Mary and the brown scapular?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gospel_Truth
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gospel_Truth

Guest
Can you please tell me where in scripture it tells us to pray to Mary, and to wear the scapular. Thank you.
 
Does it have to be in Scripture? Why?
Yes, It is easier for me to put faith in the written word. As I understand the Catholic faith, all that she teaches (faith & practice) is rooted in sacred scripture or is atleast implied in sacred scripture.
 
Yes, It is easier for me to put faith in the written word. As I understand the Catholic faith, all that she teaches (faith & practice) is rooted in sacred scripture or is atleast implied in sacred scripture.
Have you ever asked a friend or relative to pray for you? We ask Mary to pray for us. Mary, being the mother of Jesus has a special place in his heart. We pray to her and the communion of saints to intercede for us. We are not worshipping them, we are just asking them to pray for us.

You’re not going to find that in the scripture, but what better person to ask to pray for you than Jesus’ own mother?

The Catholic faith is rooted in scripture and tradition.
 
Can you please tell me where in scripture it tells us to pray to Mary, and to wear the scapular. Thank you.
The Intercession & Communion of Saints
Yes, It is easier for me to put faith in the written word. As I understand the Catholic faith, all that she teaches (faith & practice) is rooted in sacred scripture or is atleast implied in sacred scripture.
See the link above from my Catholic blog.

There is nothing in the Bible that teaches that everything that Christians believe and practice has to be found in the Bible. This errant doctrine is known as Sola Scriptura, and it cannot be found in the Word of God, (not even in a Catholic Bible which contains all 73 books) nor can it be found in the verifiable teachings of the early church. It is a modern new wind of doctrines of men that only came into being some 500 years ago.

Praying to Mary and the saints is taught in scripture and is known as The Communion of Saints (Mp3 Bible study)

The Brown Scapular is a devotion that has been around for a long time and here is a history and basic catechism on it.
 
Yes, It is easier for me to put faith in the written word. As I understand the Catholic faith, all that she teaches (faith & practice) is rooted in sacred scripture or is atleast implied in sacred scripture.
Actually, it’s the other way around. Sacred Scripture is rooted in the teachings of the Apostles, aka the Catholic faith. The Church was passing on the Faith for nearly 400 years before the canon of Scripture was determined by the Holy Spirit-guided Catholic Church. Scripture is a product of Sacred Tradition.

That said, the brown scapular is an optional devotion, and is not in any way something that all Catholics must believe and practice. I’m sure the link that CM provided above will explain that there’s more to the brown scapular than just wearing one. It’s a tangible reminder to live, with God’s help, a holy and blameless life.
 
Yes, It is easier for me to put faith in the written word. As I understand the Catholic faith, all that she teaches (faith & practice) is rooted in sacred scripture or is atleast implied in sacred scripture.
You are almost correct, everything that the Catholic Church teaches and none of her official practices are ever opposed to anything found in the Scriptures, and all she teaches is supported either explicitly or implicitly in the Scriptures.

So by your authority you require this personal devotion to be in the Scriptures? Sorry, you won’t find too many Personal Devotions detailed in the Scriptures. Personal Devotions are those things not required by the Church, that the faithful may if one chooses practice.
 
Can you please tell me where in scripture it tells us to pray to Mary, and to wear the scapular. Thank you.
Implicitly, yes, but first can you show me in scripture, either specifically or implicitly where the list of the books of the bible is listed?
 
Not in scripture. Our Lady appeard to St. Simon and gave him the Brown Scapular with instructions on how and why to wear it with devotion. Here… read about it domestic-church.com/CONTENT.DCC/19980701/SCRMNTL/SCAPUL.HTM
How do you know it was the real Mary and not a deception?
According to tradition, in the 13th century Our Lady appeared to Saint Simon Stock, Superior General of the Order, and gave him the brown scapular saying that whoever wore it would be preserved from eternal damnation and on the 1st Saturday after their death, would be taken by her to heaven.
Since when did salvation from eternal damnation involve wearing a brown scapular? 🤷 Where’s that in the Bible? Only Christ saves from eternal damnation.
 
How do you know it was the real Mary and not a deception?

Since when did salvation from eternal damnation involve wearing a brown scapular? 🤷 Where’s that in the Bible? Only Christ saves from eternal damnation.
If you read Br. Rich’s response above, you’ll see that personal devotion, as he says, is not a required belief of the Church. I guess it’s my faith that tells me it was the real Mary. Only Christ saves from eternal damnation, but Christ’s mother is our great intercessor for salvation. In the experience of many Catholics, devotion to Mary always leads to devotion to Christ, including a devotion to the Brown Scapular.

Incidentally, it is not the mere “wearing” of the scapular that gives us salvation promised by Mary. It is the practice of our faith that goes with the promises of the devotion. The wearing of the scapular is just an instrument which shows our membership in this Carmelite practice.
 
“One day through the Rosary and the Scapular I will save the world” - Mary to St Dominic 1208, but Jesus said that He was the way , the truth and the life, and that no one could come to the Father eccept by Him. So how can Mary save the world when Jesus is already the savior. Thank you.
 
