Marriage outside the Catholic Church?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ajalduhon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

ajalduhon

Guest
My brother-in-law got married to a non-catholic. They were married by his wife’s Minister/Pastor. If he chose to have his marriage blessed in the Catholic Church, would he be able to since he was married by another religious, non-catholic, person? If so, what would he have to do in order to have his marriage blessed in the Catholic Church?
 
My brother-in-law got married to a non-catholic. They were married by his wife’s Minister/Pastor. If he chose to have his marriage blessed in the Catholic Church, would he be able to since he was married by another religious, non-catholic, person? If so, what would he have to do in order to have his marriage blessed in the Catholic Church?
He should speak with his pastor. If this is the only Marriage for both his pastor can arrange for Marriage preparation and the Convalidation.
 
My brother-in-law got married to a non-catholic. They were married by his wife’s Minister/Pastor. If he chose to have his marriage blessed in the Catholic Church, would he be able to since he was married by another religious, non-catholic, person? If so, what would he have to do in order to have his marriage blessed in the Catholic Church?
Assuming your brother is Catholic, and that he was married without a dispensation from form (permission to hold a non-Catholic form of ceremony) from his bishop, he will need to see his parish priest to inquire about having his marriage convalidated - this is sometimes called “having the marriage blessed” (usually by those who have not needed to have their marriage convalidated 🙂 ).

From memory, there are generally two types of convalidation: (i) a renewal of consent (basically a new ceremony, small and private or as big and public as the couple wants), and (ii) radical sanation (which I believe translates as “cleansing from the root”), which usually involves the Catholic party petitioning his bishop, through his pastor and diocesan marriage tribunal, for what is in effect an after-the-fact dispensation from form for the original non-Catholic ceremony. The latter is the route I took (my non-Catholic wife was distrustful of Catholic church authority and “the nerve” of the Church to tell her our marriage was not valid - not that anyone blames her, it is a tough teaching), and our marriage was convalidated via radical sanation last summer. I immediately went to confession and was then back in the bosom of Mother Church.

For more info, I suggest doing a search on the terms “convalidation” and “radical sanation” - you’ll get much better information than my summarized version.

As posted above, marriage preparation may be needed, depending on the specific circumstances.

We will be praying for your brother-in-law, and his espoused.

Peace all.
 
The major difference between the two:

With a simple convalidation you renew your consent, essentially getting married in the Church. Your valid marriage exists from that day on.

With a radical sanation, your marriage is deemed to have been valid from the day you originally spoke your vows.
 
With a radical sanation, your marriage is deemed to have been valid from the day you originally spoke your vows.
Not quite. A radical sanation is still a convalidation, except there is no ceremony.
 
Not quite. A radical sanation is still a convalidation, except there is no ceremony.
Well, yes, there are two types of convalidation with different results:

Simple convalidation which involves renewal of consent and at which point your marriage becomes valid.

Can. 1157 The renewal of consent must be a new act of the will concerning a marriage which the renewing party knows or thinks was null from the beginning.

and Radical Sanation which doesn’t involve renewal of consent and by which your marriage is deemed to have been valid from the very beginning.

Can. 1161 §1. The radical sanation of an invalid marriage is its convalidation without the renewal of consent, which is granted by competent authority and entails the dispensation from an impediment, if there is one, and from canonical form, if it was not observed, and the retroactivity of canonical effects.

§2. Convalidation occurs at the moment of the granting of the favor. Retroactivity, however, is understood to extend to the moment of the celebration of the marriage unless other provision is expressly made.
 
. . .With a radical sanation, your marriage is deemed to have been valid from the day you originally spoke your vows.
This is absolutely correct.

And, I might add, the reason I am so happy the sanitio in radice was granted - now we’ve been validly married before God since 1995 even though it took me 13 years to set things right!

Ta-da!!!

(Man, I love the Church…)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top