Meat last Friday

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert_Sock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Robert_Sock

Guest
So I opened a can of chicken noodle soup instead of the vegetable soup I had bought for Friday. Instead of wasting the chicken soup, I ate it thinking that it would be less of an offense. I’m actually indifferent to the 2 types of soup, and I was actually looking forward to the vegetable soup. Did I sin?
 
It was an error. It would have been more of a sin to throw it away!!
 
It was a mistake to open it, But you intentionally ate it.

There was no way to save it for Saturday or Sunday?
 
I agree that it’s a mistake and that mistake doesn’t justify throwing food away. Although, depending on the circumstances, it could have been put in a container for Saturday. Still, no sin.

That said, on a light note, I have a hard time calling anything in the can of chicken noodle soup actual chicken. 😃
 
I would have put it into the fridge and opened the other can. I shouldn’t talk though… I was at a restaurant with a terrible menu Friday and had no choice but to order a burger.
 
Why not just fish out the pieces of chicken? I have done that before. It doesn’t take very long. And it’s the “flesh” of the animal we’re prohibited from, not the broth.
 
I would have put it into the fridge and opened the other can. I shouldn’t talk though… I was at a restaurant with a terrible menu Friday and had no choice but to order a burger.
There is always a choice. You may not like anything else available, but you had a choice and you made it.
 
I would have put it into the fridge and opened the other can. I shouldn’t talk though… I was at a restaurant with a terrible menu Friday and had no choice but to order a burger.
Fries only, salad and fries, cheeseburger without the burger, just a soda: there are always choices.
 
It may be permissible if you have bad health or are past the age of required fasting.
 
That’s between you and your confessor. But I will share my Lenten “game plan” (as my pastor calls it) of prayer, fasting and almsgiving. Prayer is to participate more in the LOTH; I have been listening to the Podcast and I want to pray actively instead of passively while I fiddle on the computer.

Now for fasting and almsgiving, that is going hand-in-hand. I began a portion-control diet on Pentecost last year, and I lost over 30 pounds by simply cutting in half what I ate at each meal. For Lent I resolved to cut that in half again. So now I am eating 1/4th of what I originally was. I hope to lose another 30.

My almsgiving is simple, and it goes hand-in-hand with the fasting. I pledged to feed the hungry whenever I can. Especially from the half of the food I am not eating. I eat out at restaurants and order delivery for most of my meals. So it is very hard to eat small portions. I have to cut stuff in half, save it in the fridge, make several meals out of it. Now if I am walking away from a restaurant with a to-go container, and I see someone begging, I simply offer the food to them. So far people have been incredibly nice and appreciative. I don’t believe in giving money to beggars.

So what I would have done with that chicken soup is heat it up and immediately go out and find someone who wants to eat it. A neighbor, a beggar, a stranger. If it’s a sin to waste food and a sin to eat meat knowingly, why do you choose the sin of disobedience, when there is a third choice?

At the very least, if you can’t find someone hungry to eat your soup, then Ziploc it, throw it in the refrigerator, and eat it in 24 hours. I mean, you were at home, weren’t you? That’s a fourth option.
40.png
year14:
It may be permissible if you have bad health or are past the age of required fasting.
There is no provision in the law itself for exemption from the rule of abstinence for those who are infirm or elderly. Those exemptions are for fasting. Therefore, you would have to approach your pastor for a dispensation from the law of abstinence if you wish to plead poor health or old age. If you don’t, then it must be confessed.
 
So I opened a can of chicken noodle soup instead of the vegetable soup I had bought for Friday. Instead of wasting the chicken soup, I ate it thinking that it would be less of an offense. I’m actually indifferent to the 2 types of soup, and I was actually looking forward to the vegetable soup. Did I sin?
This happened to me last Lent! I had a crazy day and ran through the Taco Bell drive they and two bites into my taco I realized it was Friday!

I researched what to do and came across this video from Francis Cardinal George on the matter.

youtu.be/p7yWXgLlqv4
 
This happened to me last Lent! I had a crazy day and ran through the Taco Bell drive they and two bites into my taco I realized it was Friday!

I researched what to do and came across this video from Francis Cardinal George on the matter.

youtu.be/p7yWXgLlqv4
Thank you so much for the common sense and sanity of your post and link!
 
I actually thought about putting it in another container and refrigerate it, but I suffer from major depression and I remember not wanting to take the extra effort. (Yes, the depression is that severe. I shower but once a week; I wear the same unwashed clothing for about 6 months at a time; I get a haircut about 3 times per year; all this I do due to the depression. But I feel free to use my computer, and I often feel peace and calm by sitting perfectly still.)

LOVE! 🙂
 
So I opened a can of chicken noodle soup instead of the vegetable soup I had bought for Friday. Instead of wasting the chicken soup, I ate it thinking that it would be less of an offense. I’m actually indifferent to the 2 types of soup, and I was actually looking forward to the vegetable soup. Did I sin?
Yep. You knew it was a Friday in Lent and after you opened it, you knew it was chicken and ate it anyway. An opened can of chicken soup will keep nicely in the refrigerator for 24 hours.
 
Yep. You knew it was a Friday in Lent and after you opened it, you knew it was chicken and ate it anyway. An opened can of chicken soup will keep nicely in the refrigerator for 24 hours.
You probably didn’t read the OP’s last post. So, I’ll explain that under the circumstances (also keeping in mind that there is no confessable sin in this situation) he was doing the best he could.

That said, an opened can(!) will never keep safely in the refridgerator - it must always be transferred to an appropriate container prior to refridgeration.

And again - who even calls those weird bits of whateve’s chicken?!? 😃
 
I was under the impression that Lenten fasting was something the Church did together, out of solidarity, not something whose omission is sinful. Am I incorrect about this?

(If I am incorrect, I admit I don’t understand the teaching. It would seem to me that all fasting is necessarily voluntary.) 🤷
 
Prodigal,

From the Catechism of the Catholic Church
2043 The fourth precept (“You shall observe the days of fasting and abstinence established by the Church”) ensures the times of ascesis and penance which prepare us for the liturgical feasts and help us acquire mastery over our instincts and freedom of heart.85
The Church has established that we fast on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday(age 18-59) and that we abstain from meat on Ash Wednesday and all Fridays in Lent(from age 14 until death). To disregard this is a grave matter which would fulfill the first requirement for a mortal sin, however, the other two conditions of full knowledge and full consent would still have to exist.

If you are talking about the idea of fasting from something of your choosing, it is recommended, but is not obligatory under pain of sin.
 
Prodigal,

From the Catechism of the Catholic Church

The Church has established that we fast on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday(age 18-59) and that we abstain from meat on Ash Wednesday and all Fridays in Lent(from age 14 until death). To disregard this is a grave matter which would fulfill the first requirement for a mortal sin, however, the other two conditions of full knowledge and full consent would still have to exist.

If you are talking about the idea of fasting from something of your choosing, it is recommended, but is not obligatory under pain of sin.
Thanks for the info, Marty! I still don’t understand fasting as obligatory, but I’m fine with submitting to it. I mean, I always have fasted on Fridays in Lent, anyway, so it doesn’t take much to submit. 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top