Does it have to be in Scripture? Why?
Br. Rich,
Mary said that through the rosarie, and brown scapular that she would save the world, but Jesus said that He was the way, the truth and the life, and that no one could come to the Father eccept by Him. So how can Mary save the world when Jesus is already the savior? Thank you.
 
Br. Rich,
Mary said that through the rosarie, and brown scapular that she would save the world, but Jesus said that He was the way, the truth and the life, and that no one could come to the Father eccept by Him. So how can Mary save the world when Jesus is already the savior? Thank you.
Yeah, that jumped out at me, too. Since when is the Rosary and scapular the gospel? 🤷 Since when is Mary the savior of the world? 🤷
 
“One day through the Rosary and the Scapular I will save the world” - Mary to St Dominic 1208, but Jesus said that He was the way , the truth and the life, and that no one could come to the Father eccept by Him. So how can Mary save the world when Jesus is already the savior. Thank you.
Sigh . . . let’s think about this: God’s plan required that His son sacrifice His life for our salvation, right? Now, God could’ve come up with a different plan, for sure, but He didn’t, He stuck with this one. So, His son has to have a life, has to be fully human, in order for this sacrifice to work, right? So . . . looks like Jesus had to get that “humanness” from someone, as far as how God intended His plan to go. Sure, Jesus could’ve suddenly appeared on the Earth as a 30 year old human ready to start His ministry but that’s not the way HE chose to do it, right? He wanted to have a mother, a human mother, obviously, that’s how it happened.

Now, let’s think about this: In God’s overall plan, did He want us to have free will? Absolutely! He could’ve done it the other way, but He didn’t, He wanted to create all of us with a free will, so He did.

So far, looks like God wanted what He wanted and put it into action, can any Christian disagree with what I’ve said above?

So, let’s go here: If it was God’s plan (not ours) that He have a human mother, and it was ALSO God’s plan that ALL OF US have a free will, then it must have also been God’s plan that His mother must agree, of her own free will, to participate in God’s plan, right? So, basically, with God’s plan the way it is, she could’ve screwed it all up, she could’ve said no. She didn’t. She simply, obediently aligned herself with God’s plan. But she used her God-given free will to do so. None of the rest of us, NONE OF US, were asked to do this, OR DID IT. Does this make her divine? NO. Does this make her different than us in terms of her relationship with God and with us? Of course it does. We did not personally participate in everyone else’s salvation, she did, because God wanted her to, asked her to, and she agreed, He didn’t make her.
 
Br. Rich,
Mary said that through the rosarie, and brown scapular that she would save the world, but Jesus said that He was the way, the truth and the life, and that no one could come to the Father eccept by Him. So how can Mary save the world when Jesus is already the savior? Thank you.
What “Mary said” in private revelations is just that private revelations. It does not add to or conflict with Divine Revelation (Scripture and Apostolic Tradition (teaching)). The way I personally understand this is that by the use of the Rosary (prayer) as a personal devotion and the wearing of the Brown Scapular individual persons will tend to keep themselves focused on Christ and what is needed for their salvation. The Salvation which Christ by His death on the cross and resurrection from the dead obtained for mankind which now only needs to be accepted and applied to individuals.
 
Yeah, that jumped out at me, too. Since when is the Rosary and scapular the gospel? 🤷 Since when is Mary the savior of the world? 🤷
Have you ever reflected on the mysteries of the Rosary? They are nothing but the Gospel!
 
Yeah, that jumped out at me, too. Since when is the Rosary and scapular the gospel? 🤷
The Rosary is a meditation on the Gospel of Jesus Christ, with prayers asking God to make us more like Him. Asking “since when is the Rosary…the Gospel?” demonstrates that you are not familiar with the Rosary and what it’s purpose is, which is to enter into the sacred mysteries of God becoming a man like us, in order to die for us.
Since when is Mary the savior of the world? 🤷
Have you ever told anyone the Good News about Jesus Christ? By pointing them to the Saviour, you have assisted in their salvation - saved them, if you will. Not that you personally died on the cross for them, but you told them about the One who did just that. Mary doesn’t think she’s the saviour of the world, and neither does Catholicism.
 
There is a precedent for wearing the Scapular in the Book of Numbers 15:38-40 where God told Moses:
Speak to the children of Israel, and thou shalt tell them I to make to themselves fringes in the corners of their garments, putting in them ribands of blue: That when they shall see them, they may remember all the commandments of the Lord, and not follow their own thoughts and eyes going astray after divers things, But rather being mindful of the precepts of the Lord, may do them and be holy to their God.
Evedry day my Scapula reminds me to offer everything that day to God as a love offering… to take up my daily cross as it were. It reminds me to be chaste according to my state in life (and dress modestly at all times) and to pray the rosary.

When I pray the rosary I spend 20-30 minutes reflecting and meditating on the Gospels.

While some come to CAF believing they have nothing to learn and want to help Catholics by “removing the splinter in our eye” others come in a spirit of genuine curiousity about why Catholics believe what we do, and the way we respond to posters such as Gospel Truth and WindGirl will help them to better understand.

Having said that, I have been reading through a couple of posts where the OP of the posts keep repeating their original (well, NOT really so original!) question ad nauseum, despite having it answered in great detail.

My New Years Resolution is to not get involved in this sort of futile tail chasing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top