Marriage

  • Thread starter Thread starter jp54321
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jp54321

Guest
How should married couples deal with infertility?? Seek an annulment to get a more fertile partner? The primary purpose of Marriage is procreation so why not? A married couple without kids is a difficult existence. Kids make Marriages worthwhile
 
How should married couples deal with infertility?? Seek an annulment to get a more fertile partner? The primary purpose of Marriage is procreation so why not? A married couple without kids is a difficult existence. Kids make Marriages worthwhile
Infertility is not an impediment to marriage, so an annulment could not be obtained for such a reason.

How each couple deals with infertility is up to them to discern. Some may work to improve the conditions causing infertility, some may choose adoption, some may choose to be “spiritual mothers and fathers.” Some may choose a combination of the above.
 
Infertility is not an impediment to marriage, so an annulment could not be obtained for such a reason.

How each couple deals with infertility is up to them to discern. Some may work to improve the conditions causing infertility, some may choose adoption, some may choose to be “spiritual mothers and fathers.” Some may choose a combination of the above.
Spiritual fathers and mothers? How??
 
😦 Think about what you just suggested. You suggested finding someone, promising your life and everything you have to them until death do you part, and then up and leaving because of a physical condition beyond their control. I know this happens to infertile people way too often, but I think it’s tragic. Finding out that you can’t naturally reproduce to grow a family is hard enough, but finding out that you’ll be losing what you do have because of it would just be too much to take.
 
Spiritual fathers and mothers? How??
I think that is “easier” in some cultures than in others. It could be that you get very involved in the care of a young person who is extremely sick . . . and get to love that “child” and his/her family . . . then it is “very natural” to call the young one my son or daughter – in the USA, I would ask the parent’s permission. It would be good to let them know it is a love relationship and let them know how much you love both the child/young person and them.

It could be a mother abandoned by her husband and father of her children. You then have a daughter and grandchildren :extrahappy:.

That is my :twocents: worth. Hope it helps somehow. You are in my prayers. Our Lord can do any thing at all.
 
How should married couples deal with infertility?? Seek an annulment to get a more fertile partner? The primary purpose of Marriage is procreation so why not? A married couple without kids is a difficult existence. Kids make Marriages worthwhile
Why would you seek out an annulment?

Being infertile is not an impediment to marriage.

There are a number of things that one can do that are perfectly fine within Church teachings.

I would consult doctors to figure out why we are infertile and take it from there.

You can also adopt if all options are exhausted.

There are plenty of examples of infertile couples in the bible…couple who were infertile for a vast majority of their marriages until God blessed them with one child later in life.

They never sought an annulment and were very holy men and women.

There are Saints who were infertile too.

What you are suggesting is very heartless and disrespectful.
 
Spiritual fathers and mothers? How??
Being Godparents is definitely one way. I had the honor and privilege of asking my wife’s cousin and her husband (who I’ve come to count as one of my best friends and who are both active Christians) who have been dealing with really bad infertility issues for some time (they’re never going to be able to have kids of their own) to be my daughter’s godparents. None of our family to date had asked them to be godparents as we’re the first members of the current generation to want to baptize our kids, so she was beyond happy to have been asked.
 
My wife and I have been married for 37 years, never used any form of birth control [even now:rolleyes:…], and never had any biological children…we have many Godchildren, and help take care of other children who are in less than ideal circumstances…some of ‘our kids’ are now grown and have families of their own, and the ‘grandchildren’ are regulars at our house…we haven’t missed much, and ‘our kids’ haven’t, either…
 
Infertility is not an impediment to marriage, so an annulment could not be obtained for such a reason.

How each couple deals with infertility is up to them to discern. Some may work to improve the conditions causing infertility, some may choose adoption, some may choose to be “spiritual mothers and fathers.” Some may choose a combination of the above.
In addition to all of these excellent ideas, some couples use their childlessness as a door into a vocation that would have been difficult with children such as missionary work, housing foster children, being house parents in half-way houses, etc.
 
My wife and I have been married for 37 years, never used any form of birth control [even now:rolleyes:…], and never had any biological children…we have many Godchildren, and help take care of other children who are in less than ideal circumstances…some of ‘our kids’ are now grown and have families of their own, and the ‘grandchildren’ are regulars at our house…we haven’t missed much, and ‘our kids’ haven’t, either…
So you’re saying that your marriage is worthwhile even without having biological children?!:eek:

I kid, of course. I know that it isn’t an uncommon attitude, but I’m always blown away by people who think that kids are the point of marriage, or who wonder why you would bother getting married if you didn’t want or couldn’t have kids. There are no guarantees in life. When you marry someone, you’re marrying them, not what they can produce.
 
How should married couples deal with infertility?? Seek an annulment to get a more fertile partner? The primary purpose of Marriage is procreation so why not? A married couple without kids is a difficult existence. Kids make Marriages worthwhile
I suggest you talk to your pastor. Infertility is not grounds for a decree of nullity and I’m not sure where you got this idea. You need to have a more firm understanding of the sacrament of marriage. Your pastor can give you that. It will be hard to come by on the internet.

Frankly, I find this question bizarre.
 
I was told by specialists that I would never get my wife pregnant. I prayed and we have our twins.

I prayed with faith but my soul must have been crying out more than usual.

I think it is impotence and not infertility that annuls a marriage. No idea what female impotence is though. Not sure if viagra helps impotence, I was never any good at science.
 
How should married couples deal with infertility?? Seek an annulment to get a more fertile partner? The primary purpose of Marriage is procreation so why not? A married couple without kids is a difficult existence. Kids make Marriages worthwhile
I think the primary purpose of marriage is love.
 
Being Godparents is definitely one way. I had the honor and privilege of asking my wife’s cousin and her husband (who I’ve come to count as one of my best friends and who are both active Christians) who have been dealing with really bad infertility issues for some time (they’re never going to be able to have kids of their own) to be my daughter’s godparents. None of our family to date had asked them to be godparents as we’re the first members of the current generation to want to baptize our kids, so she was beyond happy to have been asked.
In fact, there’s a thread still running about how hard it is to find practicing Catholic godparents.
 
I was told by specialists that I would never get my wife pregnant. I prayed and we have our twins.

I prayed with faith but my soul must have been crying out more than usual.

I think it is impotence and not infertility that annuls a marriage. No idea what female impotence is though. Not sure if viagra helps impotence, I was never any good at science.
There are conditions that can prevent a woman from being able to engage in intercourse.

As I understand it, though, in most cases today impotence is not permanent or total and can respond to treatment.
 
In fact, there’s a thread still running about how hard it is to find practicing Catholic godparents.
Hard to find Christian Godparents in some circles too, not just Catholic. I’d have loved to have had my brother (and his wife) or my sister serve as Godparents/sponsors as well since the Episcopal Church allows up to 4.

But my sister and brother who were both baptized, confirmed Catholics who were far more active in church life growing up than I was, being altar servers and the like, have both fallen away from Catholicism and indeed Christianity in general. My sister I’ve always known has become at best at best a weak agnostic (ie: believes something but more personally hers than anything else). My brother I’d always figured was the same, but when I brought up the idea that we were going to get our daughter baptized he was actually dismissive, almost hostile, toward the idea asking me why I’d “waste my time.”

Makes me somewhat glad the couple who are going to be her godparents are faithful Christians. Not only are they the most “in need” of having an opportunity like this, they’re also really the only people I still know who’d even fit the bill as active Christians. And they’re already embracing it peppering me with questions about the when, where, what, etc… that I won’t have the answers to for several months yet. 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top