational activity and personal decision that should be free from consequences “so long as they are using protection”. The reason girls are sexually active earlier is because of contraception–and since contraception FAILS, we have teen pregnancies and abortions at much higher rates today than we did before the sexual revolution.
 
Women having abortions - The reason women nowadays have more abortions than they did in the 1950s and earlier has to do with women’s liberation and can be linked to the development of oral contraceptives, but it’s not a cause-and-effect thing. The reason women had more abortions after women’s liberation was because they suddenly realized they could. Suddenly, we had power over our own bodies.
Abortion is not “power over our own bodies”–it is an exercise of power over the body of another human being, whatever the pro-choice rhetoric says. There is a clear connection between contraception and abortion, not only in our legal jurisprudence (the right to privacy first applied to contraception, then to abortion) but in the minds of many women who consider abortion to be a form of birth control. Many of the women who have an abortion have multiple abortions. That any woman has more than one abortion shows that she doesn’t regard it as a last resort but as a form of birth control, a way to limit the number of children she has in her lifetime.
“Women and men delay marriage into their late 20s” - How is this a bad thing? I think people should wait as long as possible before getting married. It’s a big commitment and sometimes people jump into it too soon, when they’re not mature or ready for it.
As someone who married young, I have plenty of reasons, both secular and religious, for why young marriage is a great thing. Age is a number; maturity can come at a younger age for some than for others, so I fully support the early marriage of mature adults who know what they are getting themselves into.

Many older and wiser married folks than myself will tell you that it is much easier to build a life with someone when you haven’t yet built a life of your own. Young people are much more flexible and able to grow together than 30somethings who are fairly set in their ways. Negotiating career paths as they begin is much simpler than trying to reconcile two separate careers of two different people. Also, it’s much easier to raise young children when parents are young themselves. Plus, parents who start their families in their 20s are usually able to enjoy their adult children as they grow older. If you have a baby at 25, you are just nearing retirement age as they hit 30–plenty of time to enjoy seeing their vocations blossom, families grow, and careers succeed.
 
inawhale

“this made me laugh” - - In a good way, I hope? I loved the Veggie Tales version. I wasn’t sure if your nic was a purposeful choice descibing the current state of your spiritual journey, or something else; either way, it’s clever and I liked it.

“I’m not disagreeing with everything the Church teaches” - - OK, thanks for clarifying. I suppose my question boils down to if you accept the Church’s definitions on some really fundamental beliefs, like the Eucharist, why do you not accept it on other fundamental matters? If the answer is, I don’t agree with the Church (because the Church’s answer does not comport with my experience, intuition, etc.), does not that really set you up as the ultimate authority/arbiter of the Truth of revelation? Where exactly were you (or any of us, of course) granted such authority?

To me, that is why a teaching authority exists. You, I, and other believers can sincerely study Scripture, tradition, Tradition, the ECFs, etc., and come to differing or even contradictory conclusions about God’s nature and how we are to act as Christians. We both cannot be correct. That’s why, I humbly suggest, Peter was given the keys to the Kingdom, and those who hear the apostles hear Christ.

I didn’t want to come off as demanding answers to the questions posed in my prior post, so that’s why I termed them rhetorical, moreso for you to think about how you are arriving at your beliefs. I do not think you are terrible (your word) or anything like that.
 
As someone who married young, I have plenty of reasons, both secular and religious, for why young marriage is a great thing. Age is a number; maturity can come at a younger age for some than for others, so I fully support the early marriage of mature adults who know what they are getting themselves into.
Regarding ‘age’ when marrying, I would suggest that what is most important is the ‘age you are at’ when you meet ‘the one’ who is to become your spouse.

Some people meet their soul mate when they are young, and others when they are a bit older. Obviously there are numerous examples of couples who married young and had great marriages, as there are numerous examples of people who married later and also had great marriages.
 
Regarding ‘age’ when marrying, I would suggest that what is most important is the ‘age you are at’ when you meet ‘the one’ who is to become your spouse.

Some people meet their soul mate when they are young, and others when they are a bit older. Obviously there are numerous examples of couples who married young and had great marriages, as there are numerous examples of people who married later and also had great marriages.
Right. This is why I think advocating delaying marriage “as late as possible” is misguided. Why date for 5-10 years before marrying? What is even the point in that? Relationships develop and deepen over time, and it doesn’t take more than a year or two (sometimes less) for two mature adults to realize whether or not they should make a lifelong commitment to the other person.
 
Right. This is why I think advocating delaying marriage “as late as possible” is misguided. Why date for 5-10 years before marrying? What is even the point in that? Relationships develop and deepen over time, and it doesn’t take more than a year or two (sometimes less) for two mature adults to realize whether or not they should make a lifelong commitment to the other person.
I understand your point. I suspect that your comments are based in part on your own situation and experience. However, everyone has their own unique experiences. From my perspective, I am not going to make any value judgments on anyone with regard to the age they get married or the length of their courtship. There isn’t a one-size-fits-all formula with regard to successful marriages.
 
I understand your point. I suspect that your comments are based in part on your own situation and experience. However, everyone has their own unique experiences. From my perspective, I am not going to make any value judgments on anyone with regard to the age they get married or the length of their courtship. There isn’t a one-size-fits-all formula with regard to successful marriages.
I’m not saying that there is a “one size fits all formula,” and I wasn’t intending to say that there is any one best way. However, following the Church’s teachings on the Sacrament of Marriage generally requires that we let go of secular attitudes regarding marriage, and even regarding dating relationships, particularly those attitudes which recommend delaying marriage “as long as possible,” or advocate extended periods of dating (one person or many) before one “settles down” to marry. The conventional wisdom about dating and marriage doesn’t exactly encourage lifelong commitment.

This is not to say that some people just don’t meet the person they are to marry until they are well into their 30s, or that some people are not mature enough to commit to marriage until later in life. All I’m saying is that our society promotes “arrested adolescence” and encourages young people to “find themselves” and live carefree lives throughout their 20s, before they get married. The Church, on the other hand, teaches us that we can only find ourselves through a complete gift of ourselves to another person, whether that person is Christ or our human spouse (Gaudium et Spes para. 23).
 
I’m not saying that there is a “one size fits all formula,” and I wasn’t intending to say that there is any one best way. However, following the Church’s teachings on the Sacrament of Marriage generally requires that we let go of secular attitudes regarding marriage, and even regarding dating relationships, particularly those attitudes which recommend delaying marriage “as long as possible,” or advocate extended periods of dating (one person or many) before one “settles down” to marry. The conventional wisdom about dating and marriage doesn’t exactly encourage lifelong commitment.

This is not to say that some people just don’t meet the person they are to marry until they are well into their 30s, or that some people are not mature enough to commit to marriage until later in life. All I’m saying is that our society promotes “arrested adolescence” and encourages young people to “find themselves” and live carefree lives throughout their 20s, before they get married. The Church, on the other hand, teaches us that we can only find ourselves through a complete gift of ourselves to another person, whether that person is Christ or our human spouse (Gaudium et Spes para. 23).
I’ll agree with that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top