Marriage and NFP

  • Thread starter Thread starter stjoetheworker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

stjoetheworker

Guest
My fiancee and I, both devout Catholics, are getting married soon, and we had some questions about marital abstinence that we were hoping some NFP veterans could help us with.
It is looking like we will be in phase two, the fertile phase, of her cycle on our wedding night and honeymoon. However, after spending several months speaking with our priest and parents (who are also practicing Catholics), as well as praying about it, we have decided that, for the time being, we will seek to postpone pregnancy using NFP. Therefore, sex on our wedding night, unless God changes our hearts between now and then, will not be happening. That brings me to my questions.
First, objectively, “how far is too far” in regards to physical intimacy between two married persons in an act that will not end sexually?
Second (and this is targeted at you NFP veterans), subjectively, “how far is too far” concerning physical intimacy between two married persons who want to maintain enough control to not cross the objective line?
Obviously my fiancee and I will be talking with our priest and parents about this, but we were also looking for a general perspective from faithful Catholics. On a final note, both my fiancee and I have BAs in Catholic Theology. So we both are, at least decently, versed in Catholic moral theology.

Thank you, and have a blessed Advent.
 
For readers (I imagine the poster is well aware of such)

Compendium issued by Pope Benedict XVI
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for serious reasons; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
 
I imagine there is a good deal of writing out there regarding suggestions for while abstaining (from NFP sites).
 
When my wife and I were just starting NFP, “too far” meant being within 1 foot of one another. That’s all it took (during the fertile phase) for the NFP rules to be tossed out the window.

In all sincerity, if you are not wanting to engage in sex, then don’t do anything that might lead to sexual desires. Talk, hold hands, go for walks, read books, etc…but don’t put yourself in a position where you get all wound-up just to throw on the parking break. If you are going to get physically romantic, be prepared to be open to sharing in the marital embrace. Otherwise you may end up frustrated…and cold showers don’t really work that well, in my experience. 🙂
 
Certainly avoid that which would cause a vehement arousal…

Humm… newly married? Wedding night?

Perhaps kiss each other good night briefly…before you go to your separate rooms…😉
 
I was really looking to see if anybody know the answer to the objective question, if there is one. I will rephrase it. What is the objective beginning, if there is one, to a physical act that must end in the fullness of the marital embrace? At first glance, from what I know of moral theology, it would be direct genital stimulation. Once that occurs it is proper to end that particular act naturally. However, is that the “point of no return” or is the line drawn farther back?
 
I was really looking to see if anybody know the answer to the objective question, if there is one. I will rephrase it. What is the objective beginning, if there is one, to a physical act that must end in the fullness of the marital embrace? At first glance, from what I know of moral theology, it would be direct genital stimulation. Once that occurs it is proper to end that particular act naturally. However, is that the “point of no return” or is the line drawn farther back?
Strong question uh? The objective begin if it must end in marital embrace cannot be determined frm theology and it’s not thesame for every couple, for explosive ones french kissing is objective enough for others it’s touching, others it’s…you will find out what is objective for u. HAPPY NEW BEGINING! Believe me when i say it’s a new begining.
 
Strong question uh? The objective begin if it must end in marital embrace cannot be determined frm theology and it’s not thesame for every couple, for explosive ones french kissing is objective enough for others it’s touching, others it’s…you will find out what is objective for u. HAPPY NEW BEGINING! Believe me when i say it’s a new begining.
This is pretty good advice. Every couple will find their “line” is in a different spot. Some can handle more than others before they find themselves losing control. As your relationship matures and grows, you will both figure out where exactly that line is for you. Just be honest with each other as you begin your new life together!
 
OK, I will be the one to point to the elephant in the room and give you a very unhelpful piece of advice: postpone the wedding until you are ready to have children.

Other than that, I agree with SummerSmiles. And best wishes for your upcoming marriage.
 
My BIL and SIL, knowing they were in phase two on their wedding day, post poned the honey moon for a week and a half. The time alone together on vacation would have proved to be too much temptation…so for the first week of their married life, SIL slept in the bed, and BIL slept on the couch. They also repainted tehir new apartment, unpacked, arranged and rearranged furniture, did minor repairs, and basically threw themselves into renovations and repairs until they were too exhausted for anything more than a chaste kiss goodnight. Then they enjoyed their honeymoon.
 
