Marriage convalidation and vasectomy

  • Thread starter Thread starter Veronica97
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

Veronica97

Guest
First, let me say I am trying to make an appointment to speak with my priest about this issue. 15 years ago my husband’s first marriage was anulled, and we had our marriage convalidated in the Catholic Church. He was a baptized confirmed Catholic, and I had not yet been baptized. We had been married civilly 10 years before that and had a child, so the priest didn’t require us to go through marriage prep. While we were in his office filling out paperwork for the convalidation, it occurred to me that maybe I should tell the priest my husband had had a vasectomy three years’ previously, but I was afraid to speak up. Now I am concerned that either his consent or my consent may have been defective. When the priest asked the question during the ceremony, “Will you accept children lovingly from God, and bring them up according to the law of Christ and his Church?”, I remember thinking specifically, “Yes, I would accept a ‘surprise’ baby.” My husband said when he aswered the question, he was thinking about raising our child together and his children from a previous marriage in the Catholic Church. He said he wasn’t really thinking about the vasectomy during the time before our convalidation–that he was instead thinking how he wanted to do the “right” thing and be married in the Church. He has told me that if I had gotten pregnant anyway, he would have been upset at first but would have accepted and loved the child. My concern is that everything I’m reading says that this should be confessed before the ceremony, and the priest didn’t say anything to my husband about confession period, even though he had been away from the Sacraments for a decade. I can’t shake the feeling that a Tribunal could declare my marriage invalid b/c there are probably several people who could say they knew he had had a vasectomy and that we didn’t want any more children. This doubt has been in my mind for over a year now. Should I refrain from the Sacraments and from marital relations until I can speak to my priest?
 
Definately speak with a priest. I would confess that this was not brought forward before.

I would have thought the same way since there are children already involved and now the focus is to bring them up catholic.

If you could not speak to a preist right away I would go to confession and take care of it there and will guide you.

I will pray for you to get the answers you need.
Myriam
 
By all means, talk to your pastor about this.

Your husband should have confessed prior to your marriage if he had been away from the sacraments. However, this does not invalidate your marriage, nor does the earlier vasectomy. Those attempting Christian marriage must be mentally open to children but it sounds as though you were at the time of your marriage.
 
Sterility is not an impediment to valid marriage. This would not impact the validity of your convalidation.
 
Sterility is not an impediment to valid marriage. This would not impact the validity of your convalidation.
Correct. In the case of vasectomy, it is of course grave sin that needs to be confessed, but once confessed it is not an impediment to marriage nor to marital relations.
 
Correct. In the case of vasectomy, it is of course grave sin that needs to be confessed, but once confessed it is not an impediment to marriage nor to marital relations.
That’s what I’m saying…it wasn’t confessed before the ceremony to my knowledge. It has been confessed by now, but my husband can’t really remember when. He thinks it was sometime after the convalidation. So he is forgiven NOW (and I was forgiven at baptism) but it wouldn’t have any bearing on whether our convalidation was valid at the time.
 
That’s what I’m saying…it wasn’t confessed before the ceremony to my knowledge. It has been confessed by now, but my husband can’t really remember when. He thinks it was sometime after the convalidation. So he is forgiven NOW (and I was forgiven at baptism) but it wouldn’t have any bearing on whether our convalidation was valid at the time.
If it’s been confessed now, and you knew about the vasectomy before the convalidation, then all’s well.

I think where it would have been problematic for forming consent is if you didn’t know before getting married.
 
That’s what I’m saying…it wasn’t confessed before the ceremony to my knowledge. It has been confessed by now, but my husband can’t really remember when. He thinks it was sometime after the convalidation. So he is forgiven NOW (and I was forgiven at baptism) but it wouldn’t have any bearing on whether our convalidation was valid at the time.
Whilst both spouses should be in a state of grace at the time of receiving the sacrament of marriage, it is not essential for the validity of the sacrament.

Also if your husband went to confession earlier and honestly forgot to mention he had consented to a vasectomy, this sin would ahve been forgiven along with all others.
 
Whilst both spouses should be in a state of grace at the time of receiving the sacrament of marriage, it is not essential for the validity of the sacrament.

Also if your husband went to confession earlier and honestly forgot to mention he had consented to a vasectomy, this sin would ahve been forgiven along with all others.
If he went to confession a long time before the convalidation ceremony, then he couldn’t have been truly absolved b/c he was living in a state of sin at the time–in a civil marriage w/o annulment, and we weren’t living as brother and sister. No one told us we needed to. I wish he could remember exactly when he went, but he absolutely remembers going at some point and confessing the vasectomy specifically.
 
First, let me say I am trying to make an appointment to speak with my priest about this issue. 15 years ago my husband’s first marriage was anulled, and we had our marriage convalidated in the Catholic Church. He was a baptized confirmed Catholic, and I had not yet been baptized. We had been married civilly 10 years before that and had a child, so the priest didn’t require us to go through marriage prep. While we were in his office filling out paperwork for the convalidation, it occurred to me that maybe I should tell the priest my husband had had a vasectomy three years’ previously, but I was afraid to speak up. Now I am concerned that either his consent or my consent may have been defective. When the priest asked the question during the ceremony, “Will you accept children lovingly from God, and bring them up according to the law of Christ and his Church?”, I remember thinking specifically, “Yes, I would accept a ‘surprise’ baby.” My husband said when he aswered the question, he was thinking about raising our child together and his children from a previous marriage in the Catholic Church. He said he wasn’t really thinking about the vasectomy during the time before our convalidation–that he was instead thinking how he wanted to do the “right” thing and be married in the Church. He has told me that if I had gotten pregnant anyway, he would have been upset at first but would have accepted and loved the child. My concern is that everything I’m reading says that this should be confessed before the ceremony, and the priest didn’t say anything to my husband about confession period, even though he had been away from the Sacraments for a decade. I can’t shake the feeling that a Tribunal could declare my marriage invalid b/c there are probably several people who could say they knew he had had a vasectomy and that we didn’t want any more children. This doubt has been in my mind for over a year now. Should I refrain from the Sacraments and from marital relations until I can speak to my priest?
A vasectomy is not an impediment in itself, since sterility is not an impediment to matrimony. But if the will was against accepting any children that could result from the granting of the gift of reasonable conjugal act, then the matrimonial consent is invalid. If the consent was invalid at the time of convalidation, but was not publicly and widely known, then correcting the consent privately is sufficient, so no public validation is needed. Invalid consent must be provable for annulment.
 
That’s what I’m saying…it wasn’t confessed before the ceremony to my knowledge. It has been confessed by now, but my husband can’t really remember when. He thinks it was sometime after the convalidation. So he is forgiven NOW (and I was forgiven at baptism) but it wouldn’t have any bearing on whether our convalidation was valid at the time.
Again that does NOT impact validity of your convalidation.
 
My husband and I spoke to our priest today–he said our marriage is valid. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top