May I confess wherever I like?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarianCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MarianCatholic

Guest
The other day I made a 40 minutes long train fare only to confess to a different priest than I usually do, you see Im a bit embarrassed that Im confessing the same sin over and over again and the only way to recieve the sacrament of reconsiliation at my local parish is to make an appointment including my name and the time.
I like to be more anonymous therefor I decided to visit a church where they offered confession at specific times every day.

Should I stop doing this or is it perfectly ok to make confessions where Im feeling comfortable or is it like some sort of betrayal against my own parish?

Thanks in advance for any replies:)

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
This matter seems to me to be related to very specific circumstances. There might be overall general guidelines but not a hard and fast rule. It is not a sin to do this, make confessions where you’re feeling comfortable. I would suspect however that the embarrassment of confessing the same sin over and over again might encourage you to stop committing that sin. I have felt that embarrassment, and it encouraged me. Less frequent confessions with more change between confessions might also be better than more frequent confessions with little change between each one. But if you would become so embarrassed that you would stop going to confession, then it is better to keep confessing anonymously. If you are seeing an appropriate spiritual director and you are following a style of spiritual direction which includes obedience (which is only really mandatory for clergy - as far as I know), then you should probably do whatever the spiritual director suggests.
 
Yes, you may confess to any Catholic priest who has the faculties to hear it [which is pretty much all of them - I only added this qualifier because there are strange cases, certainly confessing at any parish is fine].

There is no requirement to stick to your parish priest, and in your situation with needing to make appointments, I probably wouldn’t either.
 
I would suggest that you do this as long as you are committed to going to the same place on a regular basis. The priest may never know who you are at this location, but he can still help you with consistent penances and answers to any questions you might have. Some people are just better at confessing under more traditional settings. I am the opposite, I have to go face to face. Enclosed confessionals make me very anxious, I forget everything I want to confess and I even start crying before I even start.

Just make sure you are not “priest hopping.” That is going from place to place to place…
I think you are fine. As far as embarrassment: offer it to God as part of your penance. Better to be a bit embarrassed here than to spend eternity separated from God.
 
Canon law even says you can go to any priest:

Can. 991 Every member of the Christian faithful is free to confess sins to a legitimately approved confessor of his or her choice, even to one of another rite.

I normally go to confession with my spiritual director who is not from my parish. It has nothing to do with anything negative about my parish, it’s just that I prefer to go to him. I see it as beneficial to my spiritual life.
 
Canon law even says you can go to any priest:

Can. 991 Every member of the Christian faithful is free to confess sins to a legitimately approved confessor of his or her choice, even to one of another rite.

I normally go to confession with my spiritual director who is not from my parish. It has nothing to do with anything negative about my parish, it’s just that I prefer to go to him. I see it as beneficial to my spiritual life.
Well stated.
 
It’s also your right, I’m fairly sure, to confess anonymously if you so choose. It sounds as though the policy at your parish makes that impossible.

Usagi
 
Yes, you may confess to any Catholic priest who has the faculties to hear it [which is pretty much all of them - I only added this qualifier because there are strange cases, certainly confessing at any parish is fine].

There is no requirement to stick to your parish priest, and in your situation with needing to make appointments, I probably wouldn’t either.
Thanks for answering at my thread Iron Donkey.
It’s good to know that Im not the only one wanting to be anonym when confessing.
Yes appointments aren’t entirely my thing, but I can do it that way as well, but I prefer to do it anonymously.

Thanks again for your reply:)

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
I would suggest that you do this as long as you are committed to going to the same place on a regular basis. The priest may never know who you are at this location, but he can still help you with consistent penances and answers to any questions you might have. Some people are just better at confessing under more traditional settings. I am the opposite, I have to go face to face. Enclosed confessionals make me very anxious, I forget everything I want to confess and I even start crying before I even start.

Just make sure you are not “priest hopping.” That is going from place to place to place…
I think you are fine. As far as embarrassment: offer it to God as part of your penance. Better to be a bit embarrassed here than to spend eternity separated from God.
Thanks for answering Cricket2.
Im not sure you got it right when I talked about embarrassment.
I ment that Im embarrased becouse the priest knows me and know that Im confessing.
When Im confessing often it becomes a bit embarrassing.
Im Allways embarrased in front of God in the confessional so what I refered to was additional
Unneeded humiliation.

Well I hope this made more sence…

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
Just make sure you are not “priest hopping.” That is going from place to place to place…
Nor “priest shopping”, looking for the lightest penances – It’s not sporting to take all your worst sins over to the Polish parish, where old Fr Stanislau from the old country doesn’t know English and only ever gives “T’ree Hail Mary…t’ree Hail Mary…”

😛

tee
 
Canon law even says you can go to any priest:

Can. 991 Every member of the Christian faithful is free to confess sins to a legitimately approved confessor of his or her choice, even to one of another rite.

I normally go to confession with my spiritual director who is not from my parish. It has nothing to do with anything negative about my parish, it’s just that I prefer to go to him. I see it as beneficial to my spiritual life.
Thanks a lot SuscipeMeDomine, it’s good to know that it’s my right to do so according to canon law:)
It was very comforting.

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
It’s also your right, I’m fairly sure, to confess anonymously if you so choose. It sounds as though the policy at your parish makes that impossible.

Usagi
With only two priests at my local parish it makes it difficult, yes.
I wish it was put aside at least 1 hour a week to confessions.
We have confessions once every week after the mass on Sunday, but even then one must get a hold of a priest to let him know that you’re in need of confession.
So again it isn’t anonymous at all.

Unfortunately it seems like the interest in confession is lower than ever at my parish.
So it’s not to odd that the priests are spending their limited time on other matters.

Thanks for replying:)

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
It’s also your right, I’m fairly sure, to confess anonymously if you so choose. It sounds as though the policy at your parish makes that impossible.
The grille of a confessional doesn’t *really *guarantee anonymity, though it is often a comfortable side effect.

tee
 
Nor “priest shopping”, looking for the lightest penances – It’s not sporting to take all your worst sins over to the Polish parish, where old Fr Stanislau from the old country doesn’t know English and only ever gives “T’ree Hail Mary…t’ree Hail Mary…”

😛

tee
Haha, I get your point:P
What a amazing idea, Lol.

Nah, in my case it’s actually more of the opposite.
My local priest are from Asia and does not talk my native language to good (good enough to understand each others though) and the priest Im confessing to at the other parish 40 mins away is Norwegian and talks perfectly good Norwegian so it’s nothing like “an easy way out”.

Thanks for replying:)

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
there is nothing wrong with going to different parishes , and in fact i have received particular grace upon confessing with a new parish , however , there are also benefits and graces that can be poured out for going to the same parish / confessor over and over such as developing a strong bond and trust in his mercies, growing weary of sins and what not…

i think that as long as you are making decisions in prayer and trusting in gods providence everything will be ok…

the bottomline is that you cant "hide " or “run” from God, so be honest and open to whomever you are confessing too because it is more so about YOU than your confessor
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top