Well who knows where your fiance’ will be in her cycle on her wedding night. The stress of planning a wedding, especially as you get closer to the date of your wedding can do crazy things to a woman’s cycle.

Now, when you are married, you have conjugal rights. It is not sinful for you to have sex (even when you’re fertile.). It is not sinful to get caught up in the moment. It can actually be sinful for one spouse to reject the other sexually. If its a reasonable request to have sex, you should have sex (regardless of if you’re practing NFP or not. Any period of abstainence ought to be mutual) That’s not to say you can’t discuss things, but ultimately God wants husband and wife to be united to the point where they can trust each other to love each other well. If you feel that you can’t automatically consent, either you need to learn to trust your spouse more or you’ve got larger marital issues you need to work through.

Because you have conjugal rights, practicing chastity is not like practicing chastity while dating. Overall the issue is that you want to postpone pregnancy. First, you do need to discern whether or not you have legitimate reason to do this. What meaning will it take on your wedding day to delay consumating your wedding vows for the sake of preventing pregnancy just after you give consent to accept children? That’s not to say that it is sinful to abstain. There is an older tradition of dedicating the wedding night to St. Joseph and doing a religious devotion that night to him. The big question is how do you abstain without contradicting your marital vows?

Where the sin in this area would lie are two areas. 1. Substituting other sexual acts for intercourse by diverting and deriving ways to stimulate each other in a manner that violates the procreative meaning of sexuality. 2. Putting the other in a situation where the continence/abstainence is not mutual. You should not be having to be playing gatekeeper with your spouse saying “thou shall not pass!!” And simply restricting to lesser and lesser expressions of love does not mean that you’re not playing gatekeeper.

So here’s my advise. If you’re going to abstain your wedding night, realize a few things. You probably will not sleep well the day before your wedding. The entire wedding day is very busy. Receptions have been known to go on till pretty late. So if your looking to love each other and just abstain but not reject each other, enjoy the entire wedding day. Tire yourselves out with dancing. Go up to the hotel room, get in your normal PJ’s and go to sleep. However, I emphasis that the abstainence needs to be mutual. If your new spouse during the reception says “I’d really like to consumate our marriage tonight” don’t turn it into a situation where you both end up trying to find a dark corner to have a quiet but heated discussion about your “agreement.”

Even if you do decide to consumate your marriage on your wedding night, try not to be too goal oriented about it. Let nature guide you. Sex is not like tying your shoe and while it can be really obvious when a man is ready for sex, it is not as obvious as when a woman is ready. The majority of pain a woman experiences when she loses her virginity has more to do with engaging in sex prematurely and being ignorant of how her own body works. The hymen actually has very few nerve endings, and yet women are consistantly told the myth that sex hurts the first time because of the hymen. Do not be surprised if you do not complete the act on your wedding night even if that is your intent. You may have to finish up in the morning. There is nothing abnormal about that. Being too stressed and exhausted to have sex on your wedding night is normal. Usually its the virgins who are all jumping at having sex their wedding nights. A lot of non-virgins know when they’re too exhausted for it and go straight to sleep anyway.
 
I was really looking to see if anybody know the answer to the objective question, if there is one. I will rephrase it. What is the objective beginning, if there is one, to a physical act that must end in the fullness of the marital embrace? At first glance, from what I know of moral theology, it would be direct genital stimulation. Once that occurs it is proper to end that particular act naturally. However, is that the “point of no return” or is the line drawn farther back?
There is no clear cut line (even touching certain body parts), because it is all based on the fact that couples have conjugal rights. Periodic continence must be mutual. You do take a risk with any sexual activity that you will stir their desires in each other where to even mutually abstain would be to put each other in the occassion of sin. But there is no definitive point as to where that line is. That it dependant on the individual. And even without putting your spouse in the occassion of personal sins, there is still the fact that you have conjugal rights. Even if you are not terribly aroused, your spouse has every right to ask you for sex and you should consent. This means you have to really love each other well. You cannot rely on your own self preservation and self love to protect yourself. You have to rely on your spouses love for you. Without their love and goodwill to you, you will be a more divided couple. So you both have to mutually look out for the other, discern together and trust each other immensely. Anyone who feels they need the right to sexually refuse their spouse is dealing with a spouse who they feel they can not trust to love them. That can mean trust issues or it can mean a much larger marital issue. NFP is not a morally legimate use for denying conjugal rights. Its permitted upon mutual consent